Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

God, Jesus and Satan...

By CosmicConservative
So, with the hoopla surrounding the claim by Mike Huckabee that Mormons believe that Jesus and Satan are "brothers" I can't help but speculate on the subject. Let's examine some of what the Bible tells us about God, Jesus and Satan. God is "the All-Father" the "Creator of all things." In that sense every being that exists is a "child" of God by definition. Right off the bat that means that there is some familial relationship between Satan and Jesus. The Bible repeatedly refers to the "Sons" of God, especially in the book of Genesis. If this is divine truth, then God has other sons than Jesus. In the New Testament Jesus is not described as God's "Only son" but as His "Only Begotten Son." The "begotten" part is usually interpreted to mean "the only Son of God who was born as a mortal being." If God has other sons, then who would those other sons be? The highest order of heavenly beings described in the Bible are the "Archangels". That includes Michael, Gabriel and.... Lucifer. Yes, Lucifer is a fallen archangel. In fact, the Bible tells us that Lucifer was God's FAVORITE archangel. If there are no higher beings in heaven than archangels, (excepting Jesus, of course) and God had other "Sons" than Jesus, then it is a fair assumption to conclude that the archangels are siblings of Jesus, although not possessing a physical body as Jesus does. So to conclude that Jesus and Satan are brothers is quite reasonable, and does not conflict at all with what I know of what the Bible says. I'm not saying that Mormons believe this, I have no idea would not presume to state what Mormon doctrine says on this subject, all I'm saying is that the way I read the Bible, it's pretty obvious that Jesus and Satan are very, very closely related, and to suggest that they are siblings as the most senior children of "God" does not seem to be a heresy in any way. Many people forget that the Bible tells us that Lucifer was God's favorite and the most powerful of the angels of heaven for untold ages before he fell. During that period, before the fall, surely Jesus and Lucifer were very close. One of these days I'll address my speculation of why Lucifer fell, but that does start to creep into the area of heresy, so I better not. But to think of Jesus and Satan as brothers? I've got no problem at all with that.

Comments (30)

Drax
LDS believes this. Depending on the source, the reasoning seems to be anywhere from: Jesus is the oldest son of God and his Wife and Lucifer is the second son....to Jesus and Lucifer (and all humans) began as the spirit children of God and his Wife and are brothers....as we are all brothers.
CosmicConservative
Drax: I know quite a bit more about LDS doctrine than I usually let on for a variety of reasons. One reason is because I think it is a bit cheeky of me, a non-LDS person, to state what LDS doctrine is. There are LDS members who read this blog (obviously) and I suspect they won't appreciate having their doctrine espoused by a non-believer.... ;)
Drax
Heh. I'm unconcerned about whether or not they appreciate it or not. I merely reported what my research revealed. I could find not a single official source which stated a contrary position and many which stated exactly what I wrote in one fashion or another.
Drax
Oh. Why would you think it "cheeky" for you "a non LDS person" to comment on LDS doctrine? The doctrine is published. It's not like it's some sort of secret.
CosmicConservative
For the same reason that I think it's cheeky for a non-Baptist to comment on Baptist doctrine. There are always nuances to these things, and to experience those nuances usually requires that one belong to the group with the belief. Language is a very poor means of communicating religious doctrine, and words that may seem clear and straightforward are usually inadequate to explain the concepts that the experience of believing actually provides. It's like the difference between a photograph of Yellowstone and being in Yellowstone.
Drax
I'm sorry. That's inapposite. The LDS have published doctrine. There aren't any "nuances" to that doctrine. They either do or they do not believe that Lucifer and Christ are brothers as a matter of doctrine. This is a FACTUAL matter, one not subject to interpretation or nuance. Any Baptist church likewise has a published doctrine. (Pick your poison of the many, many different offshoots of the Baptist religion...) I don't need to BE a Mormon to understand these issues of DOCTRINE. Other issues of that (or any other) faith...okay. But, not DOCTRINE.
CosmicConservative
There are nuances. Jesus is a "Begotten" son of God and Lucifer is not. To say that Jesus and Lucifer are "brothers" is not a clear statement as to say that you and I are "brothers." They are both children of God, but they are not equal in creation. The nuance here is critically important because the general use of the word "brother" implies equality of origin, while LDS (and other Christian doctrine) assert that Jesus and Lucifer were of UNEQUAL origin. Jesus was begotten and was created as a perfect creature. Lucifer was neither begotten nor created perfect. These are critical nuances that must be taken into account before simply asserting "Hey, Mormons believe that Jesus and Lucifer are BROTHERS!" This specific difference between the creation of Lucifer and Christ is critical to the understanding of why Christ is the savior, and Lucifer is the deceiver. I am not stating LDS doctrine here, I am stating interpretations of the relationship of Jesus and Satan that can be interpreted directly from the Bible. I will let Mormons describe the complicated relationship of Jesus, God and Satan. But to simply call them "brothers" simplifies things far too much to be meaningful, except as an exercise in stirring bigotry.
