Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Music's Greatest Decade: Exhibits #45, 67, 132, and 12

By Dadman
If it please the court, I submit for your consideration: What a tragic loss when Croce died. This is just one of his great songs... Eric Clapton almost makes the 70s the best musical decade all by himself. This song is one of the best ever... This song was played at virtually every dance I attended in high school, and virtually impossible to dance to with any competence... Lindsey Buckingham could and still can make a guitar sing. Fleetwood Mac's Rumours is one of the best albums produced in any decade. Crank this one up blogsters...

Comments (14)

CosmicConservative
BTW, Eric Clapton was just as active and well known in the sixties as the seventies. He was George Harrison's best friend, and he married George Harrison's ex-wife, Patti Boyd. Patti was the inspiration for the song "Something" by the Beatles, and the song "Layla" by Clapton. Clapton was a founding member of "The Yardbirds," "Cream" and "Derek and the Dominoes." How I left "Cream" out of my list of Sixties bands is a mystery to me. I can play that Layla guitar lick, by the way. ;)
CosmicConservative
Oh, Jimmy Page was also a member of the Yardbirds. It's getting sort of interesting how many of your favorite 70s performers made their name and became famous in the 60s... ;)
CosmicConservative
Oh, and on the Croce thing, it was equally tragic that his guitarist died with him. I still think that the virtuoso finger-picking done by Maury Muehleisen is as much a part of the sound as Jim's own voice. That's Maury beside Jim in your video. That sort of guitar playing is far more difficult than most rock guitarists ever attempt. Maury was a classical guitarist by training, and it shows both in how he plays and how he holds his guitar. I think he was the equal of Eric Clapton, he just chose to stick with the acoustic, and as such never gained the fame that he could have.
Dadman
I know all about Clapton. He's one of my favs. In the video you will see Steve Winwood (member of the band Traffic) and Mark Knopfler, one of the founding members of Dire Straits. I knew a pair of twins once who could play the 'Layla' piano run quite well...
CosmicConservative
Mark Knopfler, man that's a man who can play a mean guitar. I consider Dire Straits to be the first band since the Beatles that understood the importance of BEAT! That's a rockin' band.
Dadman
I really don't care when the artist got his or her start, I care when they were active. If an artist was producing good music in the 70s, whether it was 1970 or 1979, then I consider them part of the musical landscape of that time and part of my claim that the 70s were the best musical decade...
Dadman
Fleetwood Mac understood the importance of beat quite well, IMO...
CosmicConservative
Well, I'll do the same with artists who were active in the 60s. I bet we've got at least a 50% overlap of artists if we truly examine their careers. But not the Beatles. By your own standards, they were not producing music in the 70s. Their last recorded work as a band was in 1969. There is not a single note in any recording that has ever been released as a "Beatles" work that was recorded between Jan 1, 1970 and Dec 31, 1979. Their first attempt to produce anything new was on the occasion of Lennon's murder, which was in December of 1980. In the 80s and 90s the remaining Beatles got together and recorded or mixed two more songs.
CosmicConservative
Sure, Fleetwood Mac and just about any other musician understands the importance of "beat." But there are very, very few performers who understand "BEAT!" My short list: The Beatles (the name is no coincidence) CCR (John Fogerty) Dire Straits Pink Floyd CCR and Pink Floyd were contemporaries of the Beatles, so they don't count as "since the Beatles." That's about it.
Dadman
Perhaps, but we still had much of the solo work of Lennon, McCartney, Starr and Harrison come out in the 70s, some of which is quite good and helps bolster my argument. However, regardless of when Let It Be, the song or album, was recorded it did not enter the psyche of popular culture until 1970 so I'm still going to call it part of the 70s... ...if you don't mind. ;)
Dadman
No, Fleetwood Mac understood "BEAT!". No doubt about it...
CosmicConservative
I absolutely agree that the solo careers of the Beatles belong in the seventies. And they made some great music as individuals. But their individual stuff, as good as it is, does not resemble "Beatles" music, which was something that was remarked on at the time. They truly went their separate ways. I don't care where you put them, but I won't put them in the seventies. In my opinion the Beatles more or less defined the 60s. They opened the decade freshly back from Hamburg where they quickly charged up the charts in Britain. By 1962 they had their first #1 hit and in the next seven years they had 18 more. They broke up almost exactly at the close of the decade and their breakup more or less slammed the door on the sixties much like the grand piano chords at the end of "A Day in the Life" slammed the door on Sgt. Pepper.
Dadman
It was during the 70s that the musical legacy of The Beatles began to be defined even as their music continued to gain more fans... But, I don't disagree that in terms of immediate impact, they defined the 60s.
CosmicConservative
There have been hundreds, probably thousands of doctoral dissertations and scholarly journal articles about the impact the Beatles have had on music, on Western culture and on the world as a whole. I'm sure we can't revisit that here. And yes, the Beatles had a profound impact on the 70s. And the 80s. And the 90s. And the oughts, and no doubt the teens and into the forseeable future. I have voiced my opinion that the Beatles will one day hold the same sort of cultural prominance and reverence as Mozart or Beethoven, they are almost there already. But their impact on the 60s was probably the most profound of all. In the 60s their impact was not only due to their legacy, it was due to their presence on the music and art scene like a planet-striding colossus. No top-level band could embark on any effort without first asking themselvs "what are the Fab Four doing?" "Will their next album make my current work obsolete?" The impact the Beatles had on bands like The Who, The Byrds (whose name was inspired by the Beatles), The Doors, and probably most notably, The Beach Boys has been long and well established. I think maybe there are two different kinds of impacts, and perhaps in the long run you are actually right here, and the long-lasting changes to the music scene were more impactful than the immediate effect of rivalries, competition and collaboration. It's a hard thing to quantify. I'll just say that the Beatles STILL dominate the music scene. I had an interesting conversation with a Michael Jackson fan years ago when Jackson was "hot." He said that Michael Jackson was the "new Beatles." I told him that if people 25 years after Jacksons career were comparing new artists to Michael Jackson, he could make that claim. But I predicted that 25 years from then (which would be right about now, actually) that people would STILL be comparing new breakout artists to the Beatles, not to Michael Jackson. And until some act comes along that supercedes the Beatles in that ultimate comparison, I have to conclude that the Beatles are still the most compelling musical act of our lifetimes, and most probably for far longer than that.