Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Has Conservatism been hijacked by a moderate Republican establishment?

By Dadman
From my vantage point on the right, it seems to be precisely what is happening. I am amused how a left-of-center Republican establishment is lining up to endorse McCain - governors, senators, congressmen, etc. Many of these people are members of the entrenched Washington insider class, the same people who largely failed to defend conservative principles over the past 7 years, and their endorsements have the distinct stench of a bunch of fat and happy good ol' boys protecting one of their own. Even worse, many conservative Republican voters in Florida seemed to buy McCain's ruse that he was a foot soldier of the Reagan Revolution. Well, maybe he once was, but he must have taken a head shot in one of the battles because he has clearly lost sight of what it means to be a Reagan Republican. The Republican party seems to have lost its conservative soul. The closer McCain gets to the Republican nomination the more clear it become that my conservative ideology has no viable voice in American politics - at least not in this election cycle. I have an overwhelming feeling of political disenfranchisment and it's not a very good feeling. On the issues that matter most to me - border security, taxes, limited government, strict constructionist judicial appointments, life, a sane approach to limiting greenhouse emissions - McCain is playing for the other team. Only on the GWOT has McCain been consistently strong, if you ignore the fact that he wants to limit the tools the U.S. government uses to monitor and interrogate suspected terrorists. So he's suspect even on the issue of protecting the American people from blood-thirsty jihadists. For the life of me I just don't understand what Republican primary voters are thinking. Perhaps it's the electability issue. The problem with that proposition is the fact that a President McCain will not govern much differently than a President Hillary. It will be interesting to see if the true Reagan conservatives, assuming any remain in any significant numbers, come out to the polls on Tsunami Tuesday. I think they will, but regrettably I don't think it will be enough to stop the 'Staight Talking Charade'.

Comments (16)

Paul
Sad, but true, the candidates running on the republican side have little to ZERO conservative leanings. The democrats should really call themselves socialists, and the people running the show for the republicans right now are not too far behind. It does not appear that smaller government, less taxes, and a strong military are very important right now. Paul
ams182764
It will be one day when China starts overflying our newly agrarian nation with long range bombers and ICBMs. By then though, it will be far too late for a politician to snap his fingers and magically re-create an industrial economy and military.
Andy
Cosmic: I don't think conservatism has been hijacked by the Republican establishment. You can't change something that has a clear definition. I know I'm splitting hairs here, but if it's not "conservative," then it's something else. Kind of like "marriage." There is no such thing as "gay marriage." If it's not a man and a woman, then it's something else. Sure, the lib Republicans want to change the definition of "conservative." But it's just something else. You and I both know what "conservative" is. We won't have that knowledge "hijacked," or influenced. We're not winning right now. In fact, we're losing. The libs may own and control the Party for now...and maybe from now on. It's time to regroup, and look for a new coach. I truly believe that there are millions of us ready to play...we just need the right coach, with the right game plan. Somebody's gonna have to step up pretty quickly though. It looks like it's over this time around. But maybe next time...we'll see I guess.
Bart the Builder
Cosmic: I agree that this election cycle for a true conservative is and has been a disappointment. Like you said in an earlier post, "just hold your nose and pull the McCain lever." I don't care if Ann Coulter thinks Hillary would govern more conservative than McCain. The Hillary alternative is just unacceptable and plum scarey!
CosmicConservative
Just to be clear, this was Dadman's post, not mine. Although I do think it mirrors and clarifies a lot of the things I've been saying about the current political landscape. I blame Bush. I really do. Peggy Noonan was more or less right when she said that Bush had squandered the Reagan legacy by abandoning true conservative principles while outwardly claiming the conservative mantle. The end result was that true conservatives lost faith with Bush and those who would have become conservatives in the face of a Reagan-esque figure bought into the "Bush is evil" mantra of the left and have instead adopted "moderate" or even "liberal" positions. When the press repeatedly calls a President who oversaw spending increases greater than any since the "Great Society" a "conservative" it is no wonder that people are confused about what a conservative is. You can go back to my earliest posts on CosmicConservative about GW Bush and you will see that I have said he is no conservative from day one. Not that I have any real dislike for GW, I think he was far better than the alternatives we had to choose from (including McCain) for the past eight years. But he's no conservative and his actions have seriously fractured the Republican base while galvanizing the Democrat base. I am still hoping Romney can pull it out. But those who say that McCain is the best hope Republicans have to win the White House in '08 are probably right. And whether it is McCain vs. Obama or McCain vs. Hillary, I'll vote McCain either way. But I won't be fooled into thinking I'm voting for a conservative.
