Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Comments (72)

Andy
This one made me think. First of all, I like the artwork. I know the point of it, but it is a pipe dream. The founders were wise men. I am sure that they never believed that religious bigotry would disappear simply by prohibiting a State religion. In fact, some of them probably were religious bigots (just assuming). There will always be religious bigotry as long as there are humans on the planet. I know a bunch of them...of various faiths. It's a noble idea, but human nature is what it is...it ain't gonna happen. It was almost 200 years before a Roman Catholic became President...and not another one in the 11 elections since. Think about that...there are about 80 million Roman Catholics in the US. Roman Catholicism is well-entrenched, broadly embraced, and was for hundreds of years before the founding of the US. Mormonism is a relatively new movement. It is not well-entrenched (on a nationwide scale), broadly embraced, or understood by the public at large. It may be a hundred years more before a Mormon is elected President. Religion is always going to be an issue in politics...always has been...always will be.
Dadman
So, bigotry is inevitable? I agree with that. But I will continue to call it out when I see it and make an issue of it. To do any less would make me guilty of the thing Edmund Burke warned us against: "All that is necessary for evil to triumph is for good men to do nothing"
CosmicConservative
I am afraid that I agree with Andy that religious (and other forms of) bigotry is inevitable as long as human beings are still human beings. One of my main beefs with liberals is that they seem to think that simply by wishing something that we could make it so. The "utopias" that liberals build in their minds are only utopias so long as human beings are excluded. As soon as you get actual human beings involved the utopias crumble as reality meets fantasy. That's not a very flattering portrait of humanity, but I'm afraid it is a (perhaps cynically)accurate one.
CosmicConservative
As far as the 'toon is concerned, I just can't figure out why Abe is the only one with hands.
Andy
Oh crap! Cosmic agrees with me...maybe I need to revise and extend my remarks. ;) Dadman: I have a beef myself with the use of the word "bigotry." I have always thought "bigotry" to mean "not able to tolerate, or respect, etc." I believe that it is a word that is thrown around too often. There is a big difference between a guy that just hates gays (who would be called a bigot), and a guy that goes out and bombs a gay bar ( definitely not able to tolerate gays). Or, a guy that thinks Mormons are nuts, and a guy that would fire an employee because they are LDS (that is the bigot...intolerant). Or a guy that thinks tongue-talking Pentecostals are moonbats, vs. a guy that would go burn down their church. "Bigotry" is a strong word. I have been thinking throughout the day for a better term to describe those that criticize the religion of another...and do their best to persuade it's followers of fallacies, etc., as opposed to someone who is truly intolerant. Maybe someone has got a better term. Maybe there should be a "bigotry scale...1 to 10." I don't know. But I do know that there is a difference. I mean, Islam in many parts of the world is truly bigoted (will not tolerate). Convert, or die, etc. I just don't see or hear any Roman Catholic, or Protestant Christian that is so intolerant that they would call for abolition of any religion (Mormonism included). Abe couldn't have been Italian...too tall, and no mustache.
Dadman
When an individual will not consider voting for a good man running for President simply because they disapprove of his faith, I think that is intolerant. I would call it bigotry. What Larry O'Donnell said on The McLaughlin Group show - pure bigotry in my view. I'm sure Mitt is open to discussing the 'fallacies' of his faith with anyone, but it should be a different conversation than the one regarding his qualifications to be President. The bigots can't seem to separate the two...
Dadman
By the way, Andy, I agreed with you too. Bigotry and hate are inevitable as long as humans are involved. So, both Cosmic and I agree with you. Might be time for you to check into the looney bin... ;)
CosmicConservative
I'm pretty sure that insulting the host of the blog is something akin to "bigotry." Maybe I'll just call it "blogotry" and coin a new term. ;)
Andy
Dadman: I would consider checking into the looney bin, but I am busy...I have a book to color.
Andy
Dadman: You wrote: When an individual will not consider voting for a good man running for President simply because they disapprove of his faith, I think that is intolerant. I would call it bigotry. What Larry O’Donnell said on The McLaughlin Group show - pure bigotry in my view. Okay...Larry O'Donnell is the exception, not the rule. This O'Donnell character would not support a fellow Roman Catholic if they were staunchly pro-life. This guy is a political hack. He is not intolerant...he is just a small, mean, man that just hates "goodness" in any candidate. I guarantee you that this guy will support the Dem. candidate for President...I mean, it's PBS...they aren't going to put forth anyone without an ax to grind against a possible Republican nominee. Secondly, I guess that I am a bigot. I would not vote for an Islamic candidate for anything. I find the Islam faith to be so devoid of any value, or hopeful purpose that I would (as we say down South) never, ever, never vote for a Muslim for anything! I guess I am a "5" on the bigotry scale when it comes to Islam. I don't want to wipe them all out, or abolish their religion in the US. But I surely don't trust anyone that is wacky enough to adhere to it. Okay...you distracted me...I almost had Cinderella and Prince Charming finished...where is my pink crayola?
Andy
Cosmic: You wrote "I’m pretty sure that insulting the host of the blog is something akin to “bigotry.” Maybe I’ll just call it “blogotry” and coin a new term. ;) " Go for it man...If you can get a copyright on "blogotry," you might just be able to buy a bigger TV.
