Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Tiger's greatest tournament?

By CosmicConservative
Tiger Woods has the third round lead at the U.S. Open. He leads by one stroke at three under par. In Tiger terms, that would seem to be a disappointing performance, after all this is the man who won his first U.S. Open by lapping the field. But this is a different Tiger Woods. This is a Tiger who grimaces and clutches his surgically repaired left knee after climbing out of a bunker, and who limps noticeably as he makes his way down the fairway. This is a Tiger playing in pain, and playing on nothing but heart after a two-month layoff where he was unable to even play a full 18 hole practice round. The big question going into this tournament was not if Tiger could win it, but if Tiger could make the cut. He still has not won, and today he may have more difficulty after three days of playing on a hurt knee than he has had up until now. But regardless of whether he wins or not, his performance so far has been as astounding and as inspiring as any he has ever done, and that is saying something. I have to root for Tiger today. I don't play golf competitively, but I play golf on occasion, and even I know how little it takes to throw off the precision required to make a clean golf swing stroke after stroke, hole after hole, day after day. If anyone had any doubts about Tiger's mental toughness and his uncanny ability to seemingly perform based on pure willpower, yesterday's remarkable surge when he was on the verge of fading into oblivion should put that to rest forever.
ESPN - As others faltered, Woods held it together to take Open lead - Columnist The greatest part of Tiger Woods is the fact that he couldn't spell surrender if you stuck a dictionary in front of him and opened it to that page. He never gives up. While faint-hearted fellows like Phil Mickelson were collapsing Saturday at the first sign of adversity, a wounded Tiger regrouped to deliver the greatest six holes of his absurdly accomplished career.

Comments (28)

Andy
Cosmic: If you golf "occasionally," you're a better man than I am. I gave it up about 25 years ago after sinking 5 straight drives in the lake at Eastwood #8. :) I am a Tiger fan...not just the LSU Tigers. I watched him yesterday, and I've got to say that it was one of the most amazing rounds I have seen. Terrible drives...great drives...double bogeys...eagles...terrible putts...great putts. I know he's hurting. He's not the kind of guy that would go out there and look for pity. I think he may have come back too quickly. Heck, if I had knee surgery a month ago I'd be on the couch popping pain pills still. This could go down as Tiger's greatest tournament. Win or lose, I know he loves the game. He sure doesn't need the money. ;) I'm going to watch as much of The Open as I can this afternoon...it's Father's Day (sigh).
Drax
I'm not a Tiger "fan," I'm a Jack "fan," so every Major he wins brings him closer to eclipsing Jack. But, he's been playing in pain. I really don't give him much for this. He wants to eclipse Jack. There are only 4 majors a year. He already lost one. He HAS to win Majors to eclipse Jack. This is his best PGA course and best chance to win this year. Without some really LUCKY shots, insanely good putting (i.e., "luck" in the sense that a blade of grass didn't divert a 35 foot put away from the hole or a blade of grass diverted a 35 foot put into the hole....) he would still be back several strokes. If those types of shots don't continue, he will lose his first major going into the final round with a lead. I don't WANT him to lose, I just don't want him to WIN. Heh. Splitting the hairs....
Andy
Drax: I'm a Jack fan, too. I'm a fan of all the great ones. He's probably going to pass Jack one of these days...just like Aaron passed Ruth...and Bonds passed Aaron (sigh). That darned game of golf is so hard, that I have a great appreciation for the guys that can go out and master it. Tiger seems to have "luck" that other guys just don't. Hmmmmm...
Drax
Don't get me wrong, it's not "luck" when the ball goes exactly where you aimed it. That's skill. But, it's the SAME skill that MISSED 90 out of 100 of the SAME putt (or more, who knows) or caused the ball to ding away from the hole when it hit the flag instead of go in. Tiger has more "lucky" shots because he has more SKILL than all the rest of them, so that he'll HIT the flag more often, roll the ball correctly so that it will more often go into the hole (while missing that ball mark or sturdy blade of grass). Man. That 18th hole putt he made was just Tiger at his best, wasn't it? An 18 hole playoff against Tiger? Oh, man....that's a hill to climb!
