Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

How to get a fake memoir published

By CosmicConservative
Just hit all the Lefty buttons with it. What is this, the fourth fake memoir in the past few years where some fraud created a Leftist fantasy story about victimization, exploitation and the "voice" of obscure minorities? What is so hilarious about these stories is how easy it is to schnooker all the liberals in the publishing industry who are just drooling for the opportunity to publish anything that validates their ideology and their bigotry. It doesn't have to be TRUE. That's not the POINT. All that matters is that it's the RIGHT message. I love this stuff... So, is the author going to pay back all the money now, like Steve Martin's character in "The Jerk" after his glasses nose-grabber caused widespread cross-eyedness? Now THAT's a story I'd like to hear.
Author admits acclaimed memoir is fantasy - International Herald Tribune Seltzer's story started unraveling last Thursday after she was profiled in the House & Home section of The New York Times. The article appeared alongside a photograph of Seltzer (still using her pseudonym) and her 8-year-old daughter, Rya. Seltzer's older sister, Cynthia Seltzer Hoffman, saw the piece and called Riverhead to tell them that Seltzer's story was untrue. "Love and Consequences" immediately hit a note with many reviewers. Writing in The New York Times, Michiko Kakutani praised the "humane and deeply affecting memoir," but noted that some of the scenes "can feel self-consciously novelistic at times." In Entertainment Weekly, Vanessa Juarez wrote that "readers may wonder if Jones embellishes the dialogue" but went on to extol the "powerful story of resilience and unconditional love."

Comments (6)

Ira
You are kidding, right? This kind of memoir serves a "liberal" cause? Only in the European sense of "Liberal" - in which George W. Bush and Winston Churchill both deserve the label. The reason US publishing conglomerates focus on this "rise above it" memoir form is to assure people that - in true Horatio Alger form - there is no reason for things like welfare, universal health insurance, or affirmative action. If "Margaret Jones" could do it - so can any poor, abused minority group member in the urban "jungle" - so just 'pull up your bootstraps' and get to work! Without these kinds of faux tales Americans would far more quickly realize that they have less chance for social mobility than any European or most Brazilians. The Times Company - and pearson International - are all just doing their parts for the preservation of 'market capitalism.'
CosmicConservative
Ira: It is really sort of sad how far away from reality your view of the world and the United States is. Speaking as a person who was born into poverty, the child of an enlisted soldier raising six kids at the time, I can absolutely guarantee you that opportunities in the USA exist to do exactly what you describe. Work hard, go to school, get a good job, work hard at it, make a better life for yourself. I've done it. Here in the USA you could to. That's not to say that social safety nets aren't valuable too. They are two completely different issues. Confusing the two is what leads to publishers accepting stories like this without fact-checking them. They didn't publish this story because it was about rising above circumstance, they published it because it paints a picture of poverty that fits in their (and no doubt your) world view.
JSullins
"less chance for social mobility than any European or most Brazilians" HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA Sorry. Ahem. I'll leave it to Cosmic to explain just what is so funny about that line... my own facilities just lack the *oomph* to do it justice. Nearly fell out of my chair, though. Oh, man. *wiping away tears*
Ira
Sorry Cosmic - it isn't my view of poverty at all. It is the view of poverty held by the kind of rich, powerful people who run global publishing houses and global media corporations. My experiences (and they are real) suggest that the statistics are correct, about 1 of 100 people born in poverty in the US will escape poverty by the time they have children. You and JSullins can hand me all the examples you want of those "ones," hell, I'm an example of that, but I also know the advantages that I had and the breaks that i was given. These memoirs, to repeat, belong to an almost 150-year-old American tradition of Alger's "news boy." That against-all-odds rise from poverty to success fashioned by hard work (and individual effort) alone. Unfortunately I've also seen the rest of the 99. The US being the only NATO nation where a full time job won't lift a family of four above the poverty line. The US being the only NATO nation where a family can be bankrupted by a child getting sick. The US being the only NATO nation where a university education can be out of reach because of family finances. So, I have to ask you this - why would a "liberal" (in your use of the term) fantasy include proving that a girl from this kind of background could make it to the top on her own? I would imagine a "liberal" fantasy being one that featured affirmative action solving her problems for her. This book is a fantasy. But it is the fantasy of a rich white kid imagining how those born into disastrous circumstances succeed. And that will never serve as effective left-wing propaganda.
CosmicConservative
Ira: OK, I wasn't fair to your first post. You present a good argument and do a good job of supporting it. Here's what I think. I think you are partly right and I am partly right. I do think that this sort of "memoir" gets published because it pushes the right buttons in the publishing industry. According to statistics the publishing industry is nearly as Left-leaning as Journalism, with something like 90% of publishers and editors identifying themselves as "liberals" or "Democrats." So since it is obviously getting past them without any fact-checking, I think it's a reasonable assertion that it is doing so because it satisfies and reinforces some of their prejudices. But that doesn't mean that your points aren't valid too. Although I think you are being way too cynical. You see the story being all about this one person's ability to rise above, needing no help. I think the liberals who read and reviewed the book instead saw the portrayal of poverty in the book and saw the "author" as the EXCEPTION to the rule, while the rule completely vindicated their view of poverty. In other words I think you are taking a completely different message from the book than they are. But you do point out how the book can be interpreted as a Horatio Algiers rags-to-riches story, and I concede that it can. And I haven't read the book, so I really should be careful about commenting on its content. But.. (isn't there always a "but"?) from the reviews I've read, this book focuses on the travails and suffering of the poverty stricken more than it does on the heroic efforts of the author. Or it may just be a Rorschach test sort of thing and the reader can take it either way, depending on their preconceived notions. Now, as far as "1 in 100" statistics you quote, would you care to cite them so I can see where they came from?
CosmicConservative
Oh, just for the sake of argument, in the original, traditional meaning of the word "liberal" a rags to riches story IS a liberal fantasy. But of course we both know that's not how it is used today. ;)