Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Another reason Huckabee won...

By Dadman
I've been saying, much to the annoyance of some who visit this blog, that Romney is being negatively impacted by an ambient anti-Mormon bias that exists in our culture. I believe such a bias is even more pronounced within evangelical ranks, who just happened to comprise the majority of Republican Iowa caucus participants. But, of course, Huckabee won Iowa for other reasons, legitimate reasons. Peggy Noonan says it well...
OPINIONJOURNAL.COM - Out With the Old, In With the New What we have learned about Mr. Huckabee the past few months is that he's an ace entertainer with a warm, witty and compelling persona. He won with no money and little formal organization, with an evangelical network, with a folksy manner, and with the best guileless pose in modern politics. From the mail I have received the past month after criticizing him in this space, I would say his great power, the thing really pushing his supporters, is that they believe that what ails America and threatens its continued existence is not economic collapse or jihad, it is our culture. They have been bruised and offended by the rigid, almost militant secularism and multiculturalism of the public schools; they reject those schools' squalor, in all senses of the word. They believe in God and family and America. They are populist: They don't admire billionaire CEOs, they admire husbands with two jobs who hold the family together for the sake of the kids; they don't need to see the triumph of supply-side thinking, they want to see that suffering woman down the street get the help she needs. They believe that Mr. Huckabee, the minister who speaks their language, shares, down to the bone, their anxieties, concerns and beliefs. They fear that the other Republican candidates are caught up in a million smaller issues--taxing, spending, the global economy, Sunnis and Shia--and missing the central issue: again, our culture. They are populists who vote Republican, and as I have read their letters, I have felt nothing but respect.
I can appreciate that...

Comments (17)