Dadman
Having fun guys? I must tell you, as a frequent contributor to this blog and a Mormon, I'm not entirely comfortable with CosmicConservative becoming a forum in which Mormon doctrine is debated. I don't mind discussing my faith, but not here. If you want to talk about it give me a call. Cosmic should have my number. Since Cosmic has already published the post I will go ahead and say that his statement of Mormon doctrine is essentially correct. Mormons believe in a pre-mortal existence in which Jesus, Lucifer and all his children (including us) were present. We believe all of us are God's children, including Jesus and Lucifer. In that sense we are all related. The notion of Lucifer and Jesus both being the creations of God the Father and therefore brothers seems supported by Biblical passages as Cosmic has pointed out. I'd love to hear why you think Lucifer fell...
CosmicConservative
Nah, you probably wouldn't. By the way, I don't have a problem with CosmicConservative being a place to discuss or debate any doctrine, unless it bothers my regular contributers. I wish it were possible to discuss things like religion and politics without it becoming a minefield of misstatements and misunderstandings. But it is what it is. Sigh...
Dadman
Hmmmm...nuance... Both Jesus and Lucifer are sons of God the Father spirtually created on essentially equal footing. The difference between them now is fundamentally a result of the choices they made. Jesus chose to follow God the Father's plan to become the only begotten Son of God in the flesh and Savior of the world, while Lucifer chose a path of rebellion, self-aggrandizement and deceit. A third of those in the pre-mortal existence (heaven) chose to follow Lucifer. Mormons actually rarely think about this kind of stuff. We expend most of our time and energy just trying to live up to Christ's example of love and service. That's difficult enough. And I can't help thinking that on a blog like this, dedicated to rational conservatism and visited by many secular atheists and dedicated agnostics, my credibility drops in direct proportion to the number of times I say anything about my faith. So be it...
Dadman
As long as your theory as to why Lucifer fell does not specifically mock my or someone else's faith, I don't think I would have a problem with it. I have no real issue with someone rejecting what I believe in as long as they are rejecting something I actually believe in and not something they think I believe in. It's the misinformation, mockery and ignorance that bothers me so much...
Drax
I'm just responding to what is on the Blog. I'm pretty comfortable that I have a pretty good handle on the Mormon faith as I have a pretty good handle on most of the major religions as I have attempted to spend a goodly portion of my life reading more than the Sunday comics. I think that the not-so-offhand remark by Huckabee was a low blow which was INTENDED to "demonize" Mitt to the ignorant voters. But, when you wear a bullseye, you really can't fault someone for shooting at it when you're in a fight with him and the stakes are this high. Mitt is Mormon; the Mormon doctrine is as set forth; it was a fairly predictable shot. It's akin to someone wondering if JFK is a cannibal what with the Church's stance on transubstantiation and all if you "Grok" what I'm saying.... The difference is that, currently, Catholicism is a FULLY accepted religion (as it was NOT not so many decades ago in America) while Mormonism is not...yet. And, Dadman, in just about any other context, the remark should result in any Mormon who knows Mormon doctrine saying...."That's right! Here. Let me tell you WHY we think that."
Drax
Dadman: I'm somewhere between agnostic and athiest...dunno which. But, it isn't because I haven't dabbled in religions in my time. I spent a good deal of time reading about and discussing various religions in my own journey, although I don't think anywhere to the degree that CC has. I don't know of many who have spent as much time reading and thinking about these issues as has CC who don't do this for their livelihood. I have a PROFOUND respect for people of faith. Well, those of ACTUAL faith, not those who go to church on Saturday or Sunday and act the fool the rest of the week...or for "true believers" who mindlessly follow doctrine and dogma and the directions of those who tell them what to believe and what to do. But, those who have actual faith, who attempt to live in accordance with that faith (again...excluding "true believers") have my deepest respect. As with CC, my experiences with Mormons has been ...almost without exception good and honest people (Catholics too, frankly...not so much most of the other major religions....) I would no more attempt to convert you FROM a religion than you would attempt to convert me TO one, and would no more denigrate your religion than you would my lack of one. That doesn't mean that we can't TALK about it, does it?
