Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Nancy Grace case to continue...

By CosmicConservative
Interesting story.
FOXNews.com - Judge Won't Nix Suit Against Nancy Grace in Mom's Suicide - Celebrity Gossip | Entertainment News | Arts And Entertainment CNN and Grace argued the wrongful death lawsuit brought by Melinda Duckett's family would "severely chill" journalists' coverage of missing-persons cases. But U.S. District Judge William Terrell Hodges on Thursday denied their motion to dismiss the lawsuit. Duckett, 21, was on Grace's show after her son Trenton went missing from her apartment in August 2006. Grace grilled the woman, accusing her of hiding something because Duckett did not take a lie-detector test and answered vaguely regarding her whereabouts. Duckett fatally shot herself before the network aired the pre-taped interview. The family claims Grace's intense questioning caused severe emotional distress that led to the suicide. The lawsuit also claims that the decision to air the interview after her suicide caused the family to suffer severe emotional distress and media and public harassment. They are seeking a jury trial, unspecified damages more than $15,000 and punitive damages.
You know what? I don't think I have a problem with "severely chilling" news coverage of missing persons, especially children. I think the media has become completely irresponsible and hides behind the "free press" mantra to excuse their absolute inability to exercise any form of reasonable editorial control. My least favorite "news" person is probably Greta (I call her "Ghoula") Van Susteran. What a vile, creepy witch! She practically drools over any story of a missing young white girl. I can see her and her editors cheering in their prep room when a new missing person story hits their desk.
"Oh this is GREAT, look at that photo! You say she was an ex-cheerleader? No, only on the pep squad? Well, they lead cheers don't they? We'll run with "missing cheerleader was honor student and beauty pageant queen." That's PERFECT! This will keep our ratings up for WEEKS. Let's hope they don't find her, or if they do it's pretty gruesome. High five!
Man I despise her.

Comments (15)

Andy
Cosmic: I don't watch Greta's show, but I have caught bits and pieces before. I guess I don't get the same vibe as you do...but as I said, I haven't watched her enough to judge. I don't watch Nancy Grace either. But, I have caught bits and pieces. She turns me off...probably the southern accent...can't stand it. :) But at the same time, I don't believe that any one event (like the grilling by Nancy) can be held out as a single reason for someone to off themselves. Sure, it might have been the last straw...but any thinking human knows that there may have been even more damage done by other events in her life previously...and you can't sue everybody. Nancy may have gone too far, but what do you do? Say you're a cop. You push really hard to get info from the parent of a missing child. The parent goes out and eats a gun. Should the family be able to sue the cop? Of course there is a difference. It's the cop's job to gain all info possible to find the kid. It is Nancy's job to present an entertaining program that gets good ratings. But the line might get fuzzier if Nancy loses. You never know what kind of suit some idiot judge will allow in the future...cops might find a "chilling effect" on their ability to investigate. Dunno! I hope you aren't right. I hope these TV lawyers don't take joy in these kinds of stories. But, sadly, you probably are.
