Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Texas must return polygamist children

By CosmicConservative
I don't want to get into how much I hate "Child Protective Services" and any other government organization that has the power to presume your guilt and steal your children away from you before any due process whatsoever.... I'll just say that I was waiting for this ruling and I am not surprised by it at all.
Court: Polygamist sect's children must go home | Postcards Child Protective Services should not have seized more than 450 children from the YFZ Ranch near Eldorado, the Texas Supreme Court ruled Thursday, moving families from the polygamist sect a large step closer to reunification. The almost unanimous decision — three judges filed a separate opinion disagreeing with part of the ruling — is a blow to CPS efforts to keep the children in foster care.

Comments (31)

Andy
My opinion of the judiciary is that if courts played baseball, they'd never make it to the majors. I think they bat about .175. But the Texas Supreme Court has gone yard on this one...and the appeals court before them. This has been one of the true travesties of my lifetime committed by any State. I lay this deal right at Rick Perry's feet. Thank God that the Court stepped in. Heck, I don't know the level of "abuse" in Eldorado...or if there was any at all. I still suspect that nut-job woman from Colorado was the "little girl" that called CPS. I really believe that CPS didn't like these folks, and just used the occasion to try and clean house, never suspecting that the public at large would be outraged. I think those CPS people live in their own little cave and believe themselves to be doing "God's work." After a while (living in your own kingdom) you can convince yourself that you "are" God. Every once in a while the Court hits a dinger. Kudos!
Drax
I believe that it is abuse of the highest order to close off your children from the world, tell them that they must live by rules given by theocrats or go to hell, and marry your children off at a young age to older men in a "family" setting which is contrary to the laws of the country you live in (and whose protection you seek when you're caught).
CosmicConservative
So you put yourself in the category of those who know best how other people should live their own lives then? You consider this to be child abuse "of the highest order?" Really? Higher than, oh, I don't know, throwing them into gas chambers? Or enslaving them to work in factories 14 hours per day? I'm all for enforcing the law, but taking children away from their families on the strength of one unconfirmed phone call seems to be more than the state should be allowed to do. Just my $.02....
Andy
Drax: I am usually in locked step with you, but come on... I have friends that had their children snagged from them in a restaurant by CPS because they chose to give them a whack on the butt to try to stop them from bothering every other patron. They ended up spending tons of money, going to "parental counseling," and had their kids really "damaged" by being put in foster care for almost a month. Look, no matter how "weird" you (and I) see this cult, it is a very, very slippery slope. Heck, who knows? Maybe shielding kids from MTV, YouTube, Rap Music, and "MF'ing this and that" you hear everywhere might be more "enhancement" than "abuse." And I have a strong opposition to the idea that marrying off a child at a young age is such a big problem. My great grandmother was 12 years old when she married in the backwoods of North Carolina. She did just fine, and raised a fine family. My own mother married my Dad way before "legal age." She did just fine, and raised a good family. The Virgin Mary was probably about 12 when she bore The Savior. I know that it is a different world now. But my Libertarian self tells me that it's nobody's business how parents choose to raise their children. How would you feel if one day a theocracy ran the US, and told you that letting your kids have an IPOD was damnable...or that your daughter must be married by the time she hits her prime child-bearing age of 13 to 17? It's the same thing. You say that it is the "highest order of child abuse to close off your children from the world..." It might well be the the highest order of love to not allow their minds to be polluted by this putrid society that we live in. I think that the truth is somewhere in the middle...but come on...child abuse? When you talk about the "laws" of the country, I can go with you on that one. I am wondering if any of these FLDS people went down to the county courthouse to get a marriage license, and lied about the ages of those younger than 18? I doubt it. Marriage license laws are just a big old joke. They are a way for the State to collect fees, and establish legal (and taxing) control over people. I could be wrong, but I doubt that any "legal marriage" ever took place between a 14-year-old girl, and a 28-year-old man at the FLDS compound. These people marry in the eyes of God according to their religion. The legal argument doesn't apply to their marriages. If sex between a 28-year-old, and a 14-year-old is illegal in the State of Texas...well, let them prove it happened! Get a real, living, breathing human woman to file a complaint against her abuser...then investigate that complaint...bring charges against the evil abuser! But don't grab up over 450 children (many young boys), and subject them to separation from the stability of their life (however odd you and I may find it). I'm Sorry...this case really ticks me off!!!!
