Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Schwarzanegger backs gay marriage ruling

By CosmicConservative
I know that this is probably a severely minority position for a conservative to take, but I just can't get worked up about gay marriage. I just don't see the point.
Governor backs same-sex marriage ruling A day after the state Supreme Court ruled that same-sex couples should have the right to marry in California, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger said Friday that he supports the court's decision even though his personal view is that "marriage is between a man and a woman."
If gay people want to suffer the same as straight people have suffered for millenia, I say knock themselves out. Or knock each other out. ;)

Comments (10)

Drax
Not caring about same-sex marriage stretches the definition of "conservative" pretty dang far.
Dadman
You still blogging? I thought you'd be too busy playing WoW...
CosmicConservative
Heh, I'm not a total WoWhead yet. I guess I'm just a different kind of conservative.
Dadman
I dunno. We live in a complicated world and homosexuality is an inextricable part of the equation. There is a rational argument for supporting and legitimizing, from a legal perspective, the committed relationships of gay people. Whether you call it 'marriage' or 'civil unions' doesn't much matter. Gay people are having relationships whether or not government recognizes it in any way. However, when I consult my religious sensibilities I just don't believe God condones homosexual behavior, just as He does not condone promiscuity, fornication, or adultery. I believe homosexual behavior is inconsistent with God's plan for us. Of course, that perspective is purely a matter of faith and difficult to enforce in a diverse, secular society wherein all people are guaranteed life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. This issue, frankly, gets me all twisted up. It does bother me without exception, however, when courts strike down the vote of the people as they recently did in California.
CosmicConservative
I agree with that Dadman, my conservative sensibilities are far more outraged by the activist California Supreme Court than by the subject matter itself. And frankly I think the abuse of judicial "authority" is currently the single biggest risk to the continued liberty we have taken for granted in this country. I've blogged about that many, many times. I do not understand why the Executive and Legislative branches have simply ceded complete authority to the other "equal" branch of government. I can guarantee you that if I were President I'd engineer a constitutional showdown with the SCOTUS just to reassert the power of the executive branch.
Drax
I sometimes can't help but chuckle at some of the writings on this blog. On the one hand, we have a committed Mormon who is all "twisted up" about the issue of making same sex marriages the NORM in our society as if there's any possible interpretation of his religion which would condone such a thing. On the other hand, we have a "rational conservative" who isn't bothered one whit by the substance of making same sex marriages the NORM in our society, but because the California Supreme Court exercised its Constitutional function of determining the legitimacy of a law passed -- whether by initiative or by legislation. After all, that's what Supreme Courts DO. The notion that they're "overturning the will of the people" is NONSENSE. It is a straw man. EVERY law that a Supreme Court finds unconstitutional is one which is "of the people" via one avenue or another. It is one of the main FUNCTIONS of the Supreme Court to prevent the "tryanny of the majority." As is usually the case, whether one screams "foul" at a Supreme Court ruling is based on whose ox is being gored. Same Sex Marriage NORMALIZES this behavior. There is NO DISTINCTION between two men marrying and a man and a woman marrying. How any "religious" person can't oppose this or any "conservative" person can't oppose this befuddles me. It is both contrary to every mainstream western religion and the exact OPPOSITE of a "conservative" position. It is the SUBSTANCE of this ruling, not the FACT of this ruling which should offend both.
Dadman
I do oppose it based on religious and other grounds, but I can comprehend, and sympathize with it to an extent, the secular side of the argument. The reason it twists me up is precisely because it WOULD normalize behavior I believe is counter-productive to the health of individuals and society. But, as a Mormon, I do not believe in imposing my beliefs and perspective on other people.
Andy
Even though Dadman and I completely (yet lovingly, and respectfully) disagree on the whole "born gay v. chose to be gay" issue, we do share a common struggle here. My Christian beliefs...well, that's not really right...My "moral compass" tells me that gay relationships are "off of true north." Disclaimer: I am sure that my Christian beliefs feed that conclusion. But, I would like to think that even if I were not a Christian, I would have a problem with a governmental "seal of approval" on gay marriage. I do not want to live in a USA that is a theocracy. As a Christian, I look forward to the day that Jesus reigns in righteousness over the Earth. But I do not want to live in a nation ruled by an Osama Bin Laden, or the Pope, or a John Knox reformist approach to puritanism. That is where the struggle begins. Even though I am not a Mormon, my Libertarian self cries out for personal freedom and personal responsibility...and not for imposition of my own faith, or morals on anyone else. But this question of a societal "stamp of approval" on