Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comedy musings

By CosmicConservative
I think I've probably posted on this subject before. I find myself thinking about comedy on occasion, particularly after I've watched comics perform. For the past few days I have found it difficult to do things that take much concentration, and one thing that takes very little concentration is sitting in front of the boob tube and flipping through channels. Which is not something I do much when I am feeling well, I pretty much consider that to be about the biggest waste of time I could imagine, outside of surfing the web, which I do for hours at a time.... Well today I watched about two hours of comedy routines on some cable comedy show (while doing laundry, thus the laundry post down below). And I saw three different comics, not one of whom whose name I recall. But they were very different comic styles. I am a poor comedian audience. I don't tend to laugh at the jokes. I "get" the jokes just fine, and I am amused by them, but I don't remember laughing out loud at a comedian's routine since listening to Bill Cosby as a kid. Instead I find myself analyzing the jokes. Not just the words, but also the setup and the timing. And there are so many things that are common that I find myself anticipating things, which may be why I appreciate the humor, but don't laugh so much. Many comics try to make you think that they are making it up as they go along. I think this is because it makes the audience think that the comic is quick-witted and naturally funny. But it rarely convinces me. Especially when the "off-the-cuff" stuff at the beginning of a routine somehow finds itself revisited at just the right moment in the obviously pre-written routines. This is particularly obvious when the comic is trying to add audience banter to their act. One of the comics I saw today was particularly interesting to me because he was either consciously or unconsciously telegraphing his own comedy analysis during his routine. He was one of those "edgy" comics who seemed to take great pride in telling jokes that most of the audience groaned at, but a few in the audience found rib-hurting funny. He clearly enjoyed when his jokes puzzled the "average joe" in the audience, but nailed a particular type of humor appreciation. As an example was a short routine on drugs. He started off with the "setup" part of the routine, which involved convincing the audience that he was a "good guy" who might joke about marijuana, but would never smoke the stuff himself. The routine went something like this: "And what about smoking pot? I mean who does that anymore? I guess if you want to spend your life in the basement of your parents house, that's your decision, but I have an actual life and things to do!" That's the setup, the purpose of which is to get the audience to believe that the comic is a funny guy, but is basically a responsible adult who has a socially appropriate attitude about drug use. Which of course is only to set up the first punch line, which was his next line: "I mean grow up! Forget that pot, cocaine is what you need if you want to actually get things done!" And that's the punch line that most comics would end with and move on to their next bit. But this guy wasn't done yet. He had hooked the audience and delivered the shock line that triggered the reflexive laugh that most comics would consider a job well done. But he treated that as another setup for his next line: "I mean, that is if you aren't man enough to handle crystal meth." This actually stunned most of the audience, but not everyone. There was maybe a tenth of the audience that howled at this line, and he nailed them, pointing them out physically and saying: "Yeah, you know what I mean! These guys," here he waved his arm around the general audience, "they don't get it, but you do!" With that he put on a maniacal grin and looked around the audience, most of whom did not know now if they should laugh or be offended. Then he smacked his forehead with his hand and said "Yep, I went too far with that one, didn't I? Well, some of you get it, and the rest of you, well, just forget I ever went there." And then he went on to his next routine, which was similar in its weird focus. And the thing is, I think I do know what he was doing. And why. He was looking for the boundaries, and he had found them. I expect he'll refine that routine to get a few more laughs from the general audience before he hits that odd target in his next routine. But he'll still push the envelope. That guy, I think, will become a better comic as time goes on. He's developing and refining his routine while onstage. And he's taking huge risks. And he's doing it with the complete intention of using each audience to make him better. I liked him, even his weird stuff. But maybe I'm unique in that regard, maybe he's too edgy for most audiences and will fade away from the scene. I wish I could remember his name. But that's how I watch comedians. I watch THEM perform, and try to figure out what they are doing. Which probably just makes me a weirdo myself.

