Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Borked by Bork?

By CosmicConservative
Robert Bork's piece on Harriet Miers in the Wall Street Journal yesterday leads off with this statement:
With a single stroke--the nomination of Harriet Miers--the president has damaged the prospects for reform of a left-leaning and imperialistic Supreme Court, taken the heart out of a rising generation of constitutional scholars, and widened the fissures within the conservative movement. That's not a bad day's work--for liberals.
He ends with this statement:
This George Bush, like his father, is showing himself to be indifferent, if not actively hostile, to conservative values. He appears embittered by conservative opposition to his nomination, which raises the possibility that if Ms. Miers is not confirmed, the next nominee will be even less acceptable to those asking for a restrained court. That, ironically, is the best argument for her confirmation. But it is not good enough.
In between these comments he calls into question everything from Miers' basic competence to her disdain for the Federalist Society, one of the foundational conservative think tanks that has spearheaded the conservative movement for a generation. This column will no doubt be seen by some on the right as more evidence of conservative elitism run amok, but it is hard to discount the opinion of Robert Bork after years of describing him as one of the greatest legal minds of his generation. With all the focus on Dick Cheney, Scooter Libby, Condi Rice, Judith Miller and the whole Valerie Plame investigation hanging like the Sword of Damocles over the heads of this adminstration, it is easy to allow the Miers nomination to fade into the background. But as surely as Hurricane Wilma is churning towards Florida, an ugly battle is headed towards Bush with the Miers' nomination.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.