Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

AIG senior VP resignation letter... interesting read

By CosmicConservative
Op-Ed Contributor - Dear A.I.G., I Quit! - NYTimes.com After 12 months of hard work dismantling the company — during which A.I.G. reassured us many times we would be rewarded in March 2009 — we in the financial products unit have been betrayed by A.I.G. and are being unfairly persecuted by elected officials. In response to this, I will now leave the company and donate my entire post-tax retention payment to those suffering from the global economic downturn. My intent is to keep none of the money myself. I take this action after 11 years of dedicated, honorable service to A.I.G. I can no longer effectively perform my duties in this dysfunctional environment, nor am I being paid to do so. Like you, I was asked to work for an annual salary of $1, and I agreed out of a sense of duty to the company and to the public officials who have come to its aid. Having now been let down by both, I can no longer justify spending 10, 12, 14 hours a day away from my family for the benefit of those who have let me down.
The amount of political posturing over these bonuses compared to the actual losses of the company has been a national disgrace. The spectacle of our elected officials on a public witch hunt to demonize businessmen is another disgrace. I can't put it much more clearly than the letter, so read the whole thing. Instapundit leads this with the question of whether this is a letter from John Galt. There is no doubt a bit of Galtness to it.

Comments (17)

Drax
Whenever I read something about the "outrage," as expressed by our elected officials (from every side) I can barely restrain myself from screaming. The "outrage" stems from the "bonuses" which were received by members of AIG -- "bonuses" which came from tax payers' money. (I write "bonuses" in parenthesis because, in great part, they were no more "extra" money than a "signing bonus" for a football player is "extra money," i.e., it was simply part of the agreed upon pay for the employee -- structured in such a fashion as to maximize the benefit both to the employer and the employee. It is a TERM OF ART -- not any "extra pay" based on performance, but part of the EXPECTED pay from the perspective of both parties to the contract which promised it...) Now, the PREMISE of the "outrage" is that we are paying these "bonuses" to employees of AIG (from taxpayer money) when they are the employees of the very people who helped "crash" the American/World Economy. This is where I go offtrack on this issue. Our "outraged" elected representatives clearly think that it's entirely appropriate to give these SAME PEOPLE 165 BILLION dollars to do with as they please but think that they're SO INCOMPETENT that they don't deserve their contracted for pay when they do. Why doesn't someone ask Frank and Dodd WHY it's a "good" decision to give these SAME PEOPLE 165 BILLION DOLLARS to do with as they please with almost NO restrictions when Frank and Dodd clearly think that they're SO INCOMPETENT that they don't deserve their pay?
CosmicConservative
... because logic isn't part of this. This is pure political pandering where Dodd and his peers have tried to tap into public outrage to further their political agendas. Nothing else.
Drax
CC: Heh, I fully understand that it's "political posturing." What I don't understand is why even the most conservative of commentators don't ask this question. Either AIG employees are competent enough to receive 165 Billion dollars to do with essentially as they please or they are too incompetent to receive their agreed upon pay for doing so. Frankly, I agree with Geitner, Dodd and the Administration in its (obvious) agreement to allow AIG to pay its employees the pay it agreed upon. If you want those people to stay and work at a company which may dissapear at any moment (with their jobs...) you have to give them incentive to do so AND that incentive must approximate or exceed the pay that they would receive in the open market for their expertise. Further, it simply would have been (under normal, non-pitchfork bearing Congressmen circumstances) much, much more expensive for the Government to fight those contracts. Under Connecticut law (and almost certainly pursuant to the terms of the contract) the party which breached the contract would have been liable for the other side's attorney's fees (and their own), court costs, interest from date of demand, and PUNITIVE damages (double or treble...) At the time of the negotiations, apparently the Administration and the Legislative members didn't figure that they could extort the bonus recepients with threats of taxing them into the stone-age and/or PUBLISHING THEIR NAMES so that ACORN and other insane people could picket their HOMES -- or allow some of those who made death threats to more easily carry them out. No, the decision to pay the obligations that the Government ASSUMED when they bought up 80% of AIG in the name of the American People was the CORRECT one...it was the LEGAL one...it was the RATIONAL one...it was the MORAL one. So, of course, it was immediately repudiated by the worthless, lying sacks of human excrement we vote into office year after year after year ... even though we know that they are worthless, lying sacks of human excrement.
CosmicConservative
Drax, you and I are pretty much on the same page here. I said from the beginning that the only "outrage" I felt over the bonuses was the fact that Obama has inexplicably been able to blame GW Bush for a bill that was written under his administration, with language his Treasury Secretary put in the bill, and voted on almost entirely by Democrats. Yet he still blames Bush publicly for the fiasco. How he gets away with that without being laughed off of his teleprompter-laced podium is completely beyond me. All I know is that it proves to me that this country is doomed. Our citizens have become so ignorant and so swayed by image that basic, provable, fundamental facts no longer have any weight in public discourse. Ideology is all that matters.
