Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Sarcastic blog comment gets Wisconsin teacher arrested

By CosmicConservative
This, my friends, is very scary.
Teacher arrested for pro-Columbine blog post - CNN.com Buss, a former president of the teacher's union, allegedly wrote that teacher salaries made him sick because they are lazy and work only five hours a day. He praised the teen gunmen who killed 12 students and a teacher before committing suicide in the April 1999 attack at Columbine High School. "They knew how to deal with the overpaid teacher union thugs. One shot at a time!" he wrote, adding they should be remembered as heroes. The comment disturbed at least one teacher, who called police in West Bend, 40 miles north of Milwaukee and home of the blog's administrator. Police traveled to arrest Buss at his home in Cudahy, south of Milwaukee, last week after the blogger gave them the anonymous poster's IP address.
The guy made a sarcastic comment, clearly in bad taste, but because it "frightened" a teacher who called the police, the man was arrested. So be careful before you post another comment. Especially one that might frighten somebody.

Comments (13)

Robert
Well, the arrest was because the remark was perceived to be threatening in general though I'm not at all sure how the police came to that conclusion. Obviously, our right to free speech extends only so far and inciting violence or making threats is not protected under the constituition but therein lies our dilemna. Rather than all speech being protected we now have to have someone (officers of the court, DAs, Judges, ect.) interpret what is proteced and what is not and I doubt there are many officers with the requisite training and knowledge to make that determination in an instance like this. Many people will feel that the comments were abhorent and that the man got what he deserved for purposely being so inflammatory (and maybe he did) but I cannot escape from the idea that we do not need freedom of speech for non-controversial thoughts. It is that very language that makes us uncomfortable, that we find offensive, abhorent and socially unacceptable that needs protection. Otherwise, it's not a freedom at all...
CosmicConservative
See it's the "perceived to be threatening" part that I have such a problem with. All it takes is one overly sensitive, self-proclaimed "victim" with an agenda, and pretty much ANYTHING can be "perceived to be threatening."
Mark
The most threatening aspect of this whole story is the action by the police over a satirical posting. The teacher's post is nothing by comparison. Watch out, here comes the Thought Police!
Brian
The most threatening aspect of this whole story is the action by the police over a satirical posting. The police did not take the action on their own - a complaint was made. I am not sure what the responsibility of the police is in this situation but ... are they supposed to send someone back out the door because - in their opinion - the complaint is vague and satirical?
CosmicConservative
Brian: All I know is that a few years back I called the police on New Years Eve to report a drunken reveler literally firing his pistol wildly into the air in my own front yard, and they told me that they couldn't waste their time running down every story like that. But they can check out every sarcastic, "threatening" blog comment? I don't think so.
Brian
But they can check out every sarcastic, “threatening” blog comment? I read the blog in question. From a post a few days later .. The next week the detective called and we spoke about it. At no time did the detective even so much as hint that the proprietors of B&S were at fault. He asked us to remove the comment if we could preserve a permanent record. He also revealed that the complaint was filed by a member of the West Bend school administration. West Bend is larger than where I live by 8,000 people or so. The 'crime report' in my local paper has a listing or two a month about internet fraud and threats being investigaged. They are skimpy on the details but .. ya it appears that in a middlin' sized town in Wisconsin a detective will investigate threats like this.
Andy
Okay, if this article is correct (which I always question), this guy is a former union official. It says: Buss, a former president of the teacher's union, allegedly wrote that teacher salaries made him sick because they are lazy and work only five hours a day. There is always more to a story than we read in the press. It might be possible that this guy had some earlier "run-ins" with other teachers. It might be possible that this guy has an "axe to grind" because of some personal issues with a teacher (or teachers) in the past. It might be possible that this guy is just ticked off at teachers in general because they removed him as President of the Union (maybe for good reasons)...and has a few favorite targets of his resentment. Like I said, there is always more to a situation than the press reports...the guy could have been a nut case ready to explode. Who knows? I mean...even level-headed people like Postal service employees go crazy every once in a while.
Brian
And .. we find out now that the charges have been dropped, and the person who made the complaint was West Bend School District. I suppose if the boss lady of the schools call a detective it carries a bit more weight than an ordinary joe calling about a yahoo in his front yard with a gun.
CosmicConservative
Hey! I resemble that remark! And this begs the question of how you get to be the boss lady of a school system with such poor judgment about "threatening" blog posts. I hope she doesn't read many blogs, or that phone is going to be worn out with police calls.
CosmicConservative
Hmm odd comment there from "heahsweeleLes"... I suppose I probably shouldn't have approved it...
Drax
If he thinks I'm going to click on those links, he's as crazy as a Bloombug.
CosmicConservative
The email associated with the comment seems to be a TV news station...