Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The soft tyranny of good intentions

By CosmicConservative
Another example:
(CNN) -- Frustrated parents are dumping their teenagers at Nebraska hospitals -- even crossing state lines to do it -- and the state Legislature has scheduled a special hearing to try to stem the tide. A 14-year-old Iowa girl was left Tuesday at Creighton University Medical Center in Omaha, Nebraska. Nebraska's "safe haven" law, intended to allow parents to anonymously hand over an infant to a hospital without being prosecuted, isn't working out as planned. Of the 17 children relinquished since the law took effect in July, only four are younger than 10 -- and all four are among the nine siblings abandoned by a man September 24 at an Omaha hospital. On Tuesday, a 14-year-old girl from Council Bluffs, Iowa, was abandoned at Creighton University Medical Center in Omaha, Nebraska, just across the Missouri River from Council Bluffs. The case marks the first time a parent has crossed state lines to abandon a teenager in Nebraska, authorities said.
This is why liberal policies so often fail. Because they are created with the best of intentions, and are invariably abused by people with the worst of intentions... This is why conservatives are called "hard-hearted" and "cruel" because we SEE these sorts of things as the natural and predictable result of these policies born of "good intentions." Expect a lot more of this with an Obama Presidency and a Democrat controlled House and Senate. (Not to mention a SCOTUS with a liberal slant). It's depressing.

Comments (16)

Dadman
It's sad too. I wonder what these kids are thinking. I wonder what they are being told by the parent(s) abandoning them. I wish there was some way to give prospective parents competency testing BEFORE they become parents. I totally agree with your assessment on this. Liberals consistently fail to see the likely consequences of their policies and if they do, they don't seem to care. Intentions are more important than actual results. It's maddening.
Andy
We have this law in Louisiana. To my knowledge, it hasn't been abused like this. But this post did cause me to look into what our law actually allows. The guidelines allow for a parent to take an "infant" to a designated place (hospital, fire station, police station, etc.). But not just to leave the "infant" on the doorstep, or in a bathroom, etc. As I understand it, they must alert an official that they are surrendering their child voluntarily. The fuzzy thing about our law, as I read the guidelines, is the word "infant." Like I said, I haven't heard of any abuses (and I follow the LA news pretty closely. I guess these Cornhusker legislators need to go back to the drawing board...poor kids...
CosmicConservative
I am absolutely certain that those who opposed this bill on the grounds that it would be abused were mercilessly attacked for their black hearts.
mtnlurker
Dadman: who would get decide if we were "competent" to have children? I know you were just wondering but this sort of leads to CC's point. And my first question, also, was what are the kids thinking. Colorado has a similar law but not sure what the cutoff age is.
Dadman
I realize my comment was counter to the point of this post. I don't really advocate competency testing for prospective parents because I know in practice it would be VERY DIFFICULT to do. I just wish it could somehow be done for the sake of all the innocent children who are being raised by people so dysfunctional the children's lives are at risk. And if they don't die, they are often so wounded (physically and emotionally) they have little hope to live a normal, productive life. Incompetent parenting should be taken a little more seriously than it is...
Stevo
Parents who find themselves faced with incorrigible teens (for whatever reason) are in a tough spot. Dealing with the well intended laws against corporal punishment and "neglect" sometimes trap these people into living with abusive and violent youngsters. You can't just kick a kid out of the house for bad behavior anymore,,,that's neglect and you will be charged for it because social services doesn't want them any more than you do. Mrs. Stevo was a social worker for many years and I suspect this scenario might be the reason for abandoning some of these older kids. If so maybe it's a form of poetic justice?