Drax
CC: I used a "tad" (and only a "tad") of hyperbole in saying "higst order," but you went straight to comparing GENOCIDE to "child abuse" in your response....sheesh. Andy: The only thing which distinguishes people from animals is our MINDS. The opposable thumb ain't worth much if you can't think. These people take from their children the ability to THINK FOR THEMSELVES, not only trying to teach them and protect them from this "putrid" world, but SHUTTING THEM OFF from it in a compound segregated from the rest of us. And, in that COMPOUND, what do they do? They hand off their female children to fulfill their roles as child bearers and man servants to the men. In America. If a thinking person of age decides that this is the kind of life they want to live, that's one thing. RAISING them to fulfill this demeaning role, telling them that this is their lot in life as ordained by GOD, and preventing them from (whether directly or by the INDOCTRINATION they receive from birth) becoming actual, living breathing, THINKING human beings by keeping them so cloistered...I'm sorry, but that's QUITE another. Believe me, I'm as antagonistic as humanly possible towards CPS and have fought them tooth and nail in many a case. My father and I used to call the the "Brown shirts," likening them to Italy's facists of WWII...even to their faces...even in court. I have significant difficulty with not only their extra-constitutional power but also their methods which are frequently exercised with arrogance which would astonish anyone who has not encountered it first hand. And, this case should have been handled differently. But, if it is the PRACTICE of this CULT to marry off THIRTEEN YEAR OLD CHILDREN to have sex with grown men WHAT CHILD IN THAT COMPOUND IS SAFE from what, in every state in the union, STATUTORY RAPE? Really. How is that NOT sufficient cause to remove the children from this compound? Can anyone here say with a straight face that that was NOT the practice? How many underaged girls were pregnant? (I read one account that 44 were. I don't know for sure. Some reports puts it at 5 of 27 or rougly ONE FIFTH of the underaged girls were pregnant.) AT THAT MOMENT. At that moment. At that moment. How many more had been pregnant? How many more were having sex with their "husbands" but weren't yet pregnant? We know that in this supposed RELIGIOUS COMPOUND that ONE IN FIVE (viewed in the BEST light possible) of the underaged girls WERE pregnant AT THAT MOMENT. Spare me.
Andy
Drax: I'll spare you! I have no doubt that many of the girls were pregnant AT THAT MOMENT. And I have no doubt that many of the fathers were a good bit older than the girls. But, I have a different view of whether that is bad or good than you do. As I said before, I have many family members that bore children in their teens. My great grandmother was one...my Mother was one...Heck, Mrs. Andy was one of them. Hmmmm...maybe that explains the obviously brain-damaged actions of my family. ;) You know...they're all pixillated...except me! :) You are a lot more experienced than I am in legal matters, but I think that there is a big difference in "child abuse," and "statutory rape." I have seen 19-year-old guys go to jail for having sex with their 16-year-old girlfriend for "statutory rape." Both kids were happy about it, but one parent pressed charges...and there ya' go...sex offender registry for life! I do have my limits. If there was some guy in the FLDS compound having sex with a 7-year-old girl or boy, I'd say "chop his boys off!" I think that you and I are on the same page in our repugnance of the practices of Social Services, as they are known down here in LA (I know that you know that)...I call them "The SS." I want to apologize in advance if I have read something that you have not written in your comment. What I read was: "If a thinking person of age decides that this is the kind of life they want to live, that’s one thing." From that, it seems that every child in America should be exposed to modern American culture, regardless of their parent's religious beliefs, so that they could make up their own mind about how to live their lives as an adult. Once again, if that's not what you meant, I apologize. That is not what I want for my children. I don't want their schools offering "Jenny has two Mommies," or "Johnny has two Daddies" as an example of something acceptable. Even though it is a real slice of American Pie, I don't want my kids to see it. Does that make me a bad father? Just because I want to shield my kids from the evil in this world before they are able to process it all, I should not have them taken from me if I object at a School Board meeting. I am sure that you would agree with me on that one. (I know that is an extreme example, but it's right around the corner Pal.) One man's "righteous" life can be viewed as "sinful" by another man. I've done my very best (well...kinda) to raise my kids in a righteous, and loving way. But, an FLDS member (or an Islamic cleric) looking at my family might believe that I am "abusing" my children. I allow them to surf the internet...to listen to rock-n-roll (they love classic rock from our generation)...to watch some of the garbage on television, etc. I know from your comments that you don't like the way this case was handled at all, and I appreciate that. The truth is that much of the world lives this way still. Only in the last 100 years or so of human history has it become verboten (in Western society in particular) for a 13-year-old girl to marry a 30-year old man and begin to bear children. Maybe we are a nation of "thinking people" that have traded our opposable thumbs for an expanded cerebrum that dooms our kids to not becoming an adult until they are 18 years old (the magic, legal number)... Maybe these FLDS people teach their children early on to be