Drax
CC: I don't know about "doomed," as I have high hopes for the 2010 and 2012 elections, but we are clearly in a heap of trouble.
Old Goat
Think about this selective tax of 90% that our "wonderful" elected leaders are trying to get put on these bonuses. Most of the higher paid people who received these are giving them back. Its for the simple reason that it saves them money than keeping it. Those bonuses also get hit with state and FICA taxes which when coupled with the 90% tax rate of the Feds amounts to 102%. I find it really troubling that there is no outrage over this. This is just a set up to float out the absurd tax rate of 90% so when they get around to raising the taxes for the upper income earners to 60% it will seem like a bargain. They are attacking the people who help make this country run. This is part of the push to socialism. Is there any word on who hired the bus to bring those people to the AIG homes? Where is the outrage from that?
CosmicConservative
ACORN hired the bus. I think there is plenty of outrage at the retroactive tax. I do expect that to get challenged in court and at this time, from what I know about the Constitution's provision against "punitive taxes" I would think the current SCOTUS would rule this unconstitutional. But I've been wrong before. The best thing about this tax and this whole situation is that it is likely to cause other companies to reject government bailout money.
Drax
CC: I've heard that Wells Fargo and at least one other "financial institution" are going to give the money back. I know that Wells Fargo raised three kinds of hell over being "forced" to take the TARP money in the first place. I'm not really sure what has changed that Wells Fargo now believes that it is no longer "forced" to take the money. I'll do some research.
Drax
Old Goat: I think that you, like many, simply give Obama too much credit. He ain't that smart. The 90% punitive tax is just what it appears to be, i.e., the politcal class doing what it does best -- covering its collective arse when it appears that they may be in danger of losing their jobs. Obama didn't propose it. He just knows which way the wind is blowing.
Drax
CC: Hmmm. Seems that U.S. Bancorp, Goldman Sachs & Wells Fargo are talking about "returning" the TARP money. I'm not sure how they can do it, though. They issued STOCK to the U.S. government in exchange for the cash. (In the case of Wells Fargo, 25,000 shares of preferred stock @ $1,000,000.00 per share.) That stock pays dividends (5% cumulative in Wells Fargo's case.) I'm not sure how they can get a "do-over" without the government's consent.
Drax
Heh, the Iberia Bank of Lafayette, LA wants to return the money as well... Bet it's the first time the Iberia Bank of Lafayette, LA made the NY Times...
Old Goat
Drax, Obama isn't dumb. While this may not be solely his idea, he is the face of the democrat party and this is right in their play book. The tax rate during the time of Kennedy for the upper level of earners was near 90%, if I remember correctly. Kennedy reduced it to around 70%. You think these dems wouldn't love to go back to that kind of punitive tax rate? Its a move toward socialism, and by hammering on the business folk, the way the dems and especially Obamalamadingdong is doing, its all about setting the stage so there won't be outrage.
Drax
Old Goat: Dick Morris has opined some similar conspiracy thoughts. He's been so wrong about so many things lately that I don't give him much credence any more. No. Obama isn't dumb. I agree that he's a socialist and have been saying as much for much longer than most. However, I don't think that he has the ability to orchestrate the "outrage" (without which the 90% tax would be impossible).
Old Goat
Drax, its not like Obama is alone in his desire to transform this country into some socialist model though. Couple him with Pelosi and Reid and a good portion of the MSM, with Obama spearheading this. I didn't even read or hear anything Morris wrote or said. It just seems to me that all this stuff is playing too cozy with an end game in sight. Look at how fast this group is trying to work. Pushing legislation. Creating more worries within the stock market by the constant doom and gloom talk. It isn't all that hard to fool the masses, unfortunately. Heck, this past election proves that.
Drax
Old Goat: I agree in the thrust of your post. Obama is a socialist, a "true believer." He has been directed towards this job from an early age with the "transformative" goal as his ultimate achievement. As you note, the alignment of the stars is in his favor -- Pelosi, Reed, the MSM following a "Republican" President who abrogated most of conservative values at least in a fiscal sense. This explains his agenda, his spending, his willingness to ignore/trample all dissenting voices regarding the danger of bankrupting the U.S. with his agenda. He is WILLING to do so so long as he gets his agenda passed. He is completely willing to accept a "one term Presidency" so long as he gets his agenda passed. I do have hope that the public (or enough of them -- or enough of those who vote anyway) will see him for what he is, will see Pelosi and Reid (and the MSM) for what they are before it's too late to reverse course, because I'm fairly certain that, once Health Care is Nationalized there is no way to turn back that clock.
Old Goat
Yeah, while its always possible to fight against something such as healthcare becoming nationalized, once it goes that way it is almost impossible to take it back. The only thing I am not quite so convinced of is that Obama is willing to be a one term President. Unless he is banking on becoming the first dictator of the US. I have to wonder if things will be slowed down enough for 2010 to bring in enough change and hope (pun intended) to derail these aims and goals. That is about the best we can hope for, and I have fears that with groups like Acorn, we will never see a truly fair election again.
Drax
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB123879833094588163.html Hold onto your saddles...gonna be a bumpy ride...