Andy
Drax: I know what you mean. I missed the 18th. I had watched off and on through 17, but had to leave my Dad's house to get one of the kids back home in time for something...watched the replay. You're right. It's a hill for sure, but he's a stepper...we'll see.
CosmicConservative
Tiger's knee has got to be a factor today. Sure it's tough to face Tiger in an 18 hole playoff, but I am quite certain that having to play 18 more holes of golf was not what Tiger and his knee were hoping for. Right now I'd say Tiger is the underdog.
Drax
Heh. Someone actually did a study. Tiger has almost a 2 stroke advantage over the field just be being in the tournament. On average, the field does 2 strokes better when he isn't playing in the tournament. He's completely in their heads man. And, after that clutch "add to the legend" putt on the 18th yesterday, he's just going to dig ever deeper into their psyche.
Andy
Drax: I believe it! I started to mention just my anecdotal observations of such, but didn't. Tiger is in their heads, whether any of them will admit it or not. Jack was in his competitor's heads...Arnie was in his competitor's heads...etc... I have believed for years that Tiger gets an advantage just by showing up. Good, great, lucky, and intimidating... But every once in a while somebody sucks it up, locks the emotions in the closet, and beats him. We will see.
CosmicConservative
Seriously, he did it. This could go down as his greatest tournament ever. Man, I am a Jack Nicklaus fan myself, and I have always been a fan of his, but mostly I'm a fan of greatness, and Tiger is undeniably great. I love this. Way to go Tiger! On a bum knee no less. Woohoo!!!
Andy
Drax: It just ended on the 19th hole. I have to admit that I was secretly pulling for the old "journeyman" Rocco. It's kinda like me trying to keep up with my sons in basketball, or a five-mile run...I know I can't do it, but I hope that they stumble. I am always the one that stumbles! Tiger sucked it up. Rocco may have let Tiger finally invade his "head." Tiger is good. No, Tiger is "great." I hope that he takes a few months off, gets some good advice from his wife, agent, trainer, caddy, and knee surgeon. I'd like to see him just "sit out" for a while. He is a young man. He has several years yet to live his life. He is going to need his legs if he wants to enjoy it all. This Is One For The Ages. I hated golf while whacking around...but I love those the guys that can actually figure out that darned game!
Drax
It was an amazing tournament. It wasn't amazing only for what Tiger did, but for what Rocco did. He faced Tiger down in the final 18 holes of the tournament and went into the clubhouse with Tiger trailing. It was TIGER who had to chip in from the bunker and make the 35 foot putt to catch HIM. Rocco did what no other has done with Tiger in a major, caught Tiger when Tiger was ahead at the beginning of the final round. And, then the next 18? Rocco was 3 down with 8 to go and he caught up and passed Tiger until the 18th where Tiger had to put it on the green in TWO to catch up. The fact that Tiger DID make these shots when he needed to just adds to his legend, but, without Rocco NOT wilting under the pressure FOR NINETY HOLES is what made the TOURNAMENT one for the ages. It was something man...
CosmicConservative
By the way, these stories of one golfer or another "not wilting" under the enormous pressure of Tiger's presence are not new. The first time I saw such a story was in 2001 or so when Hal Sutton, of all people, held off a Tiger charge to win a tournament. If you want to see how many times a golfer did NOT wilt under the pressure of Tiger's presence (just like Jack's) look at Tiger's record for coming in second. Just like Jack he comes in second a LOT.
Andy
Cosmic: Did you see that Tiger is "out" for the season? I heard on the radio that he has a stress fracture that will require season ending surgery. I'm glad that he is going to sit out for a while. It will probably sink the PGA television ratings, but he is a young man. He has a long life ahead of him. No reason to hobble around as an old guy. It crossed my mind..."Man, poor Rocco!" His best chance ever to win a major...and Tiger just wouldn't quit! I hope he didn't do any damage that can't be undone. It gives credence to the idea that it was Tiger's greatest tournament. His second greatest tournament might have been the 2008 Masters. I know I'm panting like a bobby-sockser at an Elvis concert... But the guy is just great!
