Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Jay Cutler a Bear

By CosmicConservative
So the Chicago Bears win the Jay Cutler derby
Chicago Bears acquire Jay Cutler from Denver Broncos - ESPN The Chicago Bears pulled the big upset Thursday afternoon by acquiring Denver Broncos quarterback Jay Cutler. To acquire Cutler, the Bears had to give up quarterback Kyle Orton and first-round picks in 2009 (18th overall) and 2010, along with a third-round pick (84th overall) in 2009. To complete the trade, the Broncos had to give back a fifth-round pick (140th overall) in 2009. That pick was acquired by the Broncos from the Seattle Seahawks in a trade for wide receiver Keary Colbert. The Bears beat out the Redskins, Buccaneers, Lions, Titans and other teams to land the 25-year-old Pro Bowl quarterback. The Broncos had made it clear they were asking for at least two first-round choices.
Two first round picks and Kyle Orton? Not a Herschel Walker level deal, but more than I'd have given up for Jay. For Jay at least this is better than some of the other possibilities, at least the Bears have some legitimate talent on their team. Now I guess we'll see how Cutler performs when he's not on a team of hapless has-beens and never-weres...

Comments (23)

Drax
Heh. Two firsts, a THIRD and a starting QB. Now, I never said any of those things about the players on Denver. I just said that the team sucked and that Cutler wasn't surrounded by any "greatness." Not quite a "team of hapless has-beens and never-weres..." Denver had a legitimate pro-bowl #1 wide receiver. (Hmm...checking...checking...yep...I acknowledged that.) Chicago has what has been characterized as three #3 Wide Receivers. But, Chicago has a potential pro-bowl Running Back and a much stronger defense than Denver. (I don't tend to pay much attention to 'Da Bears since, well, they have "sucked" for a while on offense even when (a few years ago) their defense was great. What I read now is that they have a porous OL. And, it doesn't matter how good you are as a QB if you're running for your life all the time. (Ask David Carr or anyone who has ever taken a snap for Detroit.) Now, the Bears have given up their #1 pick for this year and next year. They did pick up Orlando Pace to shore up that OL (maybe just for the leadership?). That can't hurt. They need a WR, though. However, it's possible that the upgrade at QB will help mold one of the current ones into a 1000 yard receiver. Maybe Devin Hester will establish that he can be a solid receiver. He certainly has the speed. I think the Bears will be better. Denver might be better as well. Certainly will have the potential to be better with all the picks -- which won't have to be used for a starting QB. We'll see. One thing for certain. Chicago won't put up with any of that whining stuff... Urlacher might stuff him in a towel cart...
CosmicConservative
Heh... I've not paid much attention to Chicago either. All I know is that they have been a pretty mediocre team with a revolving door at QB. This will be a pretty good test of your assertion that QBs are only as good as their receivers, because from what I can tell, Chicago is not considered to have a solid receiving corps, and that's not just at WR, but also at tight end. That doesn't bode well for Cutler having another "pro bowl" season. Also testing your theory will be Kyle Orton finding himself with a legitimate elite WR and a decent tight end to throw to. If I were to accept your premise about QBs and receivers, and if I were the Broncos GM and head coach, I'd probably use my draft choice windfall to continue to beef up the defense, and get at least one more "elite potential" receiver, probably also at wide receiver. Then I'd let nature take its course and let people start calling Kyle Orton an "all-pro QB." We'll see. I guess this is a "good deal" since both sides seem to think they hoodwinked the other side. I frankly don't see how this is bad for Denver, assuming they can do anything halfway decent with all the draft choices they got.
Drax
Denver made out like a bandit here. I have NEVER said that a QB is only as good as his receivers. I haven't even come CLOSE to saying that. I've said many things which clearly show that I think that the weapons available to a QB (and to a team) greatly determine his SUCCESS (both stat-wise and w/l), but, as in the case of ALL professional NFL football players -- EVERY starting WR in the NFL is in the top 100 or so on the face of the planet and are, therefore, "good" at their jobs. As with EVERY world class athlete, the margin between mediocore and good -- between good and great -- between great and legendary is a SLIM margin, and frankly one's teammates may raise a mediocre to good...even a great to legendary (and vice versa). So, I fully expect that Brandon Marshall to be a very good receiver, but don't expect him to be AS good with Orton as with Cutler. By the same token, I expect that the "medicore" WR's on Chicago to be BETTER with Cutler than they were with Orton -- even a 1000 yard receiver (for the first time in who knows how long...) (And, by the same token, I expect Orton's numbers to be slightly better with a better WR corps and Cutler's to be slightly worse with a diminished corp to throw it to...)