Andy
Cosmic & Dadman: Sorry...gotta start reading the byline more closely I guess. The writing sounded like Cosmic. Hey, are you guys really the same person? ;)
Dadman
Man, I don't get any credit for anything. ;) Ran into Joe Montana today at The NFL Experience. Much larger in real life than what you might expect.
Andy
You ran into Joe Montana and lived? You're a tougher Dadman than I figured you were.
Drax
Just how far right do you have to be to be called "conservative?" Do you have to be "conservative" on ALL issues before you're a "true conservative," or can you actually use your own brain and heart to make your decisions rather than being in lock-step with the rest of the "conservatives" (which make up a minority of the Republican party)? Take global warming...Does one have to nay-say that it exists or that it is caused by Man in order to be a conservative, or can you, as McCain, believe that it is happening...it is being caused by Man...and, if he's wrong, then the harm is that we're left with cleaner air, while, if "conservatives" are wrong, we're left with...well, not much of anything. I'll never get it.
CosmicConservative
Well, that's a fair question. First though, I have to take exception to the "if he's wrong, then the harm is that we're left with cleaner air" comment. If he's wrong what we are left with is a seriously degraded economy, perhaps millions of lost jobs, seriously more expensive cars and gasoline, which will reduce the ability to purchase other things, like HDTVs or movie tickets, etc. The danger of overreacting to AGW is that it will cripple the economy to the point that we fall into a deep worldwide recession or even depression. That's why conservatives are opposed to draconian government-mandated "solutions" to what has not been proven to be an actual problem yet. Here is why John McCain does not qualify as "conservative" to me. 1. Finance reform. The McCain-Feingold campaign fincance reform bill is about as anti-conservative as you can get. It fundamentally violates the right of citizens to criticize their leaders. It clearly is designed as an incumbancy protection act. I would put this as a litmus test on conservatism. If you support it, you aren't conservative, period. If you SPONSOR it, you are anti-conservative. 2. Shamnesty. McCain's position on providing legal protection to illegal aliens in this country is not only anti-conservative, it has turned most of his own state against him. The idea that our government "owes" something to individuals who have broken our laws, and who abuse our social programs, is again about as anti-conservative as you can get. I would also suggest that shamnesty is a conservative deal-breaker. You can't support it and be a conservative. It violates too many principles. 3. Interrogation procedures. McCain has joined the chorus on the left calling water-boarding "torture." In doing so he has accused our own government of committing torture. I wouldn't go so far as to call this a conservative deal-breaker, but it's close. To afford constitutional protections to in-combat Geneva-convention breaking terrorists is a major break with not only U.S. law, but international law. The Geneva Conventions were written to encourage combatants to conform to international guidelines for combat. Individuals who do not recognize, nor conform to those conventions should receive no protection from them. To me it's basic common sense. If you're in a street fight and your opponent pulls a knife, you are a fool if you stick to the Queensbury boxing rules. And that's what McCain is saying we should do. Those are just three off the top of my head. The first two are deal breakers. You can't hold McCain's position on them and be called conservative. Not in my opinion.