responsible...to clean up behind themselves...to work hard, etc. Maybe they teach them the way that my Baptist great grandmother in Union County, NC was taught as she grew up before being married at age 12. Maybe, by the time these FLDS girls are teenagers, they are ready to take on the rigors of raising children. And maybe, just maybe, they are not so consumed with "our world" that they really care about a career, climbing some ladder, or finding "Mr. Perfect." Maybe, it is their culture, and they are completely contented with it. It might seem really "weird" to you and me, but it is "what they know." And I am not willing to deny anyone contentment, regardless of how foreign it is to me. To go a bit further...It might be possible that those FLDS teenage girls like having sex, and love babies. I mean, God did put a "nature" within us all. Teenagee girls have always had children, and liked sex. As a very unattractive guy that had more than one decent-looking chick "offer," in my younger days, I can say that I was pretty surprised! I am not willing to label this as "abuse." There is an inherent yearning in girls to be a "Wife and Momma." It's just the way that God constructed females. I know that The State of Texas has laws. I'm not arguing that. And you and I both know that there is a better way for all of these children to come up. But as I said earlier...the truth is somewhere in the middle. Once again...this case just gripes me big time!
Drax
Andy: I have always had an issue with the arbitrary assignment of a certain age for a person to engage in sex with an "adult" (again, an arbitrary age in itself). However, there MUST be such an age. If there isn't AN age, however arbitrary, then...well, then there isn't any age which is protected however young. So, if we just say that ONE IN FIVE girls of that "society" have been statutorily raped in that particular slice in time, it is utterly certain that it has been happening for a long period of time and will continue to happen ... since it's supported by and encouraged by the PARENTS who, themselves, were indoctrinated in this way of thinking. It is a society which condones and encourages the rape of their children. While THEY may not think it's "rape," that HARDLY matters. THEY don't get to choose what is and what is not criminal. And, of course, absent brainwashing to the contrary, just about every person, girl or guy, "likes" having sex. However, most parents don't throw their girl-child into the arms of a 50 year old man on their 13th birthday either to "enjoy" sex. I didn't understand this at all: "It might seem really “weird” to you and me, but it is “what they know.” And I am not willing to deny anyone contentment, regardless of how foreign it is to me." I'm not going to delve much into that, I'll let you re-read your comment with an objective mind and decide for yourself just how large an umbrella such gives to any abberrant behavior, asking yourself whether skin-heads, Islamic fanatics, Nazis or whomever finds "contentment" in their beliefs. This concerns me: "Maybe, by the time these FLDS girls are teenagers, they are ready to take on the rigors of raising children. And maybe, just maybe, they are not so consumed with “our world” that they really care about a career, climbing some ladder, or finding “Mr. Perfect.” Maybe, it is their culture, and they are completely contented with it." WHO CARES? This cult doesn't get to make up their own laws. Beyond that, it doesn't matter what the adherents to this cult believe, because they BELIEVE AS THEY ARE TAUGHT. They, no more than any person who is captured and controlled has the ability to think for themselves. While I don't BLAME the parents for their OWN brainwashing, the cycle MUST be broken for a cult which makes as a practice the CRIMINAL ACTIVITY they engage in cannot be allowed to survive as it currently exists. We don't get to make up our own laws. Period. It doesn't matter if you dress up your criminal enterprise in "religion" or whatever, you have to OBEY THE LAW. How far would you go with this forgiving attitude? We have determined that statutory rape seems to be "okay" so long as it is "in the name of religion," so what other criminal activity is cool with you so long as it's dressed up with religious overtones? While I don't think that every child MUST be exposed to this "putrid" world if the parent(s) would prefer sheltering them. That's the parents' choice. But, if in exercising that choice, they raise their child by brainwashing them that CRIMINAL BEHAVIOR is not only acceptable behavior...but it is behavior demanded by GOD, then we have a problem. When that singular parent becomes a self-sustaining CULT where generation after generation of children are raised in such a fashion, then we have an even bigger problem. People tend to reflect the society in which they are raised. The more cloistered and closed-off a society is, the greater the adherence to the society's mores since the CONSEQUENCES of not adhering to those mores is so great. In the case of this cult, each member is told from the earliest age that leaving the cult puts their very soul at risk, dissallows them even in the afterlife from seeing their parents, friends, loved ones. With NO ability to critically examine these beliefs, the brainwashed children become the next generation of "parents" who pass their "wisdom" down to THEIR children. Just because something is done in the name of "religion" doesn't make it excusable. Just because we recognize that the age for "adulthood" is an arbitrary one doesn't make it a HARD LINE beyond which one who is over it doesn't have sex with one under it...let alone BEAR CHILDREN and pass this criminal behavior down to their own children. They want to live in a world of their own rules, then they need to go somewhere they are able to do so. That ain't here.