Drax
I mean ... really... Have we learned NOTHING from the Brady/Moss team-up regarding my assertion that the weapons available make you better? Brady broke the TD record. Moss broke the TD record. I mean, come on. BRADY broke the TD record? Before Moss, when did he give us a GLIMMER that he might be capable of that?
CosmicConservative
LOL, well, when you argue repeatedly and forcefully that Tom Brady would not be Tom Brady without Randy Moss, that Tony Romo would not be Tony Romo without Terrell Owens and Jason Witten, that Joe Montana would not have been Joe Montana without Jerry Rice... etc.... You have to at least acknowledge that someone might REASONABLY assume that you are arguing that QBs are only as good as their receiving corps. As I said, I don't follow the Bears, but I seem to remember in 2008 that Chicago was swooning over the play of Kyle Orton until he injured his ankle. It is also fair to factor in the game plan that McDaniels is likely to put in place, which will be much less of a downfield fling the ball with all your heart approach to a passing game than Shanahan/Cutler seemed to be employing. The new Broncos offense is going to look a lot like the old San Francisco offense with a lot of short, high-percentage passes over the middle, to tight ends and even running backs, with the downfield bomb mostly used to set up the short stuff, instead of vice versa. Orton may do well in that sort of game plan. It will be interesting to see. Of course Brandon Marshall may be the next whiner on the Broncos if that happens...
Drax
I don't argue that Tom Brady (winner of THREE Super Bowls) wouldn't be Tom Brady without Moss. I argue that Tom Brady wouldn't have broken Manning's record without Moss. I might argue that he would be the winner of three Super Bowls on a different TEAM with a different SCHEME with a different COACH, but his skills and his mind are his alone. I would say much the same of Montana. (I think Young might say the same...of himself -- since he clearly remembers his days on the previous recordholder for the "worst team in the history of the NFL.") We'll see how Cassell does without Moss to throw it to...
Drax
Heh..should have said he "wouldn't be the winner of three Super Bowls..."
CosmicConservative
Winning a Super Bowl once can be attributed to luck, circumstance and even momentum. Winning three Super Bowls in four years, or winning four Super Bowls is something that seems to justify "elite" status for those key players who pull off the feat. When we look at quarterbacks who have won 3 or more Super Bowls, here is the list: Bart Starr* Joe Montana Terry Bradshaw Tom Brady Troy Aikman (* Bart Starr had two Super Bowl rings, but won three NFL championships before the AFL-NFL merger, so he can claim FIVE NFL championships, two in Super Bowls) Are these the best five quarterbacks who have played the game in the Super Bowl era? Well, maybe not, but they certainly make everyone's list of top QBs of all time. Now we look at quarterbacks who hold or have held all the major QB passing records: Brett Favre Dan Marino John Elway Warren Moon Peyton Manning* (* I put Peyton Manning on this list ahead of Fran Tarkenton and Vinny Testaverde because he's clearly going to pass both of them by the end of his career, heck he'll end up ahead of Brett Favre.) What is remarkable is that there is nobody who appears on both lists. So who are the better quarterbacks? The ones who have led their team to multiple NFL championships? Or the ones who have thrown for the most yards? Well, personally I'd rather have ANY of the five top Super Bowl QBs running my team than ANY of the five top yard gainers. (Well, I claim the Terry Bradshaw exception, I'd rather have John Elway than Terry Bradshaw.. but then on the list of yardage leaders, John IS the one with the most Super Bowl wins... For that matter I'd take Peyton Manning over Bradshaw too. Peyton could still become a multiple SB winner... jury still out on him.) But that's just me. At the end of his career, I suspect Cutler will be higher on the yardage list than on the Super Bowl wins list.
CosmicConservative
Actually if you do some sort of numerical combination of Super Bowl wins and passing records to form a composite rating of quarterbacks, John Elway is probably going to end up at the top of that list now, and by the end of his career, Peyton Manning would almost certainly be at the top. Hm.....
