Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Of Myth and Message...

By CosmicConservative
So... I've been contemplating writing again. I haven't attempted to write anything for almost two years now, in fact since my father passed away. But lately I've been thinking more often about getting back to the keyboard and putting words to paper. As such I've been looking back over the craft part of writing, and reading up on successful techniques and the styles and practices of great writers, particularly of great fantasy or sci-fi writers. This sort of thing inevitably leads to Joseph Campbell and his thoughts and teachings on the power of myth, the use of archetypes, and the human attraction to a particular epic story arc. From memory the Campbellian epic myth arc goes something like this: 1. The protagonist of the story begins as a reluctant participant in their own story. 2. The protagonist carries some seed of prophetic greatness (usually genetic, but not always). 3. The antagonist (usually a demigod or even god) knows about the existence of the protagonist, but not specific enough to immediately locate them, and so seeks out the protagonist through minions or some supernatural (or technological) power. 4. The protagonist is identified and attacked, usually through his family, and barely escapes alive. 5. The protagonist is effectively forced through custom, anger or loyalty into pledging battle against the antagonist. 6. The protagonist joins forces with an aging, once-powerful source of wisdom and training who both warns the protagonist of his travails ahead, and provides wisdom and training to unlock the protagonist's prophesied abilities. 7. The protagonist joins forces with a small group of unusual, usually widely diverse allies whose abilities are not nearly as powerful as the protagonist, but whose activities serve to provide the stimulus in unlocking the protagonist's prophesied powers. 8. The protagonist meets a series of ever-more-challenging obstacles and eventually succeeds in unleashing his inner power, frequently in the process of saving one of his allies. 9. The protagonist almost succeeds in defeating the antagonist, but at the last second is betrayed by one of his supposed allies. 10. The protagonist is forced to escape, regroup and eventually engage in a final, climactic confrontation with the antagonist where the protagonist wins an overwhelming victory. 11. The protagonist is heaped with praise, adulation and acknowledgment of his fulfillment of prophesy. Now, this particular formula has clearly been used very successfully for thousands of years. And for the most part I think Campbell gets this right. Done properly this story arc is probably the most compelling and universally engaging story arc that humans react to in a positive manner. Here is a short list of stories that follow this arc almost to the letter: 1. Gilgamesh 2. Beowulf 3. The Iliad 4. The Odyssey 5. The Lord of the Rings 6. Star Wars 7. Shane 8. The Chronicles of Narnia 9. Harry Potter etc. etc... And of course I love all of those stories. But there is something about that formula that has always sort of bugged me. I think I've finally sort of worked it out. The whole business of the elite superman who is born to rule, or born to excel is not very egalitarian. I mean Harry Potter did not achieve his powers through study and practice, he was born to them. As was Luke Skywalker. Of all the stories above, probably the one that diverges most from the fundamental story arc is actually The Lord of the Rings, since Frodo and Sam represent the "everyman" and are the true heroes of the book. In most of the stories the only role the "everyman" has in the story is to serve as cannon fodder or comic relief. The stories are presented as battles between the opposing wills of the superman protagonist and the demigod antagonist. Entire villages, cities or planets can be wiped out and the reader is not led to care about their lives except as markers to prove how evil the antagonist is. In some cases even the hero lays about with abandon, creating his own mountain of innocent corpses (particularly Achilles). In fact the reader is usually presented with a choice between the personal dictates of the antagonist against that of the protagonist. There's not a lot of room for, say, democratic self-rule, involved in these stories. So I'm wondering what that says about humans in general. Does it mean that humans truly yearn for the rule of a benevolent dictator who rules by right of divine decree? George Lucas actually said that. One of the acknowledged themes of his Star Wars movies is that the best form of rule is a benevolent dictatorship of elites with divine powers. George actually is proud of that. I guess he doesn't care much for all the messy nonsense that surrounds a democratic society. So now I'm trying to decide if I really should follow that story arc if I want to write a story. It's a fairly well-proven formula to attempt, and I don't deny that one of my main motivations to EVENTUALLY write a successful novel is to MAKE SOME MONEY. But as I said, the more I think about that formula, the more I think it is a bit too elitist for my taste... What do you think?

Comments (14)

Bob Hawkins
Well, you don't insist on commercial success on a Star Wars scale, do you? So you still have a choice.
CosmicConservative
What's wrong with Star Wars levels of commercial success?
