Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

And the winner is.... Joe the Plumber!

By CosmicConservative
Yeah, McCain did score a hit with that one. But overall, from what I read, it wasn't nearly the knockout McCain needed. Let me be one of the first to welcome our new Marxist overlords... Freedom was fun while it lasted... ;)

Comments (29)

Dadman
Do you think 4 years of Obama's socialism and a stinky economy might set Mitt Romney up for a successful run at the White House in 2012? I'm thinking it might...
bellecurve
Don't read the polls or the punditry. Zombie makes a great point: http://www.zombietime.com/lefts_big_blunder/ The meta-campaign the left is promoting has a disheartening effect on voters. That being said, there was no knockout. Instead, there were a good number of quality jabs. Luntz's interviewees had few conversions. The consensus there was Obama won the debate, but still didn't made the sale with all of them.
Mr. Personality
I'd like to see Senator Government debate Joe the Plumber.
Cullen
Yeah, the plumber was definitely the winner last night in what was a very boring debate. Dadman, I'm looking forward to a Bobby Jindal candidacy in 2012. Heck, maybe a Jindal/Palin ticket.
meesterbig
It would have been worth the price of the popcorn to watch Alan Keyes debate AliBama last night. Keyes would have mopped the floor with him, without calling referring to any of us as 'my friends' even one time.
donniebnyc
Joe the plumber is related to Keating. http://www.eisenstadtgroup.com/2008/10/15/joe-the-plumber-wurzelbacher-related-to-charles-keating-oops/
CosmicConservative
donnie: Two points: 1. Joe the plumber is an indeterminate cousin of the son-in-law of Charles Keating? And you seriously think this is a connection that matters? Seriously? 2. Correct me if I'm wrong, but the issue with the "Joe the Plumber" comment wasn't anything Joe the Plumber said, it was what OBAMA THE CANDIDATE said. Are you suggesting that Obama's socialist redistribution of "wealth" comment is somehow not valid because of WHO it was said to? I mean this is one of the most hilarious things I've seen all year. Thanks, I needed a laugh.
Stevo
Do you really think the McCain campaign would be dumb enough to plant a close relative of Keating? Give me a break, if this turns out to be a close relation the only logical conclusion is that it is a stunt by the Obama camp to reconnect McCain to a scandalous banker. Timing is everything. Even I can think several moves ahead in a chess game,,,and I didn't graduate magna cum laude from Harvard.
CosmicConservative
This is just an example of what happens when people get too absorbed by the political scene. They start seeing boogeymen in every shadow, and they look for any connection and exaggerate anything they find. I'm pretty sure if you looked hard enough you'd discover that Sarah Palin and Joe Biden have some family connection. This is the whole "6 degrees of Separation" theory, which basically says that ANYONE is connected to ANYONE ELSE in this country by no more than six hops among their friends or relatives. Even if this story is true, it's already FOUR hops from McCain by the time it gets to Joe the Plumber. I'd almost bet you could find a connection from Obama to this same guy in four or five hops. All someone has to do is want to find it badly enough to go do some digging.
Matthias
I haven't heard an Obama proposal that hasn't been tested out in other countries - countries that you would never, ever describe as "Marxist" or "Socialist". Germany, for example, which I have first-rate experience with. At least superficially (and I haven't looked into all the details), the health plans sound similar to what Obama proposes. I share some of the concerns about Obama's other proposals, but since I didn't use to live in a socialist country before, I'm not afraid of living in one in case that Obama is elected :)
Andy
Heh! This reminds me of the 90's, when Colin Powell (while contemplating a Presidential run) was tied as a distant relative of Bush 41...some 200 years back from the West Indies I think. I once heard a fascinating geneology expert speak. He opened his talk by telling the crowd (all white southerners) that we were probably all related. My memory is fuzzy, but I think he said that about 40 generations ago, King Charlemagne fathered over 200 children by just about that many wives...and that almost all white people with European ancestors are related through his loins. I saw Joe the Plumber this morning on television...I'm pretty sure that Cosmic and I are related to him along with Keating. It was the hairdo that tipped me off.
CosmicConservative
Matthias: Just because YOU wouldn't describe another country as "socialist" doesn't mean I wouldn't. Particularly when it comes to health care. I pretty much consider most of Europe to have socialized their medical care, and the resulting poor quality and long lines are the proof of that.
Matthias
CosmicConservative: Do you have any first-hand experience with a European healthcare system?
CosmicConservative
Matthias: If the measure of whether someone can have an opinion on something is based on whether they have "first hand experience" with it, then our entire educational system is simply a waste of time, no man can have a position on abortion and I can't even root for a professional football team since I never played professional football. Matthias, do you have a substantive position to take on healthcare, or do you just like throwing red herrings into the argument?