Drax
Again, you conflate "team wins" with "individual stats." Ben Roethlisberger , Kenny Stabler, Trent Dilfer, Mark Rypien, Brad Johnson, Eli Manning, Jeff Hostetler, Doug Williams , Jim McMahon, and Jim Plunkett have more Super Bowl wins than Dan Marino, Fran Tarkenton, and Jim Kelly. Are you seriously suggesting that any of them are even in the same LEAGUE as Warren Moon or Dan Marino or Fran Tarkenton? Seriously? Brett Favre, bless his heart, couldn't win the big one UNTIL he had Reggie White on the other side. And, Bradshaw (he of "I have two more touchdowns than interceptions for my CAREER fame...) had more HOF's on his team (both Wide Receivers and his running back -- as well as a HOF Defensive LINE) -- than some teams have HOFers in their HISTORY. Big Ben has more Superbowl Wins than: Favre, Unitas, Dawson, Young, Manning (or Marino or Tarkenton), so he's better than THEM? He has as many as Staubach, so he's as good as STAUBACH? Seriously? You can be a GREAT QB on a terrible team. (Ask Elway...he of the great hold-out....) But, once a year...only once...43 times in history...a TEAM wins the Super Bowl. If your TEAM is good enough, you can win with Dilfer throwing and Gruden coaching. If you have a PLETHORA of great players...say HOFers at QB/RB/WR and on the OL and on the Defense...(See Montana and company, Bradshaw and company, Aikman and company, Starr and company...you can win MULTIPLE Superbowls. Only Brady breaks this mold, but he has had that special combination of "almost great" players on the offensive side of the ball and some "great" players on the defensive side of the ball -- coupled with an offensive/defensive SCHEME which is unparalleled in the history of Football -- along with the possibility of cheating -- to go along with Brady...) I really can't believe that you would rather have Bradshaw than Marino (in their primes) with ALL OTHER THINGS being equal. I really can't.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I wonder if you actually read all of my posts before teeing off on them. I said that you could argue that winning ONE Super Bowl could not really be used as a measure of greatness, but THREE? Different story. So all of your ranting about the single SB winners completely ignored my fundamental point. And I already claimed the Terry Bradshaw exception, did you read that? As far as SPECIFICALLY would I rather have Terry Bradshaw as my QB or Dan Marino... That is not nearly as obvious to me as it seems to be for you. Yes Marino was a great QB, but he had some years when he was surrounded by great talent too, and failed to convert the deal. Still, I would say that the Terry Bradshaw exception probably applies to all of the record holders, even Warren Moon. I'm really not a fan of Terry Bradshaw and I think the Pittsburgh defense had much more to do with Pittsburgh winning four Super Bowls than Terry did. But Terry didn't screw it up either. I'm not nearly as big a fan of Marino as other people are. I see his gaudy individual statistics and I agree they display phenomenal individual talent. But in MY OPINION when Marino was in his prime, he had the talent both on the field and in the coaching booth, to win the Super Bowl. He SHOULD HAVE WON Super Bowls. Why didn't he? Just bad luck? Maybe I don't want a QB with such "bad luck" running my team either.
CosmicConservative
By the way, if you look closely at this list of "most Super Bowl wins" there is ONE QB statistic that they all were at or near the top in during their heyday (except Terry... Terry is the exception to all this...) Joe Montana, Bart Starr, Troy Aikman and Tom Brady were consistently at or near the top in quarterback rating. Since QB rating rewards accuracy, consistency, lack of turnover and WINING GAMES, it just might be that the quarterbacks who tend to win the most Superbowls are those who MANAGE THE GAME best, instead of throw the ball farthest. Which, if you think about it, has been my core contention all along. I want a quarterback who WINS GAMES BY MANAGING THEM BETTER, and Cutler has not shown me that he has that ability.
Drax
Yes, I read your posts. Your "Bradshaw exception" (the original one) delimited it to taking Elway over him. I merely took your premise that winning multiple superbowls indicates QB greatness moreso than winning a single one and extrapolated it to also mean that winning one made you a better QB than if you won none. (As you supported in your critique of Marino.) So...on Marino.... Who were his HOF receivers? Who were his HOF running backs? How Many HOFers did he have on the OL or defensive backs? In ANY year? Let me help you out there. He had ONE. In ALL his years on the Dolphins. ONE. Dwight Stephenson, who played with Marino for four years (84-87) How many did Montana have? He had TWO (Well, Rice isn't in yet...but, hey...we know how that story ends, don't we?). Of course, having the best receiver to ever play the game and one of the best corners in the history of the game...along with Roger Craig (so so so close to being HOF -- one of the finalists last year...although I doubt he'll make it with the huge numbers some RB's are putting up -- especially in the TD area...) the first 1000/1000 running back in the game. (And lest we forget Dion Sanders in SB 29....) Aikman, we know...Smith, Irvin (not hall yet, but will be), Sanders. Bradshaw, we know...(don't have enough "ink" to list them all...) I could go on. (Bob Griese...has two...just a "fluke" that his TEAM never lost a game one year...had Czonka on it...Warfield...) The list of multiple winners when compared with who their TEAMMATES were shows clearly that it is the TEAM that wins -- not individuals. This is NOT to say that Montana wasn't GREAT (most say THE greatest QB although I think Johnny U.) or that Elway wasn't GREAT, just that INDIVIDUAL GREATNESS ALONE doesn't get you there in a team sport. You can be great on a bad team. You can be bad on a great team. It's when you have enough greatness surrounding you that you have a CHANCE at making it to and finally winning a Super Bowl. And, even then, you have to have things go your way...(You'll never convince me that the Giants were a "better team" than the Patriots. But, they won. A "miracle" escape; a "miracle" catch, followed by a good throw to a TALL receiver who held onto the ball is the difference on THAT DAY... Or the "Immaculate Reception" or the fumble that wasn't a fumble, or a missed field goal, or a 100+ yard interception return for a TD...) I'd take Dan the Man over just about anyone ... All other things being EQUAL.