CosmicConservative
I was already impressed before I knew he played 91 holes on a fractured leg. This reminds me of the Rockies pitcher last year who pitched a full game after a first-inning line drive bounced off his leg, fracturing it. Like I said, I am a huge Jack Nicklaus fan. For that matter I am a huge Fred Couples fan and Phil Mickelson fan and any other number of golfers (Lee Trevino is actually one of my favorite golfers). I "like" many of them more than I "like" Tiger, but I root for Tiger because I root for greatness. And other than Jack, I have never seen a golfer with such an indominatable will and such mental toughness as Tiger. I love the idea that I am watching the greatest golfer ever, in his prime, each week in the PGA. I am bummed that he is out for the season. I hope he heals fully and comes back just as dominant as when he left. He has been fighting this knee for a year. In that time he has won something like nine of eleven tournaments he's played. That sort of dominance in the game of golf is phenomenal. Now, you can argue, as many have, that Jack had to deal with a far more competitive field than Tiger, which may or may not be true. But Jack never won nine of eleven tournaments, even on two GOOD knees.
Drax
As to quality of competition, here's a list of the people with the most top 10 finishes: Sam Snead: (1934-1965) 358 Most wins on the PGA Tour but mostly pre-Jack Jack Nicklaus - (1962-1985ish) 286 Arnold Palmer - (1954-1980ish) 245 Arnie had a huge overlap with Jack's career. For example, he was the Tour money leader in 1958, 1960, 1962, and 1963. "Palmer's most prolific years were 1960-1963, when he won 29 PGA Tour events in four seasons" He won SIX majors in four years. He had 62 tour wins, fourth all time, the vast bulk of them in Jack's years. Billy Casper - (1955ish - 1975ish) 236 Between 1964 and 1970 "Casper won 27 tournaments on the PGA Tour, which was more than legends Jack Nicklaus, Arnold Palmer, and Gary Player did during that time period." He had 51 PGA victories, placing him 7th all time. Tom Watson - (1971 - 1985ish) 218 "Watson was named PGA Player of the Year 6 times, 1977-1980, 1982 and 1984, and trails only Tiger Woods who was named 9 times" He won 8 majors in 8 years, heading the money list 5 times. He had 39 tour wins, 9th all time. Gene Littler (1954 - 1975ish) - 213 He had 29 tour wins, 18th all time. Tom Kite - (1972 - 1990ish) 209 His career was towards the end of Jacks, so not so much impact although he certainly had an impact. Gary Player - (1953 - 1980ish) - 177 Won 9 Majors during Jack's playing years. "Player is one of the most successful golfers in the history of the sport, ranking third (behind Roberto de Vicenzo and Sam Snead) in total professional wins, with at least a hundred and sixty-six, and tied fourth in major championship victories with nine. Along with Arnold Palmer and Jack Nicklaus he is sometimes referred to as one of "The Big Three" golfers of his era — from the late 1950s through the early 1970s — when golf boomed in the United States and around the world, greatly encouraged by expanded television coverage. Along with Gene Sarazen, Ben Hogan, Jack Nicklaus and Tiger Woods, he is one of only five players to win golf’s "career Grand Slam"." Lee Trevino - (1960 - 1990ish) - 166 29 Tour Wins, 18th All time. He won SIX