Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

"Tenth Planet" found, or Pluto demoted to minor planet?

By CosmicConservative
CNN has the story now, although it's been floating around the astronomical websites for over a year. There has been a long debate over whether Pluto is actually a planet or just another Kuiper belt object. Those who have long argued that Pluto should be demoted have used as one of their main arguments that Pluto is unlikely to even be the largest Kuiper belt object, it just happens to be the one we found first. Proponents of maintaining Pluto's planetary status have been responding in some cases with "well, when you find a bigger one, we'll deal with it." That day has come. So look for the Astronomical authorities to revisit the naming standards for planets. And as a result several things could happen, depending on how they are defined. If Pluto ends up a "planet" then this new object should be a planet too. You might ask yourself, if it were up to you to classify and create definitions for "planet," "moon," "asteroid," "star" and "comet," what would you come up with, and what would that mean to our existing nomenclature? Would Ceres become a "planet"? Would Mercury no longer be one?

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.