CosmicConservative
Isn't Cinderella the princess in blue? Or was that Snow White? I guarantee you the Cosmic Daughter would know...
Andy
Okay Cosmic, go ahead and destroy my faith in pink...actually I couldn't find it, so I opted for aquamarine. It looks pretty good.
Dadman
I confess. There is some bigotry in my heart too. I'll plead guilty of being human. In today's world, I would also have difficulty voting for a Muslim just because they are Muslim. To some extent I feel justified in that position given that some extreme Muslims have declared war on my country and have justified the most horrific acts of brutality in the name of their religion. Radical Muslims also believe their true feelings should sometimes be hidden from the world, particulary in Western nations, so that they can remain hidden until it is time to go into jihad mode. That's what the 9/11 attackers did. So, on one hand I do feel it's prudent to be wary of Muslims on some level. On the other hand, if I failed to examine the individual history and character of, let's say, an American Muslim running for office dismissing him or her without scrutiny simply due to their faith, well, I would have to accuse myself of some soft bigotry, perhaps a 3 or 4 on your bigotry scale. I believe large numbers of evangelicals are guilty of, at the very least, a soft bigotry toward Mitt Romney because of his faith. They do this because in their minds you just can't trust the judgement and character of a man who believes in 'Mormonism'. They persist in this line of thinking in spite of evidence to the contrary, e.g. Mitt's recent speech, educational resume', business and political accomplishments, and the clear high standards on which he has based his entire life without fail. Because of this I believe evangelical bigotry toward Romney is somewhat worse than our own personal bigotry toward Muslims. There do seem to be some rational, reasonable considerations one should ponder above and beyond just religious faith (like are they radical Bin Laden sympathizers) before pulling the lever for a Muslim. With Mitt and the evangelicals (the ones who won't vote for him) it seems to be all about religion. Just my perspective. I realize most on this blog are not likely to agree...
Andy
Dadman: I will come clean finally, and agree with you. There are some thousands (maybe hundreds of thousands) of evangelicals that will not vote for Mitt in the primaries because he is a Mormon. They are short-sighted. But I still contend that if Mitt is the nominee, the voting faithful will put his religious faith on the back burner, and show up in droves when the polls open to make Mitt the most powerful man in the world. There is a soft bigotry (3 out of 10) against Mormons in the evangelical world. I mean...it's hard to really, really hate Mormons. They are so decent and wholesome...and don't behead their enemies. It is much easier to really, really hate Muslims. It has been a long time since Mormons have hijacked airplanes, and flown them into buildings. ;) I know for sure that I like Mitt on a human level. I just wish that he had not waited so long to come out of the closet on his faith. His remarks were very impressive. I have heard that Huckabee is now the darling of the Republican primary-goers. His theology is very much closer to mine than Mitt's is. But, I am not impressed with him at all. I think the guy is incompetent. I guess that I am hoping that Ronny RayGun will be resurrected, and come back to save the world...folly, I know. Well, gotta go...I have a Christmas program to attend at #4 son's school.
Dadman
Huckabee is the currently GOP darling due in large part to the soft bigotry of evangelicals toward Mormons. They are short-sighted because I think Mitt is simply more qualified to serve as President. Guiliani is more likely to give the Dem nominee a run for their money...
CosmicConservative
Wow, I actually remembered something from DisneyWorld! Cinderella's dress is blue. She and her nasty vermin friends made a dress that was pink, but her fashion-savvy stepmother destroyed it to save her from the embarrassment of putting pink against her alabaster skin, which would not have accentuated her features properly, and her fairy godmother, being a fan of "Queer as Folk" recognized the proper accentuating color and made her a blue one, and the rest, as they say, is history. It's a shame that ungrateful Cinderella never thanked her stepmother for stopping her from going to the ball in such a color-challenged vermin-made dress that would surely have made her the butt of the ball fashion jokes. But kids these days, they never appreciate what their parents do for them.
Drax
I simply don't understand the resistance to forming an opinion as to the worth of a person based on his STATED religious preference. If one chooses to believe in Satan Worship, then don't we have the right to make certain assumptions about him/her? Too much? Well, how about a Christian snake handler? He might keep the White House free of mice... Still too much? Well, how about a Christian Scientist? We could use someone who believes in the active hand of God to such a degree that they would allow their children to forego necessary medical treatment, couldn't we? Still too much? Where do we draw the line between "crazy religions" and the "we're okay with this one" religions? Because there certainly IS a line for each of us, isn't there? Religion forms the fundament of a person's world-view, or it ain't much of a religion. Professing to adhere to a particular religion SHOULD mean that the person so professing has ACCEPTED all of the precepts of that religion...or they really shouldn't be saying that they're a (fill in the blank...) should they? And, if their religion forbids abortion, don't we have the right to think that this religion might inform them when they make their Supreme Court appointments? Most religions agree on one thing: All other religions are wrong. When a person is being considered for the highest office in the world, why on earth wouldn't a rational person examine CLOSELY his professed religious beliefs? That ain't biggotry...that's common sense.
