Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: "An American Carol"

By CosmicConservative
This movie is being billed as a conservative answer to liberal Hollywood fare. It is going head to head with "Religulus" this weekend. We'll see which one comes out on top. As a conservative statement, I'll give this movie some credit, it does make some fairly powerful points at different times in the movie, the George Washington scene in particular was worth watching. But overall I found the movie to be far more cringe-inducing than funny. I'm not really much for mean-spirited slapstick comedy. I also don't care for "parody" which is really just thinly disguised playground insults. Most of this movie was so banal and crude that calling it "sophomoric" would be high praise indeed. Personally I wish they'd leave the borderline crazy childish petty attacks to the Left where they are so much more common and appreciated. I'd like to think conservatives are better than that. I don't like nastiness and straw man arguments no matter who is making them. Yeah, I know, someone will say "it's just a movie" and so it is. But it's not a good movie and believe me, if anyone thinks this will change any minds out there, they are fooling themselves. For those who view the Right as a bunch of redneck Rambos who think the best way to answer an argument is with a bunch of xenophobic bigotry and an AK-47, this movie isn't going to give them any better impression of the Right since that's more or less exactly what they did in this movie. So if you enjoy mixing your politics with scatalogical humor and enjoy watching someone get their face repeatedly shoved into plates of food, by all means go see this movie. It's 90 minutes of my life I wish I could get back.

Comments (3)

Stevo
Cosmic, Thanks for saving me the trouble. Luckily it wasn't at the theater in the town where I am working, or I might also have wasted 1.5 hours of my life as well. Realistically though, what did you expect, sublime satire? After all David Zucker is the archbishop of pun and parody.
Dadman
Heh. I had already decided to wait until this movie came out on DVD. I read some reviews of 'An American Carol' yesterday and they more or less said the same thing you did. I did see 'Appaloosa' this weekend. It's not bad, but a far cry from the quality of '3:10 to Yuma'. Maybe I'll do a review if I find the time...
Andy
Thanks for the heads-up Cosmic. You know that I'm a habitual moviegoer...but I guess I'll pass on this one. ;)