Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Closing Gitmo (and other Obama actions)

By CosmicConservative
OK, so among the first things Obama did in his official capacity as POTUS is to sign an executive order "closing" the Guantonimo Bay prison facility. In doing so he repeated a mantra he and his surrogates have been promulgating for weeks, which is that "It is a false dichotomy to say our ideals are in conflict with our safety." There are multiple levels to address here, and all of them, frankly, are bad. First, this platitude that Obama has been spewing is one of the more obviously incorrect platitudes that anyone could possibly conceive of. I know Obama cannot possibly be stupid enough to actually believe that there is no conflict between ideals and safety. Such conflicts are so obvious and so prevalent that it is almost like speaking to a two year old to point them out. Example: Automobile licensing and the freedom to drive where and when we like on our highway system has the direct and obvious result of 30,000 - 40,000 annual highway deaths and untold personal injury carnage. This is fifteen to twenty times the death toll of our entire war in Iraq ANNUALLY. Yet we endure it because the PERSONAL SAFETY we sacrifice is considered APPROPRIATE in the context of the PERSONAL FREEDOM we enjoy. Anyone who cannot see this is simply an idiot. The fact that the press does not point this out is just one more example of the fawning sycophancy of the press which will continue for an unknown period. So, since it is OBVIOUS that our national ideology NECESSARILY is in conflict with our PERSONAL SAFETY on a REGULAR AND ONGOING BASIS, the question that must be asked, is what is the actual national security risk that Obama's executive order creates or exacerbates? The answer is pretty simple frankly. If we close Gitmo we have essentially three choices. Each of those choices has its own national security risk. 1. Let the prisoners go free. Since we have seen scores of released Gitmo prisoners turn up on the battlefield shooting at US soldiers already, it should be obvious even to someone like Obama that simply letting them go is going to result in more guns pointed at US soldiers and more casualties in the battle. I put this in the "duh" category of analysis. Besides that, SOME of them will eschew the battlefield in favor of targeting innocent civilians, a much easier target with much higher PR returns for their ideology. So releasing them IMMEDIATELY exponentially increases the risk of massive U.S. civilian casualties. 2. Move them to another off-shore prison facility. Well, the problem with this is that Obama has already promised that he won't do this. Not only has he ordered the CIA to end all "secret prison" arrangements with foreign nations, he has said that he will not use foreign prisons to hold these enemy combatants because, in his view, those foreign countries do not adhere to U.S. ideals of due process, interrogation and general prisoner treatment. So this option is cut off entirely. Which leaves... 3. Move them to US prisons. Which is what most experts immediately assume is Obama's plan. In fact several states (including Colorado) have already begun drafting legislation that will attempt to BAR Obama from moving the Gitmo prisoners to their state facilities. The reason for that is that the officials in those states charged with public safety of their citizens IMMEDIATELY recognize the UNPRECEDENTED danger of putting enemy military combatants in the general prison population. This is dangerous for two reasons. First there is the danger to existing domestic prisoners from hardened sworn enemies of the United States. These people may be prisoners, but their safety is still our responsibility, and putting them in the position of being captive targets of men who have promised to kill Americans anywhere and everywhere they find them is monumentally irresponsible. But that's not the reason I object to putting Gitmo prisoners in the general prison population. I am much more concerned about the certainty that these men will recruit NEW terrorists from a population of sociopaths and psycopaths that populate our prisons already. Anyone who knows anything about prisons in this country should know that the most troublesome aspect of our prison system is the domination of the culture by violent gangs. Currently most of those gangs are racially based, but there is already a proiminent radical muslim element to many of those gangs. Those groups are RIPE for further radicalization by Islamic jihadists who will recruit them and organize them into terrorist cells which operate in the prisons and which will then extend their reach into the local communities where prisoners are released, or where they have family or community connections. This, in fact, is why GW Bush has kept them in Gitmo. Make no mistake about it, With one swipe of the pen President Barack Obama has just made YOUR personal safety MUCH less secure in spite of his much-repeated platitudes. On a related note, Obama has signed two other Executive Orders, one to release what had previously been privileged top-secret documentation at the Presidential and Vice President level. The purpose of this is simply to provide fodder for fishing expeditions for the still raging Bush Deranged lunatics in the House and Senate. This is very disappointing because it is a purely political thing that is clearly intended to do nothing but placate the hard left whose most powerful motivation is to hate GW Bush. Also he has signed an order to "end torture" which is completely meaningless since the U.S. has never PERFORMED torture according to any actual legal review of U.S. interrogation policies, and the ONE procedure that is at the center of the whole "torture" accusation (waterboarding) was made illegal by GW Bush in 2006. This move is purely symbolic and is intended to do nothing but placate the far left Bush Deranged average citizen who is incapable of recognizing actual policy and fact and instead reacts (and votes) on a purely emotional basis. So, overall I have to say that these actions do not bode well for an actual Obama Presidency. We are less safe, he has thrown the rabid Bush deranged wolves a bone that may embroil Washington DC in fractious partisan fighting for years, and he has demonstrated a willingness to ignore reality and react to partisan hatred when it suits his political goals. Hope and change folks. I hope you realize what just changed.