Dadman
I 'Grok' what you are saying. A presidential election should not be allowed to devolve into a debate over religious doctrine, but that's where everyone seems to want to take this race, including some of the candidates. Mitt just wants to run on his ample record of public service and a life well lived. I have engaged in far too many religious debates over the years - with strangers, friends and family members - that have resulted in hard feelings and/or fractured relationships. I don't want that to happen on this blog. However, if you ever genuinely desire to know WHY Mormons believe something please let me know and I'll be happy to discuss it with you one-on-one. www.lds.org is also a good resource...
Drax
I've never understood why people allow religion to be a source of division. Once we agree that we each aren't privy to the secrets of the universe, then we can engage in discussions about the secrets of the universe safe in the knowledge that we're "just talking here." It's when one or the other in a conversation actually DO believe that they are privy to the secrets of the universe and attempt to convince the other of their superior knowledge that conflict ensues. I happily admit that I have absolutely NO CLUE regarding the secrets of the universe.
CosmicConservative
I can't think of anyone who routinely reads or contributes to this blog who would think less of someone for having a personal faith. If there are some, I would try my best to educate them about the importance of accepting people for what they are, not for what someone might prefer them to be. It is hard to be a truly devout follower of just about any faith I have ever encountered. It is too hard for me, for example. I can't do it, and I have tried. I do think about this a lot. I used to talk about it a lot, but it lost me too many friends, so I mostly stopped. Although, as here today, I fall back into the habit all too easily... The bottom line of this is that if you examine the deeply held fundamental beliefs of any human being, Catholic, Mormon, Agnostic or Atheist, there is not a single one of us whose beliefs can not be parodied, mocked or misrepresented to make us look like fools or worse. I don't know anything about the nature of God except what I feel in my own heart. And what I feel there tells me that if God does exist, he is so profoundly different from what any current religious doctrine describes him to be that it is almost impossible to even talk intelligently about it. And that is only IF he exists. My lack of knowledge extends into the existential reality of God himself. But what I do "know" about any God that does exist is that he has to be far more reasonable, rational and fair than any religion I have encountered describes him to be. Or else he's not much of a God to begin with. I may one day delve into my thoughts about Lucifer, God, free will and the Fall of 1/3 of the heavenly host. As with most things I believe about philosophy, it all boils down to the question of free will. Because there is nothing else important in the universe. Certainly nothing important enough to foment civil war in heaven.
Drax
Many believe that it is the issue of free will that formented the civil war in Heaven.
CosmicConservative
Yep, many do. And Judeo-Christian theology is not the only one that addresses this issue and describes it as having led to civil war in heaven. There's something profound there, and I've spent most of my adult life trying to work out exactly what it is. I sometimes feel like I get glimpses of it, sort of like Tolkien's concept of "True Myth" that is shattered, but still shows tantalizing fragments of the deeper truth of things. The real question in Lucifer's Fall is not whether the issue was free will, but why the issue of free will would split heaven apart. It is amazing to me that the vast majority of Christians hear the story of Lucifer and 1/3 (1/3!!!!) of the heavenly host rebelling against God without contemplating the implication that the 1/3 who rebelled against God actually KNEW God and experienced his divinity directly and daily. One Third. One, freaking, third.
Drax
Heh. It's a better story when there's an actual war in Heaven with 1/3rd against the righteous host rather than a stray angel throwing a hissy fit.
CosmicConservative
True, and it is always possible to argue that every religion is just fairy tale gone viral if we want. But for the purposes of this particular issue, I'm willing to stick with the postulate that there is something behind the story other than just a desire to tell a good yarn.
Drax
Well, if the tales in the Bible were uninteresting and unengaging, I doubt that many would have read it, so, "telling a good yarn" was of paramount importance. Even today, most preachers/clerics/whatevers tell us that many parts of the bible are just that....good yarns, but they call them "parables."
Drax
Heh...and that "picking and choosing" between that which is a "parable" and a real event causes me no small measure of mirth.
CosmicConservative
Sigh.. one more post... then off to bed. Really... I can't say that I agree that "parable" is a euphemism for "good yarn." Parables are not merely made up stories, they are supposed to be attempts to communicate deeper truths through example. Equating "parable" with "good yarn" is about the same thing as equating "theory" with "wild guess."
