Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Dr. Phil-good

By CosmicConservative
drphil.jpg I have never liked "Dr. Phil." Just as a general principal I find myself severely distrustful of any media figure who goes by "Dr." and ANY first name. I've never been an Oprah watcher (somehow I keep finding myself at work while that is on) and so can't really talk about what he does on her show, or on his own show now, but I have to admit, I would wash my hands pretty thoroughly if I ever had a need to shake hands with him. He comes across to me as the prototypical snake oil salesman. He makes my skin crawl when I see clips of him "performing." I don't see much difference between him and that John Edward dude who claims to be able to speak with dead people. Both, in my opinion, make a living off of publicly exploiting the pain and suffering of others. Now he is in trouble for rushing to Britney Spears' hospital room to provide a little unwanted therapy (and grab a headline or two at the same time). Personally I think they should throw the book at him.
PROBE OF DR. PHIL-BRITNEY CASE January 18, 2008 -- DR. Phil, who is reportedly under investigation by the California Board of Psychology for practicing without a license in Britney Spears' latest flipout, may be off the hook. California authorities are compelled to investigate any time a complaint is filed. But McGraw's visit to Spears in the hospital earlier this month has turned into a huge embarassment for the TV shrink.

Comments (5)

Drax
I don't get the whole thing. He doesn't have a license to practice (anywhere) yet practices on television and NOW he gets into trouble? I don't get it, frankly.
CosmicConservative
I don't get that either. I suppose he is allowed to "perform" on TV, as opposed to "practice psychiatry". So his onscreen actions aren't really "practicing." Of course then you have to ask, "then why the heck are people watching?" Certainly THEY think he's practicing.
Andy
Cosmic: Gonna defend Phil for a minute. He is a Dr. Wik says: McGraw transferred to Midwestern State University in Wichita Falls, Texas, where he graduated in 1975 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in psychology. He went on to earn a Master's degree in experimental psychology in 1976, and a Ph.D in clinical psychology in 1979 at the University of North Texas[6], where his dissertation was titled "Rheumatoid Arthritis: A Psychological Intervention." Now, I have watched Phil before and really haven't seen him give what I would call bad advice to people. He may have, but then I don't watch his show very often so I don't know. How different is he from the twins Abigail Van Buren and Ann Landers? People have always reached out to "celebrities" for help with their struggles. McGraw is only different because people can actually "be seen" by millions while pouring out their crap to him. How different is he from a preacher on television preaching about marriage, family, relationships, etc.? How different is he from political pundits on television? They influence thought and activity by spouting opinions. They are listened to because of their experience...not their sheepskin. Don't get me wrong. When I need some advice I go to someone that I trust...privately. I try to pick out someone that has been in my spot and can give personal experience insight. I don't think Phil is a snake-oil salesman. A snake-oil salesman knows that his product is crap, but sells it anyway. I think that Phil is a guy that has made the most of a once in a lifetime opportunity...and believes that what he's selling is a real cure. Could be wrong...but I just don't think he's a huckster (pun intended).
Drax
My understanding is that Dr. Phil was accused of improper behavior in his practice in Texas, and never did what the disciplinary board required in order to maintain his license. I further understand that he does not have a license ANYWHERE to practice psychology or any type of medicine. So, if he's not practicing psychology, what value the "help" he is supposedly providing...what OTHER "help" is he supposedly providing than psychological "help?"
Andy
Drax: I know what you're saying. All I'm saying is that anyone can give advice. Heck, I'm not psychologist, but I can give advice to people. That doesn't mean I'm practicing psychology. As far as I know he doesn't charge these people anything, so that's not really "practicing" in a sense. Now, I know he charged Oprah for his work on her case, but I think that was "jury consultant" work, not psychological counseling. I'm not sure about that, but I think that's how he got hooked up with The O. Like I said, I don't watch the guy often, but do pick up a snippet or two. Maybe I'm a little prejudiced toward the guy because every time I have heard him I think "yep, that's what I'd tell them."