Andy
Drax: You are right. "That ain't here." But you don't know that 13 year-old girls are given up to 50 year old men at the FLDS compound, any more than I know the atomic weight of barium. It's a cult for sure. Nobody knows anything. Nobody even knows how old the mothers are, or who belongs to who. You ask how far I would go with "this forgiving attitude." It's not a forgiving attitude at all. I think they're all nuts! I think those kids would be better off in a loving, stable household like mine. ;) As I said at the outset, this case really gripes me! It has gotten under my skin big-time. My great revulsion with this whole deal is that law enforcement "came for them." And one day they might "come for the rest of us." They came with flimsy allegations, flawed procedures, and an obvious disregard for the fact that 460 kids were taken away from their families...their stability. Maybe I am more sensitive to this kind of thing than others might be. I have seen up close and personal the damage that can be done by separating a child from a parent. I guess we all have seen it, but it just rips my guts out. I could go into long details, but suffice it to say that I have in the past, and am in the present dealing with young people that probably would have loved to have parents that would go to court to get them back. Like I said...this case really gripes me!
Drax
I agree that this wasn't the way to do it, depending on how "it" is defined. But, here's the problem: They have a report of a statutory rape. It comes from a cloistered cult where the practice of child marriage is well known, where polagamy is known to be practiced. But, how to get proof? They can't infiltrate the "compound." They can't patrol it. No witnesses will come forth (or very few) since excommunication takes on a whole new and foreboding reason in the Mormon religion -- especially these fringe Mormon religions with a meaning which goes beyond the end of life -- even to the "end of all things." As you say, those living in the compound think that their lifestyle isn't only "right" but is "moral" as ordained by GOD. Are they supposed to be ALLOWED to live a lifestyle which condones and promotes underaged sex? (I really don't know how anyone could argue that this isn't the case since approximately 20% of the underaged girls in this "religious" compound -- which is closed in and everyone knows everyone else and what everyone else is doing -- are pregnant) How are they to know who is married to whom since they don't get married in the eyes of the STATE -- just in the eyes of the cult? Birth records? Not so much... Etc. The state knows that this cult is practicing a "religion" which condones statutory rape and illegal marriages, so HOW were they to deal with it once they "received the call" by one of the girls? (If, indeed, it was one of them or they actually received the call...) Are people supposed to be able to just set up a closed off community and set their own laws in violation of the laws of the state in which they live? I hate cults. All of them. What is done to the minds of children (and adults) in the name of religion never fails to sicken me.
Dadman
It's obvious, Drax, you hate cults...and maybe religion too. Let me try to set the record straight (again), the church I belong to which is frequently referred to as the 'Mormon' church has virtually nothing in common with these FLDS sects. The way I and my family live our lives and express our faith is utterly different than these so-called 'Mormon' FLDS communities. There are many zany cults out there that base their doctrine on the Bible and may even claim to be Christian (the kool-aid gulping People's Temple may have been one), but in fact are orders of magnitude different than, let's say, Methodists who also use the Bible and claim to be Christian. The same distinction needs to be drawn between these seclusionist loons and the mainstream Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. If you are unable to discern that distinction I can only assume you don't want to...
Dadman
Bottom line: My religion and their religion are not the same religion...not even close. You implied that, Drax, in your last post.