Comments (11)

Bart the Builder
Cosmic: I had never thought the REAL consequences for closing gitmo and specifically your point number 3 moving gitmo detainees to the US general jail populous. Of course I never really dreamed we would actually see an Obama presidency! Please wake me up from this terrible dream!!! How come I never heard John McCain or for that matter any Republican make the point you did about the inherent problem of mixing the gitmo detainees with our prison system. I definitely agree with you the gang systems within our prisons would be ripe for Islamic extremist to indoctrinate a whole new jihad gang on the streets of America. This would be just as difficult to combat on the streets of America as it is for our soldiers in Iraq and Afganistan.
CosmicConservative
Bart: You haven't heard it because it doesn't fit the media's narrative.
esox67
Unfortanetely, our prisons are already ripe with Islamic extremists. Yes Comic, you are also correct that this is one of many topics the media cannot seem to find directions in its manual to report on, as it goes against their oath to defend any and all opposition to their anointed party of choice.
Old Goat
I did hear talk about how Gitmo being closed would mean that those prisoners would have to be moved, likely to the US. It was talked about a good deal, but the MSM ignored it. Interesting little tidbit. A former detainee of Gitmo has emerged as a terrorist... aQ's number 2. This news is out right after hearing Obama signing the Executive Order that Gitmo be closed in a year. Of course Obama doesn't actually have to close it, a year is a long time for other "facts" to come out, or "unforeseen" problems will arise. It just gives me goosebumps that Obama was elected. Change we might live with. Or not.
Dadman
I dunno. Moving these guys to a U.S. maximum security prison populated with blood-thirsty murderers might just be the solution to this messy problem. I say lock them up with the White Supremacists and see how long they last...
Old Goat
Dadman, while that might be a nice simple solution, I bet this administration would go out of its way to protect them. The Democrats also wanted to give them every legal protect that a US citizen has. During the Clintonian era, they treated terrorism as though it was a criminal act, rather than an act of war. It helped lead to 9/11, as they felt there was little consequence to mounting such an attack when it would end up in American Courts. Having them on American soil just invites them into this country instead of keeping them out, as was the whole reason behind Gitmo. Yeminis are the majority of detainees, and they are major supporters of al Qaeda. The al Qaeda number two man is from Yemin, and HAD been in US custody in Gitmo. That doesn't exactly make me sleep better at night, knowing we had him and let him go. How much more so will it be against us when we allow others out?
Boyd
Your analysis is hampered by being quite wrong on your point #2. President Obama has not said he will not send prisoners to other foreign counties; he has said he won't send them to other countries where they'll be tortured. There's quite a lot of talk about sending them to various European nations, which opens up another argument entirely. But the "Obama said he won't send Gitmo prisoners to other countries" is flat wrong. And that's why that's what will happen, in one form or another.
CosmicConservative
Boyd, Perhaps I misunderstood Obama's pledge on that. We'll see if turns out to be right. If that is right, I find it morally indefensible that we would put our allies at that same sort of risk.
Andy
Cosmic, I really do believe that this is much ado about nothing. 6 months from now, one of Obama's spokesmen will come out and say that this issue is much more complex than we understood...the Bush administration was so secretive that we didn't have all the facts when this order was signed...yada yada yada. His statement will come on a Friday press dump, and none of his kool-aid drinkers will really care anymore. Behind the scenes, Obama will have been told that there is no good solution to the problem with the prisoners at GTMO. Nobody wants them here in the US, etc., etc., etc. Heck, I'd be glad for Obama to close GTMO and move the prisoners all right here to NW Louisiana. You know he's not going to put them in gen.pop anywhere...so a new Camp X-Ray would have to be built. We could use the construction jobs... But it ain't gonna happen. I truly do not mind at all bringing them to US soil (other than the fact that it's a waste of effort and money). What concerns me is affording them US civilian court rights. I can just see the first trial...The terrorist takes the stand, and his defense attorney asks, "Were you told when taken into custody that you had the right to remain silent, the right to an attorney, etc...?" "No...the evil satan did not apprise me of my rights." A big old can of ugly judicial worms will work their way through the courts, and it will become an International Circus. As ugly as this sounds, I think we need to close GTMO, and arrange to transport all prisoners to Miami on a leaky boat with a bad engine.
mtnlurker
Why can't we put them back on the battlefield and then shoot them?
Andy
Heh! I think mtnlurker just solved the problem. Wish I'd said that...