Matthias
You presented a verifiable false statement as fact to back up your argument, and I content that if you had had first-hand experience with the very system that you criticize, you would not have made that statement. You are right, you don't need to have had personal contact with a topic to have an opinion on it. But you do need to have arguments that back up your position. You said that "most of Europe to have socialized their medical care, and the resulting poor quality and long lines are the proof of that." Point #1, "poor quality". I have to look no further than the World Health Organization's ranking of health care systems (easily found per Google) to show you that the US ranks behind every major European country in quality: http://www.photius.com/rankings/healthranks.html. I will trust the WHO's position on this one. Do you have any statistics or other data on waiting times, for example? I would genuinely love to see them, because I do not have such a chart for waiting times. But I have 30 years of anecdotal evidence that your assertion is wrong. Both through my parents (who still live in Germany, have had many recent situations that required medical care and have never had to wait for a hospital bed or emergency room longer than you would have to in America), and through a long medical history for the 20 years that I lived in one of those European countries. I never had to wait for a hospital bed longer than during 10 years in the US, either.
CosmicConservative
Matthias: So, have you examined the means the WHO uses to rank health care systems? I have. Here's a quick rundown. Among the categories that are used to rank health care systems are the following: "Fairness in level of contribution." "Health expenditure per capita." "Health level" I submit to you that those first two are inherently biased against privatized health care, and as such it is virtually impossible for the USA to compare favorably to countries who have nationalized their health care. The third one is, imho, not only completely arbitrary, but has many factors not related to health care built into it, not the least of which is something like lifestyle, which may be an American failing, but it is NOT related to the quality of health care. In other words, you are making a circular argument. I say that Europe has more nationalized health care than the USA and you turn to a study that is biased towards national health care to prove that Europe is better. Not convinced.
Matthias
"I say that Europe has more nationalized health care than the USA." And I'm not disagreeing with that statement. It's true, it's a fact. There's no circular argument there because I'm not disputing it. I take offense specifically with your allegation that "the resulting poor quality and long lines are the proof of that." You make a connection between nationalized health care and resulting poor quality/longer waits. You're arguing with somebody who has experienced both systems personally and saw no evidence of your claim. It's okay if you don't put as much value on the stats that I quoted as I do. I'll accept that you won't take my stories for granted - you don't know me. But I expect an actual counter argument, backed up by statistics that prove it. If your evidence is only anecdotal and is not based on first-hand experience, you'll have to content with people with that experience challenging you on it.
Dadman
Matthias: The potential issues associated with nationalized health care are well documented. Your personal experiences do not prove the issues do not exist. Perhaps you should do a little research beyond what WHO is providing. Of course, if your life is anything like mine you may not have time for that. ;)
CosmicConservative
Matthias: I will admit that most of my reading of long lines and poor quality care is from the UK and Canada. I can't claim to have the same knowledge of France, I just haven't looked. But I'm okay with using the UK and Canada as my examples since those are the ones I am familiar with, and those are the two that are most frequently cited by Leftists as good models for the USA.
andrea
I know I arrive a bit late to this exchange but, why does it appears that you guys present the health care issue as one or the other - an exclusionary choice. Every developed country, except us, has a national health system of one sort or another. And alongside, there are flourishing private prectices for anyone who prefers to pay. You should look at national health care as a baseline with a private practice above it, in the shape of a gaussian curve. We in fact are doing already except that instead of having a good, efficient, system, everyone goes to the emergency room. We have become too ideological.
CosmicConservative
Andrea: I think what you are describing is a possible means to address health care. The debate does tend to polarize between treating health care as a commodity (like pork bellies) and treating it as a right (like free speech). It's really something different from both of those, and trying to restrict solutions to what works for those two options probably does make it hard to deal with the real problem. I could be convinced that there is room for some out of the box thinking on health care. But I'm not going to go so far as to say ALL health care is automatically some sort of natural right. The commodity side of the argument has a point too, someone has to provide the service, and they aren't going to do it for free.
