Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Art and morality

By CosmicConservative
One of the more popular posts on this blog was one I did over a year ago called "Art and Science." In that post I talked about Van Gogh's masterpiece "Starry Night" and wondered whether it was purely abstract or if it represented some level of Van Gogh's actual experience in looking at a particular starry night. The comments took a turn towards evaluating "abstract expressionism" as an art form, and my position on the subject more or less was that the great bulk of abstract expressionism is "art" only in the sense that it furthers the goals of a "con artist." Now we have the story below about a Yale University senior, Aliza Shvarts, who has produced a bit of "performance art" where she claims she spent nine months artificially inseminating herself and then taking "herbs" to induce abortion just in case she got pregnant. As if this isn't morally repugnant enough, she filmed herself doing the procedures and collecting the results of her experiment. Yale claims that it's all a hoax, but Shvarts is sticking to her story and has some video to prove it. Now, as much disdain as I have for most "abstract expressionism" I have to admit that my total inability to appreciate most modern "performance art" is even worse. George Orwell once described the work of a contemporary by saying that it was unethical and immoral to excuse reprehensible behavior by calling it "art." I would tend to agree. And to be the "artist" is even worse, in my opinion. Yale's press release stated that it would be unethical for Shvarts to have actually done what she claimed, but because it was supposedly a "hoax" there is no punishment for the young "lady." Well, she claims it wasn't a hoax. If she is right, doesn't Yale now have to follow through on their word and bring down some punishment on her? First they'll have to explain what part of what she did was "unethical." Was it the act of inseminating herself? Was it the act of aborting the potential fertilized eggs? Was it the act of collecting the results for the purpose of public display? Or was it just the act of filming it? Or was it her intentions that make her acts unethical? I am quite sure that since Yale cannot dare to pursue that line of thinking lest they be called "judgmental" by their academic peers, there will be no punishment for Shvarts whatsoever. In fact the whole thing will probably just launch her "performance art" career, and soon we'll be able to see her doing all sorts of grotesque things with her body in the pursuit of "art."
Yale Daily News - For senior, abortion a medium for art, political discourse Art major Aliza Shvarts ’08 wants to make a statement. Beginning next Tuesday, Shvarts will be displaying her senior art project, a documentation of a nine-month process during which she artificially inseminated herself “as often as possible” while periodically taking abortifacient drugs to induce miscarriages. Her exhibition will feature video recordings of these forced miscarriages as well as preserved collections of the blood from the process. The goal in creating the art exhibition, Shvarts said, was to spark conversation and debate on the relationship between art and the human body. But her project has already provoked more than just debate, inciting, for instance, outcry at a forum for fellow senior art majors held last week. And when told about Shvarts’ project, students on both ends of the abortion debate have expressed shock — saying the project does everything from violate moral code to trivialize abortion.
See, I'm just an old country boy. When I hear something like this, what I immediately think is "what is wrong with that girl? What is wrong with that university? and what is wrong with our country?" Because anyone with a brain knows that this sort of thing is a grotesque, immoral perversion of "art". There are no doubt many, many people who will say "well, if she says it's art, then I sort of have to let her do it, after all it's a free country." I call B.S. on that and I don't give a frippin' dang if someone calls me judgmental. This girl is loony, and what she is doing is morally and ethically wrong. It is, in fact, some form of insanity in my opinion. She is not right in the head. And neither is the staff of the school she went to that put such bizarre, insane notions into her head in the first place. Yeah, Yale. Yale is insane. Absolutely and completely insane. I would never let my daughter go there.

Comments (2)

pace
'Performance Art', eh? I don't get it. I think its pretty damn repugnant, actually.
expressionism
[...] called ???Art and Science.??? In that post I talked about Van Gogh??s masterpiece ???Starry Night???http://www.cosmicconservative.com/weblog/?p=3686Museum eyes Homer's legacy Worcester Telegram & GazetteBASEL, Switzerland - No, it does not [...]