Drax
The only comparison I drew to the Mormon cult in Texas and the main-stream Mormon religion was the practice of excommunication. Do you wish to discuss the main-stream Mormon practice of excommunication?
Drax
Dadman: I tried to NOT even SAY the word "Mormon" so not to offend the hyper-sensitive to any non-pleasing reference to their religion, but, I felt such a reference to the consequences an adherent to that religion would feel regarding excommunication was necessary. Are you defending the right of this CULT (notice that this is the name I gave this group throughout this thread -- quite unlike the MSM to be sure which ensured that some Mormon identifying tag was embedded in the text) to engage in marrying off minors to grown men since just ... about ... every ... single ... word of what I've said was directed at THAT -- not trashing of religion in general or of yours in particular. Yet, you chimed in only because I used the forbidden word "Mormon" to attack me.
Dadman
You said: They can’t infiltrate the “compound.” They can’t patrol it. No witnesses will come forth (or very few) since excommunication takes on a whole new and foreboding reason in the Mormon religion — especially these fringe Mormon religions with a meaning which goes beyond the end of life — even to the “end of all things.” Really? So, you're saying the loonies in Texas are feeling the same sense of forboding that us normal, regular Mormons do. Is that what you mean? And this sense of forboding that you've determined normal Mormons endure every day has a direct bearing on Texas law enforcement's ability to gather evidence against this FLDS sect because, afterall, there is very little difference between how these 'Mormon' fundies think and how mainstream Mormons think. Right? It's a 'Mormon' imperative, fundie or mainstream, to obstruct justice (or do other odious things) because of our fear of excommunication? Let me be very, very clear for the umpteenth time: Mormons are free-thinking mainstream Americans. We are not cultists controlled by some theocratic hegemon that sits in Salt Lake City. We do not live in compounds. We do not marry children. We are (generally) well educated and successful in every walk of life you can imagine. People join and leave the Church all the time. Some join, leave, and then re-join. The cosmology and practice of modern 'Mormonism' has virtually nothing in common with this FLDS sect, including a 'forboding' fear of excommunication that is, according to your theory, going to lead to obstruction of justice in Texas. Yes, 'Mormons' are sometimes excommunicated, just as Catholics are sometimes excommunicated. The primary reasons for this, as I understand it, are serious things like adultery and/or apostasy. But I'm only guessing because in 30 years I've never known anyone who's been excommunicated. I don't believe it's ever happened in the 'ward' I attend every week. It's a very rare event. I've rambled and I'm tired so I'm going to bed. Hopefully a forboding prospect of excommunication will not give me nightmares...
Dadman
I really, really hate to argue about this stuff. You think I'm hyper-sensitive - fine. I don't care. Just don't paint mainstream 'Mormons' with the same brush you use to paint these FLDS sects. Perhaps you didn't intend to do that, but when you start ascribing similar motivations to both groups you get very close to doing that...
Drax
Again. You attack anyone who even mentions Mormonism in anything other than a glowing light. You constantly say that if you're not Mormon, you can't understand the "nuances" of the religion. Here, when the obvious thrust of the thread isn't Mormonism at all, but a CULT of cloistered people closed off from the rest of the "free thinking" people (yes, including mainstream Mormons) and the effect that it has on them. The ONLY time I brought the (whisper) name "Mormon" up is because of how the threat of excommunication can affect the behavior of people who BELIEVE that being excommunicated not only can rip them from their friends and family in this world but in the afterlife as well. I remarked that...well SINCE THIS IS A MORMON CULT that this threat can be "forboding." You remark on this as if this is somehow a lie. You attack my statement as if excommunication isn't practiced in mainstream Mormon religion -- acknowledging I suppose the well known excommunication of the "September Six" for their apostasy. I never once even implied that the excommunication of mainstream Mormons was "forboding" although, if you want to get into it...you might want to ask Mormon SCHOLARS how they what they think about when they write and if they dare to write anything which isn't in lock step with mainstream Mormon orthodoxy. What I said...and what I meant is that IN THIS CLOSED ENVIRONMENT (reading all of my posts with something approaching a fair mind would help here) where ALL the family and ALL the friends and ALL the life of the person can be ripped from them through excommunication...then YES...the prospect of testifying against them, offering evidence against them, TELLING THE TRUTH when asked questions by law enforcement...excommunication would almost surely loom large as a parent is trying to decide what they are to do to get her kids back. Imagine a young girl with her kids ripped from her. She's being questioned by law enforcement. They want to know things like: Are you married? To whom? How many wives does he have? How old are they? How old were you when you married him? How old were you when you first had sex with him? How many young girls are married off this way? Are your kids being taught that this is what they are to expect when they achieve child-bearing age? You know. Looking for evidence of STATUTORY RAPE and FUTURE STATUTORY RAPE. Evidence to justify what they've done and why it was necessary to take such drastic action. Now, that young girl is frightened. She wants her kids back. SHE'S done nothing wrong and law enforcement surely tells her this. Yet, she doesn't answer. What keeps her from answering...even to get her kids back? Her whole LIFE is at that compound. Her parents, her family, her friends...EVERYTHING. And, she knows that, if she starts talking, she ain't gonna be welcome if the rest find out that she did. THIS is what I meant by the threat of excommunication being "forboding." Any fair reading of what I said would reveal that and nothing more. But, your hyper-sensitivity to all things Mormon makes you read into what I've written whatever you wish.