CosmicConservative
Heh... an endless debate that has been fought by more knowledgeable "experts" than you or me. Back on the Cutler thing. It's funny that you mention Trent Dilfer because he's a commentator now, you know, and the local evening drive show on KOA interviewed him about Cutler. Here's what he said (paraphrased): Cutler is not that good. He COULD be good, but reality can't be denied. He's bad in the red zone. He's bad on third downs. He's bad when the game is on the line. Now he's whining and acting like he's a superstar. That's poison. If he doesn't change his tune fast, he's got to go. (This was two weeks before the trade). Dave Logan, the host and ex NFL Tight End who co-hosts the show bristled at this and challenged Dilfer but Dilfer essentially said "Dave, you're a homer. He's your guy. I'm telling you what I see when I watch him play. And that's what I get paid to do." Shannon Sharpe, the ex Denver Tight End who is now a commentator had the following to say about the trade (also paraphrased): This is idiotic. Denver is making a huge mistake. Cutler is a marquee quarterback with a great arm and a great future. His win/loss record is bad due to a bad defense. This is a rookie head coach making a rookie mistake and he will regret it. In other words, Dilfer makes more or less exactly the same argument I do, and Sharpe makes more or less the same argument you do. Since both are ex-NFL players who are paid to analyze and provide commentary for the NFL, it seems clear to me that there are two sides to this, and neither side is obviously and demonstrably "correct". We'll see how it turns out.
Drax
I agree that it's "debatable," in that he can't be definitively classified as a boon/bust at this point in his career, but don't think it's debatable about his level of TALENT. I've heard Dilfer many times on Cutler and he ALWAYS speaks in glowing terms of his talent and thought that two first rounders was just about right for this guy...sufficient to "mortgage the future..." But, he's got to get on a good team. He has to have good receivers and a good running game. He has to have an OL that keeps his jersey clean. He has to have a defense that can make stops and keep the game in reach. He has to have a head coach that knows what he's doing and doesn't call plays that makes it more likely that you make errors in the end zone (ask Warner about that...). He has to have team leaders who understand about teamwork, keeping the team in line, and pushing their teammates. He has to have his stars stay injury free. THEN he'll have a chance to make it deep into the playoffs. Then we can evaluate him against those who DO and DID have those things. What we should NEVER do is judge people's INDIVIDUAL achievements based on what their TEAM does or, at least, WEIGH those accomplishments appropriately. Only one team wins the superbowl every year. Only 43 chances in the history of football. Once you take out the "dynasties," you don't have much in the way of left-overs for the rest of the poor saps who play hard, play well...but will never get within sniffing distance of the Lombardi trophy.
CosmicConservative
Now you've got me wondering if it was Dilfer or another ex NFL QB who Dave interviewed... I thought it was Dilfer... Anyway, whoever it was has as much credibility in the debate as anyone else. Unfortunately KOA does not archive or list their interviews on their website, only their entire shows. We should never judge anyone's individual achievements based on what their team does? Really? Bill Russell? Wilt Chamberlain? Larry Bird? Babe Ruth? Michael Jordan? Lance Armstrong? etc.. So whenever anyone says "Bill Russell won 11 NBA championships" we should say "BULLHOCKEY! He just happened to be on GOOD TEAMS" Really? Hey, did you know Bill Russell was born in Monroe, Louisiana? Wow, I never knew that.
