Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Romney loses California...

By Dadman
I am deeply disappointed with this outcome. The pundits are now predicting Mitt will graciously exit the race this week. Conventional wisdom would dictate bowing out as perhaps the most prudent course of action. But, Romney may have another option in mind. He may decide to forge ahead as the standard bearer of true conservative ideology and give voice to those ideals at the Republican convention. The conservative intelligensia are not pleased with what is going on in these primaries and they will likely encourage Mitt to stay the course. Perhaps this is a repeat of what happened to Reagan in 1976. I like to think so. Maybe Romney can make a successful run for the White House in 2012 after four years of liberal governance under either Obama, Clinton or McCain...

Comments (25)

Andy
What surprised me (and has been surprising me) is how wrong the polls are (and have been). The pollsters are usually pretty accurate. Go figure.
Boyd
I find it amusing that some folks consider, such as yourself, Dadman, consider Romney a conservative and McCain a liberal. We obviously view their records quite differently.
Boyd
I suppose I typed "consider" twice because I know you're really thinking hard about such things. That's my story, and I'm stickin' to it.
CosmicConservative
I think Dadman and I have similar views of McCain. I don't know that either of us believe McCain to be "a liberal" although I do think both of us consider Romney to be "a conservative." What I think of McCain is that he is politically, not ideologically, motivated. Meaning that he votes how he views the political winds to be blowing. There is no way he can be considered a "conservative" after the McCain-Feingold debacle. Not to me and many other conservatives. That legislation was so counter to so many truly conservative principles (not the least of which is free speech) that it is too much of a contortion to call him a "conservative" and put that bill into his repertoire. Add shamnesty and a few other things to it and you end up with a politician who has charted a course that is sometimes conservative and sometimes liberal. Which is, of course, why he is described by the liberal media as a "maverick". But since consistent conservatism is what I want in a candidate (although even Reagan had his non-conservative moments, and I acknowledge that) I don't like McCain because I can't depend on McCain to carry the conservative banner on issues that are very important to me. That's why I call him a "liberal Republican" because that's what he is. But a "liberal Republican" like McCain is still far, far to the right of a liberal Democrat like Obama.
CosmicConservative
Andy: I don't know that I agree that the pollsters have been "pretty accurate" for a while now. All the way back to the 2000 election we have been surprised by the outcome of major elections when compared to the polls. The polls before the 2000 election showed Bush winning the popular vote and Gore winning the Electoral vote. But exactly the reverse happened. Which was ironic because Gore was asked if it would be a problem for him to govern if he won the electoral vote while losing the popular vote and his answer was "of course not, that's the way our system works." He sang a completely different tune when the system ended up working against him.
Drax
Well since Dadman said: "Maybe Romney can make a successful run for the White House in 2012 after four years of liberal governance under either Obama, Clinton or McCain…" I think that it's pretty clear that he thinks McCain is a liberal. A liberal who is pro-life (and has been his entire political career, not just since it has become necessary politically). A liberal who is for nominating strict constructionist Justices. A liberal who is for staying the course in Iraq until it's successfully concluded and not one who is tied to any "time table." Etc. Etc. Ya'lls definition of "liberal" really galls me.
Dadman
Drax: I'm being somewhat facetious when I call McCain a liberal. I know he's a little to the right of Castro. ;)
Drax
And, I don't get ya'll saying that McCain "can't be counted on." He has pretty well consistently held the same positions his entire political life. On the other hand, Romney was pro-abortion when he needed to be in order to win Mass, and is now pro-life when he needs to be in order to contest for the Republican nomination. How one can simply "change his mind" on such a core issue (conveniently from a no longer beneficial position to a beneficial one) when the previously held position is one which runs counter to the principles of his church eludes me. Romney may or may not be "conservative," but he sure in heck holds some convenient "conservative" positions.
CosmicConservative
You are right Drax. All of us conservatives who have been complaining about McCain for years over anti-conservative issues like McCain-Feingold, shamnesty and treatment of terrorists are completely unable to determine conservative from liberal. All the millions of us. Including virtually every conservative pundit such as Rush Limbaugh, Laura Ingrahim, Hugh Hewitt, Dennis Prader, the majority of the National Review Online staff... pretty much every one of them except Bill Bennett. Yep, we're all full of crap. Every one of us.
Dadman
I don't have time to debate right now, but there is a difference between pro-abortion and pro-status quo, i.e. allowing the right of a woman to choose to stand as settled law. I don't believe Romney has ever been 'pro-abortion', but he did say that he would not interfere with a woman's right to choose when governor of Massachusetts. In Massachusetts that is a pragmatic political position to take and does not necessarily say anything about where he personally stands on the issue of abortion. As much as I am pro-life, I recognize there are some significant socio-political-legal complications associated with limiting or criminalizing abortion. I think Romney recognized the same and decided not to muck with the status quo in Massachusetts at the time he ran for governor...