Dadman
Mormons believe it (life, the universe and everything) is all about free will. In Mormon theology, Lucifer wanted to usurp free will and proposed a plan that would pre-ordain all of God's children to a destiny of exaltation. This idea was rejected by God. It was then Lucifer and his sychophants threw a hissy fit. ;)
Drax
A parable is fiction. It is, by definition, a "yarn." Whether or not it is a "good yarn" is in the eye of the beholder. It is fiction which attempts to make a point. The fact that the parable is in the Bible rather than Reader's Digest does nothing to detract from this truth.
CosmicConservative
I don't agree that a parable is "fiction" in the common vernacular sense of the term. A parable is a structured narrative with a specific intent to teach a profound concept. Parables are used to illustrate points that are difficult to communicate without a narrative. The analogy I made of "parable is to yarn as theory is to wild guess" is a significant analogy. It is not fair nor accurate to suggest that the parables in the Bible are just made up stories. The use of parable and other narrative forms of instruction were necessary (and probably still are) in a world with a lack of formal education and a strong oral tradition. I understand the point that the difficulty of separating parable from historical documentation in the Bible creates a level of doubt about the "literal truth" claims in the Bible. Is the story of Job parable or literal truth? It is presented as literal truth, but it certainly makes more sense as parable. Still, I don't agree that the use of parable is essentially the same thing as turning the Bible into a cultural equivalent to Grimm's Fairy Tales.
Drax
Parables are fiction. Apparently, since they appear in the bible and are intended to make a point, you think that they are something beyond a "made up story" which, of course, is the definition of "fiction." You may give them some sort of "uber fiction" or "almost factual" or some other sort of category than a "made up story with a point". I don't. That is what they are. You can attempt to make them something that they are not, but, in the end, they are fictional stories which attempt to make a particular point and nothing more. MOST of the "parables" in the Bible are presented as "literal truth." It is man's interpretations (not all of which agree) which have classified some as parables and others as truth.
CosmicConservative
I guess we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. I think that it is possible to communicate a deeper fundamental truth through a "made up story" using appropriate narrative and example, such that the most important thing is conveyed, even though the medium may not be factual. Einstein used to drive his peers crazy with a series of what he called "thought experiments" which were essentially narrative "stories" that he made up to demonstrate his insight into what happens to matter and energy as you reach the nearly unfathomable realm of matter moving near the speed of light. These "made up stories" were critical in Einstein's ability to describe his innermost thoughts about the nature of space and time, and many of those "made up stories" are now enshrined in the annals of the history of physics as some of the deepest "truths" we have ever uncovered about our universe. So using "made up stories" to communicate fundamental truth to others is not only not restricted to theology, but it is recognized as a powerful means to convey concepts that are nearly impossible to comprehend through the "truth" of the complex and nearly incomprehensible math that is required to "prove" it. Whether the story of the "Prodigal Son" is literal truth or just a made up story, the message of the power of a father's love and the hope of redemption is as good a means as any I can think of to describe God's desire to have his "children" come home. So whether the story is true or not is of little overall importance, what is important is that Jesus managed to convince a lot of people that God loved them in spite of their faults, their abandonment of their faith and their acknowledged sins. That is a powerful message.
Drax
I didn't say that the parables in the Bible weren't meant to convey "fundamental truths." Of COURSE that's their purpose. That's why someone sat down and created the story to begin with...to make a point. I don't know how you got that I didn't think this was so or wasn't aware of the purpose of the parables, but, I'm "hip" to why they're in the Bible. I DO get a kick out of some of the stories in the bible which attempt to make one point but, with me, make another one entirely. (Again...Job...Sodom and Gammorah spring to mind...) I understand the point which is attempted to be made, but, to me, it veers off in another direction entirely....
Porzitsku
In my heart I know that God is a pure spirit being. His desire for something else was teh spark that became Jesus Christ, through whom all things were created. It is as though God needed a point of reference, some feedback if you will, and this led to "the creation" of Jesus. I put that in quotes because it is a term causing wailing and gnashing of teeth in the mainstream Christian community. Frankly, if the world could only have been created through the intercession of Jesus, to our perspective it is impossible to see the difference in power and majesty (Lordship) of Christ and Jehovah. So what's the beef? Besides, the only important thing is bringing people to Christ. We DO know that only through him can one attain salvation. Jesus' relationship to God is only important in the sense that we rely on Him to bring us to God. Made up stories? That is convenient and comfortable for many to believe. I just hope that belief does not guide them down a dead end path. Peace out y'all.