Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Post election ruminations...

By Dadman
The National Review has a nice wrap-up of the Iowa election results. I agree with their key conclusions that Romney has been significantly damaged and needs to beat McCain in New Hampshire to remain viable. McCain, surprisingly, seems to be in the best position right now with his recent resurgence in N.H. Huckabee is not likely to have similar success in upcoming primaries unless he begins to resonate with conservatives other than those on the religious right...
NATIONAL REVIEW ONLINE - Republicans after Iowa Mike Huckabee deserves congratulations this morning. We have been tough on him, and we retract not a word of our criticism. But he managed to score a big win with almost no money, no support from Republican bigwigs, and, until a few months ago, single-digit support in the polls. That he won is a testament to his sheer political talent: not only his much-discussed fluency as a speaker, but also his sense of the moment. The fact remains that those talents would not have brought him a plurality if not for his religion and the way he has run on it. Huckabee cleaned up among evangelicals and lost, badly, among everyone else. Evangelicals will not be 60 percent of the electorate in most states. If the governor wants to win the nomination, as opposed to becoming an evangelical kingmaker, he needs to broaden his appeal to other types of conservatives.
Stay tuned...

Comments (9)

Andy
Okay Dadman: Just some "think-piece" questions. You are a clear-thinking, honest conservative, and I am sure that you will answer these questions honestly (don't feel obliged to answer them publicly if you don't want to). These are straightforward questions with nothing implied, believe me. 1) Would you support Romney for President if he was not a Mormon? Looking over the field of Republican candidates...their history of positions...their record in government, etc., is Romney the proven conservative in the field, or a Johnny-come-lately to the movement? 2) If religious beliefs were switched...Romney the ex-Baptist preacher (with Mitts' record) vs. Huckabee the Mormon (with Mikes' record)...which would you support (if either). 3) Do you know any Mormon that is not supporting Romney (not the Harry Reid Democrat Mormons...conservative Mormons)? Now this question is just for my information. I am asking because I really don't know many Mormons personally. The reason I ask this is that I know a whole lot of conservative, right-wing "born again" Christians that are terrified at the idea of Huckabee winning the nomination. Some of the most hard-headed, conservative fundamentalist Christians are in Romney's camp. (Witness one Bob Jones: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,302516,00.html ) You wrote: "Huckabee is not likely to have similar success in upcoming primaries unless he begins to resonate with conservatives other than those on the religious right…" I could not agree more...and it ain't gonna happen...in fact, he is going to steadily lose support from the religious right. We're not stupid (well, not real stupid).
Dadman
Sure, I'll answer your questions... Romney would be my guy even if he were not a Mormon. I like his resume', his track record in executive positions, the fact he speaks French (just kidding). I think he has the best conservative credentials (with the possible exception of Thompson) on the Republican side. He is no more Johnny-come-lately than Reagan was... If the roles were reversed I would certainly have less affinity for Romney, but I believe I would still vote for him over Huckabee based on his record and resume'. I would not vote for Mormon Huckabee for the reasons you have cited just as I would never, ever vote for Mormon Reid. Political decisions should be based on political considerations, not theological ones. Believe it or not, I have not discussed politics with any of my Mormon pals yet. It may come as a shock to you, but there is a fair amount of political diversity among Mormon ranks. The LDS church, and/or individual Mormon wards do not, as a matter of official policy, endorse (or denounce) political candidates. In my view there is a stark contrast between the way Mormons approach political campaigns and the way many evangelicals do. You will not hear Mormon eccelesiastical leaders talking politics from the pulpit while in evangelical circles you will often hear pastors and preachers endorsing or denouncing specific political candidates. In Iowa, Huckabee pandered to his evangelical base and they returned the favor by formally endorsing his candidacy in their meetings, on their websites, and through their talk radio stations. It is very unlikely you will see Mitt Romney visiting Mormon wards in a bid to win votes even in states with large LDS populations. In fact, he would not be allowed to do so due to the church's policy of political neutrality. As a Romney supporter I am grateful for the evangelicals who have stepped up and endorsed his bid for President. Those who refuse to do so simply because Mitt is a Mormon, well, I will call them out for their religious bigotry. In my opinion it is a distinction without a difference to call it a 'soft' form of bigotry. It seems every time I use the word 'bigot' it ruffles some feathers. I'm not sure why. Bigotry, bias, intolerance, etc. in some form or another has been part of every American election. I think religious bigotry is working against Romney (so far) in this election cycle. We can debate it forever, but it won't make it any less true.
Andy
Dadman: Thanks for taking the time to answer. Interesting quote here...you wrote: "I think he has the best conservative credentials (with the possible exception of Thompson) on the Republican side." There is another guy with more conservative credentials than Mitt, or Fred (I ain't talking about Ron Paul). Duncan Hunter...He's the real deal...but is just about as viable as a snowball in hell. He's my number one choice, but not my number one viable candidate... I'm not surprised that there is broad political diversity among Mormons. I don't understand it, but I'm not surprised by it. When you look at powerful Mormons (in government), you find David Souter (a worthless lib Supreme Court justice), Harry Reid (a worthless lib Senate majority leader), Orrin Hatch (one of my conservative political heroes...), and Romney (my jury is still out...but I like the guy okay). But I'm no more confused by that diversity than I am with Roman Catholics in power (Ted Kennedy, Mary Landrieu, etc. etc. etc.) that accept the infallibility of the Pope, yet embrace abortion. Or, right wing Roman Catholics that call for the death penalty like Hannity, or O'Reilly, etc. (guess the Pope's not so much right all the time). I'm no more confused than I am with Baptists, past and present (Jimmy Carter, Bill Clinton, Jessie Jackson, etc. etc. etc.) that embrace abortion and welfare (clearly not Biblical principles). So...thanks for taking the time to clue me in on the Mormon culture. I'm not trying to debate anything Dadman. I was just curious. I know for sure that if Huckabee was a Mormon, I wouldn't ever vote for him for anything...just like I wouldn't vote for Reid. ;) If Romney was an ex-Baptist preacher I just might vote for him in spite of it (but only after Hunter and Thompson finally drop out).
Dadman
I forgot about Hunter. I like him too. It's a mystery why some candidates never break out of the so-called lower tier...
Dadman
I didn't know Souter was a Mormon. You sure about that?
Andy
Dadman: I could be wrong (wouldn't be the first, nor the last time). I was told several years ago by a Mormon friend that Souter is LDS. My friend didn't seem very proud of it when he was telling me, so I took him at his word...I'll try to find out for sure. But please forgive me if I have wrongly linked a worthless judge like Souter to the LDS. ;)
Dadman
I did a quick search and found no evidence Souter is LDS. Up to this point, no Mormon has ever served as a justice on the supreme court. Perhaps I should go to law school and strive to be the first. ;)
Andy
Dadman: Had bad info...sorry. I looked into it pretty deeply, and sure enough...no Mormons yet on the SCOTUS...but go for it man. ;) I'll have to whip my Mormon buddy's butt over it. Just kidding...he outweighs me by about 100 pounds.