Dadman
I'm not the only one calling evangelicals who refuse to vote for a Mormon bigots. The problem is in many cases people are making judgements without a CLOSE examination of the individual or his beliefs. Instead, we get superficial examinations combined with misinformation and hearsay... Then we get...'I ain't votin' for no damn Mormon!" Not much common sense in that if you ask me.
CosmicConservative
Oh well, I tried to add some levity to this thread... There are going to be some "evangelical Christians" who won't vote for Romney because he's Mormon, and in their mind, that's not their kind of "Christian." There's going to be a whole lot more people who won't vote for him because he's Mormon and they don't trust ANYONE who truly adheres to ANY religion.
Dadman
Heh. You're right, Cosmic. And I'll keep calling them out for it...
Drax
It's all a matter of perspective. If one defines himself by his beliefs, and his belief is (fill in the blank), then, one doesn't really need to examine the PERSON....since the person's VALUES are defined by his BELIEF. If the person actually ADHERES to the doctrine of his professed religion, then his actions would (not might) be controlled (not guided) by those doctrines. It is degrees and degrees. Just how "Mormon" is Romney? Is he as "Mormon" as Pat Robertson is "Christian?" To what degree does he allow his "Mormonism" to inform his decisions of state? Does he make decisions which are CONTRARY to his professed beliefs (making him a "Mormon" in name only)? Or, are his decisions exactly in line with the doctrine of the Mormon faith? As an example: A Pat Robertson would likely make decisions which are controlled by the doctrine of his (personal) church, thinking all the while that God is guiding him. I would no more want a Pat Robertson in office than I would want a "true blue" Mormon in office. ANYONE who has his decisions of state CONTROLLED by the doctrine of a religion is a dangerous person. Anyone who gives lip service to a religion while making decisions of state which are contrary to that religion are hypocrites. I much prefer a hypocrite to a true believer. Unfortunately, to be elected to high office, one must give lip service to some religion, whether or not one actually adheres to the doctrine of that religion.
Dadman
Drax: You have an interesting view of the world... and you don't understand what makes Mormons tick. You think you do, but you don't. Romney is a successful business leader and former governor of a liberal-leaning state. He is also a, as you put it, 'true blue' Mormon. I base that assertion on the speech he just gave, not on any personal insight I might have into his soul. Public service and Mormonism are not incompatible. Faith and public service are not incompatible as you imply. Now, I suspect your belief people of faith are 'insane' is informing your opinion of candidates such as Romney. So be it. Not much I can do about that. Not much more to discuss beyond that I suppose...
CosmicConservative
As usual I am cursed with what I believe is insight into both sides of this discussion. Drax is not attacking Mormonism nor is he attacking Mitt Romney. At least that's not what I am reading into his comments. What I am hearing is that there is a sort of cognitive dissonance that comes into play when an agnostic or atheist contemplates the role of a devoutly religious person's faith when it comes to public policy. The example of the Christian Scientist is actually a better example I think. If we elect a Christian Scientist to the Presidency, and he begins to fashion public policy around his belief that God's will is the determining factor in medical procedures, and therefore strips funding of medical research because he considers it pointless, that would be something that would bother a lot of people. What Drax is saying, as I understand it, is that if a person TRULY BELIEVES that God determines the outcome of all situations, then it is reasonable to contemplate the potential that such a person would gut medical research as unnecessary. And if the person running for office as a Christian Scientist said "It is my own personal belief that medical research is pointless, but because it would bother people, I won't cut off funding," then it is fair to ask whether the candidate was either a hypocrite or was pandering to the electorate in order to get elected. It is hard for people who find faith to be a great mystery to understand how people of faith reconcile their deeply held beliefs against such things as how to form public policy. This is one reason Ahmadinejad frightens people so much. He claims to believe that he can usher in the end times by dropping nuclear bombs on Israel. If he truly believes that, then it is reasonable to assume that the threat is very real. If he doesn't, then that's much better to contemplate, but still paints him as a panderer or hypocrite. I think that's what Drax means by saying he prefers the hypocrite to the true believer. Now, I think I see the other side too. It is possible to have deeply held beliefs about the world, but to still fashion public policy based on more mundane experience. Romney demonstrated this while Governor of Massachusetts. He was able to reconcile his own faith with the reality of the bump and grind of politics, taking the victories he could take, while still staying true to his own internal moral compass. But as I said, that's a hard thing to wrap an agnostic brain around.
Dadman
You know, in the case of Romney, it's really important to get beyond the stereotypes of religious people. It's important to look closely at the man's record academically, in the business world, and as a successful governor. The fact is Mormons are very mainstream. They tend to be very civic minded. Mormons are CEOs of large corporations, doctors, dentists, lawyers, politicians, professional athletes, reporters, celebrities, engineers, accountants, military officers, fighter pilots, professors, Secret Service agents, etc. Indeed one of the church's articles of faith is: We believe in being subject to kings, presidents, rulers, and magistrates, in obeying, honoring, and sustaining the law. I wish people would quit worrying about what Mormons think about the concept of The Godhead or the notion of a spiritual pre-existence and begin to look more closely at the way Mormons live their lives both professional and personally. In my view that is where you'll find the data that are most relevant to the question of Romney's fitness for President. Instead, we get a relentless fixation on the obscure from the media, talk radio, fundie evangelicals, and now the candidates running against Romney. I personally received an e-mail today containing a editorial cartoon that was just downright offensive and mocking toward Mormons. Just to preserve some level of sanity during the holiday season I am on the verge tuning everything out. You have no idea how upsetting it is to hear your faith mocked, mischaracterized, and ridicluled everytime you turn on the TV, radio, or computer.