Drax
I'm not saying that McCain doesn't hold positions which are traditionally (as self-defining "conservatives" define them) "conservative." There really isn't much of a question about that. Have I questioned that? Have I questioned ANYTHING other than your and others' defining McCain as LIBERAL when, his record of nearly 30 years shows that he, on most of the important issues, is UTTERLY conservative (as defined by ANYONE)? There is an obvious and major distinction between being "liberal" and being "conservative." Only the most mind-numbed and unthinking of persons could POSSIBLY be completely "liberal" or "conservative" AS DEFINED BY OTHERS. Most people have some "conservative" and some "liberal" positions, leaning greatly towards one or the other in most cases. McCain is conservative in almost every area which matters to me. I don't like some of his positions, but like almost EVERY position he holds when compared to those held by Obama or Hillary. Since we've given Romney a "pass" on his convenient change of heart on abortion, why is it so difficult to give McCain a "pass" on his recent stances that he would work to make the Bush tax cuts permanent (now that he's seen them in action...but would try to put some spending constraints on them as well...) and would "secure the borders first" instead of his earlier positon on McCain/Kennedy? After all, these are isues which don't go to the "core" of his BEING and MORAL BELIEFS as does the issue of abortion. And, otherwise...in greatest, greatest part...he holds traditional conservative positions. Why is that so difficult to admit? Why continue to brush him with the "liberal" brush when any RATIONAL person knows that he holds a FEW liberal positions but has nearly three DECADES of conservative positions behind him?
Drax
Oops...in my opening paragraph of my last post, I meant to say: "I’m not saying that McCain doesn’t hold positions which are traditionally (as self-defining “conservatives” define them) deemed to be “liberal.”
Drax
Dadman: Romney has admitted, in debate and many times, that his earlier position on abortion (i.e., he was pro "right to choose") was both WRONG and that he has CHANGED his mind on the issue. It was a position of pro "right to choose," NOT a "let things stay as they are" status quo ante position. It was a position he needed to have take in order to win Mass. The opposite position is the position he needs to take in order to compete for the Republican nomination. That, as you say....is "pragmatic."
CosmicConservative
Drax, sometimes it's not quantity but quality that counts. Sure there may be some politicians that I would easily acknowledge as "conservative" who hold as many "liberal" perspectives as John McCain does. Ronald Wilson Reagan might even be one of those. But in McCain's case it's not the quantity of positions, it's the specific positions he chooses. As I have said before, he chooses to hold his liberal views on critical, core conservative issues like political free speech, treatment of terrorists and illegal immigration. And he doesn't just hold positions, he insults the intelligence and motivations of those he disagrees with on these subjects. Frankly I could deal a whole lot more with his liberal tendencies if he wasn't such a monumental arrogant ass*ole about them. But he is. And those aren't the only reasons I don't like him. He also, in my opinion, is far too easily flattered by the media and the left into fighting the conservatives. He gets a big thrill out of being the thorn in the side of the "right wing." To me he seems to itch for a chance to show the world that he's not in lock-step with us neanderthals. So I can accept every argument you are making and STILL say that his liberal tendencies are of a quality, if not quantity, that he deserves everything he gets from the right. He is the one who goes out looking for a fight. Well, he's got exactly the fight he was looking for. Now we'll see if it costs him the Presidency. I think it probably will.
CosmicConservative
Drax: You are aware, I hope, that Ronald Reagan did exactly the same thing on the issue of abortion. He flipped on it as well. When challenged about it his response was on the lines of: "It doesn't matter what I USED to believe, what matters is what I believe NOW and like most reformed believers, my belief is all the stronger for having been taught the error of my ways." I don't care if Romney was once pro-abortion. What matters is whether I believe that he will become pro-abortion AGAIN. And I don't believe he will.
CosmicConservative
But the real question we should be asking is "Is Angie Dickinson in 1960 hotter than Jessica Alba in 2006?"
Drax
Jessica has a much better looking face. Angie had a better honed body. I'm for Jessica. And CC: McCain/Feingold isn't really about McCain being against "free speech" but about "getting politicans elected speech." I sincerely doubt that you'll find any other areas of "free speech" in which McCain takes anything other than a "conservative" view. McCain is the only "conservative" on Capitol Hill (of which I'm aware) who was a POW. This gives him somewhat a different perspective about how to treat PRISONERS (as opposed to "terrorists) when we have them in OUR custody than others might have. I disagree, but certainly respect where he's coming from. I agree that he's an ass. An arrogant ass. (Like most Naval Officers I've known...) (I would argue that what I've seen of Romney makes me dislike him on a very visceral basis thus far, but I try to keep how I "feel" about someone separate from how I "think" about him...) But, I have to acknowledge that he can WIN. I'll take a 70% conservative, especially when that 70% includes Iraq and strict constructionist Justices than either of the two 100% liberal (well, 95% in Hillary's case) potential other choices we'll have.
