Huckabee campaigning for 23% sales tax - Los Angeles Times WASHINGTON -- Mike Huckabee, one of the most conservative Republicans in the 2008 presidential race, has embraced one of the most radical ideas on the campaign trail: a plan to abolish all federal income and payroll taxes and replace them with a single 23% national sales tax. The idea -- dubbed the "fair tax" by proponents -- has been a political asset for Huckabee; its well-organized backers have helped catapult him from the back of the presidential pack to its top tier.
The "Fair Tax"
By CosmicConservativeFor several years now I've been hearing about the radical idea of completely scrapping the current income tax system and replacing it with an across the board national sales tax of something like 23% on every purchase.
I've seen it proposed with things like energy costs and food costs being excluded, and I've seen it proposed with a "luxury tax" added, which is a sort of "progressive" sales tax so that things like Lear jets are taxed at a higher rate than things like a vacuum cleaner.
It is surprising how difficult it is for me to come to a single opinion on this subject. It would seem to be pretty easy to decide whether to support this or not. But I find it very difficult to anticipate the unintended consequences of this radical of a change, both the negative and the positive ones.
On the one hand I am fundamentally in favor of anything that replaces a tax system that is so byzantine that an entire multi-billion dollar industry has grown up around the need to follow it. Most people who have any complexity to their tax situation at all don't trust themselves to calculate their own taxes and end up paying hundreds (or thousands) of dollars to have "professionals" do their taxes for them. I can't even begin to describe how insane I find that to be. I have repeatedly said, and I mean it completely, that the day I can't do my own taxes, I will file a lawsuit against the federal government. So far I have been able to do my own taxes, but many people do not. Add to that the reality that the tax code has become a nightmare of public policy incentives and disincentives in order to drive public behavior, another fundamentally "wrong" thing to do with the tax code. So believe me I am more than willing to scrap the existing tax system, it is a nightmare.
But to try to replace it with a national sales tax is not an obvious improvement to me. In fact it sounds like a tax that will disproportionately put the burden of taxes on the middle class. It is the middle class who spend the bulk of their income on items like furniture, new cars, electronics, etc., which are precisely the foundation of such a sales tax. Truly rich people will spend a small fraction of their income on the same things. And if they want to buy a yacht, they are likely to just zip down to Brazil to buy it, thereby avoiding the national sales tax by purchasing their big ticket items from other countries.
So all in all I can't say that I am a supporter. Somebody will have to explain it to me in a way that demonstrates its positives more clearly.
Comments (0)
No comments on this post.