Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Movie Review: Iron Man

By CosmicConservative
I guess my complete geekiness shows quite a bit in movie reviews. I definitely tend to like the computer graphic extravaganzas. I guess I am just a fantasy and science fiction fan at heart, and comic book heroes have always been a sort of mix between the two. Marvel comics hit upon a very successful formula back in the fifties and sixties. They pioneered the "flawed hero" concept and virtually all of their heroes lived lives that were more like a soap opera than an action movie. Peter Parker was the picked-upon nerdy science geek, Thor's alter ego was a gimpy physician and Dr. Strange had suffered nerve damage that rendered his once miraculous hands incapable of the fine motor skills needed for surgery. But perhaps the most flawed of all heroes was Tony Stark. In the original comic Tony Stark was a boozy millionaire with a bad heart. He made his millions by inventing and selling weapons to the U.S. and our allies. When told by his doctors that he would have to live the rest of his life in a medical device that kept his ailing heart alive, Tony decided to create a portable version of the device, and that was how "Iron Man" was born. The movie doesn't quite follow that same story line, but it's not long before the movie version of Tony Stark is also dealing with a lifetime of poor personal decisions and a bad heart of his own. The inspiration for the movie's Iron suit was not a bad heart though, instead it was more of a "ripped from the headlines" story line. There's a lot to say about this movie, so let me break things up, then I'll summarize at the end. First the movie's direction seemed just a bit off. At times it felt choppy and discontinuous. It was sometimes hard to tell if a day or two had passed, or a month or two. The pacing was off-kilter. When it needed to zig, it would zag. When it needed to speed up, it would slow down, and when it did speed up, it went supersonic in a heartbeat. I'd give the direction maybe a B-. And I'm being generous. The final battle sequence was true comic-book computer generated awesomeness, but the lead up was very weak and hard to believe. The writing was much better. There were some clever moments and some funny bits. The dialog was not brilliant but it avoided many of the sorts of cliches that these sorts of morality plays can fall into. I think the movie will be a sort of Rorschach test of people's politics. I would expect that most hard-core conservatives will find the message of the final half of the movie to be objectionable, and most hard-core liberals will find the message of the first half to be so. I'm not saying it walked a fine line, overall it definitely took a liberal slant, but it could have been far worse. Yes the bad guys were a combination of some sort of mongol warlord and an evil corporate greedhead, because Hollywood just isn't going to make a movie with evil Islamic terrorists because that just doesn't fit the narrative. But on the other hand, the first half of the movie portrays terrorists of some indeterminate bent as pure evil bent on domination of, at least, Asia and the Middle East. And I would not be surprised if the majority of the movie-goers do not catch the mongol references and come away with the belief that the bad guys are just Al Qada terrorists. After all, they are in Afghanistan. And yes, I do get tired of the evil corporate greedheads in $5,000 suits storyline, but you know what? There are actually evil corporate greedheads in $5,000 suits, one pretty much wiped out my retirement and savings about ten years ago, so I'm OK with the evil in the movie being a combination of the two. Overall I give the writing a B (mostly because the Tony Stark/Pepper Potts dialog offset the disappointing leadup to the "Iron Monger" of the final battle scene). The acting was very good. Robert Downey Jr. was superb, as he usually is. Jeff Bridges was less compelling, but pulled off the smarmy corporate fat cat pretty well. He just smacks his lips too much. Ug. Gwyneth Paltrow does an admirable job as "Pepper Potts", Tony's girl Friday and closest (platonic) companion. The chemistry between her and Downy is surprisingly understated and the dialog between the two was some of the best dialog in this (or any other comic book) movie. These are two supremely confident adults sparring with some dialog reminiscent of when movies used to actually do romance with subtlety and wit. My only beef with the acting was with Jeff Bridges, and to be fair it may be more the direction and the script that are to blame. The implausible path that his character takes through the movie must have felt to Bridges like he was portraying a man with multiple identity disorder. It felt forced at times. Otherwise the acting was excellent, with a nod towards a very earnest and conflicted turn as Stark's military liaison by Terrence Howard. Overall the acting gets an A. The look and feel of the movie, whether it was the cinematic shots of ruggedly beautiful country, or the shots of L.A. at night, or the lavish scenes of decadent high society, all were beautifully done and will never get the credit they deserve because they were so overwhelmingly overshadowed by the special effects. In many ways Iron Man's suit IS Iron Man, and the suit was pure techno-geek awesomeness. Iron Man may be the most accessible "super hero" of them all to geek-types. We all know that we're not going to get bit by a radioactive (or genetically enhanced) spider, we weren't born mutants with special powers, we didn't come to this planet from another world, and we are DANG sure not going to spend a decade learning to fight from Tibetan monks, so what all of us need, what all of us can see ourselves doing, is climbing into a ready-made super suit where all we need to do is let the suit do all the cool stuff while we are along for the ride. That's the beauty of Iron Man. We are ALL Iron Man, all we need is our own dang SUIT! The special effects wizardry sold me on the suit, all except one brief scene. Otherwise it was completely believable that a suit of titanium-iridium alloy (it's not really iron) could turn a guy with a bad heart and a (probably) bad liver into a super-hero who can catch falling automobiles, and outfly two F-22 Raptors. I have to give the movie an A+ for this. In summary I think the movie deserves at least an A-. It was a very enjoyable movie, with lots of action and lots of great non-action scenes with some of the most well-written dialog I've seen in any comic book movie. If this is the result of Marvel's first self-funded movie, I want to see them make more. This one ought to make them a ton of money.

Comments (3)

Boyd
Did you stay for the final scene after the credits? I saw the film on Saturday, but I had to go back yesterday to see it again so I could see that final 30 seconds or so.
CosmicConservative
No, I waited for a while, but when the credits started to roll, we left. My understanding is the 30 seconds was after the credits.
Boyd
Yup, it was the very last thing in the film. And those were some looooooong credits.