majors. Hale Irwin - (1968 - 1990ish) - 165 3 Majors, 20 tour wins Raymond Floyd - (1960 - 1990ish) - 163 4 Majors, 22 Tour Wins. What does this tell us? Jack played against most of these guys...and most in their primes. That's why Jack has 19 second place finishes in MAJORS while Tiger has FIVE. (His only competition for people who are on the historical "leader board" in Top Ten Finishes OR in Tournament wins OR in Majors won are Vijay Singh (3 majors/ 31 wins/doesn't hit the boards in top 10 finishes) and Phil Mickleson (3 majors/ 34 wins/doesn't hit the boards in top 10 finishes). I can accept that Tiger is heads and tails above all of his competition. What I can't accept is that his competition even remotely COMPARES to the competiton Jack faced. I can't find a list of 2nd place finishes, but I remember a commentator saying that Jack's 2nd place finishes were about 1/2 of his tour wins or about 5 times that of Tiger. It stands to reason. During the time Jack played, he played against DOZENS of hall of fame golfers who are ALL on the historical "leader board" for Majors, Wins, and top 10 finishes. Where is Tiger's competition? Phil? Vijay? Ok. There's two. Where are the other TEN OR TWENTY who consistently won? Arnie ALONE outshines Phil and Vijay. Where's today's Trevino? Watson? Player? Casper? WHERE'S FLOYD? Or Kite? Or ANY of the hall of famers who were second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth, seventh fiddles to Jack, Arnie, and Gary? If there was a large fistful of "competition" out there today, we would SEE it. They would be IN the top 10. They would WIN tournaments. But, other than Phil and (before he got old) Vijay, THEY AIN'T THERE. They don't exist. Compare who won Majors during Jack's playing years (win number/total major wins): 1962 Arnold Palmer (5/7) Jack Nicklaus (1/18) Arnold Palmer (6/7) Gary Player (3/9) 1963 Jack Nicklaus (2/18) Julius Boros (2/3) Bob Charles Jack Nicklaus (3/18) 1964 Arnold Palmer (7/7) Ken Venturi Tony Lema Bobby Nichols 1965 Jack Nicklaus (4/18) Gary Player (4/9) Peter Thomson (5/5) Dave Marr 1966 Jack Nicklaus (5/18) Billy Casper (2/3) Jack Nicklaus (6/18) Al Geiberger 1967 Gay Brewer Jack Nicklaus (7/18) Roberto DeVicenzo (most professional wins all time) Don January 1968 Bob Goalby Lee Trevino (1/6) Gary Player (5/9) Julius Boros (3/3) 1969 George Archer Orville Moody Tony Jacklin (1/2) Ray Floyd (1/4) 1970 Billy Casper (3/3) Tony Jacklin (2/2) Jack Nicklaus (8/18) Dave Stockton 1971 Charles Coody Lee Trevino (2/6) Lee Trevino (3/6) Jack Nicklaus 1972 Jack Nicklaus (10/18) Jack Nicklaus (11/18) Lee Trevino (4/6) Gary Player (6/9) 1973 Tommy Aaron Johnny Miller (1/2) Tom Weiskopf Jack Nicklaus (12/18) 1974 Gary Player (7/9) Hale Irwin (1/3) Gary Player (8/9) Lee Trevino (5/6) 1975 Jack Nicklaus (13/18) Lou Graham Tom Watson (1/8) Jack Nicklaus (14/18) 1976 Ray Floyd (2/4) Jerry Pate Johnny Miller (2/2) Dave Stockton (2/2) 1977 Tom Watson (2/8) Hubert Green (1/2) Tom Watson (3/8) Lanny Wadkins 1978 Gary Player (9/9) Andy North (1/2) Jack Nicklaus (15/18) John Mahaffey 1979 Fuzzy Zoeller (1/2) Hale Irwin (2/3) Seve Ballesteros (1/5) David Graham (1/2) 1980 Seve Ballesteros (2/5) Jack Nicklaus (16/18) Tom Watson (4/8) Jack Nicklaus (17/18) 1981 Tom Watson (5/8) David Graham (2/2) Bill Rogers Larry Nelson (1/3) 1982 Craig Stadler