Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

The Ascent of Obamalot...

By Dadman
Prepare yourself for President Obama conservative boys and girls. Yes, I'm calling the election today. In my view, Obama is a lock for the Democratic nomination (barring any Clintonista funny business) and will easily defeat McCain in the general election. Before you protest too loudly, remember I called the World Series and the defeat of Mitt Romney. ;) So why do I think Obama is on the road to victory? There are several reasons... First, the Democrats are energized and eager to flex their political muscle this election cycle. They are turning out in droves for the primaries and will no doubt do the same in November. They are practically frothing at the mouth for the chance to repudiate the Bush administration, the Iraq War, and conservatism in general. And it doesn't seem to be only the hardcore Democratic base that is feeling this way. Moderates in both parties and independents seem ready to take the country in a new direction even if that new direction is being charted by a well-spoken empty suit. Contrast the political energy on the left with the malaise and disappointment of conservatives on the right and I think you have the recipe for a Republican defeat in November. Second, Obama represents an opportunity for white America to make amends for its racist past and mitigate some collective white guilt. This, of course, makes Obama a powerful symbol of racial reconciliation in a socio-political climate that is continually seeking to bridge racial divides. Obama will accrue a considerable amount of sympathy, and votes, simply because of his racial heritage. He will also be protected from a significant amount of criticism white politicians would be subjected to for the same reason. Of course, he will also lose some votes because of his race, but I think in this election cycle the benefits will outweigh the liabilities. Third, Obama has style and charisma and he is playing to an electorate that predominately seems to care about little else. Substance is secondary as long as the platitudes are pleasing to the ear and the candidate is pleasing to the eye. It's remarkable how successful Obama has been up to this point in the absence of any real substance. Well, perhaps not remarkable. We are talking about the Democratic primaries where substance and common sense are both endangered species. But the lack of substance has been a noted hallmark of the Obama campaign and I don't think it is going to change...that much. For the reasons listed above, I don't think Obama needs to offer much more than symbolism and flowery rhetoric to become the next POTUS. Fourth, McCain will be cast as the good-ol'-boy, Republican establishment candidate, the very thing that so many Democrat, moderate and independent voters can't wait to vote against. And to right-wingers, a significant portion of the Republican base, McCain will be viewed as a liberal RINO who can't be trusted to support and defend conservative principles. So, McCain is going to be losing votes on the right, the left and in the center. I don't see how he wins given this dynamic. And so I believe we are witnessing the ascent of Obamalot - a new world populated by charismatic demigods, lofty ideals, and inspirational rhetoric that also happens to be a fantasy world. The problem, of course, is that we live in a real world full of real problems and fanatical, blood-thirsty, nuclear-bomb-seeking enemies. We need tough, pragmatic leaders to face these challenges, not pretty-boy empty suits who offer little more than political symbolism. We need Ronaldus Maximus...

Comments (11)