Andy
Dadman: You wrote, "You have no idea how upsetting it is to hear your faith mocked, mischaracterized, and ridicluled everytime you turn on the TV, radio, or computer." "ridicluled" is spelled "ridiculed." ;) Just kidding man...please forgive! I am probably the champion of misspelled words typed in haste. No, I don't have any idea how upsetting it is to take a constant barrage. But I have had my faith mocked, and ridiculed before. Thank God we live in the US, where we don't stone infidels. By the way, I'm sorry about the bicycle thing...
CosmicConservative
Dadman: In case it hasn't been obvious, I have been tuning a lot of the daily garbage out. Especially the election nonsense. I made a promise to myself that I was not going to get all worked up over the 2008 election until, well, 2008 at the earliest. I've more or less stuck to that. I can't address your feelings of being mocked and ridiculed because of your religion, but I can tell you that the mocking and ridicule goes both ways. I can't begin to tell you how many times I have seen religious zealots of all stripes assert that anyone who does not believe in God can have no moral foundation and therefore is fundamentally supporting evil. In fact this is a rather common assertion levied by the faithful against the faith-challenged. It is quite unpleasant to be told that you are a pawn of the devil just because you don't subscribe to any particular religious doctrine. Religion is a very difficult subject. Because of what it is, it is hard to see any way that it can be made easier. The fundamental assertion of all religions is that they have the inside track on the absolute universal truth of the universe. When large groups of people believe they alone have the key to universal truth, that does not usually lead to good outcomes for their neighbors who believe otherwise. That's just the way human beings are. As I said, it's not a flattering portrait of humanity, but I think it's an accurate one.
Andy
Cosmic: Yes, I thought about the ridicule that people without a stated faith have to deal with. The truth is, everyone comes under ridicule and suspicion from someone, or some group because of their faith, or their looks, or some handicap, or how ugly their kids are, ;) etc. It is really easy to open wounds when it comes to faith. Most things in our lives we really have little control over...our looks, physical characteristics, intelligence level...but our faith is something we come to through long years of seeking. We pay a high price to come to our faith...invest much emotion, time, thought, and other resources. It is a decision we come to on our own...and we know we're right dammit! So it hurts more to be ridiculed for our faith than for any other thing in our life.
CosmicConservative
Andy: True, but only to a point. When I was a younger man (or boy), I struggled with faith, repeatedly entering and then leaving (or being thrown out of) different religious affiliations. As I got older (I won't say "matured" because that would only invite ridicule) I found myself gaining enough security in my own discovery process in the effort to uncover "universal truth" that I eventually was able to create a significant amount of armor so that being ridiculed for my faith (or lack thereof) generally does not cause me that much pain anymore. My general reaction these days is amused resignation when I find myself being attacked by a person of "faith" who is determined to make me feel that I have chosen poorly in my path towards my current position on such things. In fact it is probably true that I am far more sensitive to comments about my writing or other creative efforts than I am to comments about my faith or lack of faith. But that does not reduce the amount of confrontation and ridicule that has been offered by people who have discovered my position on matters of faith. I tend not to advertise such things these days. I used to, I used to love to get into debates with just about anyone on this subject. I can't even remember the number of door-to-door religious zealots that I have invited into my house for the specific purpose of donning my armor, polishing my sword and shield and engaging in mortal rhetorical combat with them. Mostly I stopped doing that when I got married because it seriously disturbed my wife to see me engaged in such activities. But time has taught me that combat of that nature never leads to a "winner." Nobody ever changed their faith based on a superior rhetorical or logical argument. Or damn few have anyway. That's why they call it "faith." Now when someone comes to my door with a request to explore my commitment to the supposed ultimate divine authority, I simply tell them that we both have better things to do with our time than knock heads on the subject, and I send them on their way. It's better for both of us that way.
Dadman
I don't think you guys are quite following me. Since you've not been tuned in (by your own admission) I have to suppose you've missed the fact that Mormonism has been the joke du jour of nearly every radio talk show, stand-up comedian, editorial cartoonist, op ed writer, political pundit, and partisan hack for the past week or so. I literally can't turn on the radio, TV, computer without hearing some ignoramus berating the Mormon faith or outright mocking it. I'm not talking about the normal stuff here. There is always a certain amount of the mocking and ridicule going on - I have no problem with that - but since Romney made his speech mocking Mormons seems to have become a national sport. I know it will blow over, but it's a rough patch right now for LDS people all over America. Andy, I appreciate your ability to empathize.