Andy
Dadman: I can appreciate what she is saying, too. But I'm not sure that Romney, or Thompson can't capture that same crowd pretty quickly. Huckabee is as affable, and personable as they come. I think the guy had any inherent stiffness surgically removed sometime in the past. But I just don't think the societal erosion, morals crowd (which I belong to) is going to en masse overlook his obviously liberal positions. I have said for months that Mike Huckabee would be the perfect Vice Presidential running mate. In fact, I think he got into the race actually running for VP. And his appeal to the conservative old-line democrats might just tip the scale for a Republican win (with a strong guy at the top of the ticket). When Huck loses in New Hampshire to Romney, I'm going to be back here proposing to you that people went out and voted against Huckabee because he's a Baptist...they didn't like him because of his religion. You'd better get your answer ready buddy. ;)
Andy
BTW Dadman: I wrote a piece on the blog this morning that relates to this...if you're interested.
Dadman
It may be true that some voters won't vote for Huckabee SIMPLY because he is a Baptist. I would call those people religious bigots.
Drax
Man...give it a rest. You agree with Noonan's analysis, yet continue to beat the bigot horse. They liked him...they really liked him. Imagine my great surprise that they liked a guy who, as Noonan says, shares their values "down to the core." Who woulda thunk?
Dadman
Noonan also said this...
But there are two problems. One is that while the presidency, as an office, can actually make real changes in the areas of economic and foreign policy, the federal government has a limited ability to change the culture of America. That is something conservatives used to know. Second, I'm sorry to say it is my sense that Mr. Huckabee is not so much leading a movement as riding a wave. One senses he brilliantly discerned and pursued an underserved part of the voting demographic, and went for it. Clever fellow. To me, the tipoff was "Don't Mormons believe that Jesus and the devil are brothers?"
I won't be giving it a rest...
Drax
Again. Why is it somehow "bad" for Huck to point out something which a tenent of Mormon faith? That is somehow bigotry?
Dadman
I am just amazed how consistently you guys miss my point. I have no issue with someone voting for Huckabee, or anyone else, because they think he shares their values. My issue is with those voters, and I think there are more than many realize, that will not vote for a Mormon simply because he is a Mormon. In my view that is religious intolerance and bigotry. Most evangelicals would agree, even those who refuse to vote for a damn Mormon under any circumstances, that Mormons share most, if not all, of their social values - strong families, purity, self-reliance, devotion, etc. So, the schism between Mormons and evangelicals appears to be mostly doctrinal. I would argue that is just not an appropriate consideration in a political campaign. Many evangelicals would also tell you a vote for a Mormon is a tacit endorsement of Mormonism itself. Again, a largely theological consideration and one I feel is inappropriate in a presidential election. I know you'd like me to give it a rest, but I won't. I think it is fundamentally wrong for a large segment of the conservative/Republican constituency to blackball Romney simply because he is a Mormon. When I see it happening I am going to call it out. I'm sorry if it bothers you.
Dadman
Huckabee's statement was intended to inflame anti-Mormon bias and it's a statement that is franky inappropriate in a political race. What precisely does Romney's theology have to do with his ability to govern effectively? In addition, the statement, when fully explained and the necessary nuance added, is not so unreasonable as Cosmic has already pointed out in a previous post. You're a smart guy, Drax. I can't believe I have to explain any of this to you. It's almost as if you REFUSE to see my side of the argument, an argument most seem to grasp without too much effort. But, hey, I'm willing to keep explaining it for as long a necessary.
Drax
I agree that Huck played hardball when he made that remark, but, what the heck...he's just running for President of the most powerful country in the world and he thinks he's a better choice for the job than is Mitt. I also agree that he didn't accidently make the off-hand comment as, being a preacher, he knew how it would be perceived by many listeners. (Of course, being the gregarious person he is, it is "possible" that he was just making a joke...just highly unlikely that it was "just" a joke...) It was certainly a cheap shot. Much like Mitt's attack ads on Huck in Iowa where he didn't tell the "whole story" about the pardons and commutations of Huck which, when "fully explained" were not "so unreasonable" as the remarks about them would make them appear at first blush. It's hardball. And, under no circumstances will I concede that a person's religious beliefs should play no part in our determination whether or not they should hold office. There is (should not be) no greater influence on a person's actions than their religion IF they are actually true to the tenents of their religion. If they just pay "lip service" to their religion as do most politicians, then their religion should play little or no part in our evaluation of them (except, perhaps, a mild distaste for a person who says that they are one thing but behaves in a contrary fashion). Most people don't know much about the Mormon religion other than the ubiquituous ads we see on television or the people we see riding down the streets on their bicycles (and the ever so often news reports about some radical sect doing some radical thing). They, rightly so, have a fear of that unknown. JFK had to put up with this. Louis Brandeis had to put up with this. Mitt's the first on the national scene. We'll see how much of a factor his religion plays in the primaries. Right now, a helluva lot of people are voting FOR him ... and, he may yet take NH over McCain. This election cycle has quite a few firsts. Legitimate black and female contenders for the Democratic nominee (fairly certain one will win) and a legitimate Mormon contender for the Republican nomination. I wonder what would happen if Mitt won the Republican nomination and Obama won the Democratic...with all the bigots out there...would anyone vote? Nah. I think that Mitt would have the votes of most of...if not all of...the Republican Christian Evangelicals and Obama would have the votes of all the Southern red-neck democrats. But, you gotta make it through the primaries first.
Dadman
So, you're on record that the doctrinal specifics of one's faith are fair game in a political contest. I disagree, but, what the heck, at least I know where you're coming from now. I also don't see an equivalency in Huckabee dragging Mormon doctrine into a campaign and Mitt going after Huckabee on his political record. Maybe you do. The 'ever so often' news reports you sometimes hear about 'radical sects' have very little to do with the church to which Romney belongs. Although, I do concede that such sects are an unfortunate legacy of early Mormonism. My hope is that people will be properly informed, not ignorant and afraid. Other than that...nice post. You may prove to be right on most counts...
Drax
You said: "So, you’re on record that the doctrinal specifics of one’s faith are fair game in a political contest." This is a bit off from the tenor of my remarks. Let's say someone's a Baptist or a Catholic. Now, just about everyone in the U.S. is familiar with Baptists and doesn't really have any fear of them. They might think that their Sunday activities are a bit off kilter and weird, but not threatening in any fashion. Well, not since 1960 anyway. Back then, people actually were concerned that JFK would be "taking orders" from the Vatican. But, he was so charismatic that he dispelled these misgivings and it has never been an issue again. Huck is taking some heat for being a former preacher as well since there is a DIFFERENCE between being an ADHERENT to a religion and a TEACHER of that religion, or so it would seem as one would want a teacher to be more devout than a mere adherent in a perfect world. In Mitt's case, the majority of the U.S. is NOT familiar with Mormonism and when they are confronted with some of the things they believe (in a cursory manner as with Huck's remark) they do more than shake their heads and chuckle at the Catholics' constant kneeling, the Baptists' exuberant singing, or the Evangelicals' speaking in tounges...they are struck with the DIFFERENCES between what they are familiar with and what they are confronted with...differences which strike at the very core of their world-view. It'll be different the next time around. It always is. We "may" be young enough to see the first Christian Scientist or first Athiest have a legitimate shot at being President. Unless things change significantly, I don't think we'll see a Muslim. That'll be interesting.
CosmicConservative
Wow, I picked a bad time to be away from the blog it looks like. Dadman, I think I have consistently "gotten" the point you are making about bigotry playing a role in Romney's campaign, and that role being a bigger role than bigotry towards Huckabee or any other candidate. I agree with your analysis. However, let's wait for New Hampshire before we say that Romney is the major target of religious bigotry from voters. My suspicion is that New Hampshire voters are going to reverse the Iowa results and that they will do so because they distrust and do not share values with an evangelical Baptist minister. I have some other thoughts on the evangelicals in the Rupublican party and what the unintended consequences of their attitudes are going to be. I'll put that in a new post.
Dadman
I've only been talking about the Iowa results not events that may or may not transpire in upcoming primaries. I do not anticipate the evangelical vote will have quite the same negative impact on Romney in upcoming primaries.
CosmicConservative
My point is that the voters in New Hampshire are likely to be just as suspicious of Huckabee because of his evangelical roots as Iowa voters were of Romney because of his Mormonism. I don't think they will have the same negative reaction to Romney, Mormon or not, and that is primarily because they've been his neighbor for a while and know that he did not run the state based on Mormon religious commands from Utah. But, they won't be so sure about Huckabee.
Dadman
I agree with that. I've never claimed that religious intolerance only runs in the direction of Mormonism.
Dadman
Although, it is unlikely you will see any coordinated effort by any religious denominations to get out and vote for the guy other than Huckabee. That's apparently what happened to Romney in Iowa...