Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Maybe the old man should hire John Edwards?

By CosmicConservative
So ski collisions are a daily, or even hourly event on the ski slopes. It sort of goes with the territory. When I first went skiing, I was not able to get off work in time to join the rest of my family in a remedial ski class, so I went straight to the slopes having never stood on skis before. I fell a lot. But by mid-afternoon I was confident enough in my skiing that I was able to navigate a "blue" slope, which real skiers will laugh at, but I thought was quite an accomplishment. Well during that day of skiing, I did get out of control for a short time, maybe six seconds. The immediate human reaction to losing control on skis is to attempt to maintain your balance, so by the time I reacted to the situation and regained my balance, I had accelerated and found myself about five feet from a slower woman skiing in front of me. I tried to avoid her, but skis are long, and the front part of my ski caught the back part of her ski, and both of us ended up bumping, although neither of us fell. Her male companion was displeased with the situation and yelled various versions of "get off the slope, rookie" at me. Now, the truth is that I could have hit that woman harder. If she had, for some reason, attempted to slow down, we would have collided much more forcefully. Or if I had lost it a second later we would probably have collided harder. Does that mean that I should be sued? Was I skiing "recklessly" and if so, how can anyone learn to ski at all if they can't take their first baby steps in skis?
Boy, 8, sued in ski crash : Updates : The Rocky Mountain News VAIL — A 60-year-old man is taking an 8-year-old boy and his dad to court, claiming the third-grader caused a ski-slope collision that left the older man with a shoulder injury. David J. Pfahler of Allentown, Pa., filed suit in Denver federal court claiming Scott Swimm, of Vail, then 7, was skiing fast and recklessly when they ran into each other in January. Pfahler's suit says he suffered a torn shoulder tendon.

Comments (15)

Drax
So, the old man should just suffer his injury in silence? After all, it wasn't HIS fault that he suffered the injury is it? And, if the complaint is true, then it WAS the fault of the child (and/or of the father for failing to properly supervise his child) that he got hurt. Not really sure where you're going with this. Don't you think that people who hurt by others should be compensated for their injuries?
CosmicConservative
Where I am going with this is that if you step foot on a ski slope, you are accepting the possibility that you will end up in a collision with another human being, either because you screwed up, or because they screwed up. Outside of legitimate reckless behavior, I don't think it is reasonable to sue a seven year old child because you happened to be the one that he collided with. You should have your own insurance that should take care of your medical needs and not sue somebody because of a typical event that happens several times per day on a ski slope even when people are doing everything within their power to avoid collisions. If the kid was racing down the slopes out of control and the parents were ignoring it, you might have a case, but THEIR story is that the seven year old was moving at about ten miles an hour and the collision was an unfortunate accident. As I said, if you get on a ski slope, you have to expect that there are people on that slope who are going to lose control of themselves and that you are at risk for being in a collision. If you can't deal with that, maybe you shouldn't be skiing. People are not born as expert skiers, they have to learn to ski, and there isn't really a place to do that other than a ski slope. What are you suggesting, that nobody should ever ski until they are able to ski so well that they never fall down or get out of control?
Drax
You said: "As I said, if you get on a ski slope, you have to expect that there are people on that slope who are going to lose control of themselves and that you are at risk for being in a collision. If you can’t deal with that, maybe you shouldn’t be skiing." So, since I also "expect that there are people on the ROAD who are going to lose control of themselves and that I am at risk for being in a collision" I shouldn't DRIVE? Come on. You said: "You should have your own insurance that should take care of your medical needs and not sue somebody because of a typical event that happens several times per day on a ski slope even when people are doing everything within their power to avoid collisions." All those people who are out there on the roads aren't TRYING to cause collisions, but "accidents happen." Are you saying that when we are the victim of an "accident" that WE are to bear the cost of that, whether through insurance we purchased (which, if I understand you correctly, is not your favority industry...mostly because they DON'T pay what they SHOULD pay WHEN they should pay it...) rather than the person who CAUSED the accident? It doesn't matter how fast the child was going. All that matters is that he HURT someone. Of course it was an "accident." So what? His parents should have made SURE that he was "learning to ski" in an area where this couldn't happen...like on a learner's slope when no one was around. What if the guy was killed? (It doesn't take much to snap a neck or break a back...) What if he was seriously injured? Would you THEN say: "I know that you USED to work and feed your family, but...hey...accidents happen. Suck it up."
