Cosmic Conservative

Rational Conservatism from the heart of America

Studies throw cold water on Mars ocean theory

By CosmicConservative
CNN.com - Studies throw cold water on Mars ocean theory - Dec 21, 2005 I had always wondered about the validity of the "Mars Oceans" stories that have been coming out in the past few years. One thing I am seeing more and more lately in science is over-eager scientists touting their theories as "proven" well before they can be truly considered proven. Today's scientific community needs to reign in these optimists and put the healthy skepticism back into science that I remember from my youth. Not to say that there weren't oceans on Mars, perhaps there were, but CNN reporting "there were, there weren't there were... etc..." gives people the (unfortunately true) perception that scientists are not that reliable. In a time when school boards are trying to put religion back into the science curriculum, we need science to maintain a hard line so that ID folks can't say "look, scientists don't really know anything, look at their stories on Mars oceans."

Comments (3)

The Flying Cartoonist
I'm no apologist for ID, but I'm tired dogmatic scientists who have lost that healthy skepticism you mention in your post. Science is about questioning and seeking answers through reason and observation. It's not about tenaciously clinging to ideas that may be flawed because those ideas serve some other purpose. Evolution is an elegant theory, but it has some significant gaps and weaknesses that should be addressed...even in science class. Whether or not that should be a discussion of ID I don't know. Does it really need to be an either-or proposition?
CosmicConservative
I too don't want this to turn into an Intelligent Design debate, there are plenty of those on the web already and it is unlikely that I can add anything to the existing body of debate that is worth the effort. So instead I'll mention my concern over String Theory, which is what theoretical cosmologists and astrophysicists have now begun to treat as a "theory of everything." My problem with ST is that as far as I can tell, it isn't science. By that I mean it isn't science as science has been defined for centuries. Perhaps the most critical thing that demonstrates how String Theory isn't science is that it isn't falsifiable. Which may be the most fundamental definition of science. In other words, there is no test you can devise that ST must pass or else it is proven false. I am very concerned that science itself is suffering the same problem as society in general, and that is a lack of general critical thinking skills. Logic is rarely, if ever, taught in class anymore in primary or secondary schools. My worry is that when students get into the higher, and harder, sciences, they have too much on their plates to learn critical thinking skills and as a result they end up with incredibly detailed knowledge in a very narrow area, but may not be able to recognize when someone in another field has gone beyond the bounds of logic. Which is where I think String Theory has gone. It is this lack of general critical thinking skills that leads some areas of science to think they have proven their point before they have actually done so.
The Flying Cartoonist
Agreed. From what I understand about ST, it's a theory that is currently outside the bounds of normal scientific research and testing so much of what is thought to be true about ST is merely conjecture. Evolution may indeed be fact, but I think many evolutionary scientists tend to fill in some of the evidentiary gaps with similar conjecture. A quality education should require students to examine all the evidence that supports evolution...and all the evidence that challenges evolutionary theory and then draw their own conclusions. It bothers me when politicians begin to intefere with that process. It also bothers me when those with a religious agenda do the same. Whether the creationists like it or not, evolution is the orthodoxy of the scientific community at this point in time and deserves serious attention in any science curriculum.