Tom Watson (6/8) Tom Watson (7/8) Ray Floyd (3/4) 1983 Seve Ballesteros (3/5) Larry Nelson (2/3) Tom Watson (8/8) Hal Sutton 1984 Ben Crenshaw (1/2) Fuzzy Zoeller (2/2) Seve Ballesteros (4/5) Lee Trevino (6/6) 1985 Bernhard Langer (1/2) Andy North (2/2) Sandy Lyle (1/2) Hubert Green (2/2) 1986 Jack Nicklaus (18/18) Ray Floyd (4/4) Greg Norman (1/2) Bob Tway In this EIGHTEEN YEAR SPAN, there were only SIXTEEN people who didn't have MULTIPLE Major Wins. Now, let's look at the "Tiger Years:" 2008 Trevor Immelman Tiger Woods (14/14) 2007 Zach Johnson Ángel Cabrera Pádraig Harrington Tiger Woods (13/14) 2006 Phil Mickelson (3/3) Geoff Ogilvy Tiger Woods (11/14) Tiger Woods (12/14) 2005 Tiger Woods (9/14) Michael Campbell Tiger Woods (10/14) Phil Mickelson (2/3) 2004 Phil Mickelson (1/3) Retief Goosen (2/2) Todd Hamilton Vijay Singh (3/3) 2003 Mike Weir Jim Furyk Ben Curtis Shaun Micheel 2002 Tiger Woods (7/14) Tiger Woods (8/14) Ernie Els (3/3) Rich Beem 2001 Tiger Woods (6/14) Retief Goosen (1/2) David Duval David Toms 2000 Vijay Singh (2/3) Tiger Woods (3/14) Tiger Woods (4/14) Tiger Woods (5/14) 1999 José María Olazábal (2/2) Payne Stewart (3/3) Paul Lawrie Tiger Woods (2/14) 1998 Mark O'Meara (1/2) Lee Janzen (2/2) Mark O'Meara (2/2) Vijay Singh (1/3) 1997 Tiger Woods (1/14) Ernie Els (2/3) Justin Leonard Davis Love III There are SIXTEEN first timers in ELEVEN years. Only four with three Majors besides Tiger, and only one with a legitimate shot at winning more than that. In Jack's era? Player (9), Watson (8), Palmer (7), Trevino (6) Thompson (5), Ballesteros (5) Floyd (4) and three more with 3. Tiger's good. But, he doesn't have the competition Jack did. Not even close. Cream rises to the top, and the only "cream" playing in Tiger's era are him, Phil, and Vijay. That is ALL.
CosmicConservative
OK, there are so many mathematical ways to analyze and dissect this information. Here are a few: 1. You are comparing Jack's entire career of roughly 30 years to Tiger's entire career of roughly 10. In 2028 or so we'll look back and compare 32 years of competition to Jack's 32 years of competition. Deal? 2. Competition can be measured both by the number of top rivals, and by the overall quality of the competition. Your statistics, which you think so clearly show how much better the competition was for Jack, could just as easily, and in my opinion more factually be evidence of exactly the opposite. When Jack played he had about a dozen players he had to beat, because if he didn't win the tournament or the major, one of those guys usually did. So for years the PGA tour was really Jack, Arnie, Gary, Tom, Hale, and a few others. The rest of the competition was SO POOR that they did not rise up and challenge these dominant dozen golfers. Today that is not true. Not only are there far more AMERICAN golfers who can on any given day turn in an astonishingly good performance, but there are FAR MORE European and other foreign golfers who can do the same. What you are demonstrating is not so much that Jack had MORE competition, but in fact that Jack had LESS. Tiger has to beat an elite field of HUNDREDS of golfers each week, Jack just had to beat a dozen or so.
Drax
Oops...can't count. In Jack's era, TWENTY-FOUR years, there were sixteen "first timers" compared to sixteen in Tiger's ELEVEN years. Much better.