Dadman
Drax: A word of advice...don't believe everything you read on the internet about Mormon hegemony and its suppression of free thinking. Since the church does not discuss the specifics of excommunication cases, you're only going to get one side of the story and typically it will be presented in the most sensational way possible. These so-called 'September Six' (I wonder who came up with the idea of calling them the 'September Six'; it's very dramatic don't you think?) have an axe to grind and they (and their supporters) are grinding it all over the internet. And by the way, Drax, I take on erroneous ideas and mischaracterizations of my faith; I don't attack people. If you consider a challenge of your ideas a personal attack there's not much I can do about that...
Drax
Dadman: I'll accept it that you didn't mean any of your writings as an attack, however, since you wrote so long in response to a single phrase, I'll also be content with my interpretation that you have read entirely too much into what I wrote and leave it at that. (And thank you for the admonition not to believe everything I read on the Internet! In the future, I'll heed that! Heretofore, all words which entered my brain were assumed to be true and fair, and it never occurred to me that the writer might have an agenda! On either side! Whew! To think how polluted my mind must be from all the reading I do! Thanks again!) All sarcasm aside...I do believe that I'm capable of discerning that there are agenda-driven people on BOTH sides of any argument.
CosmicConservative
Sometimes I think that a key thing that is missing in my own life is a chance to defend a deep and abiding belief system from external attack. I really don't even defend my "rational conservatism" from attack, I mostly just say "OK, whatever." Since I don't have such deeply held beliefs that come under attack I sometimes find it hard to put myself in the shoes of people whose belief systems are routinely attacked. It's like pregnancy, I can understand and sympathize with it from an intellectual perspective, but I really can't understand what it's like to be pregnant as a pregnant woman does. Because of that, coupled with my natural "foot in mouth" disease, I frequently find myself saying things that sounded a certain way in my head, but sound completely different to someone with a different perspective. In fact it is one of my great regrets in life that I don't do a better job of communicating what I MEAN when I say what I SAY.
Drax
CC: By the same token, like the cur who has been routinely beaten, one might "flinch" at the raised hand, regardless of whether it is intended to strike. Sometimes we DO say what we "mean" but what is HEARD isn't what we SAID. It certainly goes both ways.
CosmicConservative
See, I wouldn't have used a 'beaten cur' as a metaphor, I'm sure that's got potential to be taken the wrong way. ;)
Drax
I thought of that afterwards. Heh. If such is the case, there isn't anything I can do about it, is there? After all, it was "said" as a metaphor and it was "intended" as a metaphor, and if someone decides to read into it something more, there just ain't a dang thing I can do about it except shake my head. I'm not going to walk on my tiptoes around subjects or watch my (generally polite and civil) language just because someone who chooses to "might" take what I've said in a way that suits to offend them.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I'm certainly not one who has been accused too frequently of being overly sensitive to othe people's feelings, but I still would have sought another analogy. Surely it's time to move on by now... After all, Hillary is sending out concession signals today. Pretty soon we'll get to see how Obama campaigns as a presumptive nominee. I have a suspicion that he will find it more difficult to deal with Republicans than with Hillary. And judging by his over-sensitivity to Hillary's "attacks" I am wondering who is more likely to blow up in a gaffe-filled rage on the campaign trail, Obama or McCain. I suspect it might turn out to be Obama who can't manage his emotions as he deals with determined and merciless attacks from a true opponent, instead of an intramural squabble.
