Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

LSU to play for national championship

By CosmicConservative
I have some comments about this story, but go read it first. Here's a short excerpt:
SI.com - NCAA Football - Ohio St., LSU to vie for national title - Sunday December 2, 2007 9:09PM Why did LSU, which was seventh in the BCS standings heading into the final weekend, make the jump to No. 2 and into the national championship final, while Oklahoma, Southern California, Georgia and a number of others were left behind? The 174 poll voters and handful of computer nerds whose calculations make up the BCS rankings probably all have their own reasons. Among the best is that LSU was rewarded for winning the Southeastern Conference, which is traditionally viewed as one of the toughest leagues in the nation.
OK, first of all, as an LSU alumnus and a sometime fan of college football, I have to say I am glad to see LSU get a chance to play for the national title. But I also have to be honest and say I could not construct a reasonable argument that they truly deserve to be there over about a dozen other teams who have identical or better records and did not lose the #1 ranking twice already this year. Secondly, man I really, really hate the BCS system. Not nearly as much as Dadman, no doubt (in fact Dadman is probably furiously typing away at his own pointed and thoroughly researched blog entry on this subject as I type my lame attempt to address the same issue), but I really hate the BCS system. Just do a playoff man. There are no arguments that make sense against a playoff, everyone knows it's just about the money. The NCAA should show some true leadership and simply announce a reasonable playoff system and let the colleges, the advertisers and the alumni just go fight for the new pile of money it would create. In the end there will be a more accurate determination of the actual best team in the nation, and the distribution of money will be no less corrupt and incompetent than it is today. Third, man, I am so totally sick of this "computer nerd" nonsense. First of all it's an insulting term that has no place in a news story from a supposedly reputable news source. Second, it's completely inaccurate, the people who came up with the formulas for calculating the BCS rankings are no more "computer nerds" than they are "marketing morons." Most likely they are a combination of college football experts, mathematicians, statistical experts and a few computer programmers who converted the resulting algorithms into computer code. Finally, why on earth would this be the lead story on CNN on a day when Venezuela is voting to become a socialist country?

Comments (7)

Andy
As an LSU fan, I am glad that the Tigers will get a shot at the title. But, I really don't think that LSU is the best team in the country, or second best. I also don't think that Ohio State is either. My second son lives in Columbus, OH, and is a huge Buckeye fan. I was talking to him last night, and we agreed that both teams are lucky to be there. But when you look at the other high-ranked teams, none of them have distinguished themselves as "tops" either. So it may as well be LSU & Ohio State. As a fan, I am glad that we get Ohio State. We might not win, but I have a feeling that Georgia, or Oklahoma, or Kansas, or maybe even USC would be a tougher game. Of course we've got a month to get healthy...a sorely needed month...persistent injuries have really hampered LSU this year. I don't like the BCS, but I'm not sure about playoffs. The schedules are already longer than they used to be...I'm just not sure. It might settle controversy, but you can have "in game" controversy that makes one team feel "robbed" as well. Well anyway...Go Tigers!
Dadman
I might be furiously typing if a metacarpal bone in my right hand wasn't broken and presently healing. Typing hurts right now... The BCS is the spawn of Satan himself. It is the antithesis of all that is good and wonderful in sports, namely letting dedicated players and hard-working coaches decide who is best on the field of play, not within the framework of a stupid computer ranking system... I HATE the BCS with every fiber of my being...
CosmicConservative
So yeah, you still haven't told us what happened to your metacarpal... Was it a cartooning injury?
Dadman
Thanksgiving 'Turkey Bowl' injury. It's the result of a mind that remembers all too well how quickly I could get off the mark as a youngster combined with an aging body that just can't live up to all those muscle memories. Hopeful acceleration and anticipation quickly deteriorated into a 48 year old dude face-planting into the turf and landing awkwardly on his right hand. Pop goes the metacarpal...
CosmicConservative
The closest I can come to that is a few weeks ago when I tried to take the dog out in the early morning and slipped on some ice and landed flat on my back simply trying to walk down the hill. I can't even claim to have been trying to be athletic, I was just walking.
Andy
Heck, I woke up this morning with a pulled hamstring in my right leg. The most strenuous thing I did all weekend was calmly sit and watch college football. I guess you could classify that as "athletic." I guess it's Geritol time.
Drax
I can't come up with a compelling argument for any other team. LSU had a stronger strength of schedule than just about anyone NOT in the SEC. They won their CONFERENCE (not just division). Their only losses came in triple overtime to ranked opponents. I really can't come up with a compelling argument for anyone else.