CosmicConservative
Dadman: Hmmm... has it really been that bad since Romney's speech? I listen to the radio to and from work, so that's usually 2 to 3 hours of radio listening that I do depending on traffic and weather. Both shows that I listen to; "Colorodo Morning News" and "The Drive Home" are topical shows with the typical tag-team male/female format where they take phone calls and instant messages from the public. Perhaps things here in Colorado have been atypical because of events that have taken over the news, but I honestly don't recall a single day where the topic has been Mormons, or where callers have been critical of Romney's speech or Mormons in general. Obviously the big topic this week has been the Arvada and Colorado Springs "Christian shooter" who killed four people last Sunday (the two girls killed in Colorado Springs were the teenage daughters of an employee of the company I work for). Last week the big topic was the firing of Sonny Lubick from Colorado State University or the woes of the woeful Denver Broncos. When there are political comments made, the vast majority of them are critical of Hillary Clinton or John McCain, Romney is rarely even mentioned. So perhaps I have been shielded from the anti-Mormon tirades that you are seeing. Since I have not been experiencing it, I did not realize how bad it must be. I apologize if you feel I have been downplaying the anti-Mormon sentiment. I will say that the only time in the past few months that I remember a significant amount of Mormon chatter on the radio shows here was when the anti-Mormon movie came out. And most of the callers seemed to be offended by the blatant political motivation of that movie. Perhaps Denver just doesn't "get it". Perhaps Colorado is just close enough to Utah that Mormons don't generate a lot of antipathy here. Regardless, Romney's speech simply hasn't been an issue around here.
CosmicConservative
Actually the Cosmic Wife and I were reflecting recently on how few zealots we get in the hills. We probably get one visit a month during the good weather months. When we lived in Aurora we used to get a regular dose of such visitors, probably one a week or so. But when we lived in Bossier City? Oh my. We used to get several visits from various denomination's zealots every single weekend. It got to the point that the Cosmic Wife would not let me answer the door if she thought the visitor was on a religious crusade.
CosmicConservative
Heh, I probably shouldn't toss around the word "zealot" so casually. In most cases the visitors are not zealots, they are usually just sincere committed acolytes doing what they perceive to be the "Lord's work." But there are zealots among them...
Dadman
It's fairly obvious from your responses, Cosmic, that you believe I'm trumping up or imagining the Mormon mockery I've personally heard or read in the past week or so. You probably think I have some kind of persecution complex. Think what you want. I don't really care, but I am surprised you haven't noticed anything different in the political/social discourse since Romney's speech. And I am surprised by the hint of sarcasm in your response. Oh well...
CosmicConservative
Hmm... I didn't intentionally insert any sarcasm in my comments. I think I was too casually tossing the word "zealot" around. And I don't think you are trumping it up, I seriously think that Denver has had other things on their minds lately, so it hasn't been a topic here like it probably has in other parts of the country. I'll take your word for it Dadman. I guess just the stories I have seen on Huckabee trying to leverage Romney's speech to rally evangelicals is enough to support your contention. I just haven't been SEEING it here, that's all.
Dadman
I could cite every instance, but it would take me more time than I have right now. And, of course, as a Mormon I am much more attuned to it than a non-Mormon would be. Perhaps I should share with you just one instance (a cartoon) that was waiting for me in my inbox this morning, but it is so mocking and irreverent (from a Mormon's perspective) that I don't feel right making it any more viral than it already is. This is what happens when religion is thrust to the forefront in a political campaign. It has an upside and a downside. The downside in this instance is quite hurtful. Hopefully, it will blow over soon...
CosmicConservative
Perhaps the focus on it now will make it less of an issue next year. Looking for a bright side. ;)
Andy
Dadman: Jeepers...I hope Cosmic didn't draw that cartoon. ;) Then the gloves would be off for sure. Seriously, it will blow over soon. I do have to agree with Cosmic though (Sorry Cosmic). I listen to radio all day because my work allows it, and watch the news in the evening, check the net for breaking stuff, etc. There are articles and some discussion about Romney's Mormon faith on radio talk shows, but not really all that much. Even the local talk shows (very Baptist around here) haven't touched on it at all. Maybe it's localized...or maybe not, but I just don't hear that much about it. I hear more about the Colorado church and mission center shootings than Mormonism. By the way, I have been to that Youth With A Mission center in Arvada. There were a couple of kids from our church in Colorado that went through the program there, and I went up to visit, etc. Nice place...good people...darned shame.
CosmicConservative
The company I work for provided the corporate jet to fly the wounded father's in-laws and other family members to be with the family after the shooting. I was actually very touched by that.
Dadman
What precisely is the point behind telling me what you have or haven't heard about Mormons since Romney's speech? I'm telling you what I've heard and seen since Romney's speech. Larry O'Donnell on the McLaughlin Group was one example. Huckabee's recent comment about Christ and Lucifer - an odd reference in a political campaign to say the least - is another. The cartoon I saw today yet another. Our local talk radio guy, Barry Young, has devoted a segment to mocking Mormons nearly everyday for the past week. Hugh Hewitt has confronted Mormon bashers on his program with some frequency (hat tip to Hugh for confronting some of the bigotry out there). The Arizona Republic devoted an article (actually several) to explaining what Mormons believe, but the content of those articles has been right out of the anti-Mormon handbook. I'm attuned to it, evidently, and you're not. I guess that is to be expected.
