What I think of UFOs
By CosmicConservativeOK, so I see that I'm getting a significant bump in traffic from Dadman's UFO posting. I'm hoping some of those folks actually look at the site instead of just reading that one post. In case they do, I thought I'd post my opinion of UFO sightings.
First of all let me start off by saying that I think the chance that the human race is the only group of self-aware, intelligent beings in the universe is so ridiculously low that it stretches all bounds of credulity to believe that we are "alone" in the universe. As I have said in other posts, the main thought that pops into my head when I consider such a possibility is "man, what a waste of space."
So my position on UFOs starts with the basic powerful belief, which I would call as much a certainty as I am certain of anything, that we are NOT alone in this universe, and in fact if I had to bet on it I would say that there are likely billions of other planets with intelligent beings on them. I am very pro-alien life and always have been.
But does that mean that the earth is "likely" to have been visited by any of those alien races at all? Well, that's when things get a little more difficult to work out. And here's why.
The universe is big. I sometimes think that there are very, very few people on this planet who have any real conception at all about how big this universe is, how big the galaxy we live in is, and how intimidating the distances are between even the closest stars we can see.
Factor in the fact that I am pretty much a skeptic when it comes to supernatural capabilities, and I think that we may not know everything about physics, but we know quite a bit about it, and you might start to see how unlikely I think it is that there are spaceships zipping around the galaxy like an L.A. freeway at rush hour.
And then add to that the complete lack of credible evidence of alien encounters and the flood of hoaxes and fakes we have seen over the years, and I have to admit that my skepticism of alien encounters is at least as high as my skepticism of the neighborhood "psychic" being able to tell me who my soul-mate is. Much less simply predicting the next lottery drawing.
To put it as succinctly as I can, the space between stars is so daunting that it defies easy description to people who may not have any real concept of what "the nearest star to earth is 4.5 light-years away" means.
What it means is that unless there is some magical way to get around the most fundamental things we know about physics, things like the laws of thermodynamics, the laws of conservation of mass and energy, the amount of energy it takes to accelerate physical objects to anything like the speed of light, etc... and the realization eventually sets in that making a trip to another star is a BIG DEAL. And I don't just mean for our current level of technology. I mean a BIG DEAL period. And that's not even taking into account such minor details as what happens in space when a gamma ray burst irradiates everything with life-snuffing radiation.
It is highly likely, in my view, that there are some star-spanning civilizations in the universe. It is somewhat likely that there are some in our galaxy. But unless we discover some way to overcome the most basic physical limitations our physics tells us exist, then it is unlikely that there are any galaxy-wide spanning civilizations or even any civilizations that occupy major star clouds. Much less civilizations that are roaming around the galaxy looking for random places to stop and have a picnic.
The energy cost is simply too high to waste it on random chance of encountering a suitable planet or system for colonization or trade partners. It is far more likely that star-spanning civilizations grow in carefully planned steps from one system to another after using extreme technology such as mile-wide telescopes and million-mile long antennae to search the sky for the most likely candidates for the next step. And even then the effort to build and launch a colonization attempt, or even a scouting effort is such a staggering investment of economic resources that it cannot be something that is done on a whim.
I would not be surprised to learn that there are civilizations who have sent long-distance probes on low-energy flights to nearby stars, but such flights would take centuries and would likely have a fairly high rate of failure. But there could be millions of such probes roaming the galaxy as I type this, and still the odds of a single one of those stumbling into our solar system wuold likely be in the range of one in a million or more.
Then there's the whole issue of what I expect would happen if one of those probes did enter our system. What would the likely result be? At best it would send a signal back to the home planet or the nearest outpost. Such a signal would likely take decades or centuries to reach home. And it would take much, much longer for that civilization to react to the signal with anything like a scout ship or fleet of ships.
But if they did, again the massive investment of time and energy into the effort makes it inconceivable to me that once they reached here, they would simply play hide and seek with us for decades. I just can't see any benefit to them to do so. Most likely they would simply announce their presence and seek to contact us, or else they would simply watch us from a safe distance (say the orbit of Neptune, perhaps) and call for the troops to come and clear off this nice juicy planet from the current infestation of potential competitors.
The LEAST likely of all scenarios is the one that most UFO devotees usually claim to be happening. The idea that some civilization has been secretly watching us, experimenting on us, and sending ships down into our atmosphere to be seen by lucky humans and blow their cover is patently absurd.
Basically I find the arguments that our skies are full of alien ships, and our world is infested with alien visitors hiding among us to be essentially the same level of wishful thinking as those who believe in ghosts, the Loch Ness monster or inter-dimensional gateways that pop into and out of existence. Basically I think the whole thing is fundamentally an atavistic need for people to believe in some sort of magical, supernatural connection that humans have with the universe. It used to be the Gods of Olympus, satyrs and fairies. Now it's galactic overlords, robots and "grey aliens."
So expect me to view all reports of UFOs with complete skepticism. Such claims require extraordinary evidence, and any photo that could have easily been photoshopped by a high school freshman is certainly not going to get me to say anything but "sheesh, here we go again."
When they arrive, there will be no doubt. I just hope they don't come guns a-blazin'.
Comments (10)