Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Environmentalists" want human population cut in half...

By CosmicConservative
Actually they want more than that, but that's all they are willing to admit.
UK population must fall to 30m, says Porritt - Times Online Such views on population have split the green movement. George Monbiot, a prominent writer on green issues, has criticised population campaigners, arguing that “relentless” economic growth is a greater threat. Many experts believe that, since Europeans and Americans have such a lopsided impact on the environment, the world would benefit more from reducing their populations than by making cuts in developing countries.
I'll come right out and say it. If we want human civilization to be self-sustaining we need to either develop far more efficient ways of managing resources, or we need to have a lot less people. One of the two is going to happen. Eventually, when humans leave earth, human population growth potential becomes effectively infinite, but here on earth there is a practical limit that is based on three fundamental things. Space, efficiency and energy. Eventually the laws of thermodynamics even apply to human population. Note how the desire is to slash U.S. and European populations first though. Don't you love that?

Comments (9)

Dadman
So, when does human euthanasia for the good of Mother Earth begin in earnest?
mtnlurker
Nah, they just need to get with the Jihadists and work something out.
CosmicConservative
Dadman: I would suggest that human euthenasia began in earnest in this country on Jan 22, 1973.
Dadman
Heh. That's true. I guess the question is when do they plan to expand the practice to those who have already been born. And liberals think conservatives are scary...
reggie
I think that in the name of "saving the earth," all "environmentalists" should go and jump, immediately, into the nearest active volcano.
Dadman
From the article:
However, Porritt is winning scientific backing. Professor Chris Rapley, director of the Science Museum, will use the OPT conference, to be held at the Royal Statistical Society, to warn that population growth could help derail attempts to cut greenhouse gas emissions.
Expect 'science' to be politicized in the population debate in much the same way it has in the AGW debate. Once 'science' dictates that each new baby is a threat the continued existence of the human species (which will no doubt be the most ironic argument ever devised) you can expect the Left's culture of death to be expanded significantly - with government endorsement and enforcement.
Old Goat
We must look at the larger viewpoint. If the environmentalists can eliminate us humans from the planet, just think of how enjoyable the world will be then. No clutter of buildings and roads and cars and trucks. No greenhouse gases. It will be great for our grandchildren, with the small caviot that they won't exist, but hey, no one is perfect.
Andy
You know Cosmic, I have been reading about "developing countries" my whole life. Surely, there are countries that have developed in my lifetime...China, India, etc. As they have developed, their populations have mushroomed, and consumed ever larger amounts of resources, energy, etc. The earth will regulate it's population. Either by flood, famine, plague, drought, global cooling, war, or the common sense of it's human residents (which I doubt will be a major factor), it will not become over-populated. Every war is fought over either religion, or resources...most over resources. Even wars fought over religion really have at their heart "the resources of the other guy." It's the, "that guy has better stuff than me, so I want it even if I'm not smart enough to manage it when I take it away from him, but I'm gonna take it anyway because I want it...so I'll justify this in my mind because that guy is a heathen that didn't deserve it in the first place, blah blah blah." Where was I? Oh yeah...if the planet is able to sustain human life "indefinitely" there will have to be right-thinking people in charge of decision making, an adherence to morality, and true freedom worldwide. I hope we haven't, but I'm afraid that we have crossed that line in the sand where any one of those stands a chance...if there ever was one...
Bongo
Listen up. They are not advocating human culling of any kind. Just for people to consider the kind of world they are going to leave behind for their children. It's all very well people wanting three kids or more, but the world can't sustain indefinite growth when everyone's surviving and consuming much longer than nature originally intended (i.e. before healthcare). And IT'S TRUE. THE WORLD CANNOT SUSTAIN INDEFINITE HUMAN POPULATION GROWTH. Absolute fact. It's selfish to pop out 3 kids or more without any regard to what they'll be left with (I.e. not to provide for them), and it's equally selfish to do so on a global scale, condemning our future kids to a world that's overpolluted, over-exploited and under-nourished. Besides, would you want to live in a vision of a crowded future where food is scarce because we've screwed every habitiat there is for a quick buck? Yes, it's happening right now. Land is turning to desert where quick-fix farming and logging is short-sightedly ruining it for a fast profit. We are not living a sustainable existence in the West - we'll find that out soon enough. Indeed, will the future just be a melee of war after war over the last bits of oil, water and viable land? Will the 9 billion people in the world by 2050 be turning to wondering which part of the globe they should make themselves refugees to get into, because of this land loss? How depressing, no? People just need to be considerate that's all. It's easy to imagine nothing will ever affect YOUR family if you live in a nice safe part of the world at the moment. I live in the UK and it SEEMS safe for now. What would happen if the climate changed or crops failed elsewhere in the world - the UK can't feed its own 70 million people on the farmland it has, that's for sure. We need to be careful because now most personal sustainable lifestyles are gone, most are dependent on supermarkets for their food, and those on global markets and multinational companies. If those fall through we WILL go hungry. It's plain to see, but nobody even thinks about it, seemingly. Environmentalists don't want to 'eliminate' human beings, they want human beings to be aware that WE ALL DEPEND ON THE LAND TO GET FED AND WATERED, AND IF WE RUIN IT, WHERE WILL WE GET OUR FOOD AND WATER? Will it fall out of the sky? No. So please stop being ignorant and jumping on them for saying what is the simple truth - there's a limit to how much we can use and abuse the Earth's resources.