Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Is this a necessary lawsuit?

By CosmicConservative
John Ritter's family is looking for $67 million dollars from a radiologist and cardiologist because they did not save John Ritter's life when his aorta tore on the set of "8 Simple Rules." Part of the story points out that they have already won some settlements worth millions, but they aren't done suing yet.
FOXNews.com - John Ritter's Family Taking $67 Million Lawsuit to Trial - Celebrity Gossip | Entertainment News | Arts And Entertainment Ritter's second wife, Amy Yasbeck, and his four children have already received a reported $14 million in settlements with nine other medical entities, including the hospital where he was treated.
What do you think? Would you sue in the same situation?

Comments (12)

Drax
One of the reasons to sue is to teach the other person (institution) a lesson: Don't do this again. So, money obviously isn't the issue. Maybe they just want to make sure that the person(s) at fault is/are taken to task for his/their mistakes. Not a thing in the world wrong with that.
CosmicConservative
I don't see how you can possibly say that money isn't an issue here. You can certainly interpret this situation in a number of ways, but when someone already has $14 million in their pocket, plus whatever Ritter was already worth when he died, and they are demanding $67 million MORE from doctors, it does not seem unreasonable to me to suggest that greed may in fact be the driving motivation here. We'll see how the case goes, but with a sympathetic victim and a California jury, I think the family has a good shot at winning a judgment against these doctors. I will be honest, my immediate reaction to this is "geez, how much money do you people NEED?" Have any of the doctors or institutions here been reprimanded by any medical ethics boards or medical institutions? If not, why not? In my opinion this is more likely to be a case of people demanding that doctors be perfect than actually finding any sort of incompetence. My understanding of the condition Ritter had is that it very closely mimics the symptoms of a heart attack, and in the heat of life-saving emergency room procedures, it is hardly surprising that the medical staff would have thought that something that looked like, smelled like and sounded like a heart attack actually WAS a heart attack. Expecting them to immediately say "Wait, 99% of the time when we are in this situation, it's a heart attack, but we better dig deeper into this situation because there's a 1% chance it's a torn aorta" seems a bit unrealistic. Such second-guessing in trauma cases would likely lead to more deaths, not fewer. I have to admit, my immediate reaction to this is very negative towards the family, and my initial sympathies are with the doctors who I believe probably did everything the way they were taught and it was just a fluke chance that Ritter's situation was a torn aorta instead of a heart attack. To sue them for $67 million dollars for trying to save his life not only seems greedy, it seems to be a severe case of ingratitude. I might be wrong, and the doctors may have been incompetent, but with the victim being John Ritter, and their knowledge of the attention that the case would receive, I find it hard to believe that they did not do exactly what they were trained to do.
Ed Minchau
Amy Yasbeck doesn't need the money. She raked it in as a regular on Wings. Having said that, I don't think this lawsuit has merit, for the reasons Cos outlined above.
Drax
Doesn't have "merit?" Doctors and insurance companies don't shell out $14 million on cases which "don't have merit." Period. And, as to the question of whether or not "it's about the money." The Ritters are rich beyond the imaginings of most people already. As noted, his wife is rich as well. They will TAKE the money since money is ALL they can get. They can't get the licenses of the doctors/nurses. They can't put them in jail. They can't stop others from seeing them. They can't make the hospitals revoke their privileges. ALL they can do is SUE FOR MONEY. When they settle the case, the doctor now has a strike against him...both for future cases and for malpractice insurance purposes. $14 million is a meager portion of what Ritter would be expected to make as the star of a hit sitcom, so, apparently the case was solid enough to settle but not so solid that the Ritters wanted to take it to trial. But, they got the money. That is as close to an admission of fault as they are likely to get. Either this case will ALSO settle (with the above-mentioned ramifications for the doctor(s)) or they will take it to trial. (And...just for future references...in order to get good lawyers to represent them, they actually have to GET SOME MONEY...as most lawyers don't represent people for free...)
CosmicConservative
In a world where OJ Simpson is walking a free man, I just don't buy the "they wouldn't win a settlement if the doctors did nothing wrong" argument. But I am uncharacteristically uninterested in debating this issue, so I'll just let it stand at that.
Drax
Um...a jury let OJ go. An adjuster (or comittee of adjusters) aka "bean counters" handed over the 14 Million. Big, huge, glaring difference.
Kevin in WI
I will take an "until you walk a mile in their shoes" on this one and defer. Hoewever, I think it is true that you don't get to the heart of it unil you get to the doctors that directly treated him. It may be a case of peeling back the Onion.
Liz
Drax, you are completely wrong. Hospitals, doctors and insurance companies settle all the time for relative peanuts in comparison to what could be won in a jury trial because it is safer than taking the risk of losing in jackpot trial. Further, it is commonly written into malpractice coverage contracts that the malpractice carrier will reserve to the right to make decisions regarding settlement or fighting at trial even above the objections of the physician. Think of what it means to successfully defend a malpractice case... it can be months or years of involvement. Depositions and subpoenas and hearings, taking all that time away from your practice (lost earnings there), the emotional agony (its not exactly fun for physicians to be accused of killing a patient) and stress and most of all the costs of hiring your own legal defense. And even when you are 100% assured in yourself and your innocence, there is still a chance that a jury of lay-people will be more swayed by the emotion of the case and side with the poor widow anyway. And if that happens, goodbye medical practice permanently. Would you risk that? All too often doctors and hospitals decide that both the costs and risks associated with seeing a defense all the way through just aren't worth it. This is precisely what predatory personal injury lawyers are counting on when the file suit and name every physician who ever touched the patient. Its almost assured that one of them will settle.
kate
This is insane The heart condition ritter had is nearly always fatal Most victims dont even make the ambulance ride to the hospital The doctor did nothing wrong Ritters widow is a nut case and greedy to the max I hope she is never in need of a doctor to save her life No one in their right mind would treat a gold digger like her She is dumb
Sohni
I was juror (who found Doctors to be clear) who was actively involved in the decision making process in the deliberation room. I will be happy to answer any questions you may have.
CosmicConservative
Sohni: Thanks for stopping by. What I'd be interested in knowing is whether the jury considered the condition John Ritter died from to have been something that an Emergency Room doctor should have recognized immediately and treated expertly while confronted with a man whose apparent symptoms of a heart attack. I'd also like to know if the fact that the family had already won a large judgment in the case and was seeking more money played into the decision.