Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The goods on the Rocket?

By CosmicConservative
Not a good day for Roger Clemens.
WASHINGTON — Tests have linked Roger Clemens' DNA to blood in syringes that his former personal trainer says he used to inject the pitcher with performance-enhancing drugs, according to a report. Citing two unidentified sources familiar with the investigation, The Washington Post reported Tuesday that the DNA results are preliminary and subject to verification tests.
Of course it's going to be called evidence tampering by Clemens' lawyer, but when this goes to court, and it looks more and more likely that it will, the question is going to be who the jurors believe, Roger Clemens accusation that McNamee "manufactured" the evidence, or McNamee who says he kept the needles and gauze to protect himself against exactly this eventuality. I think the noose is getting tighter and tighter. If there was any chance of Clemens getting to the HOF, these DNA results might just have blown that away.

Comments (3)

Old Goat
There are really big problems that any court case against Clemens would have to face. First off, holding onto the syringes doesn't prove anything. They had his DNA on them, OK. That only proves that his DNA is shown in trace on them, it does not conclusively prove they were used on him, nor do they prove that they were used to inject him with PEDs. The burden of proof falls on the prosecution in this case. There are no positive tests that show that Clemens used PEDs during his career. The only ones who are saying they saw him use the drugs are criminals. Pettitte only testified that they had a conversation about PED use, and while it leans toward Clemens being guilty of lying, again, this is strickly a he said - he said type of thing. Do I think Clemens used? Yeah. It sure seems that way. Is there absolute proof? Nope. There is the word of a criminal who avoided prosecution if he ratted people out. DNA on a needle when Clemens claimed to take B12 shots is very thin evidence to hang him on. Though with the Dems in control of the judiciary who knows if this matters. There is no chain of custody, and frankly it is exceedingly strange and even points to further criminal behavior for McNamee to have kept the syringes in the first place. Why did he "only" keep things from Clemens? What was it really for? Blackmail in the future? What if it was a set up? McNamee was a disgraced former police officer who lied which lead to him being fired from the NYC police department. The phone call issue was a set up by BOTH sides to try and trap the other. McNamee is dirty. So is Rodomski. Their stories don't fully mesh either. Add to that the Mitchell report using taxpayer money to assist in a private and expensive report that was no where near conclusive or broad in its scope, and there are tons of ethics violations going on here. I think this is a scare tactic, but if it goes to court it will have major problems that no prosecution would like to face. This is far different from the Bonds case. There are test results that show Bonds blood levels include steroids. Clemens is an arrogant jerk, but I just don't see this having the legs to bring him down. Not with a fair and just legal system.
CosmicConservative
Goat: I disagree. I think that this qualifies not only as circumstantial evidence, but also as physical evidence which corroborates a witness's testimony. I think the Clemens legal team will try to get it thrown out as evidence, and they may be successful, but they also may not be. The bottom line is that in the absence of a smoking gun, trials routinely turn to circumstantial evidence to make or break a case. This (along with other circumstantial evidence and testimony) may not be enough to convict Clemens in a criminal trial, but I suspect that McNamee's long-term goal is a civil trial and that will have a far lower bar to reach than a criminal trial. But from a financial and reputation perspective it will have similar results for Clemens. I'd say the odds are that Clemens will beat the rap of the perjury charge, but that he will lose the civil trial, and that will be more than enough to convict him in the eyes of the public, and in the eyes of the HOF voters. As far as I'm concerned, I was pretty much convinced that Clemens was a drugged up faux athlete when his physical appearance changed significantly and his performance improved dramatically in his mid-thirties. Which is exactly what happened with Bonds and McGwire, two peers of Clemens who I think have been proven beyond a shadow of a doubt to have been users. Clemens is a cheater and a criminal. He cheated baseball, the fans and cheated at least three deserving pitchers out of a Cy Young award they earned through hard work and sacrifice instead of by pumping their blood full of chemicals. I have always disliked Clemens, I admit that. He has always come across to me as an arrogant, classless jerk who plays the game dirty. I was unsurprised when initial allegations of drug use surfaced in large part because such a possibility matched my personal opinion of Clemens to a T. His arrogance and lack of personal ethics predates his drug use, but imho presaged it as well. I hope he goes down hard. I really do. It's hard for me to express how much I truly despise him and others of his ilk who despoiled the game of Baseball and cheated deserving honest athletes from the achievements and awards they EARNED the right, hard and decent way. If I were baseball commissioner, I would revoke his Cy Young awards and give them to the men who took "second place" but did so without resorting to chemical enhancement.