CosmicConservative
This will probably come across the wrong way (as if most of what I say doesn't already...) but my personal opinion is that there are no religions that I know of that a clever satirist could not "explain" in such a way as to make the religion sound like the lunatic ravings of a schizophrenic madman. I said I believe you Dadman. I have not challenged the truth of what you are saying. All I have said is that other religions have been targeted in the past (and present) and that I have not personally seen a major media offensive aimed at Mormons in the few radio shows I listen to. I accept that you are describing events that are occuring, and I absolutely believe that anti-Mormon bigots are actively working to undercut Mitt Romney in every way they can. My recollection of Bush's election is that he was viciously attacked for his religion as well. There were plenty who said that any man who claimed to talk to God was mentally unfit to serve as dogcatcher, much less President. I suppose the difference this time is that Bush was mostly attacked by secularists who scoff at all religious beliefs, while Romney is taking it from both the secularists and the evangelicals.
Dadman
Look, I was simply sharing my own personal experiences with friends and for some bizarre reason I seem to be getting mostly argument and skepticism in return. Or at least that's how it feels. I have never claimed other faiths are not the target of mockery and bigotry. I've said just the opposite. I am not trying to lay claim to some kind of Mormon monopoly on ridicule and criticism. I am merely saying that in the wake of Romney's speech the rhetoric and focus on Mormonism has been much more prolific and intense than usual and I'll be happy when it blows over. That's all I'm saying...
CosmicConservative
You're right Dadman, my general contrary nature always gets me into this sort of trouble...
CosmicConservative
"Tom Brady is so awesome that he could win the Presidency running as a Druid."
Andy
Tom Brady is a Druid? Well, that does it for me...I'm going to pull for the Cowboys from now on. I think Romo is Roman Catholic. By the way, Wik has this on Romo...I knew he went to Eastern Illinois, but didn't know this: He is beloved by his alma mater, Eastern Illinois University, where he was also a member of Sigma Pi fraternity. The university has had few professional athletes in its history. Mike Shanahan, coach of the Denver Broncos, also played quarterback for Eastern Illinois University. In addition to Shanahan, NFL coaches Sean Payton and Brad Childress have played for the university.
CosmicConservative
Huh, that's interesting. Shanahan and Romo both played quarterback at the same school? I never knew. By the way, Mike Shanahan's current approval rating from Broncos fans is below 50% for the first time since he hit town. I've never been a big fan of Shanahan's. I think he's the most overrated coach in the league.
Andy
Not a big Shanahan fan (that sort rhymes) either. It surprised me that your Saints coach and the Vike's guy also went there...coaching powerhouse I guess. Kind of like...oh crud (thinking here)...Miami of Ohio. Okay, Wik lists Miami of Ohio with Earl Blaik, Paul Brown, Sid Gillman, Woody Hayes, Ara Parseghian, Weeb Ewbank, Bo Schembechler, Randy Walker, Ron Zook, and Joe Novak. Hmm...I always thought Lou Holtz was from there...I guess not. It looks like Eastern Illinois has some work to do just yet...but not too bad.
Drax
CC: You have expressed to some degree what I was attempting to convey. However. The big picture was missed in the details. The big picture is, on this quesiton, "Just HOW FAITHFULLY does the person under consideration for high office ADHERE to and ACCEPT the doctrine of the church (no matter the religion) to which he proffesses allegience?" This is the important question. When we're talking about Romney, I would like to know if he accepts such things as: the laying on of hands, speaking in tounges, that the New Zion will be built on American soil, prophets (including the one leading the church today), visions, anti-abortion (although with severely irrational exceptions). Does he accept ALL of the Mormon teachings and doctrine or, like most who profess allegience to a particular religion, does he just pick and choose based upon the convenience of the moment? If he believes that the leader of the LDS IS a prophet who speaks the words of God, then isn't he morally required to follow the words of that prophet? If he believes the offical stance of the LDS on abortion CAN he appoint someone the the Supremes who doesn't EXACTLY conform to the Church's position while still being a "Mormon?" THAT'S my point. Just how "Mormon" IS he? From his actions in public life thus far, I have to conclude that he is no more "Mormon" than Bush is "Christian." Both have put aside some of the core values of their stated religion for reasons of state. I agree with Dadman that we should look at the actions of the MAN over his span on earth rather than the actions of the ADHERENT. As is most often the case, very few people actually adhere to the teachings and doctrine of the church they profess allegience to. So, again. I'll take the lip-service hypocrite over the true believer every day.
CosmicConservative
You made two opposing assertions. On the one hand you asserted that "most who profess allegience to a particular religion... accept ALL of the ... teachings." Then you assert "very few people actually adhere to the teachings and doctrine of the church they profess allegience to." The second assertion is by far the more accurate one. And it's not necessarily because people lack faith, it's because people both interpret doctrine in a way that differs from the stated dogma, and because they knowingly fall short of the ideal although they do their best. As one married to a Catholic who spent 20 years on birth control pills, I can tell you that it is possible to not adhere to all tenets and still be a devout and faithful follower.
