Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

CNN science story 'nuff said

By CosmicConservative
So here's yet another example of how poorly CNN reports science. This is a story about a lungless frog that's been discovered in Indonesia. But the story confuses evolutionary processes and ends up asserting Lamarkian evolultionary principles. Here's the deal, according to the standard evolutionary model, adaptations occur because of random mutations, NOT because of environmental pressure. If a mutation HAPPENS to be benign or (rarely) beneficial, it can get carried on to successive generations. But they don't HAPPEN because of the environment the creature is in. At least not according to the modern understanding of evolution. And why is that? Because if the mutation of a frog to lose its lungs was "because the frog needed to lose buoyancy in the fast moving streams" then SOMETHING is communicating that need to the frog's DNA and the DNA is listening and responding to the message. So far no such mechanism has been proposed, much less demonstrated.
Lungless 'Jabba' frog offers evolution clue - CNN.com Graeme Gillespie, director of conservation and science at Zoos Victoria in Australia, called the frog "evolutionary unique." He said the eight specimens examined in the lab showed the lunglessness was consistent with the species and not "a freak of nature." Gillespie was not a member of the expedition or the research team. Bickford surmised that the frog had evolved to adapt to its difficult surroundings, in which it has to navigate cold, fast-moving streams that are rich in oxygen. "It's an extreme adaptation that was probably brought about by these fast-moving streams," Bickford said, adding that it probably needed to reduce its buoyancy in order to keep from being swept down the mountainous rivers.
jabbafrog.jpg Of course I can't entirely blame CNN, these biologists seem to be suffering under the same delusion. But that's probably a bigger story than the frog story. Biologists who believe in Lamarkian evolution in 2008! That's a story!

Comments (5)

David
I don't see how the article pushes Lamarkian evolution. Evolution occurs through natural selection of mutants, so it is sensible, though simplifying, to refer to evolutionary pressure toward an adaptation. The difference is really just one of inducing a change as a single addition (Lamarkian) vs. a host of additions that get winnowed down by selection pressure (Darwinian). By analogy, it's like choosing your answer on a multiple choice test directly or by process of elimination. I don't see that the article specifically embraces the Lamarkian view and I believe there are far more scientifically offensive news items out there worthy of attention.
Herpy the Herpetologist
I don't think they are referring to Lamarckian evolution. Frogs who lived in Indonesia before this lungless frog appeared probably were easily swept away by rivers because of their added buoyancy by their lungs, so those who had randomly reduced lungs and were not swept away, from, say, they breeding sites or female/male frogs, were more able to reproduce and produce offspring with also reduced lungs. While DNA mutations happen randomly, the selective pressures and the differences they encourage over many generations is certainly NOT random!
CosmicConservative
Look, I know what they are trying to say. They are trying to say that due to environmental pressures frogs with certain advantages were selected over others, leading in time to the situation where lungless frogs eventually replaced frogs with lungs. I know that is what they mean. But that is not what they said! What they said is that “It’s an extreme adaptation that was probably brought about by these fast-moving streams.” This is wrong. The "fast-moving streams" had NOTHING WHATSOEVER TO DO with the appearance of the lungless frog. They only selected lungless frogs once they appeared. I agree that calling it "Lamarkian" is a stretch, but there's no other theory that suggests that the environment drives a particular mutation. If there is, let me know and I'll use that. Maybe I'll have to make up a name for it, but the CLOSEST thing I can come up with is "Lamarkian." The bottom line is that mutations are purely random, specific mutations are not "brought about" by anything. They are "naturally selected" by environments once they occur. I also know that this scientist was using a form of evolutionary shorthand and that all his biologist buddies know what he means. But the problem is that lay people don't know that he's using shorthand, and that means that people reading this story can easily get the impression that fast-moving streams cause frogs to lose their lungs. And that is not true in any evolutionary sense that I know of. There could have been a number of OTHER mutations that could have had equal or even better survival results than losing lungs. It just happens to have been this one that occurred and was selected. People are ignorant enough of evolution, biologists should be extremely careful of the message they are sending when they give interviews to reporters. And science reporters should be sharp enough to spot such an implication and clarify with the scientist on the spot instead of simply quoting them and filing their story. That's my point.
Herpy the Herpetologist
True. Although I think you should be semantically more lenient, since this news item is just a popular news item, not a journal article. But what you said in your clarification is correct.
CosmicConservative
Herpy, the point is that it is stories like these that give the "popular news" readers their impression of things like Evolution. We should be MORE precise when explaining to lay people, not less... But I acknowledge that I'm not being realistic. It's just some biologist using evolutionary shorthand, and some reporter who probably just wants to get back to New York more than anything. What the heck do I expect? Rigor? Editorial thoroughness? I used to expect those things. But I guess those days are gone.