Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Australian scientist questions Global Warming Orthodoxy

By CosmicConservative
Tell me this lady doesn't seem to be saying exactly what I've been saying for the past five years. The question is whether the rest of the supposed "consensus of scientists" will acknowledge the simple truth of their data for the past ten years. My guess is that they will, but it will take a while, and in the meantime politicians will continue with their algorentian attempts to use global warming to implement sweeping socialist reforms on the world's population.
Climate facts to warm to | The Australian Duffy: "The climate is actually, in one way anyway, more robust than was assumed in the climate models?" Marohasy: "That's right ... These findings actually aren't being disputed by the meteorological community. They're having trouble digesting the findings, they're acknowledging the findings, they're acknowledging that the data from NASA's Aqua satellite is not how the models predict, and I think they're about to recognise that the models really do need to be overhauled and that when they are overhauled they will probably show greatly reduced future warming projected as a consequence of carbon dioxide." Duffy: "From what you're saying, it sounds like the implications of this could beconsiderable ..." Marohasy: "That's right, very much so. The policy implications are enormous. The meteorological community at the moment is really just coming to terms with the output from this NASA Aqua satellite and (climate scientist) Roy Spencer's interpretation of them. His work is published, his work is accepted, but I think people are still in shock at this point." If Marohasy is anywhere near right about the impending collapse of the global warming paradigm, life will suddenly become a whole lot more interesting. A great many founts of authority, from the Royal Society to the UN, most heads of government along with countless captains of industry, learned professors, commentators and journalists will be profoundly embarrassed. Let us hope it is a prolonged and chastening experience. With catastrophe off the agenda, for most people the fog of millennial gloom will lift, at least until attention turns to the prospect of the next ice age. Among the better educated, the sceptical cast of mind that is the basis of empiricism will once again be back in fashion. The delusion that by recycling and catching public transport we can help save the planet will quickly come to be seen for the childish nonsense it was all along.
"Embarrassed" is not the right word. "Humiliated" and "expelled from power" are the words we should be using.

Comments (8)