Jack
CC: You have to write for the love of it. Money should be a low motivator because it's so hard to make money in fiction writing. There are only about a 1000 novelists in the world who earn a living writing. For the vast majority it's an extremely low-paying part-time job. But, hey, if it's something you'd love to do, money shouldn't be a factor. I've pursued screenwriting and filmmaking as a career for decades and though I now earn money from those, I don't earn (quite) enough to do it as a full-time profession (yet), though next year's really shaping up to be a life-changer. But I always take the "we'll see" attitude on those things. That being said, there's few things more satisfying than realizing an artistic dream like standing in a book store and seeing your book on the shelf. Or sitting in the movie theater watching your movie (which I've experienced) or flipping through the cable channels and seeing your movie (which I've experienced). I doubt there's a drug that can give a greater rush than those experiences. Jack P.S. My film is on the premium channels 11 times this month and 18 times next month. It will play the premium channels for sometime but eventually be available on the basic channels. I'll let you know.
CosmicConservative
Jack: Please do let us know. As far as writing for the love of it, heh, I've been doing that most of my life. I have reams of writing done that way, but none of it made much money. I've written one novel, one how-to book, several short stories, one novella, a book of poetry and dozens of articles. Of those the only ones that got published were the articles, most of which were tech-related articles for a magazine I was the managing editor of, or for hiking reviews I did for the online version of the Rocky Mountain News a few years ago. My submissions to publishing houses have, so far, all been rejected... So now I have reached the point that I really don't want to put that much effort into something without there being SOME potential for it to make me enough money to make it worth my while. I guess that's selfish, greedy and, well, Republican of me, but that's where I am at the moment. Writing purely for the "love" of it has not yet proven to be a practical or financially rewarding approach. This blog, in fact, would fit into that category...
Jack
CC: Making money doing what you love is neither selfish, greedy or Republican; it's the American Dream! I had no idea you were so prolific; it sounds to me that you are doing what you love. And if you haven't heard it already, let me tell you myself, you are a good writer, a very good writer. So without a doubt, your novel, your how-to book, novella, short stories, poetry, articles, and this blog, has vastly honed your skills and talent. I could be mistaken but I think Ray Bradbury received something like a hundred rejections before he sold a short story. Yours is a common story, it's my own in fact. I think everybody with dreams of pursuing creative ventures eventually hits a crossroads where they have to decide whether or not to pursue their dreams or move on. Sometimes people make it, sometimes people move on. And sometimes... something amazing happens! In 1980, when I turned 20, I made an (awful) hour-long film in Super-8 thinking that would open Hollywood doors for me. It didn't. Between 1985 and 1990, I made a 16mm feature-length horror film thinking that would open Hollywood doors for me. It didn't. In fact, it left me penniless. Movie-making, at almost any level, is very expensive. In 1995, I made a 16mm short film, a comedy, that went on to air on PBS-affiliates and public access stations nationwide and won a slew of national and international awards. I thought that would open Hollywood doors for me. It didn't. And I was penniless again. In 2001, I made another 16mm short film which has been aired throughout the country and won a slew of awards. And it was the first thing I'd made that made a profit due to part of it being used in a regional commercial. I thought it would open Hollywood doors for me. It didn't. And then in 2004, on my 44th birthday, I had a life-changing experience. My appendix burst and I nearly died. Over the next week, I laid in a hospital bed socked up on morphine and pondering my life. I had pursued writing and filmmaking for so long I had basically lost every other opportunity in my life. I was broke and alone and lived like a college student in a loft apartment. Though I had won awards and gotten some exposure, I was starting to think the cost was too great. I'd never married, never had children, never had a real career or real income. At that moment, I had hit my crossroad. Do I give up on filmmaking and salvage the last half of my life and try to find a real career while there was still time? Or do I continue down the filmmaking path since I'd invested so much into it in time and money? I thought about that for a while and realized there was a third option. I could choose to do nothing. I could just surrender my life to whatever fate the universe held for me. I could decide that whatever tomorrow brings is fine by me. That life was perfect whether I win the lottery or get killed in a car crash. That maybe I should quit trying and just relax and let whatever/whoever else, that may or may not exist, take the driver's seat for a while. That way I could climb into the backseat, take a nap, and not worry about it. The car might somehow make it to a worthwhile destination or end up slamming into a tree. Either outcome was fine by me; I wasn't going to worry about it anymore. Maybe it was a revelation of how we (us humans) should live or maybe it was just the morphine talking but option "three" sounded like the right one. So I took it. I'm not a religious person but have always kept an open-mind about forces greater than us overseeing the universe. I've always taken the "I don't know and neither do you" approach. And I still do. Call it an amazing coincidence, or proof of a spiritual nature to the universe, or getting myself in the proper state of mind for success, but something very, very strange happened that day. The moment I made that decision, I felt the burden of life dissipate from me. Within six months, as broke as I was, I bought a house; a good one. Six months after that I was hired as the editor for a 35mm feature film, and six months after that I was overseeing the film's final post-production at Universal Studios in LA. Six months after that I was writing the screenplay for the film "Ghost Image" with two friends. Six months after that the funding for the film seemed to fall out of the sky and I was directing "Ghost Image". One year later we were screening it and I met the most amazing woman. She was someone I'd known 20 years ago but had lost touch with. She showed up at the premiere of my film and we've been together ever since. And now the film is on cable and will be out on DVD sometime in '09. And now people hire me to help them with their screenplays and my producer and I hope to make another film next year. My success came after I'd basically decided to quit chasing after it. Regardless of all the planning and plotting we do, we never, ever know when and/or where doors will open for us. What I've taken away from the experiences from the last few years is that we can't "make" something happen. All we can do is set events into motion and stack the deck in our favor, but even so, things will play out as they play out. A friend, commenting on my experiences, said to me, "Jack, it didn't matter that you quit chasing your dreams. After 20-something years you'd built up so much momentum you couldn't stop them from coming true!" Maybe that's the case, I don't know. All I know is that success came after I quit concerning myself with achieving it. And I still have a long, long way to go. Cosmic, though I may differ with a lot of your politics, you are a good writer. A very good and engaging writer. You love it. It's obvious. Keep at it. You just never, ever know. :)
Dadman
Jack: I like the idea of just surrendering to fate and letting go of all the worry and concern. I'm working on it in my own life, but I'm finding it's a very difficult thing to do. Wish me luck...
