Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Hillary on the run...

By CosmicConservative
It is interesting to read the national media (especially CNN) and see the reporters and editors expressing shock at the "stunning reversal of fortune" of Hillary Clinton. Actually "funny" is probably a better word than "interesting." It is especially amusing to watch CNN desperately try to spin things around to make Hillary look like a victim. The most common take is that Hillary is a victim of her own campaign managers, and even Bill is getting a few swipes taken at him in their desperate attempt to revive Hillary's flagging electoral ambitions. It is not as if people (like me) have not been pointing out how fragile Hillary's hold on the "frontrunner" position has been for months. When Obama started making noise in the early campaign I said that Hillary's campaign has to be very concerned about the portions of the mainstream media who were gilding Obama's lily, while allowing Hillary's image to tarnish. Over the course of the past few months there has been a steady defection of news writers and editors from the old Clinton-MSM cabal. Now Obama has become the "media darling" of the campaign, and without the willing compliance of the mainstream media, Hillary is not able to carry her own water in this campaign. I believe that a lot of Democrats were watching Obama while outwardly supporting Hillary. When pollsters called them and asked who they would support, they may have answered "Hillary" but they were holding their nose while doing so and secretly thinking "unless Obama can actually become a viable candidate." Now that Obama has become the statistical front-runner, more and more Democrats are going to be looking at Hillary, then at Obama, and they are going to abandon the tired old bus for the shiny new one. In New Hampshire that means that Hillary may be looking at a sound beating. Already after only Iowa her campaign appears in disarray while the "brain trust" of her campaign desperately seeks to re-invent Hillary for the fourth or fifth time in the past year. Hillary's big problem, as I see it, is that she made a very serious strategic error, and followed that up with a series of tactical ones. The strategic error was her insistence that she be seen as the candidate "with experience". Let's forget for a moment that a rational analysis of her actual experience doesn't give her an edge over her opponents, let's assume that this message resonated with the Democratic base. The reason this was a huge strategic error is because when asked what they want from a candidate, the leading answer is "change" not "status quo." And to run as the candidate with "experience" means you are running as the "status quo." So this essentially put Barack Obama in a perfect position to assume the mantle of the "change agent" candidate, which is what most voters are looking for. As the problem started to become apparent to Hillary's campaign, I believe they misread the signals and attempted tactically to solve the wrong problem. Because a significant challenge arose questioning Hillary's "experience" credentials, she spent a great deal of time and effort trying to reinforce those claims, even sending Bill Clinton out to claim (disingenuously, I think) that Hillary had some part to play in the few successes of his eight years as President. This obviously fell on deaf ears for those who never thought Hillary's claims of experience were valid in the first place, but worse for Hillary, it actually drove more people into the "change" camp because they didn't want a repeat of the Clinton years of "triangulation" and personal destruction. The straw that I think broke the camel's back, and which led directly to her defeat in Iowa, was when her campaign began sending Hillary out with the message "I have been the target of evil Republicans for sixteen years, and I'm still alive!" I don't know what she thought that was telling voters, but what I think it told voters is one of the following: 1. "I live in the past, hold grudges and am a lightning rod for criticism and attacks from half of the nation, so vote for me and we can continue to have a divided electorate and the politics of personal destruction!" 2. "I am a delusional, paranoid fruitcake, so vote for me." When I saw Hillary making those statements, repeatedly and forcefully, I couldn't help think that she was seriously damaging her own candidacy. Now she has to find some way to wrest the "change agent" label from Obama, and after eight months of "I'm the candidate who fights with Republicans 24-7!!" I don't think she's going to be able to pull it off. If she does, I will be very surprised. If I could be a fly on the wall of the top three Democrat campaigns, I would imagine the following to be happening: 1. Hillary's campaign is in total disarray, with people starting to dust off their resumes because SOMEONE is going to pay for the Iowa debacle, and Hillary can't fire her husband. 2. Edwards is seeing Hillary's problems as a way to energize his own campaign, so he is going to be going all out in South Carolina to try to upset the Obama express. I predict you'll start seeing less Edwards/Clinton dust-ups and more Edwards/Obama ones. 3. Obama's team should be working on how to begin distancing themselves from the dirty tricks level of politics and taking the high road as much as possible. Front-runners have the opportunity to make substantive policy statements and begin to line up alliances for a future administration. To be seen publicly doing that sends a message of confidence and political capability. With Hillary falling back in the race, Obama's team has to be reconfiguring their message to be one of "here is what an Obama administration means" instead of "here is why we are better than Hillary." Tomorrow is going to be very interesting. If today's polls hold up and Hillary ends up with a double-digit defeat, and is beaten again by Edwards, it is going to be very difficult for her to stay in the race through Super Tuesday.

Comments (6)

CosmicConservative
I don't buy that. Oprah may have had some incremental effect, but Obama's personality cult was what drove Oprah to him, he didn't go to her. Obama is a seriously charismatic figure. He did not need Oprah's help in this, Hillary is giving him all the help he needs.
pace
I agree with pretty much everything you've said, Cosmic. I was essentially in the Edwards camp, with a sense of inevitability that I'd end up 'holding my nose and supporting Hillary' because Obama would be steamrolled by the Clinton juggernaut and Edwards doesn't look to be electable on the national level right now. Things look a little different now though, huh? Edwards has struggled, predictably, and has let some desperation manifest as the 'angry populist' candidate. Whereas that Obama guy seems to have the cool head and has conducted himself rather impeccably thus far. Whether or not you agree with his politics (and there are areas where I strongly disagree), I think it's hard to deny that he inspires many people. Hillary never had that.
CosmicConservative
I have been critical of both Hillary and Obama's experience level, but in truth I am not seriously concerned about that. I think experience is greatly over-rated in a presidential candidate anyway because there really is no way to prepare for the job. The closest thing is probably to be governor of California, Texas or New York, but even that is far short of the responsibility of a President. What really matters in terms of a candidate's ability to BE an effective President is the character and ability of the person in the job. And I have to grudgingly admit that in the past six months my estimation of Barack Obama's character and ability has steadily increased, and is still increasing. At this moment in time if I were a liberal Democrat and were confronted with the options of a Hillary, Edwards or Obama nomination, with the fairly good chance that whoever wins the nomination will go on to become President, I would probably be thinking right now that Obama may well be the most effective of the three in that role. Now of course that is precisely why I will vote against Obama, because the last thing I want to see is such a socialist, pacifist become an effective President. But that's because I'm a conservative Republican, not a liberal Democrat. Because of this I am more and more beginning to fear an Obama nomination because he seems at this moment to be the most accomplished of the Democrat's campaigners. If he can continue for the next ten months doing what he has done for the last eleven months, he is going to be a formidible candidate this coming November. Obama is exciting. He makes people WANT to vote FOR him. All of the other candidates are hoping that they will gain votes because people will be voting AGAINST their opponents. That's a powerful tide to swim against if you are a Mitt Romney or a John McCain.
Drax
He was charismatic before Oprah, but had almost no support of any significance. Oprah's endorsement translates into lots of votes (and it doesn't take THAT many to go from a win to a loss....)
CosmicConservative
Well, I guess the line between winning and losing was reinforced in New Hampshire. Now we'll see the Hillary that I personally find very unpleasant, the smug, gloating Hillary. Still, if we have to have a Democrat, I'd rather it be Hillary than Obama, so I have to be pleased with the New Hampshire results.