Comments (11)

Dadman
I like this guy, Brian Regan. He makes me laugh every time without being a foul-mouthed cretin. I thought you might appreciate the subject of his comedy in this clip. Check out some of his other clips on YouTube if you've got a hankering for a chuckle...
CosmicConservative
I did see him before, but he wasn't one of the ones today. I like him too. He's naturally funny and has a real good delivery. I particularly like his facial control and his vocalizations. But there is something just a bit over-controlled about his comedy. He needs to be a bit more extemporaneous to really get to the next level.
Dadman
Comedy should be enjoyed, not analyzed. Brian is a very successful, popular comic who is undoubtedly making a good living at his craft. He's not in the same comedy stratosphere as a Seinfeld, but in my view he should be...
CosmicConservative
If he could do his comedy without appearing to be watching it himself as he does it, he'd reach that next level. As you have pointed out before, my inability to not analyze things is a major problem in my appreciation of life. And comedy is no exception.
Dadman
I don't believe it is his stand-up delivery that has held Brian Regan back from a lucrative TV deal, or whatever the Holy Grail of comedy may be; I just don't think he's gotten the right breaks. Success in show business is as much about luck and serendipity as it is about talent. This guy's comedy act, in my view, is much funnier than Seinfeld's...
CosmicConservative
I know that I am as naturally unfunny as a fever blister, but I still think I can see why Seinfeld went big and Brian hasn't yet. And part of it is no doubt serendipity and circumstance. But when I watch Brian, the impression I get is that he is highly pleased with his own act. His facial expressions and body language come across to me after just about every joke as "see how funny I am?" It's a subtle thing, but it is just enough that it keeps me from "connecting" with him. It's a "fourth wall" kind of thing. I know he's funny, he knows he's funny, but I don't like the hint I get that he's laughing at his own jokes harder than I am. Most comics do the opposite. Their stage persona is self-deprecating. They allow the audience to get the joke, but they pretend that the joke is on them and that they don't even get it. That allows the audience to feel superior to the comic, where Brian seems to feel superior to the audience. I know you'll disagree, but that's just the flavor I get. And as I said, it's subtle, but I think the audience, and more importantly, the talent scouts, pick up on it.
Andy
Comedians are just like musicians in many ways. "Breaks" do make a difference. I have seen "other-worldly-talented" musicians and comedians that never hit the big-time. Conversely, some of the big time performers are "iffy" at best. I assume that they got a "break" somewhere along the way. I watched this Regan guy, and he is funny. But he's not any funnier than another gazillion guys out there in comedy clubs perfecting their craft. I do like the fact that he's not throwing around F-bombs, and S-this S-that, etc. Comedy is a talent, an art, but also a "craft," just like performing music, motivational speaking, preaching, or anything else. Cosmic is right about one thing though (at least for me). The comedians that I enjoy the most are the ones that get the audience to "laugh at them" not "laugh with them." A lot of guys have done well making audiences laugh at other people, or people groups, etc. But my favorite comedians get the audience laughing at them. To each his own I guess. Good food for thought though. I had not really thought why I like (or dislike) particular comedians.
Dadman
I like Brian Regan's attitude and swagger. It's a noticeable part of his act that I feel adds to the humor. He is also one of those rare (rare for our times) comedians that I can enjoy with my family. But, to each his own...
CosmicConservative
I said I liked him. I think what you see as "swagger" comes across to me as "smugness" and if other people have a similar reaction to mine (especially talent scouts) that might be holding him back. But that's just my opinion. And I do like that he is not foul-mouthed. Most of the comics I watched yesterday were pretty foul-mouthed.
Andy
Dadman: I really do appreciate the fact that Regan is "G" rated. Most of the gazillions of comedians out there are F-this, and F-that, etc. But there are a bunch of great comedians that never go there (and don't care to). Those are the guys (and girls) that find "success" in the approval of the audience. The thickness of their wallet is less important to them than the "love" that they get back from the crowd (be it 50,000 or 50). Those are my favorites. I've got to admit (with shame) that I laugh like a hyena sometimes at comedians that I can't let my youngest son watch. Shame on me! But I can console myself in the truth that my favorite comedians of all time are Andy Griffith, Archie Campbell, Wendy Bagwell, Mark Lowrey, Jerry Clower, Jim Varney, and Little Jimmy Dickens. They are all "Ultra-G rated." Man, am I boring, or what?