Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

One of cinema's funniest scenes...

By Dadman
I know I'm probably preaching to the choir here, but 'The Sandlot' is one of the best coming-of-age films ever made. I ran around with the kids in this movie when I was young (or kids very much like them) and on a nearly daily basis did something stupid and, as it turns out, quite memorable. I played a lot of sandlot baseball and went everywhere on my Schwinn Lemon Peeler. I engaged in put-down battles and an occasional fist fight. It seems the only time I watched TV was on Friday evenings when 'The Patridge Family' and 'The Brady Bunch' made their weekly appearance. Anyway, this scene from 'The Sandlot' is hysterical. It makes me bust a gut everytime. Why don't they make movies like this anymore? Instead, we now get crap like 'Semi-Pro' or 'Superbad' or some mindless Adam Sandler tripe. Sigh...

Open the original video on YouTube

Another classic scene from 'The Sandlot' is the fake drowning stunt they pull at the pool to get the hot lifeguard to perform mouth-to-mouth resuscitation. Funny, funny stuff...

Comments (10)

CosmicConservative
Sigh... I won't even go into why I don't find this sort of thing funny. It's just not worth the scorn it will generate...
Dadman
It's too bad. 'The Sandlot' is a legitimately funny film considered by many movie buffs to be a classic. What's funny about this scene is not so much the fact they are barfing (that's been done many times before), but the youthful glee and naivete' with which they consume the tobacco and board the ride contrasted with the looks on their faces as they begin to feel sick. It's the expressions on their faces as they transform from joy to nauseu that makes me laugh. The director, David Evans, did an outstanding job of capturing that transformation. It's personally happened to me when I was about 10 on a similar type ride and it was my poor cousin who wore the aftermath of my motion sickness for the rest of the day. It still makes me smile, and my cousin too when it comes up in conversation, but of course movies are a subjective art so you're free to not laugh whenever you choose...
CosmicConservative
I understand. As I said, my analysis of this sort of thing is always scoffed at as "too analytical" at best, so it's best to just accept that you find it funny and move on. The reaction it elicits in me is most accurately described as "cringeing". I don't get the hot pepper scene in Dumb and Dumber either...
CosmicConservative
I'll just do this much (which will probably be more than enough to engender the scorn...) The main reason this sort of thing does not strike my funnybone is that the entire joke is completely revealed at the moment the first boy holds up the chewing tobacco and says "all the pros do it." Everything else from that point on is as predictable and inevitable as glacier melt from Al Gore's hot air. It would have been a lot funnier to me if they had cut immediately to the scene of the barf-coated boys and disgusted carnival attendees as they leave the scene.
Dadman
I don't agree that predictability and humor are mutually exclusive. Many things that are predictable are also funny when they actually happen. Again, this scene is funny (to me) as a result of the dialog, the acting, close-up framing on the boys' faces as their infectious grins transform into looks of distress. Sure, the barfing may be predictable, but the way it is choreographed and shot make it funny. Doing a quick cut from 'all the pros do it' to the boys exiting the ride covered in barf would have left out the best part of the scene...in my humble, humble opinion.
Dadman
You cringe when you see scenes like this? Wow, that's a strong reaction to a light-hearted comedy.
CosmicConservative
Yeah, well I do think I admitted to being humor impaired, didn't I? It's one of those things, I guess... As you have pointed out (and as Drax has) I tend to analyze the heck out of everything. I've spent (wasted) a lot of time contemplating the source of humor and why people react to things that are "funny" to them. And over the years I have discovered that I have a very distinct sense of humor. It's not that I don't HAVE a sense of humor, it's that my sense of what is funny is different than other people's. If you took an "average person" and collected the set of things they find humorous in a Venn diagram, then drew a diagram of the set of things I find funny, they would not match well. I would probably only find about 60-70% of the things they find funny to be funny. But what is really interesting is the stuff that I find to be funny that other people don't find to be funny. That's at least equal to the reverse, if not much larger. I think I have said that I was kicked out of the "Jaws" movie once for laughing at the "scary" bits. Every time they played that cello warning, I just about lost it. I think "We're gonna need a bigger boat" is one of the most hilarious lines ever delivered in cinema history. When that shark starts eating the boat, that's when I got kicked out. I mean that's FUNNY! But barfing kids on the tilt-a-whirl? Not so much. But that's just me.
Dadman
You've calculated the percentage of things both you and 'average' people might consider funny? One reason, I think, that we have differing opinions on this particular scene from 'The Sandlot" is that we are looking at different things. You seem to focused almost exclusively on the context or situation - 'barfing kids on a tilt-o-whirl'. On the face of it the situation is rather predictable, perhaps even a bit cliche', and if you described the scene to me (without acutally seeing it) I might even agree with you that the premise does not have a lot of potential for great humor. But I am not just focused on the situation. I am focused on the characters, their personalities, their emotions, the looks on their faces, their dialog, their relationships, the scene's authenticity (is it something I believe real 10 year old boys in the 60s might do), etc. So, when I look at all of those elements in their totality, in addition to the quality of the filmmaking itself, I can't help but laugh at this scene. I like these kids. I relate to them. They remind me of friends I had at that age and their antics remind me of my own childhood. In fact, if I had experienced this with my own pack of friends at the local carnival in real life, I would have been laughing my head off at myself and my buddies coming off that tilt-o-whirl. If I could suggest an improvement to this scene it would be to have them laughing at each other as they exited the ride, but of course, maybe they didn't feel up to it at that moment. ;)
Dadman
BTW, Jaws eating the boat was rather funny to me too, but I did like the music...
CosmicConservative
No, I haven't "calculated" it, but I've "guesstimated" it based on my experience with other people's idea of humor compared to mine. And I'm generally a fairly good guesstimator. Perhaps (just perhaps) if I had seen the whole movie and could put this into context, I might find it more humorous. Perhaps.