Drax
I can see how someone who wishes to view it that way can. However, it flies in the face of everything we know about competition on a major stage in every other sport well...in the history of the world. Especially in individual sports. In tennis, you have the top 10 in the world (using whatever formula they use to figure that). But, you'll always see the same handful in the quarter-finals, semi-finals, and finals. Over and over until they're replaced by another group of "elites." Same with bowling. Same with track and field. Same with Gymnastics. Same with figure skating. Same with EVERY INDIVIDUAL SPORT in the history of mankind. There are ALWAYS a group of "elites" who dominate, however small that group is. Sometimes it's larger; sometimes it's smaller -- but it ALWAYS EXISTS. We could just take the first ELEVEN years of Jack and compare. It would look about the same. 1962 Arnold Palmer (5/7) Jack Nicklaus (1/18) Arnold Palmer (6/7) Gary Player (3/9) 1963 Jack Nicklaus (2/18) Julius Boros (2/3) Bob Charles Jack Nicklaus (3/18) 1964 Arnold Palmer (7/7) Ken Venturi Tony Lema Bobby Nichols 1965 Jack Nicklaus (4/18) Gary Player (4/9) Peter Thomson (5/5) Dave Marr 1966 Jack Nicklaus (5/18) Billy Casper (2/3) Jack Nicklaus (6/18) Al Geiberger 1967 Gay Brewer Jack Nicklaus (7/18) Roberto DeVicenzo (most professional wins all time) Don January 1968 Bob Goalby Lee Trevino (1/6) Gary Player (5/9) Julius Boros (3/3) 1969 George Archer Orville Moody Tony Jacklin (1/2) Ray Floyd (1/4) 1970 Billy Casper (3/3) Tony Jacklin (2/2) Jack Nicklaus (8/18) Dave Stockton 1971 Charles Coody Lee Trevino (2/6) Lee Trevino (3/6) Jack Nicklaus 1972 Jack Nicklaus (10/18) Jack Nicklaus (11/18) Lee Trevino (4/6) Gary Player (6/9) 1973 Tommy Aaron Johnny Miller (1/2) Tom Weiskopf Jack Nicklaus (12/18) Jack hits the end of Arnie's career, in the middle of Gary's career, the beginning of Trevino's career. As Arnie falls off, Trevino comes in. As Gary falls off Watson comes in. The cream rises. That's what's so important about "top 10 finishes." Other than Vijay and Mickleson, there's no one who even rates (and they only rate at the very bottom of the "leader board.") There's no identifiable group of "elites" once you get beyond those three. But, those three ARE "elite," aren't they? By your logic, since the competition is so much better today (comparing today's players to today's players) then there should be no group of "elites." But, there is. There ALWAYS is. It's just very, very, very, very small.
CosmicConservative
I disagree completely. There is one elite, and that is Tiger. The other "elites" have won a few majors, not 7 or 9. They've actually studied this effect in sports and there have been mathematical doctorates published on the subject. This is why you had .400 hitters in baseball in its early years, but not now. The competition was WORSE in those days. There were a few really good pitchers, but most were journeymen pitchers who would barely rise to the upper tier of the minor leagues today. Similarly there were a few ELITE hitters, and they feasted on the poor pitching. Put Ty Cobb in a modern baseball lineup and he'd be hitting in the mid .330s. ;)
Drax
There is no question that athletes of today are better, bigger, stronger, than those of yesteryear, even if "yesteryear" is only a few decades ago. There is also no question that equipment is better, the player's knowledge of their games is better, that the players have better trainers and managers, and that the players have access to computerized models which help them perfect their game. Is this somehow a question? Is it pertinent? We're comparing the FIELD back then to the FIELD today. In Jack's day, the FIELD had a couple of DOZEN people who could WIN when Jack didn't and who were ALWAYS "in the hunt" even if he (or someone else) did. Today, we STILL have an "elite" group of people who can WIN on a SUSTAINED BASIS even when Tiger is playing and who on a SUSTAINED BASIS are "in the hunt" whether or not Tiger plays. THOSE are the "elite" in golf. Singh, Mickleson, Els, O'Mera, Goosen, and a few others. When Jack didn't win a Major, in the largest part, ONE OF THE "ELITES" DID. The FIELD had a large group of people who COULD win and DID win on a SUSTAINED BASIS, regardless of who was playing on any given day. There is a much smaller group of golfers who fit that description today. Saying that there are a bunch of "nobodies" who can "win on any given day" because they and the rest of the field are so equal to each other completely BELIES the fact that there IS a group of people who SEPARATE THEMSELVES FROM THE PACK and WIN or place in the top 10 ON A SUSTAINED BASIS while the rest of these golfers who appear out of nowhere essentially retreat back into their obscurity while the "elites" just KEEP ON WINNING and KEEP ON PLACING in the top 10. And, I can agree that Tiger is in a "super elite" group of ONE in comparison to the FIELD. But to say that Phil, Mickleson, Steward et al AREN'T "elite" in comparison to the rest of the field is to utterly disregard their ACCOMPLISHMENTS in comparison to the rest of the field. You know...where they keep BEATING the rest of the field or are in the hunt while the vast majority of the "non-elites" stopped looking at the leader board after the first round and just hope to make the cut?
