Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Does this photo matter?

By CosmicConservative
oldhillary.jpg So I saw this photo on Drudge and knew that it would get splattered all over the right-wing blogs. (Heh, like I'm doing now...) But my reaction to this photo was not "Oh my God! Hillary's old!" I knew that already. I knew that Hillary, like Fred Thompson or John McCain, has to work very hard to look young. And I know just as a matter of my own experience with human faces that how old or young a person looks can dramatically vary just due to how tired they are, how hard they've been working or how long it's been since they had a chance to repair the damage of daily wear and tear on their makeup. So I more or less ignored the photo thinking that it was just another low blow in a campaign of low blows. I figured the main purpose of the photo was to create a contrast between Hillary's age and Obama's youthfulness. But now I'm seeing blogs posting things like "this photo will end Hillary's campaign." Such comments bother me. I've seen photos of Margaret Thatcher where she looked old, but she was still wily and powerful. Ronald Reagan's age was an issue in the campaign until he deftly deflected the issue by quipping that he did not hold his opponent's "youth and inexperience" against him. I'll tell you this. When this country elects a woman, if she doesn't look old and worn out when she's elected, she's definitely going to look old and worn out within a few years. The job ages a person rapidly. So what about you? Does this photo in any way change your opinion of Hillary? Do you think it hurts her because it makes her look old and tired in a youth-obsessed culture? Or do you think it helps her by providing a sympathetic moment for voters who will feel sorry for her? As for me, it doesn't mean a thing. I wasn't surprised to see her looking like this in an unguarded moment, and I have no doubt that she'll manage to look young and energetic in her next guarded one. That's just how politics is.
Althouse: That picture of Hillary on Drudge right now. My first reaction to that picture is simple disbelief. How can she suddenly look that much older? I know Presidents age horribly in their few years in office, but she's not President yet, and this seems to have happened overnight. Did some treatment wear off? But here's my second reaction, on reflection: We make high demands on women. A picture like this of a male candidate would barely register. Fred Thompson always looks this bad, and people seem to think he's handsome.

Comments (4)

Boyd
I'm not surprised she looks like that; I'm surprised she manages to look so youthful on so many occasions, at her age and apparently without plastic surgery (can you say, "Joan Rivers?"). But no, I don't think this photo will change what anyone thinks of her. Those that like her will still like her, and those of us who don't like her (or worse), will still not like her (or worse).
Drax
I'm with Boyd. This surprises me only in that she is able to look so young (comparatively) in so many CLOSE-UPS.
CosmicConservative
I am not surprised by either the young-looking photos or the old-looking one. She's in her sixties. With a harsh overhead sun providing the illumination, her wrinkles are going to show. What strikes me about the photo is not the wrinkles, but the expression on her face. She looks like she is in the midst of a concession speech. Every bit of facial body language is reinforcing a negative image. Her eyes are down, her eyelids are half-closed, her mouth has no hint of a smile, her chin is tucked in and her cheeks are sagging. The whole package exudes exhaustion, frustration and a bit of testiness. She looks like a kindergarten teacher at the end of her rope.
Andy
I think that I have commented before that I really feel sorry for Hillary. When I consider the scope of her life...her motives, her demeanor, her ups and downs (for lack of a better term), I really do pity Hillary for many reasons. A photo like this puts me in a quandry. My mother is 72, and looks better than Hillary (in this particular photo). My first thought is..."crap, she's old!" But like Cosmic, I knew that. My second thought is...what is the point of Drudge making this his headline? The next thought is how rotten "politics" can be. People that enter the poltical arena are nuts! They are either true self-focused egomaniacs that think they can leap this stuff in a single bound...or they are true believers in a cause, that just don't give a darn if they are savaged. A picture like this won't change my opinion of Hillary. I pitied her before, and still do. She is a sad, sad human.