CosmicConservative
The logical extension of your position on this is that everything bad that can happen to a person because another person happens to be involved should result in a lawsuit by default. Playing softball and you get hit on the head with a throw while running to first base? Sue the man! Playing playground football as a cornerback and getting run over by a wide receiver who is looking at the ball instead of at you? SUE HIM! Walking in the park and getting tripped by a passing stranger who is ogling a jogging girl's jiggling mammaries? Sue HIM! I'm sorry, I simply don't agree that everything bad that happens should result in a lawsuit. But then again, I'm not a lawyer. ;)
Drax
You're actually comparing "contact sports" where one of the GOALS of the sport is to come into "contact" with an opposing player with driving and skiing where one of the goals is to NOT do so? I really get a kick out of your notion that you SHOULDN'T sue the guy who accidently knocks you down while he's "ogling a jogging girl’s jiggling mammaries" instead of watching where he's going. Let's say that he did as you say and bumped into the Cosmic wife who was holding the Cosmic neice causing the Cosmic wife to drop Cosmic neice on her still-forming head killing her instantly or causing her a lifetime of brain damage. "Oops, no harm, no foul there guy! I surely understand why you were watching the bouncing boobs instead of where you were walking. I know that the Cosmic neice would understand if she could still understand anything, so, go about your boob watching life as I continue on with my own! Continue on your uncaring way, taking no precautions that your inattention and carelessness might cause harm to others and I shall do so as well! Play on!" Let's just take it all the way, eh? Let all drivers be their own insurers. It doesn't matter whose fault an accident is, the injured person bears the brunt of the accident. That way, when the bread earner is killed by the boob watching drivers, he doesn't have to worry about anything except his own injuries...too bad about the family of five who must make do without a daddy. Let all doctors make whatever mistakes they desire, and if they have an "accident" and cut off the wrong limb or operate on the wrong hemisphere of the brain, no harm, no foul, eh? And, if some oil tanker accidently has a spill off the coast of Alaska because the crew was watching the Playboy channel rather than watching what they were doing, no problem, right? If some pharmicist accidently puts the wrong drug in a prescription and kills someone, let the poor family bear that burden as well, I guess. There is a REASON for tort law. It is not only "to make someone whole" (after all, it's kinda hard to replace a dead daddy) but it's to MAKE PEOPLE PAY ATTENTION...to put the burden of loss on the person it should be borne by...the person CAUSING the loss rather than the innocent victim of someone else's negligence. If doctors didn't have to worry about being sued, do you think that would lead to better "doctoring?" If drivers didn't have to worry about being sued, do you think that that would lead to better driving? If parents are allowed to have their seven year old children ski in an area where they can run into people and hurt them, why on this green earth should the innocent victim of the parent's negligence have to bear the burden of the injury rather than the person who caused the injury? Does giving parents immunity to the actions of their improperly supervised children somehow translate into "better parenting?" I just don't understand your reasoning.
Drax
Oh, and, not everything "bad that happens" should result in a lawsuit. However, everything "bad that happens" which is the FAULT of someone else should cause the person who CAUSED the "bad" to bear the burden of his actions rather than the person who had to SUFFER his actions.
CosmicConservative
So, this goes back to my initial statement that the boys parents say that he was not doing anything unusual, was not being reckless, he was just skiing and collided with someone. It is not clear to me that it is the seven year old boy's "fault." To sue in this case seems excessive to me, and apparently also seems excessive to Drudge who linked it due to its seeming outrageousness, so I don't think I'm the only one saying "come on!" Heh, I put the jiggling boobs example in there to see if you'd jump on it. I agree with you on that one.
Drax
Two people are skiing. One hits the other. How can that NOT be the "fault" of the person who hit the other? Did God reach down and push the kid into the old man? Was the kid suddenly struck blind and couldn't see where he was going? Did the snow suddenly take on a different consistency so that the child was rendered incapable of controlling where he was going? Did someone restrain the parents so that they couldn't get close enough to the child so that he didn't go astray and get into trouble? Did someone besides the parents strap those skis on that kid, take him on the slopes, push him into traffic, so that the parents couldn't ensure that the kid didn't accidently run into people? Are you trying to say that this accident was "no one's fault?" That it "just happened" and couldn't have been prevented? You haven't responded to a single one of my hypotheticals. What if every single thing about this incident was as reported except for the extent of the injury? What if the old man was killed instead of just injured? Is that acceptable to you? That a child can be turned loose on a ski slope in such a fashion that he could run into other people with impuntiy and kill them?
Drax
As to the issue of "fault," that is something which will be decided by a judge or a jury (or it will be settled). I'm not convinced of the "fault" of the child either. The report says that they ran into "each other," rather than the child running into the old man. Don't know what the heck THAT means. I'm just challenging the notion that "crap happens" and that we should just not sue people when things happen to us through the fault of another.