Jack
It is difficult, Dadman. I had to nearly die to get to that state of mind and I still fight the urge to worry about things and to grab and control everything in my life. I guess we all do. Good luck. :)
CosmicConservative
Jack: Thank you. Yours is a wonderful story. As Dadman says, I could learn a lot from that approach. I have struggled against fate my entire life, and quite frankly I have always felt that fate had it in for me. As I sit here right now, I can't say that I've reconciled enough of the difficulties in my life to think of fate as anything less than malicious towards me, and the idea of surrendering to that which I have always railed against seems too much like, well, surrender. But you make good points. My biggest problem is now what it probably always has been. I'm much too proud to be very wise.
Jack
CC: You have focused on other things - wiser things - in life than I have; getting a university degree, a career, a wife and a family. And still you found time to write A LOT of stuff! These are tremendous accomplishments! For some, they would be the grand achievement of lifelong goals. I'm sure it hasn't been an easy road (life rarely is), but you've done well. My life has not turned out like I envisioned it back in my twenties. (Hell, I thought I'd be the next Spielberg by now. LOL!) But I'm doing fine. And I have spent a lot of time in years gone by with the same feelings toward fate that you have. Though your writing endeavors may not have played out as you may have thought or hoped they might, I think you're doing fine and I think it's just going to get better and better. I think fate has good things in store for you.
Andy
Jack: I really appreciate you telling your story. You are so right. Life gets by us really quickly. I often wish that I had not stop pursuing my real passions...but those old dastardly "responsibilities" got in my way. We are fortunate if we experience "the dark night of the soul" once in our lives. It seems that you made the most of yours. Good for you! Cosmic: I know a couple of things. 1) You are a good writer with an interesting mind. The only thing that hinders good writers from being successful is "not writing." 2) I don't know anything about science fiction. I only know real life stuff like the fact that the world is ending in 2012...you can look it up on the Mayan Calendar...so you'd better get with it! Dadman: Yep!
Andy
Okay, I lied...kinda! I wrote that "responsibilities" were why I was derailed from pursuing my best. It wasn't really that. It was "fear." At 30 years old, I had finally found what I was really good at doing, and what I really loved. But when I got to a certain level (at 34), "fear" swept over me. I had all these children to provide for, the world (and people) were tugging at me from every possible angle, etc. That demon "fear" won out. I've got very few regrets in life. But one is that I succumbed to that old demon. Heck, it is possible that I would have run in a ditch and taken my whole family with me ("probable" in fact). But I do wonder sometimes how thin that wall was...maybe just a day or two longer, maybe not listening to the wrong people...maybe walking up a little higher to see the bigger picture. I know one thing for sure...I wish I knew as much at 34 as I do at 49. Crud Cosmic! Write your danged book, would ya? I promise I'll buy one.
Jack
Andy, I have read that most of us are afraid of success; that in the end, it's just as - or possibly more so - frightening as failure. I had that myself. About a month before the start of principal photography on my film the funding almost fell through. And, much to me own surprise, part of me was relieved at the prospect. I was under so much stress, and thoughts of the amount of work I had ahead of me was almost overwhelming. One week before the shoot, I couldn't sleep, I'd sweat profusely, and I'd hyperventilate. And the day before my Hollywood cast flew into town, I thought I was having a heart attack. Basically, I was experiencing a major league anxiety attack, which could still be dangerous if it goes on too long. Fortunately, once I met the cast in person and we started shooting, I rolled up my sleeves and buried myself in the task of making the film and everything was fine. You hit it on the head and you're a hundred percent right. Fear is what holds us back. It is our greatest obstacle.
Andy
Jack: Yep! I wish I had known at 34 that about 95% of what we worry about never happens anyway. And that the 5% that does materialize is good for us. Live and learn...