Bob Hawkins
"when they are overhauled they will probably show greatly reduced future warming projected as a consequence of carbon dioxide.” I wouldn't count on it. The projected warming has not changed since warming replaced cooling in the late 1970s. All the vast improvements in computer power and major improvements in our knowledge of the atmosphere has had zilch effect. The US National Academy of Science appointed a committee to review the state of the new global warming threat in 1979. It reported that a doubling of CO2 would be expected, based on the best models of the time, to cause a warming of 1.5C to 4.5C. The hot summer of 1988 made global warming a major public issue, and the UN set up the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, IPCC, to review the research and make recommendations. The IPCC First Assessment Report was published in 1990. 1.5C to 4.5C. The Second Assessment Report, 1995, 1.5C to 4.5C. In 1995, the amount of sunlight absorbed by clouds was measured for the first time. It turned out to be 600% of the amount assumed in the models. A news article in "Science" noted the disappointing lack of progress up to that point, but predicted that the correction of the massive error in cloud absorption would finally break the logjam. Third Assessment Report, 2001, 1.5C to 4.5C. Fourth Assessment Report, 2007, 2.0C to 4.5C, immediately followed by the statement "Values less than 1.5C are highly unlikely." There's a pattern here. The pattern does not permit mere data to dictate the output.
CosmicConservative
Well, you can't really fight dogma with facts, can you?
Frank
Let me quote from the article: "But we should be asking, or expecting others to ask, for the provenance of the data, the assumptions fed into the computer model, the response of the peer review community, and so on." Jennifer Marohasy (My italics. fs) Here's a little provenance for you: "The Australian" = Murdoch a.k.a. Fox "News" fs And some more: fs Dr Jennifer Marohasy is the Director of the Environment Unit at right-wing Australian think tank the Institute of Public Affairs. She is a climate change skeptic, denying that climate change is caused by greenhouse gas emissions. The IPA was not influential again until the 1980s, when C.D. Kemp's son, Rod Kemp took up the leadership. Rod Kemp transformed it from a conservative organisation to a neoliberal one, funded mainly by major corporations groups, and pursuing a pro-free-market, pro-privatization, pro-deregulation and anti-union agenda. Throughout the 1980's the IPA's primary focus was on issues such as economic policy, privatisation and industrial relations policy. It also dabbled in a few broader issues such as the role of the Australian Broadcasting Corporation and the role of churches in public policy debates. It wasn't until 1989 that the IPA began to pay any sustained interest to environmental issues. Since then it has campaigned against the ratification of the Kyoto Protocol, promoted the use of genetically engineered crops and defended the logging of native forests. More recently, the IPA has been the driving force behind the establishment of a number of new non-profit front groups, including the Australian Environment Foundation - which campaigns for weaker environmental laws - Independent Contractors of Australia - which campaigns for an end to workplace safety laws and a general deregulation of the labour market, and the ironically named Owner Drivers Australia, which campaigns against safety and work standard for truck drivers. For all their talk of 'transparency' though, the IPA has been embroiled in controversy over failure to disclose funders of its work. In June 2004 it was revealed that Australia's largest irrigation company, Murray Irrigation Limited, contributed $40,000 to the IPA. The IPA's environment unit director Jennifer Marohasy played a critical role in persuading a government committee to overturn recommendations to increase the volume of water released into the Murray River. [4] However, Marohasy did not disclose the donation to the committee. When asked by the Australian Financial Review about the MIL donation, Marohasy would not confirm or deny whether she knew about the donation while writing her report or giving evidence to the committee. She said she did not take "an interest in who funds IPA". The IPA has heavily relied on funding from a small number of conservative corporations. Those funders disclosed by the IPA to journalists and media organisations include: a.. Major mining companies - BHP-Billiton and Western Mining Corporation; b.. Pesticides/Genetically modified organisms: Monsanto; and c.. A range of other companies including communications company Telstra, Clough Engineering, Visy, and News Limited; d.. Tobacco companies - Philip Morris (Nahan) and British American Tobacco [6] e.. Oil and gas companies: Caltex, Esso Australia (a subsidiary of Exxon) and Shell [www.ips.org] and Woodside Petroleum; and fifteen major companies in the electricity industry; (Nahan 2) f.. Forestry: Gunns, the largest logging company in Tasmania; (Nahan 3) g.. Murray Irrigation Ltd - a major irrigation company contributed $40,000.[7] Even Rio Tinto, the conservative mining company, abandoned the IPA because of its strident advocacy against Aboriginal self-determination. [8]. Above is from Sourcewatch, which follows the money, nonpartisan. ISP fellow Bob Carter "...said the role of peer review in scientific literature was overstressed, and whether or not a scientist had been funded by the fossil fuel industry was irrelevant to the validity of research. "I don't think it is the point whether or not you are paid by the coal or petroleum industry," said Professor Carter. "I will address the evidence." "...a March 2007 article in the Sydney Morning Herald noted that "Professor Carter, whose background is in marine geology, appears to have little, if any, standing in the Australian climate science community." From LogicalScience.com: James Annon writes I: "... emailed Professor Carter to see if he would bet me over global warming, offering 2:1 odds that temperatures will increase in 10 years. He politely emailed me back, saying that because temperature change is a random walk, he won't bet me. I've replied to say that doesn't make sense. Either he doesn't believe temperature changes are random, or he should bet me." When figuring purported global cooling, Carter always starts with 1998, which was an anomalously hot, El Nino year, because looking at '99 on, things are getting hotter, starting with say, '95, things are getting hotter. Recalls Twain's "There's Liars, damn liars and statisticians." fs Let me sum all this up in eight words. What Marohasy writes is paid for, complete bullshit. fs
CosmicConservative
Frank: I love how people try to discredit organizations by saying "They get money from 'right-wing' sources!" While completely ignoring that THEIR favorite organizations recieve funds from 'left-wing' sources. You can believe what you like Frank. What interests me is how you think right-wing organizations like "Fox News" have managed to reduce solar output and stop temperatures from rising for ten years. How long before you accept data and facts Frank, instead of listening to what is more and more becoming religious dogma?
CosmicConservative
Frank: One other comment. I am so damn sick of you Leftist bastards immediately accusing anyone who disagrees with you of being corrupt and evil. It isn't enough to simply disagree with Dr. Marohasy, no you have to accuse her of being bribed into saying what she says. Listen buddy, if Marahasy is being bribed because she has some connection to a right-wing organization then Al Gore is corrupt because of his ties to the Sierra Club and George Soros. If it's sauce for the goose, then it's sauce for the gander. As I said, you are welcome to believe what you like. Unlike you I will just accuse you of being naive or ignorant, instead of corrupt and evil. Grow the hell up.
Simon Forsyth
The claims by Marohasy about global temperature leveling off or dropping are unfounded. A simple email to her source, Roy Spencer at NASA, can clear it up. Which is what I did. Roy says that Marohasy is confused. He states that the data is not from the much vaunted Aqua satellite project as Marohasy claimed, and is not global average but a much smaller sample of 20 degrees either side of the equator. Paper published by Roy Spencer can be found here: http://www.weatherquestions.com/Spencer_07GRL.pdf Now for some clearly needed Ad hominem. Marohasy, the scientist who has misrepresented the information in the interview, appears to have published only a dozen scientific papers or so in areas such as biological control. Her expertise is clearly not climate. She has had a long association with banking, industry and anti-conservation environmental groups that advocate actions like whale hunting. Not the person I would be quoting on climate change. Check out Marohasy's web site: http://www.jennifermarohasy.com/about.php
CosmicConservative
Simon: It is not Dr. Marohasy who is saying that 1998 was the hottest year since 1932 (note, that is not "the hottest of all time" just the "hottest since 1932") and that temperatures have cooled int he decade since, It is NASA's own data that says this. If you want to claim that NASA is misreporting temperature data, that's fine with me since it is NASA temperature data that has been used to supposedly claim that we are steadily seeing increases every year, until they FIXED their data after being called on it by a scientist/blogger who found a critical problem with their methodology. NASA admitted this and republished their data showing that 1998 more or less tied 1932 as the hottest year on record, and that the 1930s had more of the top ten hottest years than the 1990s or 2000s. The fun part of this debate Simon is that we'll actually all be able to see the truth of it in a few years. After all, if we don't see hurricanes blowing away half of the Gulf Coast of the United States, and don't see sea levels rising by 20 feet in the next twenty years, then guess what? That means Al Gore has been pushing a brand of global alarmism that turned out to be completely wrong. I'm betting that Al Gore is wrong. I think the science backs me up. You can believe what you like, but the scientific backlash against Al Gore's claims of "consensus" on global warming is growing every single day.
truckybunny
hi thanks for facts not insults as the new religion cult, pour on any question that climate change may be just a bit out there.so far no fact has been produced just projections.that it will get hotter.it was hotter then colder .and will continue as far as life exists. when some town hall clerk decrees that anyone who parks an suv outside their house must pay more local tax to save the planet questionable i think so onslow out.