Batman: The Dark Knight
By CosmicConservativeOK, so we waited a week to see the big blockbuster of the summer. The theater was still fairly crowded, even for a Friday matinee movie (I took Friday off this week). Usually matinee showings are virtually empty so that means the evening showings were probably full.
With the billions of words written and published about this movie, my minor little contribution really doesn't amount to much, but I'll go ahead and give my impressions anyway.
I've already commented recently about how interesting I find it that comic books and fantasy stories have become the standard blockbuster movie fare of our culture. I admit to feeling a bit of vindication from this, since comic books and fantasy/sci fi books and graphic novels were sneered at by "normal people" when I was a kid. If you talked about Spiderman and Batman in 1975 you were pretty much branded as a nerd. In 2005 you are completely in the mainstream, at least if you are talking about the movies BASED on the comic books. I guess talking about the comic books themselves still qualifies you for nerd-dom. Which is something I don't get, but hey, there's a lot I don't get about life.
As a kid growing up there were TWO "Batmans" (Three if you count the silly campiness of the TV series). The most common Batman was the glamorous, moralizing, de facto deputized "Caped Crusader" who roamed freely around Gotham City to the adoring adulation of the citizens who treated him like some sort of celebrity. This was the Batman who solved every problem with some amazing toy he retrieved from his capacious "Utility Belt" and who preached moral lessons to his young ward during life-and-death struggles with a string of inept henchmen and monologuing super villains.
But on occasion another Batman would appear. This is the "Batman" that came to be known in the comic book circles as the "Dark Knight." This was the Batman tormented by his past, compelled to vigilantism by the incompetence of the system and just barely (usually) in control of his rage. Those were the Batman comic books I loved. Those culminated in the revered graphic novel by Frank Miller "The Dark Knight Returns" (which came out the same year as "The Watchmen" for which there was a trailer in the Batman movie previews...)
It is "The Dark Knight" sort of "Batman" that the "Batman Begins" and "The Dark Knight" movies attempt to create on the silver screen. So there are really two questions here, one is how good the movie is, and the second is whether or not they really managed to recreate the "Dark Knight," particularly the Dark Knight of Miller's perception.
My thoughts are that they managed to create a very good movie, in fact I was quite pleasantly surprised by how good the movie was. Everyone talks about Heath Ledger's turn as "The Joker" and rightly so. If anyone has ever out-Nicholsoned Jack Nicholson, it is Heath Ledger as the Joker. His performance was stunning, perhaps crowned by the scene with the Joker in a nurse's outfit leaving a hospital in the act of being blown to bits.
The visuals in the movie are stunning, everything from the moody and gritty dark streets of Gotham to the casual luxury of the Wayne Penthouse suite. The camera work was a bit distracting at times with its attempts to create a sense of urgency in a Blair Witch sort of way, but only slightly, and when it worked, it did manage to create a frenetic sense of energy around the action. The dialogue was, in my opinion, a step above that of the other comic book movies, including Spiderman. There were attempts at true self-reflection and deeper understandings of events and our place in them.
But did it create a "Dark Knight?" Unfortunately, no. The Batman of this movie was still far too moralistic and restrained. Even in his most enraged moment, when he believed his supposed girlfriend's life was in danger, he still didn't give me that sense of having crested the very edge of the emotional cliff that the real Dark Knight dances on so perilously. Yes he tested the edges of his moral boundaries, yes he did some things that are altogether un-Caped Crusaderish. But if you want to see what I'm talking about, go read the graphic novels and see how much further into that dark psyche Miller takes Batman and you'll see what I mean.
Still, it was a great movie, and I am sure the lengths Batman went to surprised many who have never read the graphic novels. Was it better than Iron Man?
Yes, but not by nearly as much as some people are saying. Iron Man was also a very good movie. But Batman beats it.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.