Drax
Let's take them in order: McCain/Feingold: Bad law for sure. The irony of it is that, as President, McCain would nominate strict constructionists for the Supreme Court, Justices who might very well strike the law down as unconstitutional. But, wait. Strict Constructionists? How liberal of him. Anmesty: This is a complicated issue. There are, what, 12 million illegal aliens in this country right now? How much of our national treasure are we going to expend to get them out? And, wait. If they're here, and they aren't breaking laws, and are actually contributing members of society, aren't they EXACTLY the kind of "citizens" that we want...whereas those "waiting in line" are an unknown commodity? Isn't it rational to simply say that, those who are here, who aren't breaking laws, who are contributing to society, get to stay and become citizens if they fulfill certain requirements -- rather than expend BILLIONS of our national treasure shipping them back and many millions more as we LET THEM BACK IN? (Since they're the kinds we want...don't you know?) And, wait. Wasn't Reagan for amnesty and sanctuary cities? Damned liberal. Torture: McCain has NEVER advocated that we grant these prisoners constitutional protection. He simply defines "torture" differently than do others (almost ALL of whom didn't spend any time in a POW camp). I disagree with him on this issue, but certainly can see how water boarding CAN be defined as torture. It's not really a cut-and-dried issue, is it? On the other hand, McCain has never put any pork barrel in any legislation for his state and is a fiscal conservative. He's pro-life. He's for strict constructionist Justices. He's for spending ties to any tax cut. (Reagan and Bush could have used them in their tax cuts, that's for sure). He's for continuing the Iraq war to its SUCCESSFUL conclusion. He doesn't want any treaty on global warming which does not include, at least, China and India (and the other modern countries). He would require that aliens speak English to be citizens. He is for free trade. And, other issues. In my mind, there are three main issues for choosing a President: 1.) National Security; 2.) Economic outlook; 3.) Supreme Court nominees. On these issues, McCain is clearly in line with the most conservative of conservatives.
CosmicConservative
On all three issues I prefer Mitt Romney to John McCain. I am not nearly as certain as you are that John McCain defines "strict constructionist justices" the way I would. I suspect his idea of an ideal justice is closer to Kennedy or Souter than to Alito or Roberts. In fact that's one of my great fears about McCain. Not only because of his own views, but because I feel he is far too accomodating of his liberal friends on such issues and would prefer not to have a bruising battle over a SCOTUS pick and would simply pick one he knew would be accepted so as not to "waste" political capital. John McCain has proven to me over the years that he does not make political judgments based on core principles, he makes them based on his own analysis of political realities. This is why he's a "maverick" remember? On National Security I think he's superior to Obama, and I would give him a slight edge in actual practical knowledge about military issues even over Romney, but again, I don't trust the man's commitment to core principles, so I don't think he is nearly as firm in the trenches as you seem to think he is. I don't understand how you can define millions of individuals who have routinely broken U.S. laws in order to live here as "law abiding." They broke border laws, they routinely break identification laws, and there are many places where the majority of prison inmates are "undocumented aliens" instead of U.S. citizens. You think the ones who live here are a "known" commodity and the ones in line are not. I think exactly the opposite. The ones who live here illegally are "unknown" and the ones in line are the ones we have some shot at "knowing". Besides, I just rankle at the idea of rewarding their behavior with my money. I don't think we are going to agree on McCain. I have said that if he gets the nomination I'll support him and vote for him. But I do not like him. I think he is deceitful, disingenuous, unprincipled and is far to enamored of his own public image for my own taste. The man's, in short, a fraud.