CosmicConservative
I don't think you understand me. I am not saying there are FEWER Tom Watsons and Gary Players and Arnold Palmers for Tiger to deal with, I am saying that there is an order of magnitude MORE of them, and they are not only competing with Tiger, they are competing with each other. The playing field is much more level at the elite level. That's what I'm saying And that's also why what Tiger is doing is so incredible. He's putting up these numbers against an ARMY of Arnold Palmers, not just a handful.
Drax
I understand perfectly what you're saying. I just completely and utterly disagree with it. EVERY sport now draws from an international and multi-racial population that it didn't in earlier years. EVERY sport now has stronger, faster, bigger players who are better trained and more educated about their sport and who have access to better equipment as well as highly developed technology (both mental and physical) which improves their games. And EVERY sport has a group of ELITES who dominate. Period. Now and in every era of every sport. The numbers clearly bear that out. The Micklesons, Singhs, Stewarts, O'Meras are BETTER than the rest of the field (except Tiger). The BEAT the rest of the field more than they are beat BY the rest of the field. They have carved themselves HALL OF FAME careers with top 10 finishes, PGA tour victories, and Major victories. The REST of the field HAS NOT. That's because, contrary to your assertion that, other than Tiger, the rest of the field are on a par with each other, the numbers just doesn't bear that out. In order to be considered an "elite" you actually have to ACCOMPLISH something. Win a significant number of Tour victories. Place in the top 10 with some consistency. You know...do what Singh, O'Mera, Mickleson et al HAVE DONE and CONTINUE to do. When you have SUSTAINED EXCELLENCE, you separate yourself from the pack. Since we DO have a relatively small group of people who HAVE a record of "sustained excellence" it is CLEAR that there IS a group of "elites." Since that group has members leaving and joining all the time as careers begin and end, we also know that THERE'S ROOM IN THAT GROUP for more to join. If they can. They just have to DO it. Like Phil and Vijay did, like O'Mera and Stewart did. It's inevitable that some will, for some always do, in every sport, in every era. And, every sport has a "golden age," a time where many greats play at the same time. Every sport has times when it's tough to find a significant number of dominant players, when the field is weakened. It takes a SPECIAL athlete to separate himself from the field of other world-class athletes. There's never a time when SOME don't. But, there are times when there aren't that MANY who do. Golf is simply going through a time where there aren't many with sufficient "killer instinct" or whatever mental quality it takes to claw your way to the top of the heap. That will change. It always does. Whether it will happen while Tiger is still playing is another question, but I think that it will. It's been too long since Tiger has been "top dog." Someone WILL come along and challenge him for that title, maybe MANY "someones." We can talk about this in another decade and see who is right...
