Geopolitics and Georgia
By CosmicConservativeI've been thinking about Russia's invasion of Georgia lately. On the surface this seems like a horrible disaster for the West. It looks like Russia has done a daring and risky thing, and the West has reacted with appeasement and hand-wringing.
But what's the military reality of this situation? If you do a cold, logical analysis of the geopolitical balance of power, what does the Georgia escapade mean?
Well, it's not clear to me that from a military perspective that this is a "bad thing" for the West. Yes it's a bad thing for Georgia and I don't want to minimize the human cost, but the whole point of doing a military analysis is to look only at the strategic and tactical positions of the world's major military powers.
Doing that this whole thing takes on a completely different flavor. Here's why:
Russia has been the primary ace in the hole for Iranian saber rattling for several years. Perhaps the biggest military reason that the US and the West has not moved against Iran in the past decade has been the threat of the Russian Bear backing Iran and threatening to pull the world into a larger conflict. But with Russian troops now concentrating on Georgia, a country with a joint border with Russia, Iran can no longer depend on Russia coming to their rescue if things escalate. The end result is that Russia's Georgia move has substantially reduced Iran's ability to flex their muscles. What that means is that Iran is taking a hugely increased risk if they continue to meddle in Iraq's affairs. Given an excuse the US and NATO could move against Iran with relative impunity while Russia is distracted. And with George Bush being a lame duck who still commands direct control of the US Military, there is very little political downside to GW Bush taking such an opportunity to slap Iran and reinforce the confidence of Iraq's nascent democracy.
The down side of this may be a growing confidence in the Chinese military, China and Russia have always provided a balance against each other, and with Russia tied up, China could also put pressure on Russia's eastern flank. All it takes is a "military exercise" at the right time and Russia will find itself in a precarious tactical position.
Besides that, this sort of aggressive, empire-building impulse in Russia will be a serious wake-up call to Western Europe, a culture that loves to bash America until they find themselves needing American protection. I would expect to see more cooperation from France, Germany and Italy as a result of this, especially in their respective military commands.
In the long run Russia may learn that this rash action has materially reduced their influence in the world, and has materially enhanced US influence.
With all that, I would say that Georgia's best military approach at this time is probably to mimic Muhammad Ali's famous "rope a dope" against George Foreman. Let the Russians advance their forces until they find themselves seriously over-extended and embroiled in this mess while their world-wide tentacles contract and lose strength, while US and Western tentacles flex and grow.
There's always a silver lining....
Comments (1)