Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Two SCOTUS rulings

By CosmicConservative
When the Supreme Court of the United States is in session and handing down rulings, the reaction of the talking heads and pundits resembles nothing more than a convention of tea leaves and pig intestines readers. So I'll join in the fun. ;) The first case to look at is the Ayotte vs. Planned Parenthood case. In this case the SCOTUS ruled 9-0 to uphold the lower court's injunction against a law that required notice to the parents when a minor was having an abortion. Justice O'Connor, writing the court's opinion, begins the opinion with this paragraph:
We do not revisit our abortion precedents today, but rather address a question of remedy: If enforcing a statute that regulates access to abortion would be unconstitutional in medical emergencies, what is the appropriate judicial response? We hold that invalidating the statute entirely is not always necessary or justified, for lower courts may be able to render narrower declaratory and injunctive relief.
Basically this is what is normally referred to as a "narrow ruling" because it addresses specific instances and is not used as a guide to the SCOTUS general view of an issue. In this case the law in question lacked provisions for emergency medical conditions and that was the reason for the 9-0 ruling. To try to use this as a guage of Roberts' future votes on the issue is pointless. The other case was Gonzales vs. Oregon and this one is much more likely to give an insight into Roberts' legal rulings in the future. In the 6-3 ruling, the "3" were Scalia, Thomas and Roberts. Assuming that Alito would have voted with these three, then there is a pretty strong case to be made that the court is taking a strong turn to the right with Roberts and Alito. However it should also be noted that 5-4 is still a majority so things won't change as much as people think unless Ginsberg, Stevens or Breyer also leave the court during Bush's term. In that event the left will be in an absolute frenzy and will use rulings like this to bolster their claim that the religious right has taken control of the courts. The case in question is Oregon's assisted suicide law. The majority opinion, written by Kennedy, gets it right. There is no federal power that can be found either in the US Constitution or in Statutes that allows the Attorney General to exert this sort of control over the legislative powers of a state. In fact you could view this as a classic states rights issue. Which makes the ruling all the more ironic since the roles are clearly reversed in the court on this issue. And the reason for that reversal of roles is very clear. Scalia, Thomas and Roberts have personal moral issues with assisted suicide. I don't know if those moral issues are completely the result of their religious beliefs, but it is not hard to see that is how the left will see it. I am usually a tremendous fan of Scalia. But this is the third time in a year that he has allowed his personal morality to lead him to bad legal judgment. However you may feel about assisted suicide, you have to admit that it is hypocrisy to say that the federal government can impose its will on the states to regulate such actions, while at the same time arguing that the federal government cannot do so with abortion. Of course the hypocrisy is just as obvious with the other justices on this issue (except Kennedy) on the other side. Sometimes it's painful to see how even our highest legal minds cannot escape the tendency to use the power of the courts to enforce their own ideas of morality on the entire country.

Comments (0)

No comments on this post.