CosmicConservative
Ok, let's check again in a decade. By then, if Tiger performs at a consistent level, he will have won 21 or 22 majors compared to Jack's 18. He'll have come in second 12 or 13 times compared to Jack's 19. Overall he'll have come in first or second 34 or 35 times compared to Jack's 37. Comparing their first eleven years on tour, Jack won 11 majors, and Tiger won 13. That's actually closer than most people think it is, and includes a "slump" of a couple years in a row with no majors for both of them. Tiger's record is better for wins, but not as good for second place finishes, but again the overall comparison is closer than most people think. Combining first and second place finishes for the two golfers in their first eleven years on tour (and remember, this is counting a year in which Tiger is missing the second half of the 2008 season, where I think we all would agree he had a pretty good chance of winning or coming in second for one or two more tournaments) Jack has 21, Tiger has 18. In my personal opinion, in terms of dominance, Tiger and Jack are actually pretty close. The question isn't about Jack or Tiger, it's about the rest of the field and whether there is a higher quality of overall competition now or then, and if there IS a difference, then you have to say that the player who dominates the higher quality field has to be held in higher regard. If you want to argue that the field was as good or better in 1962-1972 as it was in 1998 - 2008, knock yourself out. I doubt you'll get many experts in the area of golf to agree with that assertion. Arguing that six or seven OTHER golfers also dominated the weaker field does not strengthen that argument, it just says that there were six or seven OTHER golfers in Jack's heyday that were also good enough to dominate a weaker field, and that they also competed somewhat favorably with Jack. In mathematical terms this is all about the distribution curve, and how flat or steep it is. It is my assertion that the curve was somewhat steeper in the seventies, which meant that the top ten in that period outperformed the rest of the field more than the top ten in the last decade. This is reflected by the larger number of top ten players who won several majors compared to now. The fact that Tiger is winning MORE majors in a period when that overall distribution curve is so much flatter is a fairly strong argument that Tiger is MORE dominant than Jack was, not less.
CosmicConservative
By the way, how many majors did Jack win with a broken leg and a torn anterior crucate ligament?
Drax
Dunno. Maybe if he had had one, maybe we would know. I give Tiger credit for doing what he did, but don't denigrate others who didn't -- especially as we don't know what they would have done or could have done if confronted with the same situation. Look. Apparently you think that I'm comparing the field of today to the field of yesterday, otherwise much of what you've written simply doesn't make any sense. I'm not. I'm comparing the field of yesteryear to ITSELF and the field of today to ITSELF, finding that, of the field of yesteryear, there were many more who clearly defined themselves as "elites" WITHIN THAT FIELD while in today's field, THERE AREN'T AS MANY. What POSSIBLE reasoning there could be which would lead one to the conclusion that I'm comparing today's field to yesteryear's eludes me utterly. Jack "lapped the field" twice. Tiger has "lapped the field" three times and will likely lap it at least once more unless one or more "elites" join the field and win 8-10 Majors and 50 or so Tour wins. The more "elites" who join the field, the less Tiger will win. If it continues as now with this WEAK field of golfers who can't seem to find a way to WIN or even PLACE on anything which resembles a consistent basis, then Tiger may win 30 Majors. Winning at an individual sport, especially ones more invested with SKILL rather than athletic ability, is heavily dependent on the MENTAL TOUGHNESS of the player. Maintaining concentration in the face of obstacles. Keeping "on track" when things don't go right. Thinking about THIS shot instead of your LAST shot or your NEXT shot. Etc. Etc. Etc. On any given day, any of the "nobodies" CAN win (just as in any OTHER era) but, they don't. And, they don't BECAUSE they don't HAVE that "mental toughness" to face down Tiger or Phil or just the pressure in general with any CONSISTENCY. Jack had to contend with people who we can POINT TO and say...."Yeah. These guys KNEW HOW TO WIN," because they DID win, and they won on a consistent basis no matter WHO was playing. That just isn't true today. I'm hoping for some newbies to show up who have that "intangible" which is required to separate yourself from the pack of other world-class golfers.
Drax
Heh. Vijay said essentially the same thing I did, although about British golfers. What he said about them is true about U.S. golfers...just no "fire in the belly...."