Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Mythology reprise

By CosmicConservative
So I once posted about how I believed that the mythological depiction of "trolls" were almost certainly the remnants of oral histories of human/neanderthal contact when both were viable species. I still get a surprising number of hits on that post so it seems to be something people search on from time to time. Along the same vein, I have always believed that tales of dragons are just as certainly due to early human societies encountering fossilized remains of dinosaur bones. It is highly likely that an ancient naturalist who discovered the bones of, say, an Allosaurus or a Tyrannosaurus together with the bones of a stegasaurus or a pteradactyl would be able to reconstruct a dragon, or a chimera (three headed creature) or a griffon or any other of a range of mythological beasts from the odd bones. We know that ancients did find dinosaur bones from time to time, and that they valued them because we find them among holy relics in many ancient temples. It is also quite common for the bones of many different dinosaur species to be found together because of a large kill, usually from an ancient flood, where the bones of many dinosaurs are intermingled. Because of a lack of the context of the immense periods of time involved in evolution and fossilization, it is no surprise that such discoveries would lead ancient folk to believe that the bones were of some currently viable animal. It would not be common for such cultures to assume that the bones were of long-dead beasts. When dinosaur bones were "discovered" and the science of paleontology was christened two centuries or so ago, it was considered a coincidence that many dinosaur reconstructions bore a remarkable resemblance to mythological beasts, particularly dragons. I don't think it is coincidence at all. Both myth and science were formed of the same bones, by human beings who understood how bones connect together, at least well enough to recreate a long, serpentine neck topped with a fearsome skull bearing two-foot long teeth. When put into the proper context it is clear that early myths were much more accurate in their reconstruction of beasts from bones than they were fanciful. In fact they did a pretty good job of it considering their general level of sophistication and lack of historical scientific context. To me this sort of thing is self-evident. Early humans were just as smart as we are, and they used their brains just as effectively. What we have that they didn't have is a historic scientific context. Otherwise we would probably think the same thing in discovering a pile of dinosaur bones today.

Comments (1)

Ed Minchau
I have long thought that there must be something to the dragon myth, seeing as how it is a myth that is cross-cultural worldwide. There are dragon myths from China, medieval (and earlier) scandinavia and England, there are the Thunderbird myths in North American native folklore, and the Queztlcoatl myth in central America and northern South America. It's pretty easy to see how the bones of pterodactyl, tyrannosaurs, triceratops, brontosaurus, and other creatures would have required some explanation to ancient people, and that the dragon myths would have naturally arisen from such discoveries.