CosmicConservative
I agree with your analysis, right up to the point where you seem to feel that this will go on into the future. My opinion is that depends a whole lot on how Obama actually governs as President, and how the world reacts. I think there is a very real chance that Obama will be the next Jimmy Carter, and his reign will be so disastrous that Republicans will ride to a Ronaldus Maximus type victory in 2012. We just need to find the right candidate, and we need to run interference on an Obama administration as effectively (or more, actually) than the Democrats did on the Bush administration. It can be done.
Dadman
No, I think Obamalot could be short-lived. But even four years of it is enough to scare the crap out of me...
pace
In what areas (either specifically, or generally) would you say that Obama is lacking substance where McCain and/or Hillary are not? I am curious about this, because I think there is a much stronger case for the lack of experience or credentials line of attack. The 'lack of substance' criticism simply appears to be in response to the guy's ability to deliver good speeches, yet the two really have a rather abstract relationship.
Dadman
That's good question, pace. I think the lack of substance and lack of experience charges are interrelated, at least in my mind they are. Obama is a newcomer on the national political scene who appears to be succeeding by virtue of a personality cult, rather than any substantive platform and/or track record of political success. He seems to be, at this point in time, little more than a symbol of change, a symbol of racial atonement, a repudiation of conservative ideology, who delivers good speeches and looks good in a suit, a suit that just happens to be an rather empty one by my estimation. Now, Hillary is really no more substantive than Obama. McCain, due to his long track record in the Senate, maverick ways, and distinguished military service strikes me as the most substantive of the three, although I'm not fond of all the 'substance' McCain brings to the game. As has been established, he seems to be playing for the other team all too often...
CosmicConservative
Pace: Here's how you measure it: How many substantive bills has Obama submitted on his own, or co-authored with another Senator? The answer is none. Of course that's the same answer for Hillary, or very close to it. Hillary's tenure in the Senate is twice as long as Obama's and she also has very little substantive legislation to show for it. McCain, much to my chagrin, has a very long and detailed resume of such legislative achievements. Of course I vehemently disagree with about half of them, but he HAS them. Then there is the issue of committee chairmanships. Obama was named the chair of one committee, but he has yet to have sat in a committee meeting since he was named chairperson. Hillary has a similarly ineffective record as a committee chairperson. McCain has chaired powerful committees and has made substantive changes in government as a chairperson of those committees. Again, I don't always agree with what he's done, but he's DONE things. And that's only in the Senate. Outside the Senate McCain was an Air Force officer. He led men and fought for our country. Hillary has, as far as we know, led one significant administration effort in the Bill Clinton years, and that was a historic failure. A monumental one. But at least she can say she tried. Obama has NOTHING. No business experience, no administrative experience, no military experience. He wrote a book. That's about it. Although I am not in the habit of describing Obama or Hillary as "empty suits" I think the description fits both of them rather well. The one thing both of them have done and have a lot of experience doing, is making speeches. And in my opinion Hillary sucks at that, and Obama is a master. If I were to choose between Hillary and Obama right now in terms of pure administrative ability, I would have to give Obama the edge because he has run a far better campaign than Hillary has. And that is a leadership, administrative function, so it is some indication of how effective he will be as President. But that's an awful slim thing to use to choose the leader of the most powerful country on earth. But it seems to be enough for most people.
pace
I appreciate the candid responses. You guys clearly associate 'substance' with experience. As I said, I view the relationship between the two as rather abstract. I think it is possible to be extremely experienced, yet lacking in substance, and vice-versa. I expect a candidate lacking substance to express policy with no plan to execute upon it, to express positions which pander to the current whims rather than aligning with previous actions, to make discrete claims that appear to have little or no factual basis, etc. Al Gore, for example is someone who strikes me as lacking in real substance, although he clearly is a seasoned politician. So what I am saying, is that when you more closely and objectively scrutinize these candidates, Hillary demonstrates no more substance than Obama, yet her camp has championed this 'empty suit' characterization of her opponent which Republicans are merrily picking up on. Speaking frankly, I have not seen a good deal of 'substance' from John McCain within the context of this election race. I understand his positions, but am not seeing much articulation of how exactly he is going to execute on them.
CosmicConservative
Pace: Perhaps it's not that we equate "substance" with "experience" but that we are saying that "results" are the manifestation of "substance" and until results are demonstrable, any claimed "substance" is exactly what you call it. "Abstract." And I'm not in the market for abstract substance. I want the demonstrated variety.
Dadman
I think political campaigns by their very nature are lacking in substance. Campaigns are all about canned stump speeches, properly timed sound bites, slogans, photo ops, platitudes and the like. So, in the context of this election none of the candidates can appear terribly substantive. However, outside the context of this election, McCain clearly has the better track record of political accomplishments and the credentials that put him in good stead to become Commander in Chief.
pace
There is no argument from me that McCain has oodles more experience than either Hillary or Obama (or both of them combined, probably). I think that experience is an important criteria when evaluating a candidate for any job. However, it is not the only critera that I apply.
CosmicConservative
It's not the only one I apply either. But it's a handy way to see if someone has substance to back up their rhetoric. That's why I question Obama's substance, not because I am sure he is lacking it, but because I see no evidence of it. And Hillary is not much better. Every time I hear Hillary go on about how she's "tested" I laugh out loud. If so she flunked the test repeatedly. When she was under fire for Hillary-care she crawled back into the White House and assumed the traditional role of a First Lady. When she thought Bill was being attacked by Ken Starr and Monica Lewinsky she fabricated a fantasy world of a "vast right-wing conspiracy." When she was forced to accept that her husband had been caught (again) with his pants down, she adopted the traditional role of an abused wife. In fact there is very, very little I have ever seen from Hillary that I would say demonstrates anything but a big mouth, a chip on her shoulder and an inflated opinion of herself.
» What precisely is the scenario for a McCain victory? CosmicConservative: Rational Conservatism from the Rocky Mountains
[...] the electorate is moving decidedly toward Obama. Now, I have been predicting an Obama victory since this post, but others who frequent this blog are convinced McCain will be the next POTUS. I’m wondering [...]