Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Google who?

By CosmicConservative
So I use google a lot. And I am a fairly advanced google user. I know how to use Google's search function so that I can cut through a lot of the "23,000,000 results for _________" nonsense. For example, if I am looking for an auto repair store to fix a transmission I don't just type in "auto repair" I type in "Auto transmission repair subaru city state zip Visa ...." and any other terms I think would be relevant. I still might get 23,000,000 results, but the first results are usually much more relevant. Or, that is, they used to be. These days when I do that I get page after page of "Switchboard.com" or "YellowPages.com" or "CitySearch.com" results where some other online yellowpages has no doubt paid Google a lot of money for their results to come up based on a wide range of "relevent" terms. The problem with this is that when I click on one of those links, I don't go to the website of a business that does what I need, or even a listing for a business that does what I need, what I get is a web page that has a list of results that the online yellow pages company feels will provide THEIR ADVERTISERS with as many clicks as possible. So when I type in "Subaru" their logic may say "foreign car" and the first ten results may be "Mercedes" or "BMW", meaning I need to then search through THEIR results looking for a Subaru repair shop. Now I used to work for an online yellow pages company and I actually was involved in some of the software development that allowed for this "partnership" between google and online yellow pages companies, so in a sense this is karmic revenge. But as a standard consumer am I the only one who is getting more and more irritated by this? What's the point of doing a Google search if the results I get are just links to other online search engines that are not interested in what I need, but are more interested in their advertisers' needs? Why do I go to Google at all if the result of my search is three pages of non-Google search results? I have been googling since the very first days that Google challenged Yahoo!. But I have to tell you, I am starting to look at other search engines precisely because I am tired of Google seeing me not as a person searching for relevant content online, but instead as a commodity that can be resold through clicks to other online listing companies. In a sense to me it feels that Google has lost what made Google, Google. If I wanted to search an online yellow pages, I wouldn't have gone to Google in the first place. And to have my attention directed to whatever online yellow pages did the best job of placing their search page results in the google crawler is not what I want from Google. Am I the only one who feels this way? Does anyone else get frustrated when they do Google searches only to be directed to "DexKnows.com" or "Switchboard.com" or "CitySearch.com" and have to do their search all over again in a new search engine?

Comments (7)

Andy
I've noticed it. Well, they do have to make money. Hey, you're a smart guy. How about "Gaggle.com" ? Fire it up Pal. I don't really know which search provider is the best to cut through this kind of thing. I normally use Google, because Yahoo didn't seem like it was giving me relevant results on the terms...but it seems to me that Google is heavily top-loaded on the click-through pages (if that's the right term...probably not, but I think you know what I mean).
CosmicConservative
I am thinking about what it would take to write a crawler that restricted its results to end nodes on the web instead of intermediate pages that are simply waypoints where you have to continue to search. It shouldn't be too hard to do that, either through heuristics which recognize a page that is an intermediate page, or through identifying pages by IP or domain. Anything with the domain of "switchboard.com" or "yellowpages.com" or any of the other online listing services could easily be excluded from a results list. The problem is that in order to crawl the web, process all the search results, scrub the intermediate pages and store the results for immediate retrieval requires a huge investment in computers, network and disk storage. I'm talking tens of millions of dollars worth just to be in the game. Google has so much hardware that they literally are exploring powering their data centers with their own power systems. To play the search engine game you have to have lots and lots of money...
Andy
Uh...Amen Cosmic...didn't understand anything much there, but you wrote it so convincingly! By the way...if your example of searching for transmission repair is an actual need in your life right now...I just got the transmission rebuilt in my Mercury Sable. Just a friendly suggestion...try to find out if it's not too late to take back that big screen TV, or the best deal you can get on a 2nd mortgage. :)
CosmicConservative
Heh... I know what you mean Andy. A bit more than a year ago we spent a ton of money on a new transmission for our 2000 Subaru Legacy. The car had been a wonderful car other than the transmission slippage that was getting worse and worse. With our daughter now driving we knew that we were going to be putting a lot more stress on the car, so we decided to bite the bullet and get the transmission replaced. The car was worth about $5,000 or $6,000. The transmission replacement cost us well over $2,000. Six months later the engine threw a rod and the car was essentially a total loss... Sigh.. Now our newly acquired used 1998 Subaru is starting to have transmission slippage problems... Yes, we actually had to buy an older car than the one we were replacing, that should tell you something. However, we are assured by all the auto experts that the older model Subarus are built with twice the engine life expectancy of the 1999 model year and newer. So hopefully we won't throw a rod in that car anytime soon. Knock on wood....
Andy
2 grand for a transmission? I want the name of your transmission guy. When ours went out in the Sable and found out how much it was going to be ($3,400...I checked it out, and that was the best deal in town), I told the guy to forget it. Then that weekend we went car shopping, and decided to fix the Sable...if you know what I mean. ;)
CosmicConservative
I think the transmission we had installed was a rebuilt one. When the engine blew up we tried to locate a rebuilt engine to install because, as I said, other than the engine and transmission, it was a great car. ;) But it turns out that the engine in a Subaru legacy is the perfect size to fit in a new Volkswagon body and provides about twice the horsepower so people snap up old Subaru legacy engines and super-charge their Beetles. Everywhere we checked had months-long waiting lists for an engine, and eventually we just gave up and had it towed to a car dealer who gave us $1,000 credit on our "new" car.
Andy
Been there...got the T-shirt...know exactly what you're saying...sigh, sigh, sigh