CosmicConservative
Andy: Sometimes I allow myself to hold an opinion and throw caution and deeper analysis to the winds. When it comes to TV "reporters" who sensationalize abductions, rapes, murders and every salacious detail they can squeeze out of a story, I have long ago decided that "chilling" the First Amendment has a certain visceral appeal to me. And I don't buy the "slippery slope" theory, that's the oldest straw man in every debate. "Oh, if you allow X, then it's just a matter of time before Y." Sometimes there is merit to the argument, but usually the argument is applied well more than halfway down a slope that has already been coated with teflon. My opinion of Greta Van Susteran was formed, in my memory anyway, during a confluence of events that all reinforced a supremely negative opinion of her. I think it was the Natalie Holloway story first breaking at the same time that Greta was vigorously denying an obviously botched job of plastic surgery, which just happened to coincide with her jumping from one network to another for a bigger paycheck. The impression I got, and have never been able to shake, is one of a supremely self-absorbed woman who has tried to craft a veneer of "reportage" over a level of bald ambition that would do Richard Nixon proud. It is in part because of Greta's shameless hawking of every white female abduction case she could get her hands on that I grew tired of watching TV news. It is quite possible that there are worse than Greta out there. But if so, that just reinforces my argument. And it isn't just a matter of personal taste either. It is my personal opinion that "reporting" of the sort that Greta does has led to a culture that lives in fear, and because of that fear they create security bubbles around themselves and their kids to "protect" them from the image of rampant rape, murder and pillage that brings Greta and her ilk those all-important ratings. The end result is a society that has grown farther and farther apart in their personal interactions, personal experiences and ability to learn or exercise civility or common sense. We are a nation of nearly paralyzed thrill-seeking voyeurs who are afraid to let our kids ride their bikes to the park because every stranger is a molester, every male relative is a rapist and every ex-husband is a murderer. I hold people like Greta personally responsible for this.
Dadman
Cosmic: I couldn't agree more. I think the type of reporting Greta and her ilk do contributes in a very significant way to the incivility we see more and more in our society. The media's fixation on the depraved and salacious is, in a word, unhealthy. I've completely tuned it out and I've advised my family to do the same...
CosmicConservative
Welcome back Dadman! I hope your vacation was nice.
Dadman
I'll try to post something on 'what I did on my summer vacation...'
Andy
Cosmic: Why don't you tell me what you really think! ;) I didn't mean to be argumentative. I guess I just don't watch enough coverage of these terrible tragedies to really know what's happening on shows like these. I tuned it out a long time ago...maybe about the time of the OJ trial...no, it was the Johnbenet Ramsey thing. I just really question the wisdom of a judge allowing a lawsuit that alleges that "one event" in a person's life lead them to suicide. And you might think the "slippery slope" argument is a straw man. But look at the last 60 years of SCOTUS decisions (or any court), and tell me that the argument is not valid. Dadman: Welcome back Pal! Did you get temperature shock when you got home? I'm gonna let Cosmic grade your "What I Did on Summer Vacation" essay. Please include pictures. I'd at least like to "see" some cool weather (forecast 104 and muggy today).
CosmicConservative
Andy: I don't think I've been very frequently accused of hiding my true opinions on things. The whole "Free Speech" thing has been dealt with many, many times. Whether it's pornography, incitement to violence, national security or even a desire to promote the public welfare, the SCOTUS has ruled many times that the First Amendment is not a license to print, say or broadcast whatever the individual wants to say. That's the reason I don't buy the slippery slope argument, we've been on that slope since the day the Constitution was ratified. Not only is it possible to constrain free speech and maintain an open and "free" society, the Legislative, Executive and Judicial branches of our government have been actively engaged in interpreting what "free speech" means since our nation's inception. In general the government gets involved in these sorts of things when there is a question of the greater public good, and in my opinion the way that our news media covers these cases is NOT in the interest of the greater public good, and I don't have any problem whatsoever with a civil case concluding that a "reporter" acted as judge, jury and (literally in this case) executioner by publicly accusing a person of a crime of which they have not been convicted. In this case especially, accusing a mother of killing her own child seems to me to be the sort of thing that requires the STRONGEST POSSIBLE evidence and legal determination before a "reporter" starts making such accusations directly at the parent on national TV. Since our media won't police itself, I have no problem with a jury smacking them hard just to force them to be more reasonable in what they report.
