Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

A sad day for Baseball

By CosmicConservative
ESPN - Greg Maddux to announce retirement Monday Greg Maddux has thrown his last pitch. The four-time Cy Young winner will announce his retirement Monday at the baseball winter meetings, near his home in Las Vegas. Maddux, who turns 43 in April, ranks eighth on the career wins list with 355. He went 8-13 with a 4.22 ERA last season with the San Diego Padres and Los Angeles Dodgers.
A sad day indeed. I sort of figured he would retire when he got one win more than Clemens this year. Hall of Fame lock. No doubt about it. He'll get a higher percentage of votes than anyone in a long time.

Comments (8)

Old Goat
This season we are seeing two very good pitchers retire. Maddux and Mussina. Both really should get in to the HOF, but Mussina will probably take longer than Maddux. Both pitched in an era that was tough on pitchers, yeah, that steriod bit. Mussina retired younger, which to me could mean that he could have had the 300 wins that some seem to think he would need. Speculation is that it would take 3 seasons (though probably less) to accomplish this. That would put him at the same age as Maddux is now. Sad day for baseball.... yet the time comes for every player to retire. Thanks to both for the memories.
CosmicConservative
I would have really liked to see Maddux equal or exceed the win total of Warren Spahn. Spahn is the only "modern era" or "live ball" pitcher in the all-time list who has more wins than Maddux. I personally think you could make a strong case that Spahn is the greates pitcher ever, or that Maddux is, based on their success in an age when pitchers struggled against rules or cheating that greatly favored batters.
Andy
Cosmic: Aaaaahhhh... Spahn & Sain, & pray for rain! I am gonna miss MadDog...golly, what a technician. Even though I love the fire-ballers like Ryan (which I know you don't care much for), Maddux has been a great joy to watch over my adult lifetime. I just regret that I didn't get to see him pitch in person. I know you did, so paint me green and call me Kermit.
Old Goat
You still have to consider the AL vs. NL though. Its a big difference pitching against weaker lineups. It also depends on the division you are in. Pitching in the AL East, for instance, as compared to pitching in the NL West are worlds apart. Win totals is a terrible way to rate a pitcher, in any event. ERA+, WHIP, and so on are far better means of looking at what a pitcher has done. Take Mussina's case, even though Maddux had been the better pitcher, Moose pitched in the AL East his whole career. Facing World Series Championship teams in his own division. The Rocket was a far more dominating pitcher, but how much was due to PEDs? It will be interesting to see how HOF voting falls out from this era. Not only for pitching, but for all players.
CosmicConservative
My thoughts on wins vs. other stats, AL vs. NL and Maddux vs. Clemens.... Wins are one of the most revered stats for pitchers because, well, because there is not much that matters more in the game of baseball than winning the game. Sure you can argue that other factors come into the equation than just the pitcher's skill in getting a "W" but week after week, month after month and year after year there is really no stat that speaks more to a pitcher's value to the team and his intangibles than wins. FWIW Maddux's stats in WHIP, ERA, Innings pitched, strikeouts, etc. are among the best in the history of the game, and completely comparable to, say, a Warren Spahn or (cough) Roger Clemens. In the top 20 pitchers for wins there are only two who have less than a thousand walks in their career, Greg Maddux and Pete Alexander. Roger Clemens, for example, has about 1.5 times as many walks as Maddux has (he has about 1.5 times as many strikeouts too...). However you cut it Maddux has stats that are comparable to pretty much any pitcher you want to compare him to, which is pretty remarkable for a pitcher who spent most of his career with a 90mph fastball. The whole "is it better to pitch in the AL or NL" argument is one that has been handled by far more knowledgeable baseball fans than me, and I don't believe that is "settled" in terms of which league is "better" for a pitcher to pitch in. My opinion, for what it's worth, is that the current AL designated hitter rule pretty much means they don't play baseball in that league. So comparing NL vs. AL pitching stats is like comparing NFL vs. Rugby stats. Let's just look at innings pitched, for example. In the AL you pitch as long as the manager thinks you have your stuff. In the NL you pitch until the manager has to choose to make an offensive vs. defensive move, even if you HAVE your stuff. So to stay in the game into the late innings in the NL is far more impressive than doing the same thing in the AL. And between, say, Roger Clemens and Greg Maddux, who do you think has the higher innings pitched per game average? One of the most impressive stats Maddux has is his innings pitched in a league where a pitcher going past the sixth inning is becoming downright rare. Had Maddux pitched in the AL he would likely have had a lot more complete games and a lot more wins. And I doubt his ERA or strikeouts or walks would have suffered much. For the most part I think that there are thresholds that you reach in areas, and it is probably fair to say that once you reach the level of talent of a Greg Maddux or Roger Clemens or Mike Mussina, it really becomes an academic exercise to discuss who is "better". I'd take any one of them in their prime as a Rockies pitcher...