Drax
I get a totally different read on McCain than do you. I think that he DOES stick to his "core principles," just that HIS core principles are different than yours. Has he EVER wavered in his pro-life stance? (Romney has). Has he EVER wavered in his commitment to national security? (What does Romney's "time tables" really mean anyway? After all, that phrase DID have meaning, didn't it?) And Romney is almost the military EQUAL of a person who led the largest squadron in the Navy in the Vietnam war? You gotta be kidding. He's a BUSINESSMAN turned politican, not a veteran who continued his service to the country by running for office. Has he EVER given any indication that "strict construction" doesn't mean EXACTLY that? He can only vote on the nominees that are presented to him, right? Where do you get that he doesn't mean exactly what the term is commonly accepted to mean? I'll give a bet that Romney signed into law more "pork barrel" legislation in Mass. than McCain had inserted into ANY legislation. There's a reason why sitting Senators don't get elected President; they are POLITICANS who represent a particular region....and are DUTY BOUND by their oath and their promise to their constituants that they will actually REPRESENT them...this being a "representative democracy/republic" that it is and all. The very act of doing so sometimes causes the politican to vote for/against things which he would rather not (on a personal level) but...aren't such things which violate the "core principles" of the man. I'd put how to deal with illegal aliens in that category. There are many different ways to do this. He thought that he could get something done with McCain/Kennedy, but couldn't. (I didn't see any OTHER bills moving through Congress...) On the other hand, I'd put the "surge" and backing it against the "voice of the people" (and common wisdom) in the category of a "core principle." He backed it, fought for it when it was wildly and widely unpopular. I think he is a man of HIGH principle. I don't AGREE with some of his thinking, but I'd never confuse him with being a liberal or someone of base values (as Clinton, for example). As to the "illegal aliens" breaking the law... To my knowledge, it isn't "illegal" to be an undocumented alien. If you're caught, you're not JAILED, you're DEPORTED. Certainly, there are regulations which they violate, some laws which they break (paying Social Security, income tax, etc.) in order to stay here, but, does this make them "bad people" or "criminals?" An essential part of the criminal act has always been the "mens rea" or the "evil mind," i.e., the knowledge of the fact that you're doing a bad thing and doing it anyway, usually for base motivation. Here, that isn't the case, is it? The motivation is the OPPOSITE of "base," and the mind is the OPPOSITE of being "evil." The person is here to make a better life for him and his family and he does it without robbing or stealing...but by WORKING. Again, what are those guys "standing in line" going to do and why are they "in line?" Aren't those kind of people the kinds we WANT here? And, given the choice of expending BILLIONS finding them, processing them, and deporting them...what is wrong (from a RATIONAL and PRACTICAL perspective rather than a "principled" or "moral", i.e., "it's wrong," or "it's unfair" perspective) with allowing them to stay so long as they "get clean?" (Most quotation marks in my life...sigh)
CosmicConservative
I don't think either of us is going to convince the other on this. Just a few points. Having a military background is not required, and is not even necessarily good training for the job of "Commander in Chief." Setting policy is a civilian duty, not a military one, that's the way our government is set up. The President does not arrange commando raids, he sets policy. In that role I absolutely believe Romney is the equal of McCain. In fact I believe I am the equal of McCain in that role. Immigration is a complex issue to be sure. And it is a bigger issue than just our own country's impact. Nobody ever addresses the fundamental question of what "our" immigration problem does to Mexico. But I am firmly convinced that Mexico has stayed a third-world nation in large part because its own government, with OUR support, has encouraged their best and brightest citizens to suck at the U.S. teat instead of fixing their own internal problems. It is as much for the good of Mexico as for the good of the U.S. that I think immigration needs to be controlled. There is very little incentive for Mexican citizens to fix their own problems if it is so easy to simply run across the border to get away from them. I don't like McCain. I've never liked him. I not only don't think he is a conservative, I believe he has deep rooted animosity for true conservatism. I don't appreciate him calling me a racist xenophobe because I believe that Mexican citizens should be staying in their own country fixing their own problems instead of living here and draining our own social safety nets. When someone insults the intelligence or motives of those they do not agree with, I think that says a whole lot about their character, and I listen to what they say.
Drax
I guess one can choose to be included in that remark if one is so inclined. I choose to believe that McCain was talking about actual "racist xenophobe(s)" when he made the remark. But, I don't have any deep seated hatred for McCain, so I have no baggage there to direct my thoughts on other matters. I really don't know where you get that he doesn't like conservatives. I guess that means that he doesn't like "70%" of himself as he is CLEARLY "conservative" on MOST issues....
CosmicConservative
He lumped anyone who opposed his shamnesty plan as a racist or xenophobe or both. Since I oppose it, I have to assume he meant me.