Drax
I think she will bow out once the negotiations on how to pay off her campaign debt have been concluded, probably by week's end. She can no longer win, and, I don't think that she'll force a repeat of '68. But, who knows, really? She's bent on power and may go all the way with this thing. The "buzz" is that there is a tape of Michelle Obama with an even worse tirade against whites on it in the hands of one of the major networks. And, FINALLY, after all this time, many of the MSM talking heads (and I include Fox in that characterization) are taking note of that simple, salient fact that I have brought up time and again... Obama takes his kids to that church. While we can't get inside the heart and mind of a person with any certainty, we can look at his behavior and deduce some things. If one takes one's kids to a white hating, Jew hating, America hating, "black liberationist" church, either one believes in what is being preached there or one doesn't CARE what is being preached there. And, if you believe it (as I think Obama does in large degree (see, e.g., his San Francisco remarks, his long-standing relationships with several well-known "white hating, Jew hating, America hating" personages) then, of course you take your kids there, right? And, if you don't CARE (and don't BELIEVE) and are just making those "connections" for your political future, then that speaks VOLUMES about your character when you routinely expose your KIDS to that hatred in pursuit of your political desires. Michelle certainly appears to have been properly indoctrinated in the "black liberationist" viewpoint. Maybe someone will actually start drawing the voter's attention to the fact Obama brings his kids to this hate-filled church. That's gotta be worth a point or two...
Andy
Drax & CC: You guys raised a few interesting issues in those last comments. I share Cosmic's frustration...I always know in my head exactly what I mean, but very often once it slips through the lips, it doesn't make the sense to others (or even to me) that it did while rattling around in my mind. I also share a sort of "ho-hum" attitude toward those that don't agree with me. I am more likely to spend time trying to explain what I "meant" to say than trying to convert someone to my opinion. Even when it comes to my faith, I know that I can tell someone about it, but don't ever feel any reason to argue it. Guess that's why I could never be a lawyer...not competitive enough for my point. Drax also makes an interesting point. There really is nothing that you can do to effect how anyone takes what you say. You might be able to revise and extend your remarks in explanation of your motive, or feelings...but at the end of the day, it is really on the listener to either buy it or not. Interesting...
Andy
Yes, it is interesting. I am dealing right now with the father of a young man that is living with us (long story). I guess that it what I had on my mind when I commented about "the other guy has to either buy what you say or not." I am learning (or re-learning) that no matter how pure your motive is, or how well you try to craft your words, you can only do so much. Interesting...
Drax
I have come to the conclusion that most of us generally hear what we want to hear and read into what others say what our world view has trained us to read. That's not to say that one can't filter one's indoctrination from early life or one's "learning" from later life, but we all see the world through the prism which our experiences have built around us. Frankly, it is the rare individual who is or can be completely "objective" on any subject which he has deep beliefs. For example, the vast majority of kids raised in a Catholic household are Catholic and believe that that is the "one true religion" for lack of any better term. Objectively, of course, it is impossible to say which religion is "best" or "the real one" if any of them are, but how we are raised forms us to the end of our lives with an ASTOUNDING percentage of people who never critically examine WHY they believe what they do. It's just what they know. Which is why this case so ticks me off. While I have sympathy for the young mothers and young kids who have been ripped from each other, this cycle HAS TO END at some point. Is later better than now? Is never better than now?
Andy
I don't know Drax. Most cults fall under their own weight. Sadly, when they do many people are harmed (as if they weren't 'harmed' while a part of it). It does have to end at some point. I appreciate your aversion to little kids being ripped from the stability that they know (and their mothers that love them so much). It really ticks me off too (as if you didn't know that)...on more than one level...the legal, moral, and societal aspects of this whole deal have really tied my stomach in knots. My Christian/libertairan/parent "self" has been tested by this one for sure. I guess we will see how it all plays out. I hope sooner than later.
Drax
I agree that most cults fall from their own weight, but good arguments can be made that some current "religions" with millions of members were "cults" just scant decades ago. The reason, I think, that most cults fall of their own weight is that they are "cults of personality." As such, it is difficult for any person to be all that which he needs to be to maintain the pretense of his/her divinity or having been touched by divinity. Further, many of the cults based on personality have as their leader people who are mentally unstable to begin with. (The list is too long to even question accuracy...)