annie1958
Having just spent 10 years with Children and Youth Services, I can say that in my State, and many others, lots of parents turn their unruly children over to the agency. Many also turn over multiple siblings when they cannot take care of them due to homelessness, children's behavior, mental illness, drug and alcohol addiction and a myriad of other reasons. People sometimes assume that children are in foster care solely because of bad parents. The concept of a social worker rushing in a taking the starved and beaten children from the parents is rare. From the statistics I compiled over the years, that is the case less than 12% of the time. The rest of it is essentially, the parent's inability to cope. While in some cases the social worker does remove the children, it is more because the parent's can't effectively parent than that they actually did harm to the child. Caseworkers interview everyone involved and request custody from a judge even if a parent has signed a voluntary placement agreement. The judge rubber stamps the custody request and the children go into foster care. It can be at a true foster family, a group home, or an institution. If you have an abusive or violent teen, you can get them placed rather easily, at least here in Pennsylvania, and in many other states I have studied. The biggest issue is that programs that could actually keep the child(ren) in the home like transitional housing, family intervention, intensive family preservation and others are often sacrificed when there is a shortage of funding. Foster care for children in jeopardy is mandated by law, in-home services are not. The feds only help pay, in any meaningful amount, for foster care (around 50% of the cost of care). State and county budgets are stretched to the limits as it is, so in-home services get cut, more kids go into the more expensive option of foster care, there is less money so more in-home services get cut, rinse and repeat. The idea of just leaving child(ren) at a hospital or police station and taking off though causes a whole host of issues for the agency. Having no medical history on the children can be a nightmare. Not being able to prove the facts of a child's removal home can jeopardize federal funding and mean less money for important programs. Yes, the intentions were good. Not stigmatizing people for admitting that they cannot care for a child is a good idea. But as they say, the road to heck is paved.... *sighs* Sorry for the rant, I guess my social services burnout is still pretty fresh. Annie
CosmicConservative
Annie, thanks for a very informative post. I learned something from it, so I count today as a "good day". And it's just starting! What about kids with disabilities? Are they more likely to be turned over to state agencies than "normal" kids? This isn't entirely an academic question. My son has autism and as he has gotten bigger and stronger (he is 15 now) there are times when it feels overwhelming for me and my wife to deal with it. We have a lot of advantages over other parents (I have a great job with reasonably benefits and can just barely afford some very expensive therapy for example, although I wonder about retirement but that's another conversation...) so I wonder if other parents in similar situations but with fewer resources to fall back on "give up" more frequently than families without such challenges.
Stevo
I don't think it's that easy to hand over your kids in Colorado, I'll have to consult the Mrs. I also don't think this scenario is all that common, probably a small percentage but I do know it happens. As for parents with means, they can check their kids into shelters at a hefty cost but there are no locked facilities and guess what, when little Jackie walks out and gets picked up they're all yours again. Also the shelters have the option of refusing the child so if the problem persists options soon run out. Out here they have "youth in conflict" teams I'm not sure at what point they take over but I think it has to get pretty bad. We also have a huge shortage of foster care and many of them won't take troubled teens. Anyway after being the sounding board for many spousal rants I can relate to your burnout.
annie1958
One of the tradegies of the system is that so many people turn to the foster care system when their disabled child is more than they can handle. So many insurance companies deny benefits, or limit them to a specific time period, or limit services, for children with autism, mental retardation, Down syndrome and the like that parents are forced to give up custody of their children so they can properly be cared for. In the county where I primarily worked, they had an average of 650 children in foster care at any give time, of those 650, more than 50 were in care for that very reason. Additionally, at least in this county, there was a dearth of funding for Office of Mental Retardation, so the Children and Youth offices kept these children in custody until their 21st birthday when the MR deparment could afford to take over. And so much of it depends on where you live. Whether it is state run or county run, and the poverty level in your state. Because all federal money for children's services bases income on 1996 dollars (called the TANF look-back), a family of four in Pa can only make 487 dollars per month or they are ineligible for federal funding. A child must be "needy and deprived" to qualify. Meaning they must be below the 1996 level of poverty and deprived of the support of one or both parents. Foster care funding comes from Social Security. That is an entitlement program, meaning it is uncapped. So the way the federal government has tried to cut costs is by narrowing the requirements so fewer and fewer children qualify. Thus leaving the care of these children totally in the hands of state and county government. Like "No Child Left Behind" the federal government requires states and counties to give services, but then they refuse to fund them. I am sorry about your son Cosmic, although I imagine he brings you great joy, the challenges can truly be overwhelming. He is close to 18 as well, and the available services for adults is even more difficult to deal with. Oh, and Stevo, I can assure you Colorado has locked facilities for adolescents. We have actually sent teens there. Colorado may not utilize them in their child welfare system, but most institutional and group home placements are with private providers and children are sent all over the country to different facilities. There are very few state run facilities or orphanages in this country any longer. Most all of them are private companies, and it is an incredibly lucrative business. The average price at a group home is 860 per day, and an institutional placement averages around 2000 per day. Yes their expenses are high, and their liability is unbelievable, but they do make a hefty profit. Cosmic, I am sure you have researched everything you can to help your son, but if you would like some help, I have a few links you may not have found. I would be happy to send you what I have if you email me. The one thing in your favor is that autism has been a hot button issue with politicians for the last couple of years, so you may be able to get more help than you could have a while back.
Andy
Yeah Annie, I had the same question as Cosmic. When I read your comment, that was the first question it raised. Not to be ugly here, but I know that there are many parents (usually a single parent) that live off what the kids in my neighborhood call the "crazy checks" for their kids. They get all of their kids (often 4 or 5) classified by some agency as mentally handicapped, and collect $700 or so per month each. Then, they use State dollars to get them "treated"...when the kids didn't need treatment at all. Cosmic: It would really surprise me if very many children like your son are surrendered to the State. You are fortunate, as you wrote, because you have some resources. Those that are not so fortunate do have options made possible by State programs. I could be wrong, but I would bet the numbers are tiny. I can certainly understand why Mrs. Stevo, and Annie get so frustrated. People of character, with noble goals, often find themselves fighting the system from both ends. Mrs. Andy worked for about 15 years with troubled young people...I know it's tough. Annie: I think I'd rather dog-sit a pack of wild pit bulls than do social work.