Drax
I must confess that, upon re-reading, I don't see my assertion that: “most who profess allegience to a particular religion… accept ALL of the … teachings.” I think I said this: "Does he accept ALL of the Mormon teachings and doctrine or, like most who profess allegience to a particular religion, does he just pick and choose based upon the convenience of the moment? " If I did say something which resembled your quotation, it would be close to exactly the opposite of what I was attempting to say, and, of course, did say on multiple occasions. And, as a rational and reasonable person, I can say that one cannot actually BE a "true Catholic" without accepting and attempting to adhere to the doctrines of the Catholic Church. At BEST, if you don't adhere to all the teachings of your supposed religion, one can be a "good person" who accepts the teachings of the Catholic Church when she finds those teachings agreeable." Like almost every single person who is supposedly an adherent to any organized religion...
Drax
Oh...and, most people do try to be "good," but, most people who adhere to a particular religion do NOT "fall short of the ideal although they do their best." Indeed, most people make a conscious decision to defy the stated "dogma" (actually stated doctrine of the religion they voluntarily supposedly adhere to) when they: actively seek out pre-marital sex or take birth control pills or cheat on their taxes or do whatever it is that they do which they purposefully do with full knowledge that it is EXACTLY contrary to the stated postion of the religion they profess to adhere to. And, they'll do it again and again and again and again because they KNOW that God will "forgive them" or "it's not that big of a sin and I'm a good person otherwise," or whatever other justification for purposefully and repeatedly breaking with their church. Meh. We each carry around our own version of "God" and follow our own internalized version of the "Bible" -- one which fits our personal version of what's "right and wrong." (Assuming a belief in God...) Very few people actively attempt to actually follow (or even research and know) the doctrine and tenents of the churches they attend. Where doctrine and internalized Bible conflict, we conveniently follow our own Bible.
CosmicConservative
By your definition, the only true Christian was Jesus Christ.
Drax
Where was I talking about "Christians?" I thought I was talking about ORGANIZED RELIGIONS. Once you have taken the step from "I believe in the God described in the Bible" to choosing a particular organized religion, you have stopped being "just a Christian" but a member of a particular sub-set of Christianity with a particular set of rules. As far as I know, the only requirement to being a "Christian" is accepting Christ as your savior and following his teachings to the best of your ability. I wasn't saying anything about the Cosmic wife not being a "true Christian," but about being a "true CATHOLIC." It is the Catholic Church which prohibits birth control....not Christ. It is the interpretation of the Bible by men which leads one church to this conclusion and others to a different one. Personally, I think the Catholic church's position on birth control (and many other issues) is absurd. But, then, I'm not Catholic.
CosmicConservative
If your approach to defining a person as a follower of a religion were followed, every member of every religion would by definition be heretics or apostates. Since that makes no logical sense, and directly contradicts their own self-image and self-definition, I'm going to allow human beings to be less than perfect in following doctrine and dogma and still be called "Catholic" or "Mormon" or "Baptist." Your mileage may vary.
CosmicConservative
As far as I know, the only prerequisite to being a "Christian" is ACCEPTING Jesus Christ as the Son of almighty God who died for your sins because you are not worthy of salvation on your own, you can only be saved through the sacrifice of Jesus Christ. There's nothing specific about "following his teachings to the best of your ability." Once you start talking about that, you get into the very fractious debate about "Works" vs. "Belief." It is not far wrong to say that it is this core definition of "Christian" which I have never been able to reconcile against my own personal view of a universe that is fair and just.
Drax
Heh. Since we can't all start our own churches, and many people desire to go to a church, it would be difficult for any of us to find a church which exactly fits with our own personal view of God, the Universe, and Everything. (This is why I used "true Catholic" rather than "good Catholic." A "true Catholic" would ALWAYS attempt to adhere to Catholic doctrine and teachings while a "good Catholic" would follow those which were felt right and ignore those which did not.) And, if there IS a God out there, he will be examining how we INDIVIDUALLY chose to live our lives...not how well we adhered to the doctrine set forth by others. And, that brings us full circle. The reason why people are concerned about Mitt's Mormonism is the same reason people were concerned about JFK's Catholicism, i.e., just HOW "Catholic/Mormon" (and in Bush's case "non-denominational Christian") is he? To what DEGREE does this individual adhere to the precepts and doctrine of the organized religion that he professes he follows? Would the Pope dictate JFK's actions as the voice of God on Earth? Etc. It is a LEGITIMATE question. However, I think that it is one which has been quite fully answered by Romney's LIFE, both in the private sector and in public service. He can quite adequately separate himself and his state actions from the doctrine of his church.
Drax
Well, if one accepts Christ as the savior and doesn't make any attempt to follow his teachings, I'm not sure what you might call him, but "Christ like" (i.e., "Christian") would seem to be about the last thing on the list.