CosmicConservative
So Drax... Have you ever been skiing? I ask because you post some "rhetorical" questions that are not rhetorical at all. Yes, it is entirely possible that the snow's consistency suddenly changed enough that it can cause a learning skier to lose control. It happens all the time. It even happens to experienced skiers. Skiing is basically strapping sticks on your feet and sliding across a surface you could not walk on. Snow consistency changes for many, many reasons, different types of snow conditions create different types of snow, melting of the snow at different rates exposes the different types of snow. Sometimes the snow consistency is affected by other skiers. And being "struck blind" is a very easy thing to have happen on a ski slope with white ice crystals covering everything and a bright sun reflecting off of the snow. There is a reason the word "snow blind" is in our lexicon. It is VERY easy to be temporarily blinded by the sun reflecting off of the snow. Even with good sunglasses this can happen. When you go walking in the park with children, it is not very common for children and parents to walk side-by-side. Usually the kids run ahead, and fall behind as they demonstrate their more abundant energy and their interest in things. This happens while skiing too. It is a pretty significant effort for skiers to remain together. When we went skiing with our extended family it pretty much ended up with the older folks skiing together (and falling a lot) the teenagers skiing together and the pre-teens skiing together. I suppose in your mind this makes us all bad parents, but that's the way the dynamic worked out, and that was generally true of all the skiers. We'll see how this case ends up. My personal opinion is that it is a frivolous lawsuit even if the man was injured. Skiing may not be intended as a "contact sport" but if you think you are going to go skiing over a weekend and never bump into a stranger on the slopes, you are either an expert skier, or else you are overly optimistic about how easy it is to stay in control of your skis. And I haven't even begun talking about snowboards yet, in general the ski community considers the snowboard community to be reckless, but that's because skis and snowboards work differently, you can't really snowboard gently with frequent pauses, so you tend to move faster and stop less often. This creates a scenario on the "bunny" slopes where snowboarders are constantly moving through groups of skiers, and it is simply inevitable that a snowboarder is going to collide with a skier. Does that mean the snowboarder was reckless? In general my experience on the slopes has been that reckless behavior is very rare. But collisions are very common.
Drax
I have no issue with the possibility that the accident wasn't the fault of the child or the parents, just the notion that it COULDN'T have been the fault of either or that, even if it was, the injured person should just suck it up and suffer his injury in silence which seem to be what you originally indicated. No, I've never been skiing. I have been in situations where you actually have to take into consideration external factors and actually be careful. Just because you're skiing, you don't get a free pass on running into people and injuring them. You still have to be careful. And, if you have children who are incapable of being careful themselves, you still have to control your kids so that THEY don't run into people and injure them. You still seem to be indicating that "crap happens, suck it up" to the injured guy when you have no more facts about how the accident occurred than I do. Yes..."crap happens." Sometimes it's an act of God or otherwise completely unavoidable and not the fault of someone. But, MOST of the time....almost ALL of the time an accident happens because someone does something he shouldn't have or didn't do something he should have and CAUSES the accident. In this case, the injured old man seems to think that the child did something or failed to do something which caused him injury. I'm content to allow the jury to determine whether or not he's correct instead of throwing up my arms in disgust and saying "Suck it up you sue happy bastich!" without knowing anything which even remotely resembles all the facts.
CosmicConservative
Not me, I'm perfectly happing jumping to conclusions and assuming the old man is a sue happy bastich. Whatever a "bastish" is.
CosmicConservative
By the way, a few tidbits about this case that lead me to my "jumping to conclusions." 1. The old man grabbed the boy by his legs after the collision and yelled obscenities at him along with "I'm gonna sue!" It is my personal opinion that the average person injured that severely is not able to grab someone else because they are too busy grabbing the injured limb. And it is also my opinion that the average person does not immediately think "I'm gonna sue" when they are injured. 2. The old man is looking for medical expenses for "therapy" his wife performed, which makes up a large chunk of the "$75,000" he has supposedly "spent." It is my opinion that such a thing is dishonest at root and opportunistic to boot. 3. The old man is suing for money to repay him for his Colorado vacation, again this seems to be the action of someone attempting to inflate a lawsuit award. He took his vacation, getting hurt on the vacation did not mean he did not go on vacation. 4. The old man has an injury that keeps most people (even people his age) out of work for a month or so, but he has been "unable to work" for almost a year. And what sort of work does he do? He's an editor at Readers' Digest. It is absolutely impossible for me to understand how a torn rotator cuff keeps a man from reviewing manuscripts or typing on a keyboard. All of this adds up in my mind to a man who has filed a frivolous lawsuit. My guess is that his real goal is to get an out-of-court settlement for enough to make him happy. I believe it is the defendant's attorneys who have insisted on a jury trial because they think the jury will laugh the old man back to Pennsylvania. We'll see how it ends up.
Drax
He does sound a bit like a git, doesn't he? (Of course, I don't know the source of the described actions comes from....) Is it your experience that people miss a year of work when they are able to work in the HOPES that they get a big payoff at some indeterminate point in the future? Maybe he has disability insurance or something which provides him some of his lost income. "Inflating" lawsuit awards" is a grey area...a touchy area, indeed. If insurance companies paid what they were supposed to pay when they were supposed to pay it, then it wouldn't be necessary to "pad" the lawsuit judgment, which, of course, comes many years later (frequently) and is diminished by the costs (many not re-imbursed) of prosecuting the lawsuit and, of course, the cost of the attorney (who would have been unnecessary if the dang insurance company would just do what it was supposed to do when it was supposed to do it....) Oh..grabbing the kid? I might grab the kid too...so that he doesn't get away. I suspect that, if the child hadn't been grabbed (if he was) then, he likely would have continued his merry way.