Old Goat
While the game is somewhat modified by the DH, it is still baseball. There is typically a 1.5 to 2 point swing in the ERA when a pitcher changes from the one league to the other. Frankly, NL managing is something that gets dictated by the lineup situation. The pitcher gets a break in the lineup of almost every single NL team. The last three batters are usually not very impressive, so walk totals are going to be better, swinging strikeouts will be better, ERA is better. Win totals is a terrible stat for using to judge pitching, regardless of how you cut it. Take Santana this past season. He would have been the Cy Young for the NL with the Mets this year had his bullpen not blown all those games for him. His ERA was good, his win totals were not. Wins is a team stat, not a pitcher stat. While pitching is the starting point toward getting a win, a lot depends on fielding, strikeouts, groundouts, hitting from your team. The Blue Jays this past season had the nearly the best pitching overall. They finished 4th because of not having the other important part of the game. Innings pitched per game is also very deceiving as a stat. If you are a strike out pitcher, your pitch count and therefore your innings pitched are going to affect things big time. Yankee pitcher Wang averaged 18 pitches per inning because he is a contact pitcher. A strikeout pitcher will have a much higher number of pitches needed per inning because of having to set up the hitter to swing at your out pitches. With the investment that goes into pitching, and the generally poor standard that most pitchers swing a bat, let alone the increased risk of injury is why the DH came about. It also make the game tougher to win because the offense is better. One look at the number of times the AL has won the All Star game shows where the better batters are. That means it is also a tougher test on the pitcher. Maddux was a very good pitcher, but his numbers wouldn't look nearly as good in different leagues and divisions. The ballparks play a big role as well as the team they are on for win totals. ERA + helps show where a pitcher truly is in scale because it shows what a pitcher did with league and ballpark accounted for. Maddux ranks 4th all time in the ERA+ scale, at 146. Clemens has the highest ERA+ ranking, at 151. Maddux: ERA Titles: 4 (8 top five NL finishes) Clemens: ERA Titles: 6 (10 top five AL finishes) If you factor in ERA+ along with ERA titles and NL or AL ERA titles, best is Lefty Grove: ERA Titles: 9 (12 top five AL finishes)ERA +: 148 (2nd all time) Doing it that way Maddux comes in about 6th. ERA+ also helps to account for the era they pitched in, as it is a comparison to the other pitchers performances over each of the seasons. I agree with you on the last paragraph. These pitchers are in rare company. Its a matter of degrees on who is better. As to them playing for the Rockies, that would be tough to judge. Control pitchers in Coors Stadium, even with the doctored humidified balls, won't have the same control factor there. The ball moves differently in the thinner air, and hitters generally have a better slugging percentage as well. Maddux was a tough pitcher for players to face. So was Clemens. Mussina wasn't feared but his results still are up there. Different styles and types, along with personalities. All have brought some great enjoyment to the game.
Dadman
Impressive discussion guys. All I know is the Arizona Diamondbacks OWNED Maddux. ;)
CosmicConservative
Well, as far as I'm concerned you can take 10% at least off the top of any Roger Clemens statistic based on drug use alone. The stats you refer to are probably good stats, and if Maddux ends up only in the top ten all time in those stats, I'm good with that. I admit that a large reason I admire Maddux is because he was a SMART pitcher. He couldn't throw the ball past most hitters so he had to out think them. And for the most part, that's exactly what he did, and I find that more admirable than a freak of nature (or freak of drug use) whose ability to throw the ball is just beyond what is normal human capacity. But that's just me. I know that's an unpopular attitude to have about sports since pretty much all sports are now overrun with freaks of nature. Try playing in the NBA as an average sized man. Still, I like that Maddux was so good, without the raw physical power of a Randy Johnson or Roger Clemens.