the marriage of same-sex people digs far deeper than my personal morals, my faith, or my ability to do anything about it! As I said, I do not want to live in a "theocracy established by men." (that's an oxy-moron) At the same time, I DO want to live in a nation that recognizes, and encourages the best social policies. History has proven that monogamous marriage between a man and a woman serves to enhance a society. It provides a stable environment for children. It helps build a safe place for children to run when life throws them a curve ball. It ensamples the values of faithfulness, fidelity, patience, and a forward-looking hope for the future. I agree with Cosmic. Our courts are out of control. In one of our most liberal (idiotic) States, the people made their will overwhelmingly known. But, a few old Republican judges decided that they were smarter than the voters, and sprayed a big old tinkle on all of them. The judiciary is truly out of control...on the State, and Federal level. If US citizens want to approve gay marriage, well...okay. (As I have said before, I don't think that most "married" couples are really "married"...they are just living together under a legal contract.) But the American public doesn't want to approve gay marriage evidently. I have also got to agree with Drax. (Everyone should be happy) It really shouldn't be hard for a Christian (like myself), or a Conservative to make an emphatic statement decrying the downward moral spin that we all recognize in the good old USA, and how gay marriage would just accelerate it. So I'll do it... Gay marriage is an abomination!!! If we don't stop this, our whole society will be flushed down the toilet of history!!! If we don't stop this gay marriage thing, God will stop loving us. Jesus will turn His back on us, and and go back on His promise to "never leave us, or forsake us." (paraphrased) I hope that you can tell by now, I am also "twisted up in a knot" over the whole issue...
CosmicConservative
Let's see, this particular "law" was passed by a direct VOTE of the people of California according to the CONSTITUTIONAL rules for such votes becoming law. Now the California Supreme Court says "We don't care about the people's vote. We don't care about the legal status of the intiative, or whether it dotted every "i" and crossed every legal "t", we don't care if it is the long tradition of this country and the state of California to abide by the will of the people in cases of such overwhelming majority, especially on such a conflicted subject (where arguments on both sides are valid). All we care about is that gay people be treated as if they are an oppressed minority and that we can find a loophole in the existing Constitution to claim some sort of unequal protection or other never-before-found exclusion to the rule of law, the binding commitment of tradition and the overwhelming will of the people. In this case, WE, the SEVEN MEMBER panel of the California Supreme Court WILL DECIDE THE LAW! I guess you can call that the California Supreme Court doing their job Drax, but if so, I think it's time to rewrite that job description. All this is going to do is force a Californial Constitutional Amendment, and if that passes, what are you going to say then?
Drax
All laws are "votes." Whether direct or representative makes not a whit of difference in the determination whether or not the law passed is CONSTITUTIONAL. This should be clear to anyone. The Supreme Court exercised its function. If the populace of California is unhappy with this outcome, the remedy of a Constitutional Amendment is available to them. That's how it's SUPPOSED TO WORK. I think the decision is unsupported by any rational legal argument and is, in every way, a bad decision. (Just as I think Roe v. Wade is unsupported by any rational legal argument and is, in every way, a bad decision.) The remedy in both cases is to PERSUADE THE POPULACE that the decision is so bad that it must be directly overturned by Constitutional Amendment. The problem I have with the SUBSTANCE of the decision, rather than the FACT of it (we have a system in which these kinds of decisions are inevitable) is that members of a society generally live within the norms of that society. In this country, the range of what is in that norm is becoming so huge that it is becoming impossible to be "righteous". We NEED "righteous" people, a righteous society to wag their collective fingers at those who stray from the path of what is right, the more the better. We, unfortunately, have the exact opposite of that. We have a country of enablers. Even the "religious" are afraid to say that someone is doing "wrong." Afraid to "judge." Willing to separate their "secular" life from their "religious" life and allow for others to do the same. For example, I see it even on the most conservative of talk shows with the most conservative of hosts. Hannity is unwilling to call Obama a LIAR as it relates to his knowledge of Reverend Wright's bigotry and hatred of all things (white) American. Rather, he (and almost all others) couched their critisism in terms of "judgment," rather than simply saying that Obama is a LIAR when he says that he didn't know what Wright stood for. (Anyone who says that we can't see into the hearts and minds of others to determine whether they're telling the truth apparently hasn't even a passing familiarity with the Justice System where doing that very thing is a fundamental element.) Our society has few boundaries and actively promotes behavior which, even 30 years ago, would have been deemed "perverse" (and, in many cases...criminal.) And, with cases such as this, the boundaries get further stretched.