CosmicConservative
OK, we can agree on that point. (Oops you posted another comment before I responded to your previous one. This is a response to your previous post, not the one directly above.) I have absolutely no problem with Romney's Mormonism. I have repeatedly stated my personal experience with Mormons as being virtually universally positive. In fact of all the Mormons I have known, and I have known quite a few, I can't think of a single one that was not a decent, intelligent and caring person. I cannot say the same about other denominations I could name. Of course my own experience is purely anecdotal and of course there are Mormons who have broken the law, committed murder and all of the other things that humans do. But my personal experience has been such that in general I would say that being a Mormon is an attribute that encourages me to vote for Romney, not the reverse. As to your last comment, the argument is that if you truly believe in Christ, you will behave as Christ wants you to. This is the whole "put Christ first in your heart instead of your own ego" approach. It's a circular argument. If you don't act as Christ wants you to, you must not actually believe in him, ergo you are not Christian. This is why some believe that "acts" are not the key, because God knows your own heart and knows if you truly believe, while other fallible humans may misinterpret your actions as not being Christ-like, when they really are.
CosmicConservative
I think this thread set a comment record. I hope that's a good thing. ;)
Drax
Heh. And, no name calling! In a thread which wandered into RELIGION. Sweet. I really don't understand where you're coming from when you say that it isn't necessary to actually attempt to follow Christ's teachings in order to BE "Christian." We agree that it is necessary to accept Christ as the Savior, but disagree that it's necessary to attempt to follow his teachings in order to be Christian? One can believe Christ is the savior and be a "Christian" and be the most vile and evil person who ever walked the face of the earth, choosing, at every turn to ask himself "What WOULDN'T Christ do?" and do THAT....and be a "Christian?" I'm confounded.
CosmicConservative
Let me ask you this Drax. Is Judas Iscariot a Christian? Did he go to heaven or hell? What about Thomas? the one called "Doubting Thomas." Is he a Christian? It seems that you did not read my previous comment about the circular argument.
Drax
I can't answer for either of them as I can't see into their hearts. I did read your paragraph on the circular argument; I just don't agree that it's circular. If one accepts and believes that Christ was either the son of God speaking with God's authority or was God in Flesh (different sects of Christianity believing differently and different parts of the Bible supporting both views); and That person (Either speaking God's words or actually being God) tells you how he wants you to live his life; and You accept, through him, you can receive eternal salvation; and That by rejecting him, you can receive eternal damnation; and You reject his TEACHINGS and, instead, substitute your own values for his, values which can be utterly CONTRARY to his teachings (even laws); then You are either the biggest fool who has ever walked the face of the earth since, by rejecting God's teachings you reject God and subject yourself to eternal damnation OR you didn't really believe he was who he said he was in the first place so that your choice to reject his teachings have no consequence.
CosmicConservative
There are options other than total acceptance and total rejection. The question of where Judas Iscariot is spending eternity is a very fundamentally profound question. There is a reason the story of doubting Thomas is put in the Bible, and there is a reason Jesus blesses him for doubting. It is as important as the question of where Job spends eternity. Or Job's wife, for that matter.
Drax
As to Judas. There is compelling evidence that any actions he took at the end were taken at Christ's behest, so, without knowing what is in his heart, I'd go with "Heaven." Doubting Thomas? I suppose that, if the ultimate sin of rejection wasn't occurring at the moment of his death...."Heaven" as well. Old Testament Job? Not an issue on this issue is it? He did what the old testament God wanted him to do, didn't he? His wife (maybe he liked his old wife....?) dunno. Don't remember anything untowards about her other than she became part of the bet.
CosmicConservative
The whole issue of Job, his wife and children, and the ultimate disposition of their souls is directly tied to "the bet." It was the story of Job that first rocked me so much that I got kicked out of the Church of Christ for arguing about it. Very disturbing story. Profoundly disturbing.
Drax
Job and Sodam and Gomorrah for me. I couldn't reconcile those accounts with any diety I would willingly worship.
CosmicConservative
Well, I have to admit that the whole concept of "worship" is one I have a problem with, quite apart from any biblical verses. And that's what got me kicked out of the second church I got kicked out of. I gotta hit the sack. As I said, I fall too easily into old habits. I hope this has been a decent read anyway, and that we didn't fray too many relationships... I certainly didn't intend to. But this is a dangerous subject, and I participated of my own free will ;) so I can't say I didn't know better.... Good night all!
Drax
Night. If relationships can't take a bit of yakking about religion so long as there is no evil intent, then it really ain't much of a relationship anyway.
Andy
Nobody asked my opinion, but I'll give it anyway. Judas and Job are in heaven. Job lived before the law was given, and by his faith in God could be nowhere else than with God. Judas lived under the law. He died before the Cross. Because Jesus and his disciples adhered to Jewish law, the sacrifices of the priests in the temple covered Judas' sins. Now...he committed suicide. Suicide is prohibited, but there are two categories in Jewish law...willful suicide when one has all their faculties...and suicide when one is under extreme emotional pressure (sort of a temporary insanity thing I guess). I think Judas was pretty bummed out about the time he did it, and would qualify for the temporary insanity deal. Oh yea, I almost forgot. Thomas is definitely in heaven. He lived many years preaching the gospel of the resurrected Christ before he was martyred (can't remember where right now). The point of his story is that Jesus was willing to prove himself to any that doubt. I think He got all that cleared up for Thomas. Just my opinion...plus I wanted to add on to the new comment record...you never know when some upstart is going to come along and try to break the CosmicConservative record.