Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Obama's reading list...

By CosmicConservative
Here's the list of books that Obama has mentioned as being on his reading list and which have influenced his political and practical philosophy, as reported by "Omnivoracious" a reading and writing blog.
We've been tracking, and speculating on, Barack Obama's reading on a regular basis here (e.g., Fareed Zakaria, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Fred Kaplan, and JFK), and from various press reports (and his Facebook page), we've cobbled together a list of books he's mentioned reading, and in most cases admiring, in different places, for our Inauguration 2009 store.
I won't reproduce the list here, if you want to see it, go check it out. Here are my thoughts on the list though: If this is a true example of the sort of books that Obama reads, it seems remarkably one, or maybe two, dimensional. It's heavy on politics and philosophy, but in reality there's not much there. And on the philosophy side, it's very light philosophy, almost pop-culture philosophy in fact. The fictional books listed are suspisciously "English Lit Prof approved." I mean Hemingway, Steinbeck, Melville, Shakespeare... Where is Clive Clessler? Steven King? Michael Crichton? Tom Clancy? The only book on the list that I see that is remotely "enjoyable reading" material is the Harry Potter series, but I suspect if you asked him he'd say he read them because of his kids. What bothers me about this list is not what is ON it, but what is NOT on it. For example, there is nothing on the list that remotely covers any sort of military history, strategy, philosophy or implementation. No "Art of War." No "Blackhawk Down." No "Red Storm Rising." Nothing remotely indicating any interest whatsoever in the understanding of the role, history and utilization of the military. This seems a remarkable omission for a man who intends to become the Commander in Chief of the largest and most powerful armed forces in the history of the world. There is nothing remotely addressing technology or science. Neither fact nor fiction. Does Obama have even a rudimentary understanding of nanotechnology? Computer science? Physics? Anything outside of the most narrow, dust-filled halls of the liberal arts? Not that you can tell from this list he doesn't. Does Obama know the difference between nuclear fusion and fission? Does he understand the differences between the main competing efforts to achieve nuclear fusion? Does he have any understanding whatsoever of the technical complications of a manned Mars mission? Does he understand what a cyclotron does and how it reveals the secrets of the sub-atomic world? I dunno. Even in his political readings, the choices he makes seem almost archaic. Sure he should understand the history of FDR, but wouldn't a biography of Reagan be more useful in today's world? Of course I recognize that this sort of nitpicking of a reading list is exactly what Sarah Palin was trying to avoid when she dodged Katie Couric's question about what she read, so I admit that this is a nitpicky and perhaps even snarky comment on Obama. But it still strikes me as very disturbing that Obama's idea of what books would guide him through the difficult 21st century as President hearken back to the era of Lincoln and FDR, and are heavily laced with Leftist historical and philosophical interpretations of things. I frankly would feel a whole lot better if I had seen Winston Churchill's "History of the English Speaking People" or Henry Kissinger's memoirs, or at least ONE book representing a conservative perspective. And also I'd feel a lot better to have seen at least a few pop culture fictional books that demonstrate some appreciation of light reading, something by Tom Wolfe, or Terry Pratchett perhaps. Of course I'd love to see "Lord of the Rings" on the list, since I think that is perhaps the greatest fictional book ever written... I suspect that this list is a carefully vetted list that is contrived, as so much around Obama is contrived, to create a specific image for the man. It reads to me like the list a college sophomore would turn in to his professor in an attempt to impress and influence a higher grade in his class. I suspect if you checked Obama's actual nightstand you'd find some lighter and more contemporary reading there.

Comments (6)

comorlock
The Post American World was seen in Obama's hands during the campaign. I have not read it but have seen reviews of it and it is a horribly researched book. It draws conclusions like we are in the final days of American as leading country in the world and that that is a good thing. Even the FDR books, from what I understand, do not paint a realistic picture of FDR's accomplishments. If Obama uses FDR policies for this recession it will last many more years.
Betsy
Compare and contrast the list of books from the annual reading contest between GWB and Karl Rove.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, that's what I meant by a "Leftist interpretation" of history or philosophy. I have to think that Obama is at least as plugged into the policy debate as I am, and I am well aware that the majority of economists and historians today grudgingly agree that FDR's actions prolonged and potentially intensified the Great Depression. I can't believe that Obama has not at least been presented with that analysis. Again I suspect that this list of books is largely fictional itself, and is carefully designed to cultivate the image of Obama the thoughtful, intelligent academic. I simply don't buy it. These are not the sorts of books a person with Obama's personality would read for pleasure. Even so I wish he (or whoever compiled the list) had thought to throw in a "Louis L'Amour" or "Zane Gray" novel just to show what a down-home American guy Obama really is...
CosmicConservative
Betsy: Some other blogs have actually done that comparison, and frankly Cheney, Rove and Bush come off looking pretty good in that comparison.
esox67
I was hoping to see "The Prince", or Democracy in America" but wishful thinking on my part I guess. Standard reading along with Locke's Treatise on Government in my political science degree. I am not sure I want to know what they teach at Harvard.
Old Goat
That list would be about 3 months worth of the reading that I do. Frankly it is a very weak list, though I am hopeful that it isn't comprehensive. Heck, I own more hard covered books than that. I make an effort to read views of both sides of the spectrum, as its the only way to truly formulate a well thought viewpoint of your own. I really don't care about light reading being included, though the Harry Potter series was probably more aimed at showing populist reading as part of his own. They really aren't the type of books that you sit down and read to your kids at night.