CosmicConservative
Andy: I hope you are right, I can't think of much that would be more confusing and frightening for even a high-functioning autistic person than to have them ripped from the only real structure and comfort they have and be thrown into a situation where they may not have the same level of attention and concern that a family provides. But I couldn't help but ask since I see stories of parents who seem to be abandoning "normal" children. I just wondered if the additional difficulties associated with a neurological disorder might make such a thing even more likely. Annie: No, I can't claim to have uncovered every possible program or opportunity that is out there. I've tried, but for the most part what I have found is a lot of therapy, behavioral modification or psychiatric care. What our son needs that we probably don't provide enough of is a sense of belonging and a sense of mutual appreciation and support. To be blunt, he needs friends. And that is precisely what baffles us entirely. How do you "create" friendship? I'm not sure you can.
annie1958
Okay, that is an issue Cosmic. I don't know how high-functioning your son is, so I may be out of line but... About eight years ago, I discovered a boy scout troupe specifically for austistic, aspergers, down syndrome, autism spectrum disorder kids. It included some regular kids, some high functioning autistics and some moderately functioning. I just looked for it on-line, and can't find it. It was in the South Jersey area. Unfortunately, I haven't been down there in four years and they were no where to be found the year before I sold my place. What I saw amazed me. The thing was, the essence of a boy scout meeting, the rituals and the pledge, the rules and all gave them the structure they craved and allowed them to make friends without feeling lost. The only reason I knew about it was because they often held their "outdoor jamborees" next to where I had a summer place in the pine barrens. Now, understand, their outdoor jamborees were just an afternoon in a beautiful meadow with a creek and they happened about every third weekend for only a day, no overnight stuff. I don't know how big the community is where you live and whether something like that would be possible, but perhaps you could look into something like that. Even if it wasn't boy scouts, the YMCA, Boys Club, I don't know. The most amazing thing I saw though was how the more highly functioning boys helped those a little lower down on the functional level and how the ones that appeared normal (but may have had aspergers) seemed to help them all. I was completely in awe of those boys and even more so the troupe leaders (why does the word troupe look wrong with and without the e?) I cannot begin to imagine the patience and determination of those adults and only wish I could be half as saintly. Most of them were parents of some of the boys, a couple were college students doing intern-type work. So, like I said, I may be way off base, but it sounds like you are one of those wonderful parents who would be willing to try. Annie
CosmicConservative
Each summer we have our son attend something called "Creative Perspectives". It's a group activity that has a weekly outing for spectrum disorder kids. Our son has benefited from it, but even when he connects during the activities, he doesn't seem to maintain the connections beyond the end of the program. It's a big help, they go fishing, watch movies, go bowling, etc. He seems to really enjoy it, but as I said, nothing lasting seems to come from it. Just to give you an idea of what I'm talking about, when he comes home from school and tells us he ate lunch with some other kids, we feel that to be big, big deal. And I think Creative Perspectives has helped him tremendously. But it's all relative. And incremental. And not something I really enjoy talking about frankly. Oh, and believe me, I have no illusions about my relative parenting skills or value. I know precisely what sort of parent I am. And "saintly" or "wonderful" aren't the words I'd use.
Dadman
I think you might be overly dismissive of what kind of parent you've been...
Andy
Well Cosmic, join the club of less than saintly, wonderful parents! I can identify in a small way with what you and CosmicWife deal with. Knowing your situation, I realize that what your son faces is like what my baby boy faces "to the 5th power." So, I assume that what you and CosmicWife face is equally exponential (don't know if that's proper American or not...shazzaaam!) Progress is incremental, and relative as you wrote. We measure success not in weeks, or months...sometimes not even in years. It IS a big deal when an autistic child tells his Mom and Dad that he ate lunch with other kids at school. Just a suspicion...he probably does it more often than not, but doesn't tell you about it. Our 12-year-old has just begun this school year to actually come home and tell us what happened at school. I don't know if it's that he thought in the past that we might be displeased, or what. We would ask him about some class, or what he had for lunch, or who he sat next to in class, and the answer would usually be "don't know!" It's different this year. He crossed a threshold sometime in the Summer, I guess. But it is incremental. I think the Soccer playing last Spring helped him a lot. He was, of course, the weakest player on the team, and rode the bench mostly. But the team fellowship did a whole lot for him. Well, I've rambled on too long. I'm "Amening" Dadman. Each kid is different...we all do our best. Knowing you, I have no doubt that you have (and will). Heh, I'm not sucking up here Pal.