Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Orson Scott Card on Prop 8

By CosmicConservative
Read the whole thing...
MormonTimes - Heroes and victims in Prop. 8 struggle Many people worked to pass Proposition 8 in California. Those who wish to be our enemies are working hard to blame it all on the Mormons, but our votes alone could never have done the job of protecting marriage from a fatal redefinition. If anyone doubts that, they should read the letter from Kevin Hamilton that has been circulating on the Internet. Brother Hamilton, a seminary teacher, asked his students a couple of days after the election if any of them had been treated with hostility because they were Mormon. Every hand went up.
"Ich bin ein Mormon!"

Comments (12)

Dadman
Ich bin ein Mormon? I'll send the missionaries right over. ;) I appreciate you posting this. This is the type of reference I tend not to cite since it is produced by the LDS church and is generally intended for an LDS audience. Having said that, the facts and experiences cited in the article I think are accurate. I know for a fact that young LDS kids are being put under an enormous amount of pressure by peers and a pervasive liberal culture that has taught them that discrimination of any kind is pure evil. The Prop 8 fallout has added to that pressure. Proponents of gay marriage are trying to intimidate Mormons, and the other groups and individuals who supported Prop 8, into silence and civic inaction. What they are doing is outrageous. The message seems to be now that those whose attitudes and convictions are informed by religious faith are somehow violating the 'separation of church and state' when they go to the polls and vote. Perhaps these gay protestors are auditioning for Obama's coming thugocracy... One of the reasons I am against 'gay marriage' is because I think it helps pave the way toward defining anti-homosexuality religious teaching as hate speech and therefore illegal. If such teachings or doctrine become illegal how long will it be before the government forces all churches to facilitate gay marriages or face the consequences? I'm just asking...
Andy
Dadman: It won't be long. I'm ignorant here, but doesn't the LDS church exist with a different corporate structure than most other churches? I heard once that they are not a 501-C like almost all other churches. If that's true, the government doesn't have any way to influence the LDS facilitating gay marriage. On the other hand, I can envision a day when tax-exempt status could be revoked by the IRS if a church refuses to marry gays. It could be justified as "a religious organization making a political statement, etc." Hey, did you read about the white powder letters being sent to LA & Salt Lake temples?
Dadman
Andy: Under the right circumstances a nation can elect a far-left radical as POTUS and the government can do anything it wants. What I'm saying is legalizing 'gay marriage' is a step toward making some religious tenets illegal. Maybe... I have no idea how the church is organized from a legal standpoint. Revoking tax exempt status is just one of the consequences I believe would be easier to justify if 'gay marriage' becomes legal in the eyes of the state. Yes, I heard about the white powder. I believe it turned out to be a donation of baking powder for those delicious Mormon muffins they sell near Temple Square. ;)
Old Goat
The thing to remember about this is that while the current target for this outpouring of hatred is being directed at the LDS church, it doesn't mean that it will stop there. This is something that should, repeat, SHOULD be a major concern to every single American. This flies in the face of religous freedom, one of the basic principles on which our Country was founded. What I find so disturbing is that this protest going on against the LDS church is only viewed and reported for the most part, on one side. The unfairness toward the gays and not the overwhelming unfairness of the gays demands to the majority of Americans about what marriage is. I sometimes drop in on Demcratic Underground to see what is being thought over there. The hatred, absolute hatred that the posters there have toward the LDS church is frightening. All because a church is standing up for its principles. I belong to the Lutheran Church. In discussions with the ELCA was about the acceptance of practicing gay clergy. This is bringing a rift within the whole church body, and frankly, for it being a part of any discussion has caused me to fade from my own church. The churches are meant to stand on principles, bedrock principles, not to bow to conventional desires and trends. Christians had allowed themselves to be put to death rather than give up their principle core beliefs. I am sure that LDS church has many such instances of similar circumstance where believers laid down their lives for their principle beliefs. To change from that speaks volumns about the lack of character and true faith in the teachings of their faith. Issues of faith are not meant to bend over time to suit behavioral issues of the day. Otherwise it is just a social club without core principles and they are worthless.
CosmicConservative
Goat: You have hit exactly what the core contention between "progressives" and "religious" people is. Religion teaches that there are immutable, eternal core moral values. Progressives find that whole concept to be abhorrent. That's why they are so intolerant. The very idea of higher moral law is something they find to be supremely threatening to their fundamental world view. I don't think there's a way to reconcile this.
Andy
I did some more research. The LDS Church is a tax exempt 501(C)3 Corporation, like most all churches. There is already a move afoot by gay activist groups to petition the IRS to revoke their status as a "religious" organization. I e-mailed Dadman the links, but didn't want to give them any free advertising on this blog.
Dadman
This gets back to my original point that these gay activists, and I believe a significant percentage of the Left, believes that those whose attitudes and convictions are informed by religious faith are somehow violating the separation of church and state when they go to the polls and vote. Of course, this is a patently absurd notion, but I'm beginning to wonder what portion of the population is actually buying into it. And if the courts veer any further to the Left via Obama appointments at what point will they start taking such arguments seriously? People of faith better be prepared to take a stand for the principles in which they believe because the Left (of which these gay activists are a subset) is going to use every fascist trick in the book to silence and intimidate those that stand in the way of their political objectives. I told Cosmic when he was visiting Phoenix a couple weeks ago that people of faith who refuse to acquiesce to the demands of the Left will one day be forced into internment camps and stripped of their voting rights. I was at least half kidding, but in the aftermath of Prop 8 I'm beginning to wonder...
Andy
Dadman, I know that you were half kidding when you said that to Cosmic. But it's not out of the realm of possibility. Those things have happened before in this evil old world. Well, at least I'll spend my last days eating good muffins.
CosmicConservative
There is a powerful movement on the Left to have religious thought identified as a mental disease. That is the ultimate destination that the current is taking them. Some of them know it and want that result, others don't think that far ahead and are just buying into the "we are only intolerant about intolerance" meme that the Left loves to throw around.
Dadman
As noted before, religious people specifically, and conservatives more generally, seem to be the only large group(s) still willing to discriminate between right and wrong, best and worst, etc. Conservatives are generally not shy about defining an ideal condition (such as the idea that children are better off being raised by a mother and a father in a traditional marriage) and then advocating laws and public policy that encourage and support the ideal. This, of course, is a direct threat to the 'anything goes' ideology of the Left that basically proffers policy postions that undermine the ideal and teaches that the only real evil is discrimination itself. I don't see a way to reconcile it either...
Dadman
Andy: I believe eating good muffins would mitigate a whole lot of intolerance and injustice and make internment almost bearable. You bring the honey butter, okay? ;)