Andy
Maybe I'm a cold-hearted so and so, but the whole health care debate has baffled me my entire adult life. It baffles me that ANYONE looks at health care as a public responsibility (or an employer's responsibility for employees). Before the advent of Medicare, Medicaid, and the broad use of private health insurance, health care was actually affordable. I don't have the charts at hand, but I've seen them before. Health care costs have risen exponentially higher than incomes and cost of living (in fact, have more than done their part to hike standard inflation figures over the past 30 years). Anecdotal: Mrs. Andy & I don't pay very much more for groceries than we did 30 years ago. We don't pay nearly as much for consumer goods (televisions, telephones, gadgets, etc.). Clothes cost just about what they did 30 years ago. Our utility costs are not much different now than then (some are lower). Sure, there are other things a good bit more expensive (autos, houses, gasoline, etc.) But nothing has skyrocketed even close to the cost of medical care. And it had risen a good bit in the 20 years before I reached adulthood (after Medicare/Medicaid, and broad availability of employer funded health insurance). My oldest son was born 28 years ago. The total bill OB/GYN, C-Section, 5 day hospital stay was $2400. 2 1/2 years later, #2 son was born. All things were equal, except a 4 day hospital stay...total bill $4800. 7 years later, #3 son was born. All things were equal except a 3 day hospital stay...total bill $9400. We had health insurance to cover all 3 pregnancies. 5 years later #4 was born. We did not have any health insurance at his birth...total bill $4800. I'm telling you from experience that health care would be much cheaper if health insurance (either private, or public) was not in the mix. To quote Ronald The Great, "If you think medical care is expensive now, just wait until it doesn't cost you anything." Sure, the advances in medical technology and treatment success have probably increased just as dramatically as the cost. But we have entitled ourselves into the poorhouse on this medical care issue, and we stand ready to entitle ourselves into the outhouse now. Do I want some poor kid with an infection to suffer (maybe die) because his poor Mom can't afford to take him to the doctor. Heck no! I want a Mom to be able to pay a reasonable price at the doctor's office. Arbitrary here: $30 for an office visit instead of $90. What if $30 isn't available? Well, it might have been if there wasn't a $40 cable TV bill, or a $40 carton of smokes, or a case of beer every weekend...and on and on. If it's really not available, I don't know any doctor that would refuse to treat and take it when you can pay it (I'm sure there are some, but I don't know them personally). Entitlement expectations have pushed us into this corner. Malpractice costs have pushed us into this corner. Unrealistic treatment expectations by patients have pushed us into this corner. Widespread demand for employer provided health insurance has pushed us into this corner. And Washington politicians have pushed us into this corner. I know I'm a cold-hearted so and so, but we have got to ween the whole industry (and its customers), and our politicians off this bag. If we don't, our kids are in deep guano.
Matthias
I just realized that I took this knowledge for granted, but here's a fun fact about everything I posted: Germany does exactly this, a national base layer that supports everybody, but it's not mandatory. Our family has private health care. But when I blew out my knee a couple years ago while visiting Germany, of course I didn't have health care coverage, and the public system kicked in. I payed less than $100 for a 2 hour emergency room visit, with physician's care, x-rays and painkillers. Try doing that in America, where getting treated for a simple cut in your finger racks up a bill of $1400+ (happened to me last year, luckily I have an employer plan). The hybrid model is what Obama is proposing, right? The private health care system that currently exists will stay in place, nobody has to switch. He wants to add a base national system to make sure that those who don't have coverage can afford to go to the hospital when they have to.
CosmicConservative
Matthias: Let's assume you are right. Let's assume that all Obama is doing is "adding a base national system to make sure that those who don't have coverage can go to the hospital when they have to." Is it your opinion that in today's health care system we have doctors, nurses and specialists watching TV and playing golf all day, who will just shut the TV off when the flood of uncovered people starts hitting their doors? If we assume that our current doctors and nurses are (barely) covering the current demand, who is going to provide services for those people who get the free care? And if your answer is, "well, they are getting it already", then why do we need the nationalized system?
Andy
I wonder how the Germans like their federal tax rates of up to 45% to pay for this national base layer? I wonder if they enjoy running neck and neck with France in high unemployment? ftp://ftp.bls.gov/pub/special.requests/ForeignLabor/flsjec.txt I don't put much stock in what Germany does. They seem to be lagging behind Europe, and the US in growth. Things have changed a bit since Merkel took over though. The point here is that the mindset of entitlement drags the whole society down. I truly believe that if it was made clear to every American that they are "on their own" when it comes to health care...no government help...no employer plans...no exceptions...that in two years this mess would be straightened out by the private sector. Costs would become reasonable, and while the level of care might suffer for a while, it would be much better and more affordable down the road. Neither Matthias, nor Obama, nor McCain... NOBODY can ever convince me that government can do anything in the civilian realm better than the private sector can.
CosmicConservative
Andy: I'm pretty sure Matthias won't make the connection between 45% taxes, high unemployment and nationalized health care. Even when it happens, many here in the states won't make the connection either. Pure coincidence is all it is, pure coincidence.
Matthias
Well to be honest, if you want to talk about me like I'm not here or part of the conversation, there isn't much use in having this discussion. Funnily enough Germany's health care system isn't financed by the federal tax, and nobody who is in that 45% tax bracket (or quite a bit lower) makes contributions towards the national health care in the first place.
CosmicConservative
Matthias: The idea that tax revenues can be separated out and "nobody who is in that 45% tax bracket... makes contributions towards the national health care" strikes me as fundamentally naive about how governments work. It doesn't matter if the government CLAIMS that tax dollars from one segment of the population do or don't get spent in another area, all the budget people do is adjust the money they CAN adjust so that they get everything they want paid for. It's like a married couple saying "yeah, my wife's paycheck pays the house note" except, of course, that means the married couple now is able to buy a boat, new furniture, etc... So again, I'm not convinced. And whether I was talking about you in first, second or third person, you demonstrated exactly what I said you would.