Andy
Cosmic: Point taken. I am probably so prejudiced against (most) judges, (most) lawyers, and (most) lawsuits that it's hard for me to find much grace for the family of this young lady on this one. If she didn't want to answer the questions (now...I did not see the interview so I'm flying blind here) she could have just walked out. If she didn't want to handle the emotional distress of it all, she had two feet. I'm not gonna change your mind (obviously). But I think the broader problem is that people actually watch these kind of programs. You do raise an interesting point. You say that coverage of these cases (the Greta, or Nancy type coverage) is not in the greater public good. I guess I just assume that the public can decide for itself what is in it's own best interests. I don't listen to rap music, watch porn (or movies at all), or do drugs. I figure that those that do, don't have very good judgment...and that they will bear the consequences of it all. Just too libertarian for lawsuits like this I guess. Something in my ever-expanding gut tells me that this mother was suicidal before this interview. I have known several people that did themselves in, and there were many, many episodes in their lives that lead them to end it all. Heck, I'm not taking up for Nancy Grace. I just believe that this kind of lawsuit has no place in a court. But, I understand and appreciate your passion on the subject.
istariphoenix
Nancy Grace is a cast-iron bitch that deserves every bit of prosecution she pours out upon everyone she hammers on her show. She has no sense of understanding of what her last name means, and her feeble attempts at comedy, i.e., mimicking Scooby-Doo's "Ruh-Roh", only underscore how out-of-touch she is with the necessity for empowering people, for forgiveness, for second chances, and for the recognition that you can't blanket-statement people with your own preconceived notions simply because you are the host of a popular news show. Nancy is finally getting a taste of her own medicine with this heat. I hope and pray she learns a lesson and starts to understand, truly, what "grace" really is. Her attacks on sex offenders paint ALL of them the same, even the recovered ones who are accounted as treated and healed by their probation officers and treatment providers. Her assaults on subejcts in questionable cases already have them tarred and feathered much prior to the verdict being in. Stop playing judge, jury and executioner, Ms. Grace - YOU ARE NOT GOD.
pace
I don't think it is unreasonable that Nancy Grace should at least be required to defend herself for the comments she made to Melinda Duckett. I won't rehash what has already been stated, but I agree with the position that there must be limits to what can be printed or broadcast without consequence. In this case, there was every reason to believe that the interviewee may be mentally unstable and one would expect a responsible reporter to conduct themselves with a little more restraint under the circumstances. Particularly considering that Duckett had not been charged with any crime. The manner in which Grace relentlessly pursues the 'sensationalism' angle in the following interview is pretty representative of how she conducts herself IMHO, but she came out of this one with a little egg on her face. It made me chuckle. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5x8ARIxg51I
CosmicConservative
Good for Elizabeth Smart. I would probably have been less polite about it.
Andy
Well, I guess I am the least informed commenter when it comes to Nancy Grace. From what I have read here, she sounds a lot like my younger brother's second ex-wife. She is truly the walking definition of a man's worst nightmare. Watching Nancy Grace with Elizabeth Smart really informed me. Don't you just love Elizabeth "rolling her eyes" at a few of the questions? Good kiddo! I don't want to retract my assertion that no single event in a life can be held responsible for suicide (kinda personal). But I have learned a thing or two from this exchange.
CosmicConservative
All of these people practice "gotcha journalism" which is essentially a technique of misrepresenting their intenttions and then ambushing their "guest" with questions they did not agree to address and were not aware were going to be asked. In the case of Elizabeth Smart it is clear that she had specifically told the producers of the show that she was there to promote legislation, not to relive the sordid details of her kidnapping. The problem with these "journalists" is that they think they have the right to practice this sort of ambushing, depending on the person being so intimidated by the camera and the millions of viewers that they won't, as Elizabeth had the presence of mind to do, say "hey, you jerk, we discussed the parameters of this interview and you are not professional enough to stick to them." The whole point of this technique is to catch the victim off guard and get an emotional reaction. They aren't after "news" they are after any sort of "moment" that can generate a visceral emotional response from their viewers. It's not about truth, justice or fairness, it is about ratings, personal glory and competition with their like-minded peers. I despise all of them.
CosmicConservative
You want my opinion, in the Elizabeth Smart situation, Nancy was specifically trying to get her to break down in tears so she could ooze false sympathy while dollar signs rang up in her eyeballs.