Boyd
The difference between RR changing his mind on abortion and MR changing his mind is that Reagan's change came in conjunction with a general conservative-leaning shift in his positions, which predated his Presidential campaign by a considerable margin. Romney, on the other hand, changed his position exactly at the time he enters the Presidential race. Coincidentally, at that precisely same time, he changes his position on gun control. I think he's lying in both cases. I know all politicians are liars. But the contempt you hold for McCain, I hold for Romney, because he thinks I'm stupid enough to believe that he changed his position on principle rather than for convenience. I'm not that stupid. And Romney's no conservative, no matter how loudly he claims that title. When he says it, all I hear is, "I'm a liar, and you're too stupid to realize that. Ha-ha!" I'm no McCain fanboi, but I think you folks who hold Romney up as some conservative demigod are ignoring reality. Sorry, I don't mean to be insulting, but that's my reaction to Rush Limbaugh, Laura Ingrahim, Hugh Hewitt, Dennis Prader and the Cosmic Conservative propping up Romney as a conservative, when he's clearly (to me) not.
CosmicConservative
I think I've said that I'll hold my nose and vote for McCain. And when he abandons conservatism for political reasons as President, I'll still be glad that he's the President instead of Obama or Hillary IF he gets elected. That's what makes me different from Limbaugh and Ann Coulter and others who claim they'll vote for Hillary since they want the Democrat Party to get blamed for their liberal failures instead of the Republican Party. I'm not that far gone. But I'll point it out when he does it. And I do think I divorce my dislike of a politician from their position on the issues. But when McCain turns his position into a personal attack, I think his behavior is fair game. His attacks on conservatives have political ramifications and as such are no different from policy decisions. So I'll consider that part of his "personality" too since it affects his ability to govern.
Drax
I get the same vibe from Romney as do you, Boyd. I don't trust his conveniently timed changes in position from that which he needed to be elected in Mass. to that which he needed to be elected as the Republican nominee. I don't trust his denying that he "raised taxes" and had to have the fact that he raised "fees" by hundreds of millions of dollars in the debates all the while defending the necessity to increase the fees/taxes.
CosmicConservative
Oh, my take on Jessica vs. Angie? I'll put that in the other post so that it stays with the photos...
Drax
CC: I just don't get what you mean by "abandon conservatism." Is he going to become pro-abortion? Is he going to nominate liberal Justices? Is he going to pull out of Iraq as soon as he's elected? Is he going to discard his gun-control position and take up the Aussie position? I just don't get what you mean. You think that he doesn't stand for ANYTHING when you have nearly 30 years of history to research. (As we all don't have the time to research each vote, I guess we'll rely on those who do...his opponents in the hunt. If what they're bring up is ALL they have when it comes to McCain's "liberalism," I think I'll continue to call him a "conservative maverick" rather than a "liberal" as it is much more in keeping with his track record than anything else....)
Dadman
It is much more likely that Romney adjusted his true beliefs to get elected in left-leaning Massachusetts and that the positions he holds now are more aligned with his 'core' beliefs. That said, I do understand the problem some people have with Romney's shifting positions over the last several years. It's a legitimate liability. But I think Andy (aka The Urban Redneck) has nailed Romney's fatal flaws: he's rich, intelligent, and drop-dead handsome. Boyd and Drax are just jealous! Just kidding guys... ;)
CosmicConservative
Drax: My last comment on this thread, I really am too sore to keep sitting at this keyboard today. I have already stated where McCain has abandoned conservatism and I expect his future actions to be comparable to his present ones. I have already stated that McCain can claim all he wants that he will appoint "strict constructionist" justices. I will believe it when I see it. Why should he appoint justices that would simply overturn his own legislation? It doesn't make sense. I have conceded that he will be strong on foreign policy and the Iraq War. But I have also said that I expect Hillary's actions in that area, once she is sitting in the role of commander in chief, to be virtually identical. Obama, maybe not, but Hillary will do what she has to do to keep Iraq stable. She's pandering to her base now to get elected, so I'm not paying much attention to what she is saying. Gun control is not nearly the critical issue to me that it is to other conservatives. I like guns. I own guns. I firmly believe in the second amendment. But I am also not foolish enough to believe that the founding fathers intended for private citizens to own nuclear weapons, so the argument that we have to own guns to have military parity with our own government is no longer a tenable argument. And I can sympathize with the argument that there are a lot of people out there who probably should never touch a gun. So gun control is not one of my major issues. But illegal immigration is. And I am quite certain that McCain will push through policies in that area that I will violently disagree with. Enough on this. I've stated my case, you've stated yours, both of us have had a good say and I think both of us have made good points, I'll let the readers reach their own conclusions now. There's not much of that dead horse left to beat.