Andy
I've enjoyed reading this exchange between bros. I have nothing to add, except that I did know Bill Russell was a Monroe boy. ;)
Drax
Heh... I said: "... or weigh it appropriately." I also said something along the lines of: "The more individual a sport, the more individual achievements mean." Bill Russell -- (or any of your basketballers). 1 of 5. When he has the ball, it is HIM versus whatever is thrown at him. It is HIM going for that rebound. His FT percentage is all him. His FG percentage is not dependent on his teammates. His rebounds are not dependent on his teammates. His assists are not dependent on his teammates. (They either make it or don't and the failure to make it don't count against him.) Now, clearly he needs teammates who can help him. (And Bill Russell didn't win 11 rings. Bill Russell was a member of a team which won 11 rings.) And, what TEAMMATES he had... HOF: Bob Cousy, Andy Phillip, Sam Jones, John Havlicek, Tom Heinsohn, KC Jones, Clyde E. Lovellette, Frank V. Ramsey. Not taking anything away from Bill (who I think is the greatest of all time) but HE HAD HELP. Do we need to go into the Baseball equations? No one (Not a single person) helps a hitter hit or a fielder field. That is utterly individual. Ruth (who I think was the greatest of all time -- as you know) did what he did and would likely have done similar wherever he played. Do I HAVE to go to the record books to list one by one by one by one by one the number of Hall of Famers who helped the YANKEES win all those TITLES (as opposed to RUTH attaining all those INDIVIDUAL records...) The same is true of Bird. Have you forgotten that, for example, the 1981 season, he had Archibald, McHale, and Parish (that would be 3 or 4 HOFers on the floor at the same time)...in the 86 Season he had Walton, Parish and McHale... So...again...HE HAD SOME HELP. You're really saying that Armstrong's achievements compare to that of a Quarterback? Certainly he received some help from his teammates (that's why there are TEAMS, for cripe's sake...) but it is a very individual sport overall. Wilt was a freak. But, how many championships did he win? Two. 76ers in 67 and Lakers in 72. Why didn't he win more when he CLEARLY was the best player on the face of the planet when he wanted to play. (While I think that Russell was the best Basketball player of all time, it is BECAUSE it's a team sport. Wilt did what Wilt did when Wilt wanted to do it. On the 67 team he had HOFers Hal Greer and Billy Cunningham. On the 72 team he had Elgin Baylor (for a while), Gail Goodrich, and Jerry West (the NBA LOGO for cripe's sake..) Again...HE HAD SOME HELP. I don't know why this is even a question. The more "team" a team sport is, the more "help" you need.
CosmicConservative
LOL, As I said, more knowledgeable experts than you and I have had this debate. You may recall a long time ago about three Cutler threads ago when I compared him to Romo, I made the point that when Romo walked on the field, the whole team looked more confident, while the same was not remotely true of Cutler. Great players make their team better. Legendary players make their TEAMMATES better. There's a reason Babe Ruth, Bill Russell, Larry Bird and others were surrounded by Hall of Famers. Bill Russell, Babe Ruth and Larry Bird were in part the REASON they made it to the HOF.
Drax
Oh, I certainly agree that great players CAN make their teammates better, but not necessarily. (Iverson, Jordan before he "woke up" Ramirez, Aaron...) But, you're not really suggesting that Lou Gerhig required the Babe to make him a HOFer, are you? What was Babe doing, holding Lou's bat while he swung? Or Dimmagio? Or that Wilt's presence on the Lakers made JERRY WEST better? Certainly, a great player can make others on his team "better" simply by his presence. A basketballer who is double-teamed makes another player more open. But, he still has to make the shot. A power-hitter in baseball hitting 4th makes it more likely that the 3rd hitter will see better pitches. But, he still has to hit them. A Stockton can feed a Malone, but Malone has to knock them down.
Drax
Heh. I got a chance to see Cutler's interview today. He said much the same thing....he can't do anything without his receivers; his receivers can't do anything without him. It's how well they work together. Rice could run routes and make catches others couldn't. That made Montana better. Montana could see what others couldn't and make throws that others couldn't. That made Rice better. After working together for a while and building trust on both sides, they could RELY on the other to make the throw on time or to be where they were supposed to be on time. That "gesalt" made BOTH better. But, they both BEGIN with greatness. Each has to do his job...to make the throw...to make the catch. When you have multiple people with this level of talent...you win multiple super bowls/championships/series.
Andy
Since the fun continues...I ran across this completely by chance. Thought I'd give you guys some eye candy while you catch your breath. Don't bother to thank me... http://deadspin.com/5197633/kyle-ortons-dad-is-letting-everybody-know-how-his-son-got-traded
Drax
Somewhere in this thread I used an appropriate word... Searching... Searching... Ah...yes... "Salivating..."