Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Cheesecake and webcomics...

By CosmicConservative
I've been engaged in a "debate" on the Dean's World website about a webcomic called "Day By Day" written by Chris Muir. Basically the whole thing started when one of Dean's posters posted a thread asking Dean's readers to contribute to the cartoon during a fund drive. This led to people like me voicing our opinion of the cartoon since the original poster essentially implied that you have to contribute to Day By Day because it's about the only politically oriented cartoon that does not routinely engage in Bush Derangement Syndrome. Yeah, but the cartoon is little more than a daily dose of cheesecake and titillation, so I said that I would not donate to a cartoon whose idea of a "topical subject" is to draw every female in the strip as thin, large-breasted, nearly naked and obsessed with sex. This led to some negative comments about me, since one of my comments was that Day By Day was hardly promoting any sort of family values so I was not inclined to support it. That comment may well have been read by Chris Muir because his next comic showed his main female character in skimpy thong panties with money stuffed into them and her husband bemoaning the fact that they would now lose the "family values" market. Now I know we've goofed around once or twice with "cheesecake" posts on Cosmic Conservative, such as the cheerleader photos and the Jessica Alba and Megan Fox photos, but I would not consider anything we've put on Cosmic Conservative to be unsafe for work. Certainly it is no worse than the ads I've seen on the front page of CNN.com or FoxNews.com. But I'd like to get your opinion on the strip. I'm not going to post examples of the strips that lead me to call its drawings "utterly gratuitous" if you go through enough of the strips (especially in the last week or so) you should see what I mean. Now I'm not prudish, and if the jokes were funnier I might support Day By Day anyway, but based on my opinion of the lameness of the strip coupled with the gratuitous titillation, I have no desire to support the strip as it stands. My point in the discussion was that if Chris spent as much time working on a punchline as he spent figuring out new and clever ways to draw his women as sexpot sirens, I would probably like the strip a lot more. What do you all think?

Comments (9)

mtnlurker
I used to have the strip on my homepage at work. I had to take it off because it was too racy for work. The strip is good about not getting into BDS but I have to agree with you that it is not written well enough to overcome the way he draws it.
Boyd
I can't help myself. I'm such a perv that I even enjoy cartoon titillation. Speaking of which, have you ever seen the movie Heavy Metal? Back in the day, it defined the term "cartoon titillation."
CosmicConservative
I watched Heavy Metal when it came out on the big screen. I thought parts of it were incredibly inventive and some of the music was great, but other parts were lame and derivative. It's been so long I don't remember which parts were which. I should probably rent it. Or buy it I guess, you can almost buy bargain-bin DVDs cheaper than you can rent them these days...
Ed Minchau
I like Day By Day, but took it off of my blog when I realized that I could get hundreds of comics on the darkgate comic slurper ( http://darkgate.net/comic/ ), and therefore don't have to slow down page loads on my blog. So, I now read DBD along with Hagar and the rest over at darkgate. And you know, there isn't a damn thing wrong with hot cartoon chicks. Mmmmm, Blondie.
CosmicConservative
I'm not suggesting that there is anything wrong with hot cartoon chicks. But I don't recall the last time I saw Blondie topless, with dollar bills barely covering her "important" regions, and more dollar bills stuffed into her thong, rolling around on a bed suggestively. I'm pretty sure I would remember such a scene. It isn't the "hotness" that I find gratuitous, it's the rampant overt sexuality that I frankly find to be consistent only with adolescent male fantasies about women. There's enough free softcore porn out there, I don't need to pay Chris Muir to draw it for me. I'd prefer that he write funny strips, his drawings, no matter how sexy, can't compete with the other free titillation that is all over the internet, so I wish he'd put his talents into making a funny 'toon. That's my point.
CosmicConservative
For what it's worth, just in the interest of full and complete disclosure, one of the things I said on Dean's World is that I have a folder in my Firefox "favorites" list for webcomics, and "Day By Day" is not in it. BUT "Yet Another Fantasy Gamer Comic" is in that list, and that strip is overflowing with rampant sexuality, including full nudity on a regular basis. The reason I support that strip is not because of the nudity, I support it because it's well written and funny. Also because I like the graphic style of the strip. I don't really care that much for Chris Muir's line art and flat color rendering. "Day By Day"'s artistic style reminds me of nothing so much as graphic illustrations in a style magazine. I would almost describe it as sterile.
Andy
Cosmic: Confession of ignorance. I never really looked at this guys' cartoons, or website until now. My thought is... Donate to it? He should pay for the traffic. Hey, I'm not a prude either. One of the reasons I read comic books as a kid was for the fact that artists can fabricate fake women with fake...well...parts. There are plenty of sites out there that aren't infected with BDS. If they're good enough they sure don't need contributions.
Boyd
It's all a matter of preferences. As an example, I don't think much of Morris's drawings in YAFGC. But different folks like different stuff.
pace
I checked out the last five or so, and just didn't find them very entertaining. But then, I'm not a big comic strip guy so...