Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Boston Globe sides with Extreme Islamists in cartoon flap

By CosmicConservative
Here is a perfect example of how the "elite" liberals in the world allow their desire to appear nuanced and contemplative overrun any tendency towards common sense. This is not a hard one. A few cartoons lampooning a religious figure is not justification for rioting and death threats. The fact that the Boston Globe even contemplates the idea that these Danish cartoonists bear any fault at all is quite interesting given the tendency of cartoonists at the Boston Globe to routinely attack conservatives and Christians. Here is a quote from their story:
Depicting Mohammed wearing a turban in the form of a bomb with a sputtering fuse is no less hurtful to most Muslims than Nazi caricatures of Jews or Ku Klux Klan caricatures of blacks are to those victims of intolerance. That is why the Danish cartoons will not be reproduced on these pages
Let's see them add to this list of offensive and intolerant caricatures the depiction of GW Bush as a chimpanzee, Christian conservatives as ignorant zealots and red state Americans as trailor-inhabiting beer-guzzling neanderthals. All of these are common targets of the Boston Globe's favorite "editorial" cartoonists. But I guess that's an approved form of free speech to the genteel and tolerant elitists sitting in the highest editorial offices at the Globe. And why is that? Hmmm do you think the fact that the Globe editors know quite well they can offend and insult Christians and conservatives with impunity, with no fear of riots in their lobbies has anything to do with it?

Comments (6)

Dadman
You refer to the perpetrators of this cartoon chaos as 'extreme islamists'. I have to wonder if what we are witnessing is the work of extremists in the Islamic faith or the manifestation of rage that is in fact more mainstream than we care to acknowledge. Moderation in the Islamic world seems quite hard to find. It eithers does not exist in significant measure or it chooses to remain silent. Atrocities are commited in the name of Islam on a nearly daily basis - decapitations, random killings of Christian children, riots, kidnappings, etc. The litany of gore and death is nearly endless, and the moderate Islamic world, if it indeed exists, is largely silent. It is a silly cartoon that ignites their indignation, not the horrific screams of a man being dismembered live on the internet. When a faith or a nation begins to rationalize and accommodate what any reasonable being would define as barbaric and inhumane, then tragedy on a massive scale is not far behind. Radical Islam and it's intolerant, twisted worldview is taking all of us briskly down the path to hell.
CosmicConservative
I try to be optimistic about things. I'm usually not very successful at it, but I try. I think what we are seeing is the limits of the accomodation of the politically correct crowd. It's not just Islam that the PC crowd accomodates, they accomodate mind-numbingly offensive behavior from certain groups as a matter of course. Go check out Julian Bond's speech last week where he described Republicans as Nazis, and nobody in the PC arena batted an eye. But elements of Islamism, be they radicals or somewhere closer to the mainstream, have been pushing the envelope farther and faster than any other group. It is my hope that they have finally pushed too far and even the most pacifistic of cultural relativists and apologists for the "downtrodden" are now saying "wait a minute, this is too far." Maybe not, but so far Europe is holding the line on freedom of speech. This is probably just one battle in a long war of civilization vs. barbarism, but at least this one is fully joined and the forces on both sides are visibly exchanging fire. To me that's a good thing. It helps to shine a light on the radical nature of the Muslim agenda. More and more people are "getting it" I think.
Dadman
But it is Islam itself (not just the PC crowd) that seems to accommodate, even encourage, the barbarism. When you have a major world religion with 1 billion adherents supporting such a twisted, wharped agenda it frankly scares me. Even if only a fraction of all Muslims are supportive or sympathetic to the notion of violent jihad against the West, you're still talking 100 million plus potential jihadists standing on their side of the line. The West, even the left, might be 'getting it' as you say with greater clarity, but Islam itself appears to be on a path to global martyrdom, and in their sick minds that's a good thing. Iran's recent incendiary rhetoric and nuclear aspirations is a clear case in point. My fear is they will ultimately provoke a bloody, global conflict in the name of jihad. I hope I'm wrong, but we are dealing with people who go nuts over a cartoon. They are frothing at the mouth with hate. In that climate, bad things tend to happen. I do hope I'm wrong...
CosmicConservative
So you (and me too) are casting this debate into a question of whether this reaction to a dozen lame cartoons is really about Islamist extremists or actually more about mainstream Muslim attitudes. That is precisely where the PC crowd will crucify you. (incidentally, "crucify you" could well be considered a slap in the face of Christians since it is a reference to the horrible way Christ is presumed to have been tortured and killed, but nobody seems to mind its usage in this sort of context.) I am trying to be very careful about accusing all of Islam of being represented accurately by those who shout "death to Denmark" and "Behead the infidels" and burn down embassies. The temptation is very strong because of polls of Muslims which show majorities who believe that Israel was responsible for the 9/11 attacks, or which show that suicide bombers are considered a reasonable political approach to their grievances, real and imagined. Seeing Osama Bin Laden dolls for sell in Pakistan also doesn't help. But I'm trying. But that is actually one reason I think something important is going to come of these violent reactions to such lame cartoons. I do believe a spotlight is being shone on Muslims right now, and how they act in that spotlight will change a lot of people's minds, one way or the other.
Dadman
Given the polls you cite and the fact that moderate Islam seems to be largely missing in action, it is very tempting to lump all Muslims in with the radicals. I try not to do that either, but if, as I mentioned, only a fraction of Muslims are radicalized, it's still a potentially huge, multi-generational problem. And when you throw Iran into the mix, a very large Islamic nation that appears to be run by militant, radical Muslims seeking nuclear weapons anything can happen. If a nuke or some other WMD goes off within the U.S. I believe all heck will break loose. Virgins better be standing by in heaven. If a spotlight is indeed being shone on Muslims right now then I have to ask what good that will do. Will it make them less radical? Will is force the West's hand to deal with them more assertively? I think the former is unlikely and the latter will just make them riot in the streets and commit more atrocities against innocent people. Ultimately, Islam needs to be reformed from within and I frankly don't see that happening anywhere in the Muslim world.
CosmicConservative
I've been predicting a showdown between Islamism and Europe for years. I do think this is a continuation of the same battle that first came to prominence with Salmon Rushdie and has continued on with Theo Van Gogh and now has engulfed these cartoonists, who had better be looking over their shoulders now. The battle is escalating. Europeans who have sneered at the US and pretended to be ideal multi-culturalists are in the process of learning that they have essentially nurtured a serpent in their nest. Now the question is, what are they going to do about it? I don't subscribe to the notion that Europe is suicidal and will simply roll over and let the Muslim immigrants